High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19271/2012dismissed

Sadhu Ram v. Divisonal Forest Officer And ANR

2015-02-23Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

!""#$%$&'( ) * +,- ..

"!$!$&"/ 0"/%-% $1$%$& 2 /"%! $#"/ &!,"/ ..

"%3&+"&!%

/"%"&!'.

/ &4 5 ",! 6+1# !"/!,"3"!$!$&"/

/ 1$ / ! 3*$&7,66 /8 & ,"$&%! &!:/$!3"!$!$&$%+$/"#!"+ 7 $&%!!," : /++ !"+ ) 63 %%"+ ;8!,"&+-%!/$ 2 /$;-& 2.#-<.= ;-/ -/!6$% /

&&">-/" .(6 :,"/";8 !," /""/"&#" , % ;""& &%:"/"+ 7 $&%! !," 3"!$!$&"/.:/4< & &+,", %&!;""&,"2+"&!$!2"+! &8/"2$" =" /&"+#-&%"2 33" /$&7/!,"3"!$!$&"/:-2+%-;<$!!, ! !,":/4< &, +;""&"&7 7"+ %"2+ /.#-<.

2$&+ $28: 7"; %$% :"( &+:/4"+#&!$&--%28-3!(

$&!," &%$ 2#4!,"/"%3&+"&!.

/"%!"3 /!<"&! $!,-!"1"&3 %%$&7 %3"#$$#/+"/6,": %&!3"/<$!!"+!:/4:"

,":/4< & , +&!;""&7$1"&&"<&!,?%&!$#" %%$7&$&7/" %&%//"!/"&#,<"&! &/: 7"%$&2$"-&!$#"3"/$+&/#<3"&% !$& &+ %%-#,6!,"/", + ;""& :$22-2&&.#<32$ &#"*"#!$&).

!,"&+-%!/$ 2$%3-!"% #! -&%"2:-2+1","<"&!28 /7-"!, !!,":/4< &, +<1"+ & 332$# !$& ;"/" !," = ;-/ -/! / $%%- &#" +$/"#!$&% ! !," /"%3&+"&!%!3/+-#"!,"/"2"1 &!/"#/+$&!,"& !-/"<-%!"//22%6# %, ;4 &+;$22;4"!#/!,"3"/$+

&+$&%3$!"

+$/"#!$&%, 1$&7;""&$%%-"+!!,"/"%3&+"&!+"3 /!<"&!!,"/"@-$%$!" /"#/+, +;""&:$!,,"2+ &+-&+"/%-#,#$/#-<%! &#"%$!: %$<3"/ !$1" -3&!,"= ;-/-/!!, 1"+/ :& & +1"/%"$&"/"&#" 7 $&%!!," "<328"/$&% / % %#"/! $&$&7!,"#<32"!$&A + 8%%"/1$#"$& !,"3/"#"+$&7# 2"&+ /<&!,%! 4"&/<!,"+ !" 22"7"+!"/<$& !$& $"

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

!,"#!!$% 2%:"22 ##"3!"+!, ! + $28: 7"/:-2+&!;"$&3%%"%%$&!,"/"2"1 &!/"#/+$&!,"& !-/" 33$&!<"&!2"!!"/6<-%!"//226 !!"&+ &#"/"7$%!"/"!# &+"/%-#, #$/#-<%! &#"%6$!, %;""&%"!!2"+;8!,"&?;2"*-3/"<"-/!!, !!," :/4< &:-2+, 1"+$%#, /7"+,$%&-%-3& & 332$# !$&, 1$&7;""& $2"+;"/"!,"= ;-/-/!/3/+-#!$&/"2"1 &!/"#/+!: /+%!," 3"/$+$&@-"%!$& &#"+"+286$&!," #!%!,"3/"%"&!# %"%-#, & 332$# !$& : % <1"+ %""4$&7 3/+-#!$& <-%!"/ /22%6 !!"&+ &#" /"7$%!"/"!#/!,"3"/$+

&+$&%3$!"+$/"#!$&%

.(.

, 1$&7 ;""& $%%-"+ ;8 !," = ;-/ -/! !," /"@-$%$!" /"#/+ : % &! 3/+-#"+;8!,"/"%3&+"&!.+"3 /!<"&! &+"/%-#,#$/#-<%! &#"%6!,"

%-;<$%%$&/ $%"+ & ;", 2!,"#-&%"2/+/ :$&7 & +1"/%" $&"/"&#" 7 $&%!!,"+"3 /!<"&! 33" /%!;" !!/ #!$1" !$/%!;2-%, :"1"/6!," #!%/"1" 2 +$"/"&!3$#!-/" =" /&"+#-&%"2/!,"3"!$!$&"/:-2+#&#"+"!, ! !"/ $&$!$ 2"&7 7"<"&!$&!,"8" /6!,":/4< &, +#2 $<"+,$%%"/1$#"! , 1";""&!"/<$& !"+$&!,"8" /( &+ ##/+$&7286 +"< &+&!$#" + !"+

, +;""&%"/1"+ &+#&%"@-"&!!,"/"-3&!,"3"!$!$&"/ , +;""&/"$&%! !"+$&%"/1$#","/" !"/6 %3"/#2 $<!,"3"!$!$&"/,$% %"/1$#"%:"/"!"/<$& !"+8"! 7 $&&(

:,$#,2"+!!,"$2$&7 !,"%"#&++"< &+&!$#"+ !"+((

A &+-3&:,$#,!,"/""/"&#"

, +;""&< +":,$#,#-2<$& !"+$&!,"3 %%$&7!,"$<3-7&"+ : /+6 !,$%;"!,"%! &+:/4< &,$<%"26!,"/":-2+;"&/"@-$/"<"&!/ 3/+-#!$& &8/"#/+ !!,", &+%!,"/"%3&+"&!+"3 /!<"&! &+/ +/ :$&7 &8 +1"/%"$&"/"&#" !$%!,"# %"!,":/4< &,$<%"2!, !,$%%"/1$#"%, 1$&7 ;""&!"/<$& !"+$&!,"8" /(6,": %/"$&%! !"+$&%"/1$#"&28 !"/ $2$&7+"< &+&!$#"+ !"+

-/!,"/%! &+!,":/4< & ,$<%"2 $% !, ! ,$% %"/1$#"% :"/" 7 $& !"/<$& !"+ :" (

2" /286/"$&%! !"<"&!, 1$&7#<" !"/$2$&7+"< &+&!$#"+ !"+

&+!,":/4< &, 1$&7;""&!"/<$& !"+:"(

6,"

:-2+&!#<32"!"!,"/"@-$%$!"A + 8%%"/1$#"$&!,"3/"#"+$&7 # 2"&+ /<&!,%

&+"/%-#,#$/#-<%! &#"%6!,"$&+$&7 #!/"#/+"+;8!," = ;-/-/! %/"7 /+%&&.#<32"!$&A + 8% &+3/!"#!$&

.A.

*"#!$&).

!,"#!&!;"$&7 1 $2 ;2"!!,":/4< &6:-2+&! /"@-$/" &8$&!"/"/"&#":,$2"">"/#$%$&7%-3"/1$%/85-/$%+$#!$& ,"/"$%&<"/$!$&!,"$&%! &!:/$!3"!$!$& &+!,"% <"$% #&%"@-"&!286+$%<$%%"+

"!$!$&+$%<$%%"+

!" #$% 2-#48