High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13592/2014dismissed

Union Of India & ANR v. Munish Kumar & ORS

2015-03-31Ms. Justice Navita Singh,Mr Justice Jaswant Singh12 pages

" #$ $

%$ &

#'&($ "#$

) * "

"#$

%$ &

#$(+ $ "#$

) * "

"!#$!%&$ & "'&() &$$!* + !"

,-+.'

/ 1 !) #

+ !

"!/!

,-+.'

/ "

!-$+) !

+3/

$ $( '&($,-"+ $#* $ $-( -$$,-"+ $$ * "

$)# .#$(,-"+ $$ * "

$)/ #0&$#,-"+ $$ * "

4 !

2##3$ *

#$&4# 5 *$(

#* $3#

44$ +"26#$"$ #-7 "" *

-889:)9 "$"$""

-;;9:)9

7#* $263 *$"+$

( *$""

$$& <$ #=5<$ # ( !

2##($ ,

+5+"

)&5 - #0$( =.3= "& > 44( )&5 , >?$ )&5 " ")&5 -$ $*$"&"#$

25+67&'3/&8 9&8:'

&/";

0$(

=.+=<$ # ( $@

0$(

=.+= 55 +$@

0$(

=.+= 5$$ $@ +0$(

=.+= 5=$@ +0$(

=.+=.(*% "$

" " # $ %

#& $ #* $A $&5$""

5 $5+ " $"

! "

# 7# B& $

# *

3##$# $ "

(* " $$$& ( #* <$ # ( $+5 " " &

25C

7#* $

#*$

5 #* <$ # ( $56

4 # $ "

$/" # 5 ( #**5 2 $#7$ 2& 5+ #&4##63$ ($($ "# # 5" "

#($ B&5

>"& B&5

#$3$"

, # 54$& "# $ * "

2##*

" &5

55# $

,# $ "&$3

"$" "# "

53$

($ , (56, .&( )

".#$ #$(+ $3$ *$ $$" 8 7#-7,

-889:)9 $5

$ *

4$"$ $

& ' (

* +,

$ "* ,-7,

-;;9:)9 *

4$"$ $

! $ ! !

)

% ) %

! - # ; 7#* $ A&

5+#( 56 ""##

(* " $#*&$* 5 "**

( #* <$ # ( "B& +5 *

$"$ "

*5 6"

#0+$ ( !

$"$ &

#* $

4*$ +$ * " 2 $#-7,#

( ($ 5

*$*$"26#(

$*$"&"#$

# $

% &'!( ) * $ + +

$ , -%

, +

)

/# 0 $ 1 $ &'!( 2

$ 3 &'!4(%

/# 5

&( &'!"( 4

2+ 6

# !

" 7

"/ !

>?$ $ 3,

6% '

4 #

) % ' "#

$5+ $*$"& #

# "+$

( "" ' ( ) 2)

% ' " $*+,- .

1!2 (

') 3

7# * $ A &

5 &$#$ (" $ $ "

# D&55 < # -7, < 45$

/001 2 3

4 " , 5 +

# 63#$

7#7$ 2& 5#5"

*$;

" +4 $ ! !!

8 !

2 !

! !

! 1+2 +6 %

7 7 /+88+

#19

2 $ ! !

+: +6 3 +8 ) !

6++88 ! !

; ! < '

3 6++88

! !

# 7# * $ A &

5 $5 " # "

# +

< # #

&$$*$"

/017 /708 9 4 :; !

# $

#5" ;

9 &'7 * =!

! !

> 9 &'7

* =!

# 7#* $ A&

5,#& ," ""# 5 3 # $ $

$&5$$"3 #)&5 ,

4# (#

$$ 25, $ "/& #+2 "3

5$4$*&25

$ $ $,$ * " &

5 +#( 56 &2( "

#$ * " , (56,#**5 2 $-7$($ ($ " # # 5" " 3 # $ $ ($ ?(

4 $#

,( "

*$ # $&5$$"3 #)&5 - )&5 , $ #

4"3 # #* <$ # ( $B& +5 * +

*$ (*

; 7# $&? # ($

4 $

4 #

# "**56

4 $#* 64$6 0.3 55#+ &**5( #

( $(#$(*56(

&$ #+ "B& (

5 +5 #" &**$ # ( 5 "#

( 56 "#? ,$

3 55#+2 2

" $( # " 2 $ # $ #

4 +

( 5$ " 5 )&5 - )&5 , ,.3=

#55 #+ 4 + & "$=

4 # # # #$ &$

" 553 * "$2* "26#0+$ (

$"B&(

5 +5 #" $# ( 5 "#

( 56<##

$ $$6-$ 5 "8 #

& !

$B& $" &5

55# $ "

, # (& "

$ (

( 4#5 25 " 4 AEA "3## &$"($($= "

# 4#$

($ 2&

#" #+#$ &$

($#$(*56(

&$ $ 6""

(,## 2 ("

5 2526 + $& #2+ "5 6 -# ( (,

2 " # 2

B&5

($ ?(

, #$ $, ($

# ($ ?(

#&5" 2 =

"$ "

6 5$ $+ *5 6# ( #55#+ 2"#$"

B& 56,#

$*$ $2 $$6 " $$6-$ 5 "8 #

& # #$ # ",

FGH "

# # &$" $

*$ 4 ($= "

# &5

# $

" 4 + *$ $ &# # "

(& $

4#($

"$ 7#2/ 5

"**

( *&25 * ,($

# 5$ $ 7##$

3# # $ *&5" $ #

4 " 3 # # * 7#$ $,4 +

4*$ $ 5$( # " 3#

55# - #)&5 ,

# 4#56$2 $$6 -#

/& &$

$5+ B&#"

# -*?&$$ "$"

< 4 8 /00=7

13#$

#5" '!

! ! 3

! !

0 3

)

! ++$ ! +: 3 +6

! & ?8

+ 3 !

+ 3 ;

3 ! +/

3 @ '!

5 ! +6 3 /

! 3 ) ! )

@ ! ) 3

:+ $ $

A@ $

&' B

*B =

. 1 .

2 +: +6 3

C D

< 33

6:::/2 8 7#$&59 $&5$$*5 6"

#.#& , # *

# -$ 5 "8 #

& !(& 2 $ $(#+ $2 $$

$(#355 5"

*5 ,2#*

+ " 4 +,& "$56

4-$ 5 "8 $5 #+ 3##$&5(=

4&#$ 6 3# 5 (*

$5 6+ I - )&5 , $"3 #*$ # $&5$"" 3 ?*" $*&$* " $# "&4##+**5 "$$

& $5+ $ ""

$4$" $$5+ $

3# 5

4 $#

3 #$ $ -$ 5 "8

& !

7#& 3$

"$""3 #

4*$ #)&5 - )&5, " $&5$ "" ),3 9

! "

# ; !

+ 3 &$ "

2+, 3 "

$ #

5 $ * " $

"$ # 5" $ * " $

5 "**

( *

B& , &#

#552" 3 #

3( # $(#

"6 -$"

456,# *

* " 5

6 5 6 &% 241<=