← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13671/2014dismissed

Avtar Singh Bhatoa v. Ut Of Chandigarh & ORS

2017-04-06Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

 

     

!"# $ %!&'()#*"#

%+,--%%

 .'/'

0!-%1,%-2-'

')1'



  !" #$%&'" '&!(#$)*"

'( 3

%4%5%/)%*1&%* !-)

3  + 3%*1&%! 3 .'-%+1-*1&%* !')1'

2"

3

%6%74/1%*1&%! 3

-5%*1&%* !')1'

*$2

88888  '&!(#+,- -&-%,-)'9)'-5)/,1 1'*:/' ; ;<1%1"

= $11>0- 5% ?61%%@ />& 0+&'A* 0*-%1,%-- )&1,'  %1  %  -  '%&  !  ')1  

;+%0%  %% -%/1-%0*9--'9*9%'5)%11%')%0

3

%  4%5%  /)%*  %1  &/'  )',  - )'/>5'-%-)-%1&'/&1" 5'/)-) %11/-'%51!!%'

')1'

9 %'1/&1%'%'-'%1))0*9--%1)%1!'5 5*>/'))1)%0,-'%5'& <<< 6%!-))0* -  )  -%1  %0  %))1  -  ''  51  %'  %'  -' %0%1&&059%'%''%1-%5*9-

 '11/'1-&&0&&  %&&/!;)%05!- )1,&&0>'*-!!&%'!-&&0,*-%1,%- '%))1- &&0&&%1-%%5/! '

*==* B;

5%1  /)%1  '%1  !  5%6,  ,1  -  /'%1,  %5/* ')1'

61-)''!"";!-?,%+&' /-'&* <C @!'-D <C &EA %-5%'*'% 1'-%>)%''1*''&-'&5)%&!-)'' !'/>;'&@CA!+&""!- <C &*-/'*-1'/1 &-%,%&'%&9--7/1,511>0-'/    

.    .  +/0,1  ,  / 2,  / 343

2,

!

56,,, 6 7 3-(1&11=

-%>'& !%0&'!5-%19*&&0&&&%>,

-&'/5*%')-)''!-&&0&*"## *5%'% &'/5*9-''/))19-,0>0%&''-5 >0%0-)',%,1->/'''!'/))0,,0- )/>& !&-%'%'>5%1-7/1,511 83'37,

,9 3/ 343 7,%, " ::1 ,6(;;.+-%< !/-'/>5'-%-1'%&'%&9--,/%'! - ,/%055''*5/&-''-)''!-&&0&

  &%*  3  + 3%*  1&%  ! 3 .'-%  +1-* 1&%*!')1'

%1"%13

%6%74/1%*1&%! 3

-5%*1&%*!')1'

*$%1'/>5-%- )-%'&/''%1%''%-1'%'!-%'> '/,-%,%'-5 *-'9*9%'5)%11 !%&*-%'

>)1&1-%-&&-%'>''/1-%5! 51%'%1-0-%1)%1%0%%0)!5'%1

 51%'

-',%1*)'!1>0-%'-%> 1'5''1-,/1-%-'%'-)!%11%1%' %1*-!*-%))&%'>!- 5%?61%%9%'

!  51  %'

 0  %  &%  5%  9-/  &&0  %1 /'%1,1/'&%%9%0'>)%1>0-'9-9%' 83'37,

,9 3+34=,-',%,1%9 %%$!-1%'!&'

-%5)!&&%

+&-'%/'!-%-%'>%151*-!*-   &)'*    %,5  %1  -  1&/5'  !  -  )/)'  ! >%,-&&0&&9F/1 -'>%&61)!

-5%*-%/-0-%1%91-%))&%1&,-&&0 %1''/-&&0&& -%-%1-%1&/'!-)%'*%))%'1- )%)>6%1!-9-%-'!&%1'/>'%&- '/>5'''!3

%4%5%/)%

&110*  -  &&0 &&  9%'    -  %5  ! 51%'

-%'>%'!1*5/&-''-)-%' >%>)9'-)>09%0!'%11%1-!%&/5! %'-)!%11%1%-%'%'>)19!- 7/1,511-9%))&%!"#

1%'D%+,- -%%.'/' %-51E*1&11"< "

 &-)''''!

-  )%  ')1'  -%1  >  %151  %'  %'*  -  9%'   F/5!),-&)%1%,5%1'/&-!1,'* 509*%,%%17/'!1 )'&%>1)1!%%, '&'

',%1'-&0!-/'%1,1/'*-&&0

 %1'%>0&-'%5!5-'9-9*9-' %5-5&&-%'>'%1

-'%-%')&!-5% -%!511 -%'>&-%,1>0-&&0%1 ,/1!!&'

5%1/

)'%1'1'5''1

=(  + '&!- ,2 #$)*"

7 7 3= ,5 >8 ,3

?

7 7  = ,9

?