← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1284/2015dismissed

Shyama Saini And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2023-09-19Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice Kuldeep Tiwari8 pages



               

 

 !

"" #  $%&'() * #

 

  



 



+,  -. +"

%  %% /  -. +"

%  /.  

 

 

     

       !"    # ""    $% /.  

"

& '     "(

)*&))++,-

./%0

 * 1 &23*-  4'0 1'

$40     !  )%&))++2-

. /50

 6      &+&+)+&*-

./60   (        (   ) 7  " " "  "



- 0    $ 2/3(   0  

    !    )%6)+&+     



(     8 9  : 

$6%6)%6)+&+   $6%,)%6)+&+ "  '            !       !       (   

( 

  

!(  " 9    

  

 !(       (  "   

    "       09 

     !

        <              !    1  

=         !>? %+ %%  %   .   %.

     % % 1 

   !   

  ",

&)    )+++/)++&   <  >  <   4        !              

       !      0  

   @                     

     (  1 

      "         ! 

     

       !        (         '

# !

   

  (  0      

         !       =                 )+))+&*  !   . !  (   0!   =    A  !  

          ! !

"  !B 

 5/  &23*     &23*1 =  ! 

  "     "$)2 @  =

    !

  * &23* %+ %%  %   .   %.

  %  % *    

   "                 "    (

 A  * &23*

   "&6+  63&% 

" 3+2,    

!

     8  <A$A $8C8

%&)++2      <

'AD

  >%&&))++, A       "

  !B 

 5/  !         !B 

 /          A    

)%&))++2 6 &23*(

  "6+)+  "  655,  " ;   

!      

  

 &23*   

!

         < A7:A>%&&))++2   8  

<'8A$:>%&&))++2A     

  6

 $ 2/3    0 



)%6)+&+  

(           8   9   :      ;    

$6%6)%6)+&+ $6%,   )%6)+&+    "         (

    "  

               

 &23*  .% % 5 E  

        !

 6

   !

!  

!              !!

 

  / ,                  

)%6)+&+ 

(  0    8 9 :   

 $6%6

)%6)+&+ $6%,)%5)+&+ "  :       

 (

  

   

    (  " 

  &6 &23*'  

! 

!1 =        !'    "

(     ! 4!

= %'3  !537 .'"

%'3' 3 93!3 3!

'0

* 6$$:7  % :$ % 5;3 & '5

67 .'"

3!

3! '0

%'3' 3<3 '03!

3!

'0

*  67 % :$ ' =

               3'5!

%5!=0 %'3' 3 93!3 3!

'0

*  $67  65 5>7 ##    

!1 =     

 ! 2 ' .   

  

 !        

"$)2@  =

      !    *

&23*9 .    = 

 (        &23* !   

   

* 6

&23* !      !

     !   8       "    "" !   !

  "F * 

: &23*  !!      1   

" " /   

    (  " !      ! !

  "F     !!

     "     

! "   "" 3 ' !B!   

  "F    " !          "        

                       

         

""F - 0    "F

   !     A    

    "F

 "   (

 " ! "(      ! " !  '                  "

(  !  !B 

5/ 

         "  "  A          !B     5/          &23*   '   

!  !B 



!  "                     !       B"  4! =

   

<>05 (5!5 '

3'5 !

?

5& %5!=0 )3!@* >>

!53 .3!

.34 & '

 67 6%7   4! = !B 

 - 0

! ! ! 

A        - 0    "   !B 

 @  = $)%)+G)++, <3> !

3> '3' %'3' +303 '

3@  4!  =   / <&3  '   /   ! "                  !B       5  

   !  !B  

*  "    '   /      !B       5   !           5 (     !      

(  6   !  

  *   ." &+       

  

 *     &23*         0        !

( 

  !  

  , &) '                      *-&0-0       B!

    H  =        

   :

"    &36%   

   !   ! 

  !" 

      

          

    



* ' !     56GG6   !  ! 

         4     "    $56GG&5    !   $56GG)*G)       

 *  '                      !       !

    

 

  

 -            !

   !   

  

 '      "!    ! &&   !  

      !  

  ! "  !               "



! "  

  

 &)

 "  

     6%% /7

6/.  

  $" $" #

B/& E 

"G  D G$ E! D G$