High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16857/2021dismissed

Rajender Singh Yadav v. Haryana Urban Development Authority Haryana And ORS

2023-10-03Mr. Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia,Ms. Justice Harpreet Kaur Jeewan17 pages

!"#$%#&'('$)* +

!"#$

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

- +

+0, "

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

- ,

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

- -

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

- +

1 "10.

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

2"**0 .

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

( .

%& ' ()'*+$,-./0" )"

- * ./ 000/ ./0 0

4"-

#$5/$54"- 5 5 56 56 7

""10.5/$54"-

%0"/ 5/$4 "0"5/$54-(% 88888

2 /,,"4 $ ,9 - :0 . 4 ..:0 4,90"5"* ! -4*)" ..0!.;

7 <" $ ,

5 !" #$% ()'*+$,-./0" )5()" " * 4 , 4 :0" ! 4 "

/=0 - *) " & 44 5 () '* +$,-. /0" )5 9 () "" % > " >5 + 9 - 7 4 " ?('+/@ " 0 .;,

/=0 7 0 *) - ('+/ 9" AB"*>4 )",*. 4 0 4 " - , . " - 4 " ,,-, C 5 +45('+/5 9 "4

;-:

.$).0$*$"

D">4$ 5 $ , 4

>, E *)"- """ ()F 0 F<4."E $) " =$ . <"--, 9 $ *)"- D*0)"

4 ,,. 4 , -, 0 +45 ('+/ 9 5 =,0 $,) +4 , )D,

<"- 0*. " --, 4,,.4 .,-,- .)4 5 5

<"94-,9",

9" ""- 9, 040,-,* ! C 5 +4('+/5 9 9 ,, " .

<" - 7 $*,,) 40 0

C ,,. , " - " !0 " " 20 .. 44 2.. 44 0"5 "" ,4 .,-, (9$5" ,), ! *, 4 ., -, -, 4 .,, G " H" ". - C 9" 9 , 44 *) 0" 40, 4 ,,. "0!",040,4,,.4-, ".4 , $ , 77 4

" 9 - 9 ,,9$

/=0 9 0"- 0,,., "H" ". "H"".9 0,,.,

/=0C"4

;-:

. <" ,,. ,9 04 . ,4F $ , C 4

7 9" " 9 4 , *) " - ! "

/=0

<" ",,! 4 , 4 0 4 ,,. , 9 .*)"- *)9)44 , ! $ , 6C4

5 !" % () '* +$,-. /0" ) "" - 9 -4$

/=0 7 9"*) 9 0 " - 0" $ 4) " , . 4 " - . " , ! * , ) " , !" 4 " " H" ".@

0- <"45"- 9 0",,., C

/=0 "4

;-:

. "4

;-:

7 <"- ",,!" 4"- *) 9) 4 4 , ! $ ,

C 4

9" " 9 - 4 $ ,

/=0 9" " - -) 4 -. 9 "9 " - " -) 94 $ (9$5 9*$" " 0 $,$ 9,)"9" ""-,9,,."4 -, ")

50"5" 9 - 9 -4 9 " "- "-)4"- 5 5"0*. - 9 " - 4"9> E" . .5"- 9, - ".09 "0 -0 " !"

C <" - 0*. - 6

/=06- B.0-,,.,.> ! B-).4", $-

<" - 7 " - 0*. *)"- $

/=0 "!0"- "*4 ="-$," .4 ,,.9" "9.0 !")

<"0" ,, 0-" 4 H"4" 0 F/

5 !34!)! 35!) #6#7$89#)" :";$3'"4 !)< $";#3( =( 0!)<##8!)<$";#3(20 4) !",,."- -$ , !" .4",,.

<"- ! ",,!"4 4" - *)9)44 , ! $ ,

69" "

9 -4$ 7

/=0 .4 " $ ,

6513'(;!)1:9!3 =( !34!)! 35!) #6#7$89#)" :";$3'"4 !)< $";#3( <" $ ,

6 9 - 4 " * 4 0*. . *) " 0, 4 -(% " " . * ! - ! *4 " " 4 /. 5('+/50"54", >,)*- 4 !,,"- ,0 !"-, *)"- "-

E . 4 7

/=0 5 " & 44 5 (%5 9 - 7 . " - $ ..0 ;

/=0 " $ .IB "*"!,,.-

65665 ; 0 !.0

".9 . - "0, 4 " ,,. <" , 0 .

/=0 7 4 " -). 9 , 0 (5"-9 - 94 , !",,! " ..0 ;

/=0 0.

/=07 +0 ! " -) 4 " - 9 - 5 " - 0 4" .-" $ 0

/=0 75 ! " 4 " " 4 ,,. 9 ",,! *) $ 0 ,, $ 0 E 9 " 4 0 5 " -, 0 " 4 :0 . ,,)

0 * ,, " $ .) * "! 4 " $ ! - - 0!. - $ " " % () '* +$,-. /0" ) "

C $ , "4B-0.

<" H" $

/=0 9" , - !4 $ , 7C 4

5 0!"4!>!) =( !)< $";#3( " " 4 /. 5 ('+/. ",,.- >- ! $ 9"D0,,H" 4 " 0 $ ,

!?'6 !)&;!)<!.(&!(# (:83!

- 7 4 , 9 . 0*. ! " 9" , ! " $ 0 ! ! " $)44,,.4"-,0"4:05" " 4 /. 5 (%5 ">0, " 0 , 0

9"*)5 "* "!" - "* 4"05*0"!"$ G " 4 B - 0. . 4 "0!.

!?'6 !)&;!)<!.( &!(# (:83! *) " (@*, D0,, H" 4 " 0 <" . *) " - 9 ,) - 0

/=0 70"5-)9 .4 . ,4"9 - <"- 4 ,-, "9 .4 , *)- 7 !"> "9 -

""9 ,4,,."4- 9" "9 ! ,,) 4 = "$ . /4 " 9 . 9 4 ,5

" 4,,9 !9-*)" 03 J<"0!"5 $ " - 5 " - ",,! !"" !"4 9 ,,)0!"4. ".*)"-(%4,,.4-,- ! $ .4")

5$0,,) "! " . 05 -00 " 4 " 0 H" )9$ ()'*+$,-./0" ) " 7C

- 5

5 " - "$ ,) >

5>-",- .4".4, 9 $ 5

; - :0 .5 *0 "$ , --"!B -0. .-, - " 0 4,0,4"(%54" $ ! - <" - $ - 4 " 4 " 0 )9K 4,,93 LMN4 .4 " 5- ,,) " , !"4"$ 9>*)" 04. . . ,0 ! 7

1 " 10. " $ () '* +$,-. /0" ) " " ,"- 90,*, *,-)"$ - 0 ". .- 5" , .! !,,." 4

C $ 4$0*, *) " /0"

6 "&44 52 5"=-" ",-, 4 9 4 .-5 9 " " 4 /. 5 ('+/ . " ,,. - 4 " - " , !" 4 " *$ . *$ " 0!. " *$ <"" 4/. 5('+/9 ,,,>- $ 9 " D0,, H" 4 " 0

$ " " $ () '* +$,-. /0" ) "

M N F --- * > 9 " - 4 " ." 4. " 4 - 4 4 -) 4 " MN+ -4 L 4 *,0,) 449 ""- 4 H" *0 9 " , 0, 4 " - ,, 9 !0*. "" * !"! 4" !" D,0,4"- 5,"(%5! "0!""0!.4" $"K 0- . ,5 ! ) - 4 4 -0, " 5 0

E0- 5 4"4 "*- 4 $ "K *) " D0,, H" * A B - 0.5990, 449 ""O" ) * ! * ! 0- 05 * ! 4 ,! H"O "9$5 4 " 4 B 40 * - 4 ,,) -0,5 0- 90,*"!4." - 5!,)-).5-*>9 -$ , !*9

,,"4-). P

/ - " .

5 9 0 " -(% 4 , 44 $ 4 " .- 0" )! $ !"=*>0-4".0:0 *- *) " - 4 " -, :0 - 4) ! " , .0 ,0 !" 0,4"- 9,:0 > 0 9"""- " !9 !-)" *, , " 4 90, ,, * -) ! ,. .4",,., / " 44 $ 9 4 , *) "

% ) 10.5 & 44 5(% 9 ! $ !"4,,9 !*>0-3 ! ,- 4-,$ G

;-:

. E4"- 4.

0-C

7 )AB-0.

,!9 " ! ,-

C7-:

. , G

. <, 4 -, - ,,. , " * -

=C7

). "0, 4 ,,. " . 4 ,,. C

"* 40(% 0,*) " D !5 (Q 4 )

; - :

. -"0,*,93 03 :#<!"#

3')&'8!7 ')("!79#)" !9$:)" )("!79#)" !9$:)" ')&7:<')@ 8$((#(('$) ')"#3#("

!49#)"9!<#$3)$"

;

; B .) .0

; ; ; B.0.> B4,4-, 7 C

; C; H, B .0 = 0, ,.

C C

;

; C

; CC;

;,!9 " C

;

; C

;

$"!7 ,+

A - ,A

+ A ). "0, 4 ,,. 4 $ 4 - *"0

IB -0.*,93 03 :#<!"#

3')&'8!7 ')("!79#)" !9$:)" )("!79#)" !9$:)" ')&7:<')@ 8$((#(('$) ')"#3#("

!49#)"9!<#$3)$"

;

; B .) .0

C76 ; C76 ; C76 ; B.0.> B4,4-, 7 C

; ; 7C

0 = B.0 ,) - *) ,, H,4-, * - = 0, ,. C C

; C ; C

; 66 ;

;9 " C

;

; C

; C 776

; $"!7 + + -A , ,

-A

+ A <" .-, "4 . " ,) * 0 " - *) " ; 9 ! -$ .. 7

9 "":0 .>"-).-"0,4$ ,,. P F 0, 4 " - 0*. " " - 9,040, "94-, ")

" " --, 4 ,,. $ 9 4 " . . "*"0 /=00"5" , *,-)" - " . " *"0 E 9 40"

0*. " 9 - 4 , *) " H" ".-

C9 *)" 0"9.",,." 4

;-:

.9""- "* . *).> !",,."4

;-:

.0" " .-0!9,,"0.;,. !" -).4."- " !", *,* <" - , ,", 4"* 4- ) .4"

-*)" 0 6C 6

5(;>!3 0')@;=(0"!"#$%!34!)!!)<$";#3(

" " "5 , 0, 4 " - "", 0

/=0

7"$* 04"! !"- 4"-,4."4 -, " ."* 4"

!?'6 !)&;!)<! !)< $";#3( =( !34!)! 35!) #6#7$89#)" :";$3'"4!)<!)$";#3

7513'(;!)1:9!3!)<!)$";#3=(!34!)! 35!)#6#7$89#)" :";$3'"4 !)< $";#3(

5 0!"4!>!) =( !34!)! 35!) #6#7$89#)" :";$3'"4 !)< $";#3( <" 0 .

/=0 7 " *."* 4" 0 50"5"- ,49 "!0"-- , *,* . <" - :0 " . 4 4,,9 ! :0 3

7 "" " ,,. - "! 4. " - $ .-0!

/=0 0 .

/=0 7-" 0

/=0 7 0*)"- 9 "" 4 )9@ 0-5 1 " 10.@ 0- $"@ 0-R

"""- ,- )"* 4 " H" ".@ 0- E"9 !"@ 0-

$')"$

E !?'6!)&;!)<!(.&!(# (:83! 5"(@*,D0,,H" 4" 09" ,9 !$ 0:0 ! !", .4 0 4 ,,. 4 -, 0 !" D .- <-) F/:0 5 "* , ,./5

75*$"0.)-)*, 4." 9" ""0,"$*! $"- 4"-, ,," " 0,,) ! $ " - 4 " -,5 $ "0!"5 9" - ,)40,*), *,),, !-, 0 E940"*$""0!""090,* , *4 4"- "9-$,9""4 ,"--, *0 " 9 ,, "$ -) " " .0 " 0 " " *4 404.)0 !"- 4.""0,"$

C *! $"- ,,"" 0,,)! $"- Q0 4.0, " - 03 J E"0, *,-)"- 4 =4,,. "4:0 4"0@,5"4 ,. 4,,.0"0:05"4444,,. 0"0:0"4= 4- 4,,. 0"0:0RP 7 <"*$ 4"D0,,H" !?'6!)&;!)<!.( &!(# (:83! " :0 - 03 J

<" )" 0 ".0*,9 "5 .,)5 9" " - ,) 40, <" 0 9""09 ,-,- 0, 9- *,4"-,,"-," *0") ,)04" 40, 0 4 ) 40, " - 4 " 0 <" 0, . ,,. 4 " -, .) $ 0, " 4 - , ! "0- 4$040"05 4",""09 ,"-,9""" ."--, 9 ,",,." "-9 - "$"- 4 " -, " *0 9!

,) E 0" 0. 4,,9 " " 0 90, * , " *4 4"- "9-$,9""."--, -00"--, "-, *,) ,,"-,,"0!"

(9$5$ 0"5"0.0-)*, 4. " 9" " " 0, "$ * ! $ " - 4"-, ,,"" 0,,)! $"- 4"-,54 0""0"""*4 4" 0 4 " .) 0 ! " - -- " 0" 090,"$*- $0 !" - 4"04" -, <" 40"4 0 !0.90,:0 $ $ ,)* 9 - P C " * 4 " !?'6 !)&;!)<!.( &!(#

(:83! 5 " (@*, + $ H" 4 " 0 $

0!"4!>!).( &!(# (:83! 9" , , ! 9 " " . , $)! !"4,,..)-, "" 4/. 5('+/. ",,.- " , !"4"*$ . ;!)<#3;!)0;!39!.(&!(# (:83! 13'(;!) 1:9!3.( &!(# (:83! (9$5 " (@*, + $ H" *$ " " " 4 /. 5 ('+/ 9 ,, , >- $ 9"D0,,H" 4" 0 !?'6!)&;!)<!.(&!(#

(:83! 9" "9

1- ! $ 9 " !?'6 !)&;!)<!.( &!(#

(:83! 2 " . . *) " & 44 - 7 $ .-0!

/=0 4 -). 4 $ . IB ,,.- 9,,0 4 ,,4) 4 % .

-*) H"4" 09" ,*$ !" >*)"-

(% -000!"4!>!).(&!(# (:83! 5 9*$"" -"$,)>

>-" ,- .4".4,9$ G

; -:

.5*0"$,--"!B -0.

.-, -" 0 4,0,4"(% 4 " $ ! - E 9 *$ " 9 4 *,0,) 44 9 " " - 4 H" *0 - 9!--0 )5 9!0"" , . " !"

E.4" .5"- 0, "9"" "! "

/=0 " !" )" 0*)(@*,D0,,H" !?'6!)&;!)<!.(&!(# (:83!

<"- ,), 4"!04 - )"* 4 13'(;!)1:9!3.(&!(# (:83! <" 9

" !?'6 !)&;!)<!.(&!(# (:83! 9>0*:0,)*)"(@*,D0,, H"

59" "",,-$ , . ,,)5"- , ,), 4"- ) $ 94 ;!)<#3 ;!)0;!39!.(&!(# (:83! " 9 .. ,)4 , 4 9 4 -, " )

9" " - - " 4 ,"- .0",! ")

$5 !?'6 !)&;!)<!.( &!(# (:83! 9 0*:0,) *) " (@*, D0,,H"

. ,,)5"- ,- )"* 4 (;>!3 0')@;.( &!(# (:83! " 5 " !?'6!)&;!)<!.(&!(# (:83!

9 *0!" " 4 " (@*, H" :0 " 4 0 5*"*$. - 9 4$0 4 " - ! " - <"0" .-0!

/=0 0444.) 4 . ) 4 6 E$ 94"*$594 . "- - 9 !0 4 4 " .-0!

/=0 0 .;,

/=0 7 / 0"5 " 4 - .

! . ,,0 --, 5 4 )5 , -4 00/

.- !" ""-> !; #;

"" -*, #;