← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3565/2005allowed

Kuldeep Singh And ORS v. Ompal And ORS

2018-11-30Mr. Justice Deepak Sibal15 pages

    !       "#$ %$&'(')* 

+ 



  ,,$--")#(     $(,)%$)#(

+ 

  ,,$--")#  

  $(,)%$)#( * ./ /0 /   





 ! 





 !   $

%

&'('')   $

%

&*&'')



 +

 ! 

,



 !   $

%

&'('')   $

%

&*&'')

----- 

   .  "   /

%

&'('

'

%

&*&'

'



"     /   

  !   

 /   !  

1 ! .



#"

/  "

    

4

3  5 

4 



.

 

 

!17 # 

5 &

4 

 !

   /



 

1    

    8 % 9 , ,

!

!  !



 !/ ! !5

4 , /# !

! ! 1 .

:

  !#1 ;



"

   ! $/# #   

) 

! 

!  / /

! !  !5 '

4 , .

"

  ! # 



 ! !

!  !

! ! 1  15

4   !  

  ! 7  # !

 

 

  !

  # ! 

 5

 :"  /# "

"

"    

!

#!

% 

/"

 !

1   #"

 / %.

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<< 2<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

+



+ =



<<<<<<<<<<< <<<<<<<<<<<<<

 %



0 ?.

<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

:



  :



.



<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<<

  

  +

 

1

%.

@#



@#

'

@#

&

@#

<<<<<<<<<2<<<<<<<<<<<<



 %

$@#

)

$@#

) 

##    !

'

#  +   .

:

 # 7  +

:

 6

@# &

   ! /

'

#      "

 

!!

 ! .

:

 17! ! 1

!

  

A

1

  !  #

! #! !7! ! 1

  ,

!  '

 AA8



/

 

!   A

  $# !)  '

  !

!! +

@#     

.

:



" '

" 

 1

 / "



#

  

  & " " 

# 





  

!   ;!    (  AA

  # / 

!

" 8*

 *   #   &

!   "

 " 

/

 !  ! #  ! 

A

 

   (  A'9    # ! 

  "    &1 "    

!        " 

  1

%  ! "     

  "     & " /



  

! ! !  +/  1 A A8&88 A'''(

+/

  1 A   +

 + = 

 %. " .

"



3  

*A /  '

/ "

0; +/

1 A'(   # #!

1 A* +

  !  

" 0 9* * A*  $  @ ")  !



&(&  ! 8 8 AA

0; +/

!

1 A&8 !

! + ! "

 78 



*A /  '

/ "

> #!

/  +/

1 A9* A&& A&A8

:"  +/

1 A&A8    "

 # / !    %. "

 '& /  / "

+/

1 A8&88 /  "

 '& /  / "

>#   :

1 $+/

!    !  

"

/) 1 A'''(

! /  "

  

"

"

 '

  



/ $

  *B)  

/

!

7!

!   

"  ! .

 !! %.

0  :3" $    )   

 

   # / ! %.  

0  :3"   

" *

  " 0 A  & '

'& 

8&

 '

 " "

 % 

   !

" *

2# !  0  :3" +/

1 A'''(

   

'

 

    1 "

  / ! ! !

%.



     

  

 !   /" / ! 

%. 

  



  

" 9

 !

! !      

 1 1 &  "  % 

!

   / # ! /!

 

 #

#  

# 

1   "   

" "   4   

 #       !    /"  /   /    1

   

!

 !1 

   !

 % 

 & 1 /!

  !  "  1

 

 ;!   D;

@4(7

     1 $ )

;! #   / ,

2 /"

!!

# D;

@4(7

 /3  !     %

 

8

 * 

     1

 !

!1 !  &     1  #  #       !  

 /3   



%.



  "       # ## !!

        

/  

"    

" 

  1   

! 

  ;

1  1

 #

 #!3 

  ;

:  % 

   ;

/% 

6

   &   /  



 "    

!

 

    !



> ,

. !  '

 AA8 !

 & $

) "



 

8*

 * 

> ! "

  ! 



? , !  

 ;!   

:"  , "

#"

!  

> '

 

  !

+ ! 1



A

 *  !

   (  A'9



  ! ! 1 

 ! "

# / 1 ! 

  ! ! 1

&

+

:

 ! ! 1 !

  



 "   

! 1

 

 !

 /     ! ! 

    !  %.

#!

! !   %. "



+/

1 A "   #  %. " "

 *A /  '

/ "

  + 

  .



*A /  '

/ "

!  

"

9* * A*  $  @) 

! +

:"   +/

1 A&A8  # / ! 

%.

! '& /  / "



+/

1 A8&88

  :

1 $#  +/

#   ) ! 

"



/ !1    /" # / !

"  

:"   

"



/

  . 1



/

!   +/

A8&88

6 A8&88 A'''(

+/

!

 0  :3/ !   "

3  

'

  ##

"  /

A  & 8 '

'&



/#

! 

! ! 1

 ! ! 1 " .

:



  .

:



 ! ! 1

!

" /1 !  .

:



, ! 1

! "

1 /!  



 E 

  ! ! ! ! 1 

! !

;



@

  

 # / !   

!

!

      

! !

 % "

 !

 # /

! !!

'



 

.

:

   



"  " "  

/#

"  

 1

     

 #   1

 !

     & 1  "  

D  #   1   "

  /

1 '

1 #

"   



!    " 

1   



"

# "

#   3  "

 45$(#')     

      

  %  ,, 

  



!

 #   #! 1 

   !  ! 1

3  

? , 

"   



1

 ! 

  !  

! ! ! 1 # 

/1 



   

 "      "



/

 !



! #

!  ! 

A /  * / "



 ! 

 #  #!  

3  

: 

"

 

45$(#')         



     

 

        

     

 

   

   

     

     !  "# $ %&        ' (               





! A( , ,

!  



3   !

 

   /

= 





#!

!





"



  

!

= 



.

 

  

 # 



>



   "

 !  

 !

!

   #

 !1 ! 1 ! 1F 

!/   

 !

  # !

 !  !



      8 % 9  

  

     

# !   !

 

 ! /    8 % 9 , ,

!

:"   



; !     !  

# 1 

!      !   ! /  

     !

1

 

!

! 1  

,    . /" 

D##   ,  /  . #"

! / !   "

:"  ! !

 ! .

! "

  / . /" 

!   .

!!

1  & "

 

45$(#')1         

 



   

)    *

    +  

 

      

     

 

    



   

 

           

   

 ?# !

! ! 1

!1 1  ! ! 1   ! ! 1 ;







6 / 

! ! 1

!1 

"



/ $    



)  1

!

! /  /1 /

  

:

 %   

   ## !

  ;!     !  

/ ! ;! 

!1 /

/ ;!  ;

   ## !

  1  ! ## !

! "

!  ! 

#1 !  ! ! 1

 /  !# ;

0  :3/   :

1 $#  +/

#   )

    *B 



/ 

!

"



/  #  

+/

1 A'''( /   # #!

0  :3/ !1 /  ##

"

/

 /   "     !   

! # 

"

!

:

"

 

 45$(#')        

 

               

   

 





 



(       )   

 '

"  !  !

 !

!7! #  .

:

   

  !

  A

  ! (  A'9

!

 "

 "

!

 "

/ 



 !

!1 

 /3

 #!3 

#

!



!  

 1   1/



?#  

  / $ / ) "  "  !

/  

 #  #

!  !

 

! !

!  .

:

 # 

#   

 !/ /  #!

,  #!   /

"

# '

"

 

45$(#')

        

     





                     

   

1

   

   !  1   !

    / 1 

 /   



!  

!

        /

!! !  

  

  / #!

!  

 

  #

!  !

 

3  

! 

 7 

  !  1

 # ! 

 

    !   # ! 



   ! 

! 1  1  # 

3  !

:   ! 

 ( .  

  !  /  !

 #!3  !



 



! ! 1

:

"

 

0"

      

!  !

 , /"

 

   D;

@4(7

= ! 

##  /  #

  

1

/

 0/ 0 % 0/ :  %

:" 

!

+

   



 :  %  0 

 



 !# ;

:  % "  

   



 "  

/ 

0 / AA "

  "

 ! >

% 4@ @   

! 

  !

/ , # :  %

 /

= !    !

"

 / #!

 !

! / 1 

 :  %

"

# !

%

&'('

'

" "   

%

&*&'

 

3+ 

 ')

!

!

     #

 !

  

!1  

!

 

 

.

!    !

    !!

1

/0 / 

+

  @

 ?  4  

7 G 4 % / G