M/S Meridian Milk Products And Others v. Debts Recovery Tribunal-1, And Others
2023:PHHC:135532-DB
!"#!$%&%"'$ "(!) *
+
,& !)%-% ' %./)"-0$ & '-" 1!)&
2!)&0& !( &!$"3!)4)%(0' . '-" 1!)&
5 67 898 7 8 77 67 898
!" #
$ %
& '''' 8 77*9 ( ) * +,+&!+!! - .
!(/
01 2 345) 4&(4!+!! 01
* 01 01 0
3
1 6 01
7 %
!"+8!+!! 1 * 9 3 -93 /
01
5 1
0:
* 10* 93
6
0 (&+;!+!! * 01
1
*
!$+,!+!! ! %
1 :
(<$+++++=4*
% 0
01
0
1)) "+ *
1 !+(+>6 0 * * 2
5 * * 0 4
- / !(+!!+(" (8+<!+(8 (8-!/ 5*
!!!"8+++=4 8 5
1*
7% 6
* *
(8-!/ 5* * *
4!$"+4!+(" * 01
2 3455) 6 (8-!/
5 (!+"!+(&* 0 1 % **
0
8+((!+(8 " 2 +,+&!+(&- .
!/*
!,$!&<$";(
(<(+!+(&- .
8/*
93 *
01
0
7 %
+
0
* 93
1
93 0 ($,<$,,<8; )@4!!;&(4!+!+ * 01
%
93
1 0
("(!!+!+
(<(+!+(&=(&+(!+!+* %1 * 0
*
10 8+(!!+!+ $ *
* *
*
. *
* 1
93 * * * .
)@4!!;&(4!+!+ *
6 1 * * 01
!(+!!+!! * 0 1
1 (; 5 4&(4!+!!* 01
& 2 345) (<+"!+!!
*0
(( * 0
1 01 3
0 * 0
)
0
0
* 1
4&(4!+!! * 1
01 2 3 ) +,+&!+!!*
(( 0 0
.
5 5*
:
1
1 !++"
0
*
*
* 0
; *
* 014 % +8+,!+!! 4 A 5 @ +,+&!+!!
01 20 1 3 4( ) 4(&4!+!!
6 %
1 93
)
8 93 B) 01
=% (!(+!+!+*
1 A 5 4
C
* 0 D *
93 3 *
1
0 E FGEF
$ 1 * &-/ )
*
1 012 3 " 0 0 * H
(( * 013 0 01 ((+$!++"
: 0
01
=% %
1 0 : .
01
0 !$+ 61 &&$$ 61 -(( / 0
3
(; *
5
01
H
6 ** 0 93 6 0 *93 % 01 )
1
0
,<8+
1 0 $<&! 0 1
0 !$+,!+!!
4
!,$!+!!
0 :0 3 ) (&;!+!! -!,/I 0
D ,
1 +,+&!+!! 0
01 2 3
:
0
* *01
* 0 1
6 * 0 5* 6 0 0 1 0
* 0
1*
; 0 4
3 * 1
*
1
01
7% * . (( **
0
01 2 3
*9 . 0
01 2 3
1
0 )
?
:
H F0
)
,&"-!)<8 ) 7!!7 -93!)&0&1!=$%&! '- = %"'##%$!)$0>&&!&&%'?0 1")% 4 '-" 1!)&%3%.@@! . "9 ++"#
-!$%-!-"' 9
+
* 0
1 01 15
1 * 0* <
*
*
1
1
0 *
0 *
0
?
7%
1 % *93
0
293
&
* 0
!"5*
(( * * 1 *
7% 0
01 .
3
01 1 0 1
0
3
93 **
0
(+
:
H F0
)
A9 8)!!-1 ) 3!)&0& ,& 0& "'& )0$ %"'&3 97 -9 '-" 1!)&
+ 80@)!>!"0) + ;*
1
101*1
0
0 .
5 1 0
*
:
H F0
)
7 -93!)&0&.0!" & " !.&7 -9 ")&
B
%3%.
;:; '-% ' '/ '- '" 1!)3!)&0&A9 @@%)!--%4 ) '- '" 1!)
B+ %3%.
B
5*
1 * 0
(( @
* * 0
1
C (! 1- / - /01
6
5 01
7 % 5
)@4!!;&(4!+!+ * *
* * !(+!!+!!*0 1
1 (; 5 * 0 +,+&!+!!
01 2 3 *014
1
0
(, 5?
*
B
0
6 * :
0
)
:
*
01 1
(8 @ 1
+,+&!+!!
01 2 3 0 1
* *
01
1 5 5
* 5
* 1= 1
1 5
* * * 5
1 (;
5 3 1 4
93
4:
* * 1 (, 5
1 :5 3 (( 0
*0
* 0 93
0
0
.
55 *
0
0 4
6
93 0
.
*
("
*
0
01 2 3
**
1 3
1 1
014
1
5 0 :
0
* = 9 3
1 0 01H F0
)
1! %<'") )( ' ""@!) %3! '/ 7%>% !-* %<'") '- " 1!)& 3&9
!!' .?? )C . '-" 1!)&*
8 ;95
1 0
0 . :
!!&) 5 @ '%"' '/"# '-% 398 4 C % '-"' '- " 1!)&*
B 8 * H F0
)
2 )%> -0?0 (% !--4 39 9 8)!!'%3 &0.0 '- " 1!)&*
+ 999%3%.
+: 4 A8" 5
0
*
1
20 13 01
(; 5!++!0 3 *
0 (,
0:
4 * .
1
0
*
H)
01 *
!!&) @
*
01 H)
. :
!!& ) * .
10 *3
0 4
! (,!++!D ($
0 01H F0
)
,&8"0 1 '-% '( '/7 -9 '-" 1!)&39 3!!' 1!C 1%.%@ '- '" 1!)*
+
%3%.
* * 4 A(8@ 1* * H)
!!& ) 5
*
0 ... ... ... (" * 0
* )
*
5 *
.
* 4 1 * *
*
* .
0
1 ... ... ... ... ($ 3 0: 0 $" !++! 1 0 01 )
)-% 1!>%$ .&7 -9 39 '%"' "# '-% *
:
: 8 + @
1 )
3 0 01 1 3 ** *
6 4
1
(;-(/ 5 .
.
A 1
D*
3 ... ... ... (,@ *
*
!!& ) 5
* 0 6 0 . 1 .
:
6
0
* *
D (&
* 0 1 . . 1
1
6 ***
. :
!!& ) 5 3 01
:
H F0
)
,&"-!)< 8 ) 7!!7 -9-
/
5 :
10 6 * ** 01H F0
)
H )
. (; *
1 .
1
1
0 :
1 (,
0 (< @ 1
* 0 1
1= 1 0 0 ** !+ 5 .
!(
- / 1 - /
7 8 $ "(!) *
+
@
= J = @ 0J =