Jaipal Phogat & ANR v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"# $#%&'&()*+ !&,!-./!"!($!(".#0 #"&"&(#0' 1#0'2'
3"!"# !04!(!!($".#0'
#',($#("'
)
56 3
763
0#'#(")8 0 !0&'.!&(9$:%!"#9 0".#,#"&"&(#0' 0!:##(3.#0!(9#,2"4 !04!(! .#".#0".##,0"#0' -%!-(#;',!,#0<!4=#!--;#$" '##".#>2$/<#("?
=#0# #00#$"".##,0"#00("
.#".#0".#>2$/<#("'.2-$=#0#,0"#$&(".#$&/#'"? 88 88 763
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
88 .!:#.#!0$".#-#!0(#$%2('#-' 0".#,!0"&#'!($.!:#!-' %!0# 2--4/(#".02/.".# &-# .# #B!<&(!"&( %!-%2-!"&( '.##" ((#B20#88 A2!
!&,!-./!"9 #%.!(&%,#"&"&(#0'.;'".!"".#<&'%.&# .!'=##( $(#9 ;.&-# %!-%2-!"&(/ ".# 2(82"&-&@#$ #!0(#$ -#!:# ( DDD9 * !($ ;.#0#&(".#2(82"&-&@#$#!0(#$-#!:# 0 + $!4'9
*$!4'!($
*$!4'0#',#%"&:#-4.!:#=##(0#$2%#$" $!4'( ".#!''2<,"&(".!"".#,#"&"&(#0&'#("&"-#$"<!B&<2< $!4'#!0(#$ -#!:#3&<&-!0-49&(%!'# !&=.!/;!(9 #%.!(&%,#"&"&(#09".# #!0(#$-#!:#.!'=##(0#$2%#$(C9* !($C 0<
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
.#-$ #("&"-#$ " -#!:##(%!'.<#(" ,!4<#(" " ".# #B"#(" +C $!4'9 ;.#0#!'".#4.!:#=##(/0!("#$".#-#!:##(%!'.<#(",!4<#(""".##B"#("
* $!4'!($$!4'0#',#%"&:#-4 .#!00#!0' -#!:##(%!'.<#("
,!4<#("'.!--=#0#-#!'#$"".#,#"&"&(#0'!-(/;&".&("#0#'"!"".#0!"#
DE,#0!((2< 0<".#$!"# 0#"&0#<#(""&--,!4<#("9;&".&(";<(".'
0<".#$!"# 0#%#&," %,4 ".&'>2$/<#(" .#0#',($#("'!0#
20".#0$&0#%"#$".-$!(&(A2&04!($ &B".#0#',('&=&-&"4!'";..!'
$(# ".# ;0(/ %!-%2-!"&(' !($ "!F# --; 2, !%"&( !/!&('" ".# $#-&(A2#("
&%&!- 0%!2'&(/.!0!''<#(""".#,#"&"&(#0'!($$0!//&(/ ".#0#',($#("8$#,!0"<#(""".# 20"90#'2-"&(/&(2(8(#%#''!04#B,#('#'
!($;!'"!/# "&<# ".# 20" .#,0#'#(";0&",#"&"&(&'!--;#$ 763
*+ '>F' .#".#0',#!F&(/0#!'(#$ ) #' .#".#0#,0"!=-# )