← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/29725/2023allowed

Ashish Vishkarma Alias Sunil Alias Manish v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-05Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

    













                                                '

'

'

'.'.34A 34A 34A 34A.5 5 5 5 )*

)- )*

)- )*

)- )*

)-%9% (A %9% (A %9% (A %9% (A2A 2A 2A 2A 5 A     

!"#$% &&  '

 C1 ! %  , )*%+ C1 8) '- '- '- '- !

(- !

(- !

(- !

(-.

 7/'1$ $'

 7/'1$ $'

 7/'1$ $'

 7/'1$ $'

'/ '/ '/ '/ '!1%!, !$ $ %2;) *)!(

!1 '!1 + ($ 2%+,1 ?????

?????

?????

????? / / / /21/

21/

21/

21/  $' $' $' $' 01 !

(8

* % % !$ )D53)*(

) )* !

&!) %!

20345*)! )!(6!11 17 *)!9!()*!

&()

 !

9 )100 ( 031412!

*)!

 )**

 8%

,&  % ! $ ) .

. )* (

!)(  !%9    : )(!)8 $%, ( (203@A*)! ) )!(6 $(7 $ )3)*

$ ( &( !) 2()& $( )"&) 2 (!

((

9!

$

,1 1

9!;"

)*(

 B%

 % )*,

9  8 !(

9() $( 9  (!

8 )* () )< (/)")( &(,& (    (!

8)(  =(,& ( ()(&0 

()< ( /) )")( & (,&  > )%( : 8

!"

( )! &  >  && &:

);

*!) )"(

).% )*(

!1

51 / ! )% &*)!(

  !( (

% ():

51411/ ! )% &*)!(

 *%!(

%,"

((  (

( (

 "()!: 8!);

)  )* * (

$ ( ;

 )( ,

)"8&

> 2( % 2(

8!) %( )

 %** ! *!)"

( ( 1 / ! )%  *%!(

!( ( ( )&

()!!:(

!  %

  &) %!

 (( ( )* ).% 2 "

&:   +1 / !  )% % & *%!(

! %,"

(  ( ( ( (

 )* )"

) )* (

!    %

 

 > >  &!

:  +% & % ():1 / !  )% %   *%!(

!(  ( ( (

  %**

! !( *)!")!

:

! 1 % 2!

8!:

*)!1 D1 / !  $((  )%   )8 88)  (

 8!

( 8 ) ,:

!9% (

&& ) !

9  ((

!!

)%  (%!

2( % 2

) )(

!;

)

&1/ ! )%  *%!(

! %,"

(( (

 ((, &8& ,!!

,:(

9)!  )* $

) 54 )* (

$ (2   ( % 2 (

 "

 )%9 ( () ,

1/

! $(( )%

()8&  )!

)!% ():

( 5141 A

)%!(():2>

( )!

)!1 A1

;

!)% &*)!(

; &8!(

 ;

9) !)%9

; &,& )! )*(

=1

! >  !!

) 5141 >

*(

 B%

" >  !!

 )%(    && >  8!

 ) 101D1 )(&0@8!) %( )> (

;

 2)%()*>

)&:4 ;

<"

D ;

9 %8( &&( 1

"8  %

  B% ) )& &:)(

)* &) %!

 (( ()*).% 2"

&: +1

((

+% &% ():((

>

> !!:

  % )(

)*   &) %!

1 8

!(

8!) %( );

)2(

))(

!"

"( &; &,& ()) ((

!>

)(!,

< 8( *)! (

    &) %!

 (( (1 ( () )( ( %

&) %!

 ( ( 2

, )*)!!

!),)!( )&&

!:;

;&% )(,  )& *) )! "8&

!1

  ) (

 % %, ((  (( ( !

!

)%  )%,(  ,)%( (

*   ),+ (: )* (

1  )(   8%( ( (

!>  )(8!

(((

 8)(1

;

! (:>

(9 () ((

( ()(

 &) %!

 (( ("

,:(

).% > &&, *%&&:

 ((

 )* (!

&1

 !

;& )( )  !

 ( ! 9  !

() ,(,&

&&, !( %8) %!

)%!

)*(!

&1

)%!()  )(

" (88!)8!

() &;



8 ()(

;&)( ) 2 ( (

 (9

2 & ( ": 8!

+%

 (!

&1 )(

9 (9 ,&   ,

,!)%9 (*)!> >!()

)))* *(

!, ) 9*!)"

"

8!) ) )*+% ( )! !* 9>

8!) %( =101 ( (

 +%(%!

( >)%& ,   88)  () !

! ()  +%9"

8 ,:(

)%!(   %&$!;

 %&$!;

 %&$!;

 %&$!;

! % $(( )*%+,

! % $(( )*%+,

! % $(( )*%+,

! % $(( )*%+,28 '

'

'

'.'.=A =A =A =A 3D 3D 3D 3D.D D D D A- -D03@ @ 2 >

2 *( ! !

&:

9 %8)

!( )

)*(

+%9"

( )*(

 )7,& $%8!

)%!( )* $  ;

! %  $((  )* "

%2     $%8!

 )%!( AA3E $"(1

+"%

2 ,%& "

  "

: # # /)) 8% ;

! %  $((  )* %+!(2 ! )(   )(!)& %!

%2 D

$ 3E $((  ,:  

 9&%!% ;

; 1 &&%&,   " !

"%( (( F !172  0   !

& 4= =E +:$ ; 1

$( )*!:2, !

9$8 / ;

()8 &!&1 )1 0==G52 )041A152  

& % - H=15 

  > && (,&

 8!

 )* &> ( (  )*

" ,:).% % !$ =4)*(

$(

(&: !:>  8

)* 1$%

 (( ( 2,:(

&;

2)( *)!" (

 )&  ,  *)! (

 );

) )*  %&  "% ( ,

!%( I  >  %(") ( %( )+%( ) >  )(

! %, ((

1')!

);

!2)!

);

!:

** *!)"(

8)

))*

!2>

 %, (&: "8&  %  )& &:

) (

 ,  )*  &) %!

 ((

( )* (

 ).% 1 )> !2  &8 !(  ()& & !(:)* %&2)%!( !

),& () (!

,& (>

 * 9%! 98 ! )&& !(:  %!

**  "

) )* +% (

   & ) )1 

 * &

!:;&% "

(:) )*(

 &) %!

 (( (" ,: ).%  *&& >

 )"  )* (

 (!

& )%!(  !

 () ,

+% %!

)%!

)*(

(!

)! > (,&

8!

)*&>1)> !2>

+ +% 98& *)!!

&2(

)%!( )( !

"  ),& )%  ()

  !%" (  % ! >

  ,

 !! 9  )! "8 "8& 2 &% 9 (

 (%!

 )* (

&& ) 2(

!()(

)**  > && (

!)& ((!

,%( ()(

)""

&& )** 18!

"*

<"

)) )*(

*()! 

&()  %!

2,% )!"

1J

8!) )*&> )("

=11 %!(

!2 (

 )%!(

  )*  > ! $  &   K&  > ! $  &   K&  > ! $  &   K&  > ! $  &   K&  ! %  $( ! %  $( ! %  $( ! %  $( (( )* %+, (( )* %+, (( )* %+, (( )* %+, 8

'

'

'

'.'.5543 5543 5543 5543.A A A A A A- -@30=0  

&( % -

H0D1    (%! () ,

8) (%&( !9 - 



, &8& )"

( E )* 03@A 9 )** 

$ ) 4. (

)*  *) B%( (:E

&&: !

$ )54)* $(1 



9)%! )*$ ) , &8&  )"

&9!)%

< : &%

 )

(1 

9)%! )*$ ) >

,  )%9 (*)!) !( & 0)*(

) ( (%(

  %**  &)9 % !.(!

*)&&:(

)* )(((!

,%

 (>  ) )  )(

!

  ) () (

  !111G $$)!:)(

!8

 (>  ) )  )(

!

%"%&( (%!

 !

 (

*)!

)! ) !( ) ,: , &  $ )540 , 

)* $ *)!,

(

)(9%



 , & )%!

"( &2 &% 9  8%!8) )*+% 

$%  ) ! 9% &( )! )

!%( :!

*)! +% )F%&"



&   )* 

&% 9 "( &G) &)) (),:(

1 )!) !(

)

16

)(&

&:())""

,);

.   !%"

)2 (

 *)&&)> 9

!

()* % $(

 % ! $ ) 03 )! $ ) D )!

*)! )**  9 )""

!  () "

( >

 !

9)%!  )*

)54)* $())(88&:()

 ", &))%()*:

)*

)*&) *"

&:!

&(

)54)* $(8& ()),& )%()*&)9 ! !( ;

>)* )* 1>

&.88& ( 9 & % ():2 (

 (!

 8!)! ( %(,& () % &.88& (1

 $ ) 540 ,  )* $ ( ) ) G8!"

!  )( 88& ,& <((&>1

 $ ) 540 ,  )* $ ( )(&( !( 1,)(

) !, &.8& (),  % *%&1 )%!( )* (

 ) ) ( 8%&( ( 1H(

!

 ),& 9!)%

&(:)* % )** J- !( )%9 ( () *( ( !)%9  && !

;( . !:2 <&% &: *)! (

 & 9 % &8& 1 !( )2 ) 9 (

  ( )*

)%& )( "

!!)! (

 "

  9!

 )* B% ((&)*(

% ((

* & ))*(!

&1  ,: 88& (.% 2 * :2

%"

(   %88)!( (

)*2 ": ,

&.)%!(>

+% 9 % ) ( 8%&( $ )540 , 

(:)** >

), &7- 

 >)! 6&

9 ") (! )** 9 ,: (

 ,

)!

&) 2 )

&.88& (1

&:7 )%9 ( () , !8!

  ,&  %, (( &8!),, (:)*!

.

, &.88& (2 !(

! (   "

) )%!(8!

(*%(%!

)%()* .



*(

( ( )*(

 (

 (%!

 )* )**

)> !2 (

$G)(

! )** )&% ))*

8!)8 *%(%!



 , &.)%!(

"8)  %8) (

 88 >)%& %,"

(2( %

8%&(  ,: (

 )% ) $8 %!

)& %

)2 () (

** )""

))*:)**

*( )*9  )  %

%"

!( $

)9  :

)* 8)> ! ,:  )%!(E >

) )  ( 8%&(  $ %8) (

 +% &  !

 !%" ( )*9 8) ,&:, & )> ()> *( ))*!

(%

  ( )>% *( G !% )(

9,%(%()8  ;) +% & > )"   !

"(( !1J (%&"(!

<)*9  &%

&.88& (2!)&  !

()

"2  !

 !

 () ,   &;

()1 ( )* , &.88& (  )(

9

)( 8 ) *() !

%&(

(:*)!)""

(( 9)**

!( ":2 ( (

 )* 9!( 9 , &2 &2 (.%   ) ) ( (

9%&!( )G !;& ":

%!( 9!( 9 , &2  ** ;

( , *)!

%9 )*

$ )%!(G &&B

'9 G) )&

( ( (

  )( ,

** *( !,

9!

), &1 "8) ))* % ) )":

%**

(*)! ( *( ))*) 540 , 

1

(%!

2")  <( ()* < !

 ( *:

9 &* !

9! 9 (

) 54 )* $ (E && 

< !

 ,: %  )%!(

 *(  < % ( 9%  > (>)%&) ( (%( 8!"

! *)!

% !$ )54   !:

%" ( 1' 9 % (( "8(

)%!1!9)2(

(& *(()(

) )* (

 )%!(  9 >  %

=151

;

>)*(

"(( !2(

9)! "8) % !$ )54 4 )*(

$ ( (  &%( 1 41  8 !% (): ( 5141A* ,:(

! )%

&2(

 &!

: %* ** ! !( )*)!8 ) )*  :

! 2 2 3 ")(    : 1 % %!(

!2   8 ! (

   % ():

 (( ")!

1)> !2

*(%" )(, 9!)% %**

(,:

&*2() &

)

)*!

&()(

 B% )>

 "

)%(*)!9!( )*!

&B%(

 B% ),:!( 9%8)(

*( G !%"

( )*(

   1 

9!, 8& %8)(

+% 9"

()*(

)7,& $%8!

)%!( '%&') 1"

'%&') 1"

'%&') 1"

'%&') 1"

!!!!    ;1 $    ;1 $    ;1 $    ;1 $  )* 11  )(

!2 0  )* 11  )(

!2 0  )* 11  )(

!2 0  )* 11  )(

!2 0 0 0   !

&  A@= 0 0   !

&  A@= 0 0   !

&  A@= 0 0   !

&  A@=E  

)   +%9"

( )* (

 )7,&   &%((   )%!(    )* $!

!   $!

!   $!

!   $!

!   ;1 $(( 2 033@    !

;1 $(( 2 033@    !

;1 $(( 2 033@    !

;1 $(( 2 033@    !

&  D44 &  D44 &  D44 &  D44 F +%9"

(  )* (

)%!(   '.' )15@@. ( (&     

 $  ;1 $((  )* 

 $  ;1 $((  )* 

 $  ;1 $((  )* 

 $  ;1 $((  )* **** !: !: !: !:2 )3100102&!+ &!+ &!+ &!+ +;1$(( )*!:2033@5

+;1$(( )*!:2033@5

+;1$(( )*!:2033@5

+;1$(( )*!:2033@5

!

!

!

!

& 0301

& 0301

& 0301

& 0301 $%**  () :2 *%!(

!  ) )* (

!    % !(!

 )(>!!(

*(  !%" ( )*(

@1

;

>)*,);

2(

8!

(8 &&)> 1

)!

)!

&)

*%!

9, &G %!

(:,) ()

 ( *(

/1) (!

&) )%!(G%(:'9 1)> !2

  () ) )  ( ( ": , "8)  ,: (

 )  (!

)%!(G%(:'

'9 2(

&& " ,)%,:(

*)&&)> 9 ) ) - 

&&)("





&&)(( )%"

(!:2%!



 

&&)(, .%

!(:9!( 1 "8 !> : 2)!&)!

(!

&1 (

&*):( *)!

(!

&1   

&& )( )""

( : )**  >

 ) , &1 ;



&& 8) (!

&)%!(1 ;

&& 9

9 ** !G$  &&)( 9

 !"

(!

&)

8 8)!(2 *:2>

  &&8  %", ! () (

 )* )  )&  $(( &&.8 %", !> )%(8!

)!

%!(G &&B'9

;

 

&& )(

 : " ! (!: ()  &: (

(!

&1 ;

 

&& %,"

(2)(

* ! (>)!

9:)*

!: ")( 2  ** ;

)%!(2 () (

** ( ( )""

))*:)**

 

)**  *(

 ,

9

 2)(

)*

* "( ()");

2*)!( > >

 8& 2 ,%( )* )%!

( (

)*1 (2 , *)!

 )  (!

  )( ,

*( !,

9!

), &1  *)% () ,  :

&!9  ) ,

 8!

** ;

()!)(

!>

2(

$((

> 2*)! &&( ))*

&& ,  !(  %8) 31

 )*,!

 )*:)*(

*)!

) ) ( )

>

":, "8) ,:) (!

&) )%!(G%(:'9  

,);

)! %8)

)> 9 : )(

%**

( %

G)"8& ( && ,  ( & !(: () ") );

  &&( ) )* , & )* (

!1 01 ! )! 9&:1 001

)(

9 

,);

&&, ) (!%   <8!

))* )8 ))(

"

( )*(

01 $

" 

 28 9"

&& )% 88& )2

*:2 &&& ) (  8) )**1 %9% (A %9% (A %9% (A %9% (A2 2 2 2 " ;

! L

! 8 L

!!

8)!(  A A A A

9G!

 ) - 

$'/ $'/ $'/ $'/     (,& -