High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16389/2024dismissed

Kaptan Singh v. The Chief Canal Officer And ORS

2024-07-18Mr. Justice Harsh Bunger10 pages

" !

!#$% (%)*+*&,

- -

.#/$#, 0*,12 ------ %$*$*&,%3 4%3+5+ 2% &$2%3+ ------

%+/&,(%,$+ 7 8

0 0

3%+%,$ 30#53#9 3&3#:

(9&)#$% '&3 /%$*$*&,%3- - - 0 :

8 - %$*$*&,%3 .#/$#, 0*,12 '*6%( *,+$#,$ )*9*6 ;3*$ /%$*$*&, 5,(%3 3$*)6%+

&,+$*$5$*&, ,(*#:

+%%<*,1 +%$$*,1 #+*(%

/#++%( 3%+/&,(%,$

/#++%( 3%+/&,(%,$ -

3*%'6?:

3%+/&,(%,$

#A>*3 +& >2%?

#B #6&,1;*$2 &$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+

*,&3:

'*6%( #, #//6*)#$*&, 5,(%3 0%)$*&, #3?#,# !3#*,#1% )$:

*, +2&3$ 7

)$7 '&3 +/6*$$*,1 %=*+$*,1

*,&3 *,$& $;& )2#<+ *-%- &,% #$ %=*+$*,1 +*$% #$

*,&3 &$2%3 #$

8 &, /6%# (5% ,&, +B&&$2 '6&;*,1 $23&512 %=*+$*,1 +?/2&,:

$2%*3 '*%6(+ ;%3% ,&$ >%*,1 *33*1#$%( /3&/%36?

'53$2%3 /6%# $#<%, %=*+$*,1 +?/2&, )2&)<%( +#B% ,&$ >%*,1 )6%#,%( (%/#3$B%,$ 3%156#36?-

- $ #//%#3+ /%$*$*&,%3 #6&,1;*$2 +&B% )&+2#3%3+ %=*+$*,1

*,&3:

&//&+%( +)2%B% +/6*$$*,1 >%'&3% +5>B*$$*,1 $&$#6 #3%# )2#<

8 &,6?

@ #)3%+:

&5$ ;2*)2 +&B% #3%# >%%, )&,9%3$%( *,$& 3%+*(%,$*#6 #3%# #66 +2#3%2&6(%3+ ;%3% 1%$$*,1 '566 #5$2&3*C%( (*+)2#31% $23&512 +#,)$*&,%( 6*,%( )&53+% %=*+$*,1

8 #,(:

$2%3%'&3%:

$2%3% ,& ,%)%++*$?

+/6*$$*,1 $2*+ +B#66 *,$& $;& '53$2%3 +B#66%3 &5$6%$+-

$ $3#,+/*3%+ #//6*)#$*&, +5>B*$$%( 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+ '&3 +/6*$$*,1 #66&;%( ''*)%3:

2&;%9%3:

(%)*+*&, <%/$ /%,(*,1 #//3&9#6 '&3 &5$6%$+ 2#9*,1 (*+)2#31% 6%++ $2#,

-@ )5+%)+

3%D5*3%( >% #))&3(%( )&B/%$%,$ #5$2&3*$?:

;2*)2 #//#3%,$6?

13#,$%(:

9*(% 6%$$%3

'$%3 3%)%*/$ #'&3%+#*( #//3&9#6

#66&;%( #//6*)#$*&, '&3 +/6*$$*,1 &5$6%$:

+5>B*$$%( 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+:

9*(%

%%6*,1 #113*%9%( #1#*,+$ #'&3%+#*(

/3%+%,$ /%$*$*&,%3 /3%'%33%( #, #//%#6 >%'&3% 3%+/&,(%,$

05/%3*,$%,(*,1 ''*)%3:

;2& +%$ #+*(%

9*(% -

2% #'&3%+#*( -

)2#66%,1%( 3%+/&,(%,$

#A>*3 /3%'%33*,1 #, #//%#6 >%'&3% ''*)%3:

;2*)2 #66&;%(:

9*(%

@ -

+%$ #+*(%-

, #'&3%B%,$*&,%( )*3)5B+$#,)%+:

/%$*$*&,%3 '*6%( *,+$#,$ ;3*$ /%$*$*&, >%'&3% $2*+ &53$:

+%%<*,1 3%6*%':

,&$*)%( #>&9%-

8%#3,%( )&5,+%6 '&3 /%$*$*&,%3 +5>B*$+ 3%+/&,(%,$ ;3&,16?

*66%1#66?

/#++%( *B/51,%( ;*$2&5$ #//3%)*#$*,1 '#)$ *$ (5$?

%9%3?

+2#3%2&6(%3+ %,+53% B#*,$%,#,)% )&53+% #, '53$2%3 %,+53% )6%#3#,)% %9%3?

+?/2&,)569%3$ '#66*,1 *, #6*1,B%,$ #,?

)&53+%-

$ '53$2%3 +5>B*$$%( &>A%)$*&,+ 3#*+%( /%$*$*&,%3 &$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+ ;%3% ,&$ )&,+*(%3%( #5$2&3*$*%+ >%6&;

$&$#66?

,&,+/%#<*,1

/#++%( ''*)%3:

;2*)2 #6$2&512 +%$ #+*(% 05/%3*,$%,(*,1 ''*)%3:

9*(% -

2&;%9%3:

;3&,16?

+%$ #+*(% /#++%( 05/%3*,$%,(*,1 ''*)%3:

9*(% *B/51,%(

- 8%#3,%( )&5,+%6 '&3 /%$*$*&,%3 '53$2%3 +5>B*$+ ;*$2 +/6*$$*,1 &5$6%$:

*$+ )#/#)*$?

>%%, )&,+*(%3#>6?

3%(5)%(

)5+%)+ 3%+/%)$*9%6?:

;2*)2 )#,,&$ B#*,$#*, '566 +5//6?

6%9%6 *33*1#$% '*%6(+ +#$*+'#)$&3*6?-

$ ,%=$ +5>B*$$%( %=*+$*,1 )&53+% *$+ >3#,)2%+ #3% '566?

6*,%( 2#9% >%%, *33*1#$*,1 %,$*3% )2#< #3%# /3&/%36?

$2%3% ,& &>+$35)$*&, *, '3%% '6&;

;#$%3:

$2%3%'&3%:

$2%3% #>+&65$%6?

,& ,%)%++*$?

+/6*$$*,1 *,$& $;& +B#66%3 &5$6%$+-

$ +5>B*$$%( +/6*$$*,1 +B#66 *,$& $;& +B#66%3 &5$6%$+ #1#*,+$ >#+*) 356%+-

*$2 #'&3%+#*( +5>B*++*&,+:

6%#3,%( )&5,+%6 '&3 /%$*$*&,%3

/3#?%( *B/51,%( >% +%$ #+*(%-

2#9% 2%#3( 6%#3,%( )&5,+%6 '&3 /%$*$*&,%3 2#9% /%35+%( /#/%3 >&&< ;*$2 2*+ #>6% #++*+$#,)%- - , *,+$#,$ )#+%:

3%+/&,(%,$

#A>*3 &$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+

*,&3 3%D5%+$%( #5$2&3*$*%+ (5% /#++*,1 >?/#++ 3&#( $23&512 $2%*3 '*%6(+ &, #))&5,$ ,&, +B&&$2 '6&;

$23&512 %=*+$*,1 +?/2&,:

$2%*3 '*%6(+ #3% ,&$ >%*,1 /3&/%36?

*33*1#$%(-

$ '53$2%3 +$#$%( )6%#3#,)% %=*+$*,1 +?/2&, ,&$ >%*,1 (&,% /3&/%36?:

$2%3%'&3%:

,%;

*,&3 B#?

>% +#,)$*&,%( +%/#3#$%6?

'&3 $2%*3 #3%# $3#,+'%33*,1 +#B% '3&B

*,&3-

2%?

'53$2%3 #((%( )&+$ *,+$#66#$*&, ,%;

;%66 #(A5+$B%,$ *,9&69%( ;*66 >% >&3,% $2%B 3%D5*3%( )&53+% ;*66 >% #33#,1%( $2%B #$ $2%*3 &;, 6%9%6-

- 2% #'&3%+#*( 3%D5%+$ 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+

*,&3 &//&+%( /%$*$*&,%3 '%;

&$2%3+ +5>B*$$*,1 &,6?

+B#66 #3%# >%*,1 +%39%(

*,&3 *,)2 (*# +?/2&, #63%#(?

%=*+$+ #$ +*$% '3&B ;2%3% *33*1#$*&, #3%# 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3+ >%*,1 (&,% /3&/%36?-

$ +$#$%( &, >%2#6'

/%$*$*&,%3 )6%#3#,)% +?/2&, >%*,1 (&,% '#3B%3+ #$ $2%*3 &;, 6%9%6 %=*+$*,1 )&53+%+

*,&3 #3% 6*,%( #,(:

$2%3%'&3%:

$2%3% ,& ,%)%++*$?

+#,)$*&, ,%;

*,&3- 2% ''*)%3:

9*(%

#66&;%( 3%D5%+$ 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+ &>+%39*,1 5,(%3

$ %

" "

& "

$ $ %'($) *

+ ,

- .

/ $

23// (

4/// ( (

- $ +

23// ( (

4/// ( (

7 (

& 899 "

" "9 $ $ %'($) *

- .

"9 9 " "

: " "

" "

;

<2<'- $ 5/ /5 5/5< " $ $ % '($) *

- . "

; $ $ % '($)

;

25=/'<($)'5/5< /5 /< 5/5< "

$ % > ,

;

4252'1= .'0 /< 5/5<

/ $

23// ( (

4/// ( (

"9 " "

9 " "

23// ( (

4/// ( (

7 (

899 "

" "9 "

& !

+'$$+ "

;

; $ %'(

7 @

?+ $$+ ?+ $$+

(

23// ( ( 5/= 23/ 210'2<<

<1/ 26<

4/// ( ( 2<< ACB 210'2<< ?

<1/ <1/

/< 5/5<

$ %

# , #

- 0*,)% /%$*$*&,%3 ,&$ +#$*+'*%( ;*$2 #'&3%+#*(

#))&3(*,16?:

2% /3%'%33%( #, #//%#6 >%'&3% 05/%3*,$%,(*,1 ''*)%3:

;2& 9*(% *$+ -

+%$ #+*(%

/#++%( &>+%39*,1

*,&3 #63%#(?

+B#66 &5$6%$:

)&B/3*+*,1 &,6?

#)3%+ 56$53#>6% &BB#,(%( 3%# 9*(% /#++%( ''*)%3:

*$ +/6*$$%( *,$& $;& &5$6%$+:

$2%3%>?

3%+56$*,1 *,$& %=$3# &3(*,#3?

6&;+6&;

'6&;

*, )&53+% >&$2 &5$6%$+:

;2*)2 ,&$ *, *,$%3%+$ >%$$%3 *33*1#$*&,- - %*,1 #113*%9%( #1#*,+$ #'&3%+#*( -

3%+/&,(%,$

/3%'%33%( #, #//%#6 >%'&3% 3%+/&,(%,$ :

;2*)2 >%%, #66&;%(:

9*(% *B/51,%(

%=$3#)$ ;2%3%&'

3%#(+ 5,(%3

/6 5/5<

$ % > , # $

E . " "

* " " ; - ;

23//'( (

4///'( ( "

" ; -

" "

4///'( (

23//'( ( 9 "

23//'(

4///'( ( / $ "

;

25=/'< ($)'5/5< /5 /< 5/5< "

" "

/6 5/5<

$ % > , # $

/%35+#6 &3(%3+ /#++%( ;%66 ;&56( +2&;

#6$2&512 +/6*$$*,1 >%%, /%3B*$$%( (*+)2#31% >%%, 3%(5)%( 6%++ $2#,

-@ )5+%)+:

2&;%9%3:

*$ #//%#3+ >%'&3% /%3B*$$*,1 +/6*$$*,1 &5$6%$:

,%)%++#3?

+#,)$*&, )&B/%$%,$ #5$2&3*$?

*, !%/#3$B%,$ 33*1#$*&, #$%3

%+&53)%+:

#3?#,#:

&>$#*,%(- $ &,6?

5/&, 3%)%*/$ 3%D5*3%( +#,)$*&, )&B/%$%,$ #5$2&3*$?:

+/6*$$*,1 &5$6%$:

2#9*,1 (*+)2#31% 6%++ $2#,

-@ )5+%)+:

/%3B*$$%(:

+5>A%)$ )&,(*$*&, #33#,1%B%,$ )&53+% *, /3&/&+%( )2#< >% B#(% >%,%'*)*#3*%+ %=/%,(*$53% *,9&69%( *, #(A5+$B%,$ &5$6%$+ >% 3%)&9%3%( '3&B >%,%'*)*#3*%+-

//#3%,$6?:

+/6*$$*,1 )2#<

*,&3 /3&9*(*,1 ,%;

8 *, 9*66#1% !2#,(2*6#,:

%2+*6 %3*:

!*+$3*)$

2#AA#3:

+#,)$*&,%( *,

*,$%3%+$ >%$$%3 *33*1#$*&,:

+5>A%)$ )&,(*$*&,:

,&$*)%( #>&9%-

2% ''*)%3:

;2*6% /#++*,1 *B/51,%(

&>+%39%( #$*&,#6 *12;#?

/#++%+ $23&512 )2#< %=*+$*,1 #$

*,&3

#3%# '&3 ;2*)2 ,%;

8 *,&3 >%*,1 (%B#,(%(E 1%$$*,1 *33*1#$*&, #$ +*$% $23&512 +?/2&, )&,+$35)$%( >%,%#$2 #$*&,#6 *12;#?-

$ '53$2%3 &>+%39%( +#*( +?/2&, )&,+$35)$%( >%,%#$2 #$*&,#6 *12;#?

1%$+ '*66%(

;*$2 +#,( *$ ,&$ %#+?

)6%#3 +?/2&, #1#*, #1#*,-

2%3%'&3%:

(%B#,( 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+ '&3 +#,)$*&,*,1 ,%;

#'$%3 +/6*$$*,1 )2#< %=*+$*,1 #$

A5+$*'*%( *, *,$%3%+$ >%$$%3 *33*1#$*&,-

$ >%%, &>+%39%( +#,)$*&, #66&;

&5$6%$+ ;*$2 (*+)2#31% 6%++ $2#,

-@ )5+%)+ #63%#(?

>%%, #))&3(%( >&$2 &5$6%$+ #3% 35,,*,1 #$ +*$%- 8%#3,%( )&5,+%6 '&3 /%$*$*&,%3 >%%, 5,#>6% )&,$3&9%3$ #'&3%+#*( &>+%39#$*&,+ B#(% )#,#6 #5$2&3*$*%+ *, /%3B*$$*,1 +/6*$$*,1 #'$%3 (5% +#,)$*&, '3&B )&B/%$%,$ #5$2&3*$?

3%1#3(+ (*+)2#31% >%*,1 6%++ $2#,

-@ )5+%)+-

9*(%,$6?:

<%%/*,1 *, 9*%;

'#)$5#6 /&+*$*&, %=*+$*,1 #$ +/&$:

+/6*$$*,1 >%%, /%3B*$$%( *, *,$%3%+$ >%$$%3 *33*1#$*&, &>9*#$% (*''*)56$*%+ >%*,1 '#)%( 3%+/&,(%,$

&$2%3 +2#3%2&6(%3+

*,&3- , B?

)&,+*(%3%( 9*%;:

&3(%3+ /#++%( ;%66 3%+/&,(%,$+ :

3%+/%)$*9%6? #//%#3 >% A5+$*'*%( $2%3% ,& +)&/% #,?

*,$%3'%3%,)% *, +#B%-

- , 9*%;

#>&9% (*+)5++*&,:

*,+$#,$ )*9*6 ;3*$ /%$*$*&, '#*6+ +#B% #))&3(*,16?

(*+B*++%(- %,(*,1 #//6*)#$*&, +:

#,?:

+2#66 +$#,( )6&+%(-

- -

+A<+ 2%$2%3 +/%#<*,13%#+&,%( "%+

& 2%$2%3 3%/&3$#>6% "%+