← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/15208/2020disposed of

Sukh Sagar Avenue Welfare Association v. Punjab Education Development Board And Others

2024-02-13Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl11 pages









   

  





!"

# $%&%!'

())

*+,- * .

/ 0 '+  1"

/ &&!$% %!'

)))) %%!' / 2 /&+& +'3 #+$ %!'

 0 1!56 '

!

/#

'# !- /&

))))) &5!'# '& 7

89 7) * 2:*  

 

  

   

  

 ! 

"   " #$  ;;;;

2:*  9< )

9

#

%    $$&'$$( ! )    *   #+ $,$,.

/ $,0 %    " $        " $    

   1      %" #  !

   #$ ## $,#+.

/ $0 %" $

*#$ ,2 $,$,.

/  #30  %1    11   %

' 1



%1%1 1 4 (5 %%%

$

6  %1 1 #+ $,$,.

/ $,0%   1            1  )    %1      ,3 ,& $,$, " $ 

  1    4 .

 07   .8 07  1.8 0   % !9 +,,2 $,$, %!  !  11%     " #$ " #$  " #$ ,3 ,& $,$,%: %% 1  1    * )   %1 * % 1 #+ $,$,    %



  %1   %

 *%1%" 5

%

 % %                        

  %      " $         :   ,3 ,& $,$,

(

6   1 #+-#-51 #+ $,$,%1  ,3 ,& $,$,.

/ #$0%*    !  %    % %%*    1 %1 ) %1 11 %  %" $;

 1  1   %%

)  1       

   

 <          ! 

 = )  *%

 % %% %   %

 1% 

 " $% 1

6          " #    $   %1 1%

 % %% *1 % 1    1    1 % ) %1 1

11   1

%  %1%1 1   1%        % %" $       %  

  )1 %     1     %1 */ %1

>!     &

       1       #+ $,$, .

/ $,0  #+-#-5%1  ,3 ,& $,$,.

/ #$0   %!  !% %* 1      %   



  

    



! "

   #$%#&%'#'#" (

( % '     "   

     (



   

)) % *  +  )  " 

 ,(  ""





  *%#-%'#'#

(    (

  "  "

% 



.) 

/ 0 

1 2  ! .%0% %3    

 



"

 )%

% 

  

    )

 .

   4  

1 

! ,/ 

 6 "  

  

 (

 

)%

% 5  

)) 

,  / 

          &%#*%'#-  

  

 )

  ))"

(

 ) ) %

"% / )  7 ,  '#8 

  . %  '#9, 

  )  4%*8*'-&$:

 



 ) % "%  "    2   " .%0% %3    (



  2 ( "

.%.

.

5 

(

   2  %;

5 )    2 

.%0% %3 (



   

% .." <



)  ))

 2  (  "

%

% "%

 

 2   

",





)





 2 

 . .

.

5 

,  2 (  "

. 0% %3 % ;% +

)



 2  . ." <



,

(  )

  ,  ) ,.." <



( "  

 





#%#9%'#'# '%##

 "



 %/ )  " 

 ,.

=

  .

  4 (       

  

  (

)

  )  ( 

  

 2    .." <





)

  ( %  

    )

.."  <  



  2        

  

,  >, )+,>%%.%5 

3 ,. 

1 

)

6).  , 1 

5" ) 0  



.." <





)

  ( 

  2 %.

 ,*,$ ?

) .." <



, )   . 



    



   

. 

 4 @ ?6  ,

=

'  . 

 ?/ 

* . 

6 ) ?/ 

% .:

6 ))+,>., 

3 . 

1 

) 6) .   1 

5" ) 0 A

  %   !  !1  ,3 ,& $,$,  %     *1        5# ,+ $,$,  

" #%%1% *  

%

%  1 9

" $ 

1   ?@A 8            1 )        ?!118   #& ,5 $,#+     %1  11%1 1 >  1 4 5(5$+&#3'  1B$,#(

1% $,#-  1      1  %' 

 

" # %1    %

% 1  )%   

" #  

%

% %% %* 

>

 @ % 

    %%1  1 > %% (

 >  !       

        <          !

   =  *% >     )

    

  (   2  

 

 )     

   



 

  

  

    

    )

 "    (  

 



)



  

" 

  

 

 



)

  ) 

    

"

( .



 

  

 " 

  

 

 B





 " )% >     

  "

 

)       

 ) 

A%4

))

) 

B.)



 

"#

$% &

'

 ($

   "$  ()  * 

  + ,+&-,.,

( 

  

CCCCCC ;% .))

  "  

,

  

 / /  %-

 -01!   % 

 2&   

&% 2 %%   %  1  %--1 %   2



  

  )     

 





% %  /   %  %        &

0   %-  %   %   -1!    -  ! 0--    3%     - &- 



   1  !-   !

1  4 %    %-    5%- &  

&0

% 4

   

 C 

 



)

"     

C   



%

 3   &  &

--1  !%      !-   %       %  6    %    ! &   %-   - %!1%-25%-  & !1 

&!   3  %-   % %- &0!1   

 % +



 

   ))



    (    



   "     

 "

  





"  %+ "

  





)





 





  

%

% 7

 " 2



 

      

(  " )%  

"

))

 ( 

)

  

 " 

 " 



"

%+ )     

 

 





 " )%  /   %    5   !

%- %% !- 1 

   %1 % >7 2







  

      :  

 )

    

)  



((  



 





  





)  )% -  3  

 %  !% 2%-

   %% %

 $     %        7 !!  

 8  !5 0 &-% 6  % )% >  

      

2

 

 

 (%+  



 )

 

  )         

)

   ) )

  

%?.5"

.

5 7



 ?9-8 ##(E(4"

(8* 8*8 %

  %    5     %        

 !

%       % 6 2   5   0&

--1%   

?

  0%  

 

! 9   % + ::;, :<=33 ..

2   .>  :  $ 1 & ? &  1 )4 2 <$&;.20   

 

   $

%- >    <    &     = 3   0%  5 2  @5       --     !& 

%-% @

% >  ))

( 

) "

 



     %+ , " ) (, 2 )   "



   

   "

 F5  F% GCC CCCA $% 4 ) )

) 

B5 "

0 



 

0  5

6 ? E %H%.

   

A,  998? E48,

( ,

  

CCCCCC *%       )   :

      

"

  ,(  

)  

2

  

 





%+  

)

   (  

   E". 



))

 2 





 

  





%+ 

 



))



   )

"    )      

  

( )

)  



"2 

  "

   

   "

  )



" 



  2

 

 

  , 2 

 

) 

  

     

% $% >  +   E %  "%  =%6%  5 , 

 

! ,%>%4%98#3 ?/%0% ,/0  3

 

   

 

   

''& .)

  

*&





>  

 

)



" 







 % ;% +  2 )    

    

  



))



 2 



 )  

 "  )       .) 









0 7)

.%=%6"% I

> ,%>%4%99#.% %9-$% &% .

) "

( C5 "

0 



%<%%= %#8&9 99;? 

6 %E %+ "%.

   !% ,  

-%'%99;% 8% > "

(  "

,(2 

    

           E" . 



))

    E". 

))



   

     "

  

 





%+ E". 



))

    

  





(



)

  





   

,

    

%+ 

   

  





 = %'% CCCCCCA

  % : 1  : 1  : 1 CD% 1 !"#

$% &

'

 ($

  " $  ()  = 

 + ,+&-,. CD% 1! 11E %)   :         %           1  :

)  %  1  *1  

  

 F? F >1 #+ $,$,          %  : 1%  



+

 %  1  1%  %1    #+ $,$,  .

/   $,0            



 .0 4" $1            5# ,+ $,$,     %             1     

.0 4" $ 1 %

%  %% %* *   #$ ,2 $,$,  .

/   #30              1     .0 >

1 */ %1

2:* 

 4/+ /@ (<

 

9'  H 9% G H