Naresh Dilawari v. State Of Punjab And Others


  
 

     
   !

"#$%&$'()(%*+!+!
   

     


 

 

    ,$)$*# $#(#(%*$,(*-$,)%* ,!."*/$$-.(*012 //(#(%*"3 /4%'"#$$*$,"325*6"7 !

      

   ,"8$,(*#1()"--3('"#(%*()&%,)$$9(*0-$,:())(%*#%-3"'$%* ,$'%,/,$-38&(3$/%*7$1"3&%&,$)-%*/$*#%!! %,  #1$  ,$")%*)  :$*#(%*$/  (*  #1$  "--3('"#(%*2  #1$  )":$  () "33%;$/"*/,$-38&(3$/%*7$1"3&%&,$)-%*/$*#%!()#"9$*%*,$'%,/!
   ,"8$,(*#1()"--3('"#(%*()&%,-3"'(*0%*,$'%,/ **$<5,$) "*/ !

%,  #1$  ,$")%*)  :$*#(%*$/  (*  #1$  "--3('"#(%*2  #1$  )":$  () "33%;$/"*/ **$<5,$) "*/ ",$#"9$*%*,$'%,/!

"(*'")$ 1$-,$)$*#-$#(#(%*1")7$$*78#1$-$#(#(%*$,5*/$,.$'#(%* =  %&  #1$ 
%/$  %& 
,(:(*"3  ,%'$/5,$2  -,"8(*0  &%,  )$##(*0  ")(/$  #1$ (:-50*$/%,/$,)/"#$/!!2!!"*/!!

**$<5,$)


  #%  -"))$/78#1$ 5/('("3"0()#,"#$)#
3"))2>5/1("*";1$,$78 1() "--3('"#(%* %! 
?=? #(#3$/ ") 
     

    ! "@&(3$/5*/$,.$'#(%* 
,!!
!

1")7$$*/()-%)$/%&;1(3$#,$"#(*0#1$)":$")',(:(*"3'%:-3"(*#"*/ /(,$'#(*0#1$-$#(#(%*$,?'%:-3"(*"*##%-,%/5'$1()-,$3(:(*",8$4(/$*'$(* )5--%,#%&"33$0"#(%*)! 1$&"'#)")"33$0$/(*#1$-$#(#(%*",$#1"##1$-$#(#(%*$,1"/ &(3$/"*"--3('"#(%*5*/$,.$'#(%* %&#1$
%/$%&
,(:(*"3,%'$/5,$ 7$&%,$#1$"0()#,"#$&%,,$&$,,(*0#1$:"##$,#%#1$%3('$&%,'%*/5'#(*0 &"(,"*/(:-",#("3(*4$)#(0"#(%*(*#%#1$"33$0"#(%*)#1"#,$)-%*/$*#%! 

,"*'1 "*"0$,  %& */("*  4$,)$")  "*92 "1%*%"/2 >5/1("*" 1") /$&,"5/$/1() "*9&%,")5:%&)!222(*'%**(4"*'$;(#1%#1$, 7"*9%&&('("3)2");$33")2#1$-,(4"#$,$)-%*/$*#)%!#%!1$-$#(#(%*$,2 )#"#$/382%7#"(*$/&,%:#1$ "*9#%)57)#"*#("#$#1$"33$0"#(%*)"0"(*)# #1$,$)-%*/$*#)"*/%#1$,)! A(/$%,/$,/"#$/!!-"))$/78#1$


!>5/1("*"

**$<5,$ 2#1$"--3('"#(%*%&#1$-$#(#(%*$,&(3$/5*/$, .$'#(%* 
,!!
!1")7$$*/()-%)$/%&!5,#1$,2#1$"0()#,"#$1") %,/$,$/  #1"#  #1$  )"(/  "--3('"#(%*  ()  #,$"#$/  ")  ',(:(*"3  '%:-3"(*#2  "*/ "''%,/(*0382#1$-$#(#(%*$,;")/(,$'#$/#%-,%/5'$1()-,$3(:(*",8$4(/$*'$!

00,($4$/%&#1$)"(/%,/$,2#1$-$#(#(%*$,1")&(3$/#1$-,$)$*#-$#(#(%*2 '1"33$*0(*0#1$%,/$,/"#$/!!

**$<5,$ !

,05(*0#1$'")$2#1$-$#(#(%*$,2;1%"--$",)(*-$,)%*)57:(#) #1"#)(*'$#1$-573(':%*$8()(*4%34$/"*/1$'"**%#'%33$'##1$$4(/$*'$ %*1()%;*2#1$,$&%,$2#1$:"##$,)1%53/1"4$7$$*,$&$,,$/#%#1$-%3('$&%, (*4$)#(0"#(%*! .#(33&5,#1$,2(#())57:(##$/#1"##1$ "*91")&(3$/)%:$


 &,(4%3%5)"--3('"#(%*7$&%,$#1$2
1"*/(0",1"0"(*)#,$)-%*/$*#%! #%$<#$*/7$*$&(##%1(:!#()"3)%)57:(##$/78#1$-$#(#(%*$,#1"#$",3($,#1$

"*91"/"3)%&(3$/"--3('"#(%*B5"#1()&,"5/5*/$,.$'#(%* 
,!!
!

7$&%,$#1$"0()#,"#$2>5/1("*"C75#*%%,/$,1")7$$*-"))$/#1$,$%*)% &",!

"4(*01$",/#1$-$#(#(%*$,"*/1"4(*0-$,5)$/#1$'")$&(3$2 #1() 
%5,#  &(*/)  #1"#  #1$  "0()#,"#$C  "&#$,  '%*)(/$,(*0  "33  #1$  ")-$'#) (*4%34$/(*#1$:"##$,C1")'%:$#%#1$'%*'35)(%*#1"##1$"--3('"#(%*7$ #,$"#$/  ")  ',(:(*"3  '%:-3"(*#C  "*/  /(,$'#$/  #1$  -$#(#(%*$,  #%  3$"/  1() -,$3(:(*",8$4(/$*'$(*#1$:"##$,!1$-$#(#(%*$,1")*%#7$$*/$-,(4$/%& 1()3$0"3,$:$/82"))5'1!

%,$%4$,2#1()
%5,#1")"3,$"/81$3/(*
 %& #(#3$/")@ #    $ % & '( )/$'(/$/%*!!#1"#;1(3$/$"3(*0;(#1#1$"--3('"#(%*5*/$, .$'#(%* 2#1$"0()#,"#$()*%#,$B5(,$/#%0(4$"*8/$#"(3$/,$")%*) &%,*%#,$&$,,(*0#1$:"##$,&%,(*4$)#(0"#(%*78#1$%3('$!1$'%5,)$%& "'#(%*"/%-#$/78#1$"0()#,"#$(*#1()'")$()-$,&$'#38(*3(*$;(#1#1$3"; 3"(//%;*78#1$%*@73$.5-,$:$
%5,#"3)%2(*)%&",")#1$"0()#,"#$1") #"9$*'%0*(D"*'$%&#1$%&&$*'$"*/1")/$'(/$/#%-,%'$$/&5,#1$,;(#1#1$ :"##$,(*"''%,/"*'$;(#13";! 1$,$&%,$2#1()
%5,#/%$)*%#&(*/"*8 (33$0"3(#8%,(,,$053",(#8;(#1#1$%,/$,-"))$/78#1$
%5,#7$3%;! 1$  ",05:$*#)  %&  #1$  -$#(#(%*$,  #1"#  1$  '"**%#  '%33$'#  #1$ $4(/$*'$"*/2#1$,$&%,$2#1$:"##$,)1%53/1"4$7$$*,$&$,,$/#%#1$%3('$() %& *% 1$3-! 4$*/5,(*0#,("3C (& #1$"0()#,"#$)%&(*/)"*/ &$$3) (# *$'$))",8#1"##1$"))()#"*'$%&#1$-%3('$(),$B5(,$/%*'$,#"(*")-$'#%&#1$

=
 :"##$,2#1$*#1$"0()#,"#$'"*4$,8;$33%,/$,#1$%3('$'%*'$,*$/#% (*4$)#(0"#$#1$)"(/")-$'#! #1$,;()$"3)%2(#()&%,#1$"0()#,"#$#%/$'(/$ ;1$#1$,1$)1%53/,$&$,#1$:"##$,#%#1$-%3('$&%,(*4$)#(0"#(%*%,-,%'$$/ ;(#1#1$:"##$,")"'%:-3"(*#! 1%501#1$-$#(#(%*$,1")"3)%-%(*#$/%5##1"#C$",3($,C#1$

"*91"/"3)%:%4$/"*"--3('"#(%*5*/$,.$'#(%* 
,!!
275#*% %,/$,1")7$$*-"))$/#1$,$%*21%;$4$,2(#()#1$)576$'#:"##$,&%,#1$ '%*'$,*$/ "--3('"*#  #%  #"9$  5-  #1$  )":$  ;(#1  #1$ 
%5,# %&  '%*'$,*$/ "0()#,"#$!1$-$#(#(%*$,1")*%#1(*0#%/%;(#1#1$)"(/")-$'#!

*%#1$,",05:$*#,"()$/78#1$-$#(#(%*$,()#1"#)%:$&,(4%3%5) "--3('"#(%*;")&(3$/78#1$ "*9"0"(*)#,$)-%*/$*#%!!%;$4$,2"0"(*C #1$)":$()%&*%5)$#%#1$-$#(#(%*$,!"/#1$ "*9&(3$/"*8&,(4%3%5) "--3('"#(%*2#1$)":$;%53/1"4$7$$*#1,%;*%5#78#1$2
1"*/(0",1 78*%;! %;$4$,2#1$)":$())#(33-$*/(*07$&%,$#1$C;1('1() -,%'$$/(*0;(#1#1$)"(/'")$"0"(*)##1$,$)-%*/$*#%! *4($;%&#1$"7%4$2&(*/(*0*%:$,(#)2#1$-,$)$*#-$#(#(%*() /():())$/!

33  %#1$,  -$*/(*0  "--3('"#(%*)  "3)%  )#"*/  /()-%)$/  %& "''%,/(*038!  "67(,.$1,";"#  5/0$

538+2 :%1"*7(:7," E1$#1$,)-$"9(*0?,$")%*$/ $)?% E1$#1$,,$-%,#"73$ $)?%