High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/11946/2016disposed of

M/S T & T Motors Ltd v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2017-09-05Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Gurvinder Singh Gill6 pages

!!"#$ "

% !&' (") &" *+ !"# $ %"& !"# '"& (")%" "

"& ,-' ".%/& "01 ,1,/ -.%- "&+ " ".

21",-. ,.%-3 ",-(") " 4& 2&"-. .%3 ",-(") ".

,0* -.% " "#2&' &,-.%- "('55

$ %"&* !&+ "&" &&,, 6&71 /&& 1 &# .- "&"-9&8 .9/"1 : - "+%,)!&, 1 &" %,,6" 6+1"-;6$+1"

0&, 0& -!&, "31"6 /16&< "1 / " 5 1",'":

31"6

/31"16"$ #"

1 , " & + " 1<$ & & 71 71 &,+ ,) 1+""& $ &*6&>"

$+ !" +" ) # -*&<,

*,$ .- : "&"-9& :.95 "$ :.- 71 &<&"1 "&,.-

$,)-&8 .-/&&/&1

&" 5 &+" - &8 . /1 !&1&< 6 <)>1,,; &

&1" :

?416$ :8 -&<

+ & ,)&/&" &8

.&< 1+"" -& 1"&"+" 6 < "" "$ :.- "&"+, 8 . ' :."+"1&"1 "

+&#," "!"-# & #! ./ .012 % &

& ! %'

- & " # !" #

3 /& 6 )& 6

&.- ) 6 1 "&# .-8

-= /&" /"1 " & # .71 . & < $- & - ,, +"% &.", 6&"$

$+ &,,++,)@" </&" /"1 " &<

$-& 1&+" 6&,, 11 "& +"% &# .- .& < "+,A !& ,+ B+"<)&>1,,; & &1"

91+"-B"<,/ = !& +" 6 +1"1

.",$ ,)

"+1"+ 1 6+",$ ") 71")

: "") 6 1 & 1"%) 1<,) & , +"+ < 71" ;- ++" & , " &++"+"3%"

$ C

71"&, &&) ,<4 -

) ,&"&<4 < >"&+1"+ +)$ $+ - & &, .<2 "&+1"+ B 6& "<+ "+1<, , +" "D &"" 1"&"" - <- &"",&6-&" $,)",!&" "-% &16& &

.2 & "&"$ " $+ <1 %"&, < 2 & 61 "& .!&+" 6 "71 << ,) "1++,

$ /&&&6 ,"

. !&#6,1"<)'

:.&+"% "&, +" $&%,+ " 1 "&, .5+"%& /& 6 )& :. )&, 71 6E C1 "&,8

./&" /"1 &" &<

$-& ,,&+"% :. ", 6"$ $+ "++,) !&++,<,) &+"% :

. "+)$ $+ /1, ,)<

+" 61 "&,8 < " /&&&++ ) "&

"$ :.

!&++,<,) '

:./&&,/&"+, % 6,"

&B %6&&,8 .&,, "+,!&

'1<' & %&"/+"% :.-& "+, 1 " '1< ' &,, < &, +"41"

&6 ",++,

&8 3.*+, $" $"

"$<1 1< + &

& #6,1" 5 & &"

B+",)"<) ")$+, :

./<"6"/+

. /&,,)" +"& /1,< ," "+,!&"+, "+ . , "'1<' / :.+"%@&/%"-<)'1<' +"41"

&6 ",++,

&8 3. !& / : . +"% " %", $+"")- +"6"% ,,) < , ,6,%$1"<"2 6/) "$&

&+"&,/ +"%$& $ "$ , $+ +1<, +1"+ /&& &" .!&/ :

.<, /"+"% 6 "&< , +"% ,6, &, "/&, 16&<71"&&)6&<

& /,6,%+ !& 11 .< "&++ )

"&/ :./1, 1"$

+"% "$ ' 8 3. ,) &+" 61 "&, . &% < E C < "

/&&/1,<&&"&< 1++,

$ ,,/<)," . 6 . +1<,&1 , 8 . &

, 3D <1 &

/++"," "&$$ $

:. /1, <1 <,

,/&, 1&+1<, &6% 1&+1<, <2 & +1<, & 5 ,) & +1<, &, & < &&"/ &

+" <,&$ ,<4 & !&&" <4 1 =. &+1<, ./1, <+"$<, ""+, "$$ $ :. "$ &+" 6

<&% < E C1 "&,8 . & ," 1 " ' &" & <

1 ,)/& &," 1& &, +" <&%<

E C5 &"/"- ,"

"$ . < " -&, 6

<&%< &" "- /1,,+<)%"1

:.A #"

1 , "&' +1& " ,6,+ ( 1"&"1<$& "&71", &/"/

1 <)&# ,,"-&/%"-& $+ / +&+ "

"&" 6,"

1 , "&+" " &1<$ <% &%/B+"<)>1,,; & & 1"

91+"- 1"%/-& "

' &8 .- :-&,+71&+ "- ," &8 1< " "+, &8 . $ :. 5 +" &8 .&< 1

(/%"-&'&,,<,<")&" "& +" 6 "71 " 6/&&, " +1"& 6 " 6&, " /&,/- &,

71 "71" " $+, ) +"4 " &"/ !& + "&,,$ 171"6" 6&, 71 " +" B$ & <,&'2 .,,&"1 " &/"+ ", + &1"& B+" ) + &" !&/"+ + " 6,) *4&; , F16

31"% "' 6&3,, % F16 &&"+2 6 " G &&"*+"<, G