Ganpat Singh v. Union Of India & ORS

 
    
  



!"# % &"'&()"*+ $$$$$$$$$$$$$$ ,-./ 0.$ "!"!1 " &&" !(+ ,.

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ "(-./
2
2
2
2  342$)
)5   342$)
)5   342$)
)5   342$)
)5   342$)
2 )

  342$)
2 )

  342$)
2 )

  342$)
2 )

 , "( 2,$)$5$
+&6+&"

 0!

1!,(+ ,$ 2,$,6"!.&"

 0!

1!,, "(.$ $!8  '!,( ,.!,"!(9 $+ ,(+ :6 *;

"(.+!6< 8 '!,( * .(9 )5  -4/ )5  -4/ )5  -4/ )5  -4/ ,;'6*".(+ , &(  =$

'&..

 8>  ,;

 !,

.  ,86"&< 
+&" *&,+   *!"&<  +  &( 
+&" ;&" ,  ?+ 8>  +.  <&;  1!,  *,&"(  !1 .&8<(>'

".!"+&.8

"(6,"

 !?"$+ ,86"&<+&.

?

,3. .&8<(>8 "*3 !".((6(!"&<3

?&."!(&((,86(&8< 2<(&,>.

&" (+&(+. <&;

1!,  (+  &?&,  !1  .&8<(>  '

".!"  .  &<.!  8&,,  8> <;(&(!"', ,8 6"

,)

(!" !1(+ ,;

!,

,86"&<

=-+ "&1( ,3(+  (3/$ - / ,:!"

" &",;> 6,"*"&(!"&<

,* >  "  (+  > &,  %$    &<.!  .

 "&(!"

6,"*=

5?&,8 ?&. .

1,!;

?$ $1$ $@$ -/

(  &''

&,.  (+&(  (+ ,3.  .&8<(>  '

".!"

<&;  ?&.  1!,?&,  (!  (+ !;'

"(  &6(+!,(>  !"  (+

', ;.

(+&(+ ?&. .

1,!;,;>.

 6 (!

+.'<&

"("4!?2

&<
&( *!,>$ . .&8<(>?&.

&..

..

;!, (+&" A$)(<<(+ <&;?&.

<"

!"(+

*,!6" (+&((+  .&8<(>?&. !".((6(!"&<""&(6, &"

"!(  &((,86(&8<  (!  2<(&,>  .

$  1( ,  (+ :

(!"  !1

<&;0 , &( $ =$

,..& (!

+&0 ',  &6(+!,( .  (;

 &"  &*&"  8

6".6

..16<<>&'',!& +"*(+ ,86"&<"(+ &,  $ - "(.  +&0  (+,!6*+  (+ ,  ?,(( .(&( "(  !''!.

,3.  <&;  !"  (?!  !6"(.B 1,.(<> (.&0 ,?&. .

1,!;

2<(&,>.

!"16<1<;

"(!1 ",!<;

"( !" (!".6"

;-/!1(+ &8< &""

(!,;>6< -/!1(+

,;>6< % $ )

!" <> ,?&.'<&

"

4!?2

&<
&( *!,>
- ,;&"

"(/ 6  .&8<(> D2&(6, &(&,& ( -/ ;;&(6, 
&(&,& (4 ?+ +  .  "

,  &((,86(&8<  (!  "!,  ?&.  &**,&0&(  8> 2<(&,>.

-%/  +&0 &, < &,"

!6".

<1!,(+ '&,( .&"

*!"

(+,!6*+(+

!, $ -/ '"!"*0 "8> 11 "(;

&<8!&, .+&0 &<.!

"',! 6

"(.1!,!6, !".

,&(!"$ -=/
!<6;"    !1  (+  ,;&,>  2

&<  C&;"&(!"

 '!,(', '&, &((+ (;

!1,

,6(;

"(!1'

,!"

=$ $%, &<.(+&((+  .(&"(0.!"!1+.8!(+ ?&.F$ "!,;&<&" "! .

?+&(.!

,?&.

,  ?&.  .68:

 (!   )6,0

&<!&, !" $ %$@&" (+ !'"!"!1(+ !&, .

(!(+ 1!<<!?"*

(# !$ @

=&0&"'&()"*+  *+(@ "(G@2(",(> 
F *+( H* )

 &,.

 + .(@ % * &,.

&*#D2 

-/ 22



4 )6;;&,>&" !'"!"!14
!<4!.?&;


<&..1

)'

&<.("&6(+!,(>$ "!<  !1 &(&,& (8!(+ .( -/ " &(D
E- ;'/1!,F > &,.?$ $1  8@$ !?

'!,( 1!,)2)$  "!(

 ;"6(!"!10.!""(

;!"(+!1) '@@?&. &..!

?(+, ..

'&"

!,?&( ,"*$ !+.(!,>!12$  ?&. &*"!.

&.& !12&(
&((

&"  ;;&(6, 
&(4($> $( ?&.!'

,&( !"&"

@$  "(,& &'.6<&,< ". C(,& (!"?(+ ,>!?&. !"

&'.6< 8,!H &((+ ( ,;"&<.(&* !14 ". <0 ,>$ ". C(,& (!" !;'< C(,& &'.6<&,<>8>0

(.&"

".4!!H$ I6(,!6.1!<<!?

< ".$ I(,& (!;>?&.

!"

$ (?&., ?(+,*!,.<& (&( (', "(( 
> 

! !"* .(!"

'+&.H

!6" ?

<<+ &<




6'<.<*+(<>6' ,&?"

2!.( &'.6< .

"8 +" (+ '6'<"6''

,'&,(

I( &, 6" 6.  4(  ! !"* .(!"
!,"

& JK 
JL 6'< JL $$$$$CCC$$$CCC$$CCC$$$$$$CCC$$$CC D.&<<<&8!,&(!,>( .(.&, ?(+""!,;&<<;(.$  !12&(
&((> -!'( /&"  ;;&(6, ($ (1!,, "
&(
- ,;&"

"(/E$

"0 ?!1(+ &8!0 " <.8,!6*+(8

;

&<8!&, $ ) F$4$!.?&;

> )'

&<.(E$ -@/ 2

&<!&, +&.<&.(<>!'"

!1(+  .&8<(>.D !".((6(!"&<E$

-/  1& (  (+&(  '

,  ?&.  '<&

 "  (+  4!?

&< 
&( *!,>  !"  (+  8&..  !1  &8!0  .(&(  ;

&< !'"!"  .  &"  & ;((  1& ($  +  &<< * !" (!".  !"

16<1<;

"(?+ !1(+ ,..& (!+&0  .

1,!;  .

 +&0  "

,  8

"  '<&

 !"  ,

!,  "!, '< & ?,(( ".(&( "($ ( &""!(8 &;

!

(+&(.!!"&1( , *!,M"*+;"4!?2

&<
&( *!,> ,?&. .

1,!;.

$ ( &"

(+6.

8 .&1 <> !"1 (+&(!"<>&" (+ !"<> !1 ,3.  .

 1,!;  .

 ?&.  A  .&8<(> .611 8>+; 6 3.&<;

"($ - &0"*  + <  (+&(  "

C(  N6 .(!"  (!  8

,;"

.?+ ,(+ !1 .&8<(>.&((,86(&8<

(!!,&**,&0&( 2<(&,>.

-/ 1& (.?<<.'

&H1!,(+ ;.

<0 .$+ ,3.

8!(+ .?

,1

(<>1"

"!,;&<&" + &<(+>&((+

(;

 +  ?&.  ",!<<  "  (+  > &,  %$  +

!"("6  (!  .

 ,;>  1!,   > &,.  &"  & (0 <> '&,( '&(  "  (?!  ?&,.  &<.!$  (  .

 11 6<(  (!

&

'((+&((+ <!..!1 .*+(?&."!(&((,86(&8< (!!, ?&."!( "&**,&0&( 2<(&,>.

$+ !"6.(!

',!0  .&8<(>.611 ,?&."!(

", ;!( <> !""

2<(&,>.

?&.!"(+

"(.$+  )6,0 >2

&<!&, +&.&..*"

"!

&.!"?+&(.!

,!0 ,<!!H"*(+ ;&" &(!,>, N6, !1&..*""*, &.!"-./".6''!,(!1(.!'"!"

&.(!+!?(+

.&8<(>!,  .

 ?&."!(&**,&0&(  6 (!2<(&,>

- /

"(+ <*+(!1(+ ',"

'< .<&  !?"8>(+ !"38<

)6', 
!6,(" +&,&;0,)"*+0$"!"!1 " &&"

+&,&;0,)"*+0$"!"!1 " &&"

+&,&;0,)"*+0$"!"!1 " &&"

+&,&;0,)"*+0$"!"!1 " &&"

!(+ ,.

!(+ ,.

!(+ ,.

!(+ ,.- /=)6', 
!6,(
&.

. - /=)6', 
!6,(
&.

. - /=)6', 
!6,(
&.

. - /=)6', 
!6,(
&.

. ?

6"+ .(&("*<> +!<  (+&(  1  "!(  &((,86(&8<

 <!..  !1   .*+(  ?&.

,(&"<>  &**,&0&(  8>  (+  2<(&,>  .

$  )"

.&8<(>.611 ,?&. .

% (!(+ 8 1(!1 .&8<(> "(!1'

".!""&

!, &"

?(+ *$=!1 ".!" *6<&(!".1!,(+ ,;> $ -/ +.(&H .6.(!(+ .

!" *,!6" !1, :

(!"!1 ,3. <&;8>(+ ,86"&< "&;

<>(+&((+ <&;

?&.8&,, 8><;(&(!"$ - ".!"  <&;  .  &  ,

6,,"*   !1  & (!"

?+ +&

,6 .&" ., 00 ,>;!"(+$ (. 11 6<((!

+!< (+&(.6 +& <&; &"8 8&,, 8><;(&(!"$+ ..6

.  "!  <!"* ,  , .  "( *,&$  )6 +  &  .(6&(!"  +&.  8

<&8!,&( <> &<(?(+8>& !!, "&(  +

!!, "&(  +

!!, "&(  +

!!, "&(  +";

)"*+ ;

)"*+ ;

)"*+ ;

)"*+ -C$ &H/0$"!"!1 " &&" !(+ ,.  -C$ &H/0$"!"!1 " &&" !(+ ,.  -C$ &H/0$"!"!1 " &&" !(+ ,.  -C$ &H/0$"!"!1 " &&" !(+ ,.  - /)%@ - /)%@ - /)%@ - /)%@ , , ,,"* (! (+  8" "*',

"(. !1 (+ )6',

!6,((! !"

<6 &.1!<<!?.# $$$$ !?

 ."

 &  '

,.!"  +&.

&'',!& + &1( , <&> <&;!1&,, &,.

?!6<  8 .(,  (!  &  '

,!  !1  (+,

&,.',!,(!"(&(!"!1<.

&.&"> <&;

1!,;!"

> !6< 8 <! * !"<>?(+"(+,

&,.1,!;(+  &( ,*+((!,

!0 ,>&,.

"( ,;.!1,( =!1(+ 4;(&(!"

$ +

?

1" (+&((+ <&;!1 .&8<(>'

".!" &""!(8

<"

1!,(+

&.!"(+&((?&."!(,&.

?(+"(+,

&,.!1 .

1,!;(+ ,;> 86((+

'&>;

"(!1&,, &,.?!6< 8 .(, (!& ,! !1(+,

&,.8 <;(&(!"!1 <.$E 

(+6.

"

"!((!86, "(+.!, ,?(+;!, &.!".

1!,&

'("*(+ ,3. <&;$ -%/  .6<(&"(<> ?,('

((!".&<<!?

$+ ,!1 ,86"&<  &(  =$  .  .

(  &.

 &"  (+  ,*"&< ''< &(!"1< ,.&<<!?

C( (+&(+ .+ <  (! .&8<(>'

".!""!(!"&<<>?$ $1



$$@  ?+ +  .  (!  8  ,!6"

 !11  O  % A  ?$ $1

$$+ ,.+&<<8 '& &,, &,.!1'

".!"

!"<>1!,(+ ,!  !;;

"*(+,

&,.',

"*(+

!11<"*(+ ,*"&< ''< &(!""(+ ,86"&<&"

,$+ ,.+&<<&<.!8 (!"( .(O =A'

,&""6;!"(+ &,, &,.!1'

".!"$ -/  8 1(.  .+&<<  8  ?(+"  &  '

,!  !1 (+,

;!"(+.1,!;(+  &( !1,

'(!1

,(1 !'>!1 (+.!, ,$ -)5 / -)5 / -)5 / -)5 /    

%

%

%

% -2 )

/ -2 )

/ -2 )

/ -2 )

/ ;&;(&