High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2592/2018disposed of

Virender Kumar Verma v. Ut Chandigarh

2020-01-07Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj4 pages

$ !

!# '

()*+

& &

" & &&%& % % ,-).." " %

&). !

0, &%). 1 !

0, %). 1 !

#$% &$' (') ')& *#+,$ &,$%- .&)+/% &00+/+')1#'1& .',-&))+ *23,4&..&1+,%,&,$%,$% +1,-+/, &3-,1%/,&- $' 2+*'-$,$% ','5&3,!

$%-%/%+7%2'1%/-%,+ 0&-6',+& ,$','-'/8%,+ 7&)7%2+ .-%.'-',+& &00'8% &7%- 6% ,2&/36% ,1#'1 5%+ *-3 54+-% 2%- 36'-9.%,+,+& %-:

,#'103-,$%--%7%')%2,$',$% 31%2,$&1%2&/36% ,1+ 03- +1$+ *5'+)5& 21&0'//31%2)&2*%2+ ;'+)1 #$&#'1.-%1% ,+ 0-& ,&0

00+/%%/,&- $' 2+*'-$' 2+0'

2%/&4/31,&6%-'..-&'/$%1$+6$%#&3)2/$'-*%<0&-.-%.'-+ *,$% &7%- 6% ,+2% ,+,4/'-2 + 2+ *,$%+ 0&-6',+& -%)+'5)%',-'.#'1)'+2 ,& '5,$%'//31%2 .35)+/#+, %11 '6%)4'6'-.')#'1;&+ %2' 2#'1 1% ,'12%/&4/31,&6%-' 2 '6%1$ 36'-#'16'2%'1$'2&##+, %11

,'5&3,= .

'2%')#'11,-3/85%,#%% '6'-.')' 2,$%'//31%2' 2 ,$%'//31%2,&&8<'1'27' /%' 2/'))%2,$%'//31%2,&/&6%'0,%- & %$&3- ,'5&3,"

#$% ,$%'//31%26%,'6'-.')' 2

'6%1$ 36'- ' 2 ,&&8 ,$% 0+ ') .'46% , ' 2 $' 2%2 &7%- ,$% 1'+2 &7%- 6% ,2% ,+,4 '-2,&'6'-.')$%#'1/'3*$,-%2$' 2%2#+,$,$% /3--% /4 &,%1 %# 6&-% 2&/36% ,1 -%)',+ * ,& &7%- 6% , &00+/%1 ')& *#+,$,#&1%')1#%-%')1&-%/&7%-%20-&6$+1.&11%11+& 3>'#'11% , ,&,$%.&)+/%1,',+& #$%-%3.& ,$% #'1-%*+1,%-%2

0,%-/&6.)%,+& &0+ 7%1,+*',+& ' 2')),$%0&-6')+,+%1,$% '//31%2#'1/$'-*%1$%%,%254,$%,-+') &3-,0&-,$%&00% /%.3 +1$'5)% 3 2%-%/,+& !"!!"=!"!!

$%'//31%2.)%'2%2 &,

? *3+),4' 2/)'+6%2,-+')

& .-&7%+,1 /'1% ,$%.-&1%/3,+& %@'6+ %2 '16' 4'1 A #+, %11%1' 2,$%-%'0,%-1,',%6% ,&0'//31%2#'1')1&-%/&-2%23 2%- %/,+& ?? -

#$%-%+ ')),$%+ /-+6+ ',+ *6',%-+')#'1.3,,&$+6 53,$%2% +%2,$%1'6%' 2.)%'2%2+ &/% /%' 21,',%2,$',$%#'10')1%)4 +6.)+/',%2 &%7+2% /%#'1)%254$+6+ $+12%0% /%

$%,-+') &3-,'0,%--%)4+ *3.& ,$%,%1,+6& +%1&0 &$' (')= '6%1$ 36'- %/&7%-4+, %11' 2"'6'-.') + *$2%/&4/31,&6%-' 2,$%-%.&-,&0,$% (/& 7+/,%2' 21% ,% /%2 ,$%'//31%2'1 &,+/%2'5&7%

**-+%7%2'*'+ 1,,$%;32*%6% ,2',%2 = ".'11%254,$% ,-+') &3-,' '..%')#'1/'--+%254,$%/& 7+/,5%0&-%,$%22) %11+& 1 32*% $' 2+*'-$#$&'00+-6%2,$%,-+') &3-,7%-2+/,' 22+16+11%2,$% '..%')& = !

% /%,$%.-%1% ,-%7+1+& .%,+,+&

(%'- %2/&3 1%)0&-,$%.%,+,+& %-1356+,1,$',$%2&%1 &, .-%11$+1/$'))% *%,&,$%/& 7+/,+& .'-,+ ,$%+6.3* %2;32*%6% ,' 2 /& 0+ %1$+1.-'4%-#+,$-%*'-2,&6&2+0+/',+& + ,$%1% ,% /%.'-,'#'-2%2 ,&,$%.%,+,+& %- %1356+,1,$',,$%.%,+,+& %-+16&-%,$' "4%'-1&0'*% ' 2+1 &,'.-%7+&31/& 7+/,#$&$'13 2%-*& %'..-&@+6',%)44%'-1'1 & ,&2'4 (%'- %2/&3 1%)1356+,1,$',8%%.+ *+ 7+%#,$%'5&7%,$% 1% ,% /%'#'-2%2 ,& ,$% .%,+,+& %-6'45%-%23/%2 ,& ,$%& %')-%'24 3 2%-*& %54$+6

(%'- %2 /&3 1%) 0&- ,$%

$' 2+*'-$ $'1 &..&1%2 ,$%

! .-'4%-6'2%54)%'- %2/&3 1%)0&-,$%.%,+,+& %-& ,$%*-&3 2,$',,$% .%,+,+& %-#'1/'3*$,-%2$' 2%2#$+)%+113+ *0'8%*&7%- 6% ,+2% ,+,4 /'-210&-,$%.3-.&1%&003- +1$+ *5'+)5& 21' 2,$%-%0&-%$%2%1%-7%1 & )% +% /4

%'-2)%'- %2/&3 1%)0&-,$%.%,+,+& %-'1#%)))%'- %2/&3 1%) 0&-,$%

$' 2+*'-$ $%/31,&24/%-,+0+/',%&0,$%.%,+,+& %-2',%2 !

A-%7%')1,$',,$%.%,+,+& %-+1'5&3,,&/&6.)%,%1% ,% /%&04%'-1 &3,&0?4%'-1'#'-2%2'1& ,&2'4' 2+1 %+,$%-+ 7&)7%2 &-/& 7+/,%2+ ' 4&,$%-/'1% $%&//3--% /%+ >3%1,+& ,&&8.)'/%+ ,$%4%'- $% .%,+,+& %-+11,',%2,&5%6&-%,$' "4%'-1&0'*% & 1+2%-+ *,$%'5&7% ,$+1 &3-,+1&0,$%&.+ +& ,$',% 21&0;31,+/%#&3)25%6%,+0,$%1% ,% /% &0,$%.%,+,+& %-+1-%23/%2,&,$%')-%'243 2%-*& %54$+6

%13),' ,)4,$%;32*6% ,&0/& 7+/,+& 2',%2 = ".'11%2 54,$%,-+') &3-,+ /'1% & B"2',%2!

3 2%-%/,+& 1! !"!!"=!"!"B!!!' 2 -%*+1,%-%2',&)+/%,',+& %/,&- $' 2+*'-$' 23.$%)254,$%..%))',% &3-,+

??"

7+2%&-2%-2',%2= !

B+1'00+-6%2 &#%7%-,$%1% ,% /%'#'-2%254 ,$%,-+') &3-,+16&2+0+%2,&,$%.%-+&2')-%'243 2%-*& %54,$%.%,+,+& %-

%,+,+& %-+-% 2%- 36'-%-6'#$&+1+ /31,&245%1%,', )+5%-,40&-,$#+,$+0$+1/31,&24+1 &,-%>3+-%2+ /& %/,+& #+,$' 4&,$%- /'1%

%7+1+& .%,+,+& +12+1.&1%2&00 ' 3'-4

3)',+ $%,$%- %.&-,'5)% %1<& $%,$%-.%'8+ *< %'1& %2 %1<&