Sultan v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!"# $!%&'(#)*"#
+,$
-&,& +$!$.$$/0&
&(1&
!"#$%&!&% '"#()!
&'
2,3&0$1$*1%$* !0(
+$1(+402$*+ *$.$$* !0+$
5$.$*1%$* !&(1& 6
77777 &% '"*+, &(!!%(*!&01$&%&%,18&1 ,( ,9&1 &(1&* * :;< $1 :;< 1, 9!4 ! %%$11&& +%0&$!1%$&1=&0$>$0$&8(&1 8.!0>
&*0&1&00&(1&? !0$?$11? $+-++$ ./0+
1 232 +4/+5+
$ ./+ - 2'&* 3 5+4,67 0 ( 0$& $(($%01 0& , ! @,$&04 0 A(,4111$1
!0+%$.;
0$8$<9 %,A9+A AA&&* $.$$* 0$14$0 1&A&&4 0 &(!18.0($4$&0$,%&$01
!$1 %A(&1 =0$&$
:B)#" A A$&,4 40$& &?$&,$1 $$ $$2$;&A$,&$<!
$4+?$*&%0?$$1&%!A$11$1 )
!$,!0$1;&%1%$&1<$1&49$&1!0$,%&$ 1$1
$1&%!A$1$1 )
?0$!,0($. !&&,$%?!A$1$A,&1%4&(1&
4,$& $,%&$!((.@,&!$,!0($&! 0&$1((.(&(%*0(A&*0$0 ($,%*0(0$18!,18&,%%&&!,811$1 1(&1 &
":B9 $& $& A. $1 0 &$ ?$& %!A1
)
8.0+A !!%;+$&<9%,A9&&&$AA&&*
0$8$$10(&&&&?$&110A)#
#$&0 $,%?$&&%1$5$&*?0110$A0$:&$1$1 $%&!$1 0A&$1%1&%A($10$0&$A&! $,%(%?,18 :0$!.$.%AA%4!A0$(&! .$!A01$!%!A$$1&D6E01, &$A&?,18%0$41 0&,%&1$1)
6 ;F, 9"<(A,4$1 8.0+$&$40$%$&!1!$,!($.A!&$A&*$. $5$*?00$1(,%0$&1,$$%,$1&%1&$8.$,%* 1&08$$%(%,A(&,A&$1!&$A*0$A,? 8$%%(1$1&1&$%!%$(&%81!A?8&&,1 $10&4$1*&,%&$.41?0$!A1%1 ?$&$&$1 0((.@,&?$&&,A18.00&1$ ;+$&<$1$A,1(&18.0(?$&!!111 1$1 "#
?* 0 .$
C* * "C
C 1
6 F,& 9"$1 9)*0(1(&1$A,!1, &$A&$&%A($10$!A1&,%&*8,0 +A !!%;+$&<9%,A9&& +A AA&&*$.$$* A8$$* 1 1 1$1 )
C ;F, 9:<* ,1 1? 0 !%&0A0(A&0$0(B1!$,?$& &10$1$$4$!0$,%0&!$,$111! 11,%!0$A,!,&$1%%,($%0$4&
0 $!A1 1 ?$& $&&$1 8! 0 (,. +%$. ;
0$8$<9%,A9+A AA&&* $.$$ 1 $& 6B(($B+ B+B $10&$A?$&1&A&&1
;F, 96< 0$!*0((!1&,1 ,
!0 $%3$4$ (. ,&$4$&09$,%1$1C
C# $1%!A$0!1$1
C#*?0%0?$&*111$1
;F, 9 <*1&A&&18.0+%$.;
0 <9%,A9 +A AA&&* $.$$ 0 $!A1 1 ?$& %0$418.!4 &
"6 !"## * *$!$4$(!& .$&8!0AA&&*&&$&*&&$*?0%0?$&*1 11$1""
"## *$&1&A&&1 0$!*0((!1 ?8!0AA&&$4$&011$1""
"## *?0%0 0%,1&,%%1$10&$A?$&5%1111$1
) "# ;F, < 2,3&0$1$*$1%,&(&40( 0$&1,(01%&118.0&48%0!0&,
686 *(+$ ./1 232%/ $+
+9+ ++ - 2,'1%11C "# %10$0&A$ !$%& $1 %%,A&$%&* 0& , 0$1 1%1 0 +$ (1
$$&$1*0!*&9$&10$,%8.44 6?3&A 0($&
5$.$*$1%,&(&4&(1& 6
&,8A&0$0$!A111$1C "# ?$&$&&$18.0 !!%1($.1>$ $(($
!"# $10&$A&$1& $1A1111$1
"# $10&$&$.1*8,&,8A&0$ 01%&!0&48%0%$8$1($A$$0!$%& $1%%,A&$%&!0(&%$&*!*F($$!1$.!& .$&$&&$401!
"## 0$&84*&&%*0 ?(&8!!0$!A1$A 0!4!& $10?&048,$$%!$44$1GA 2*0 (0$1&0?0&8$!1&!$A&0.$&8!0 $A,!$,%?$&!!1 (&!0$A,?,1F1 0A&($$%$,&!$%B40$&0!&0$,%?$&01
C#$1 %!A1
C"$10(%0$410&$A8,%,1 &,%%1*0,&*$$10!$.$1,4&0&,!1&A&&$!0 ?(
+A$&0$4,A!2 +$1(+402$*+ * $.$$ $11*0&,8A&0$0(0$1%0$4101 1$1
$!$A& C .$& $1* 0!*0 ? ( 1&&81&A&&104,1!1$.$1$%0&
0$0$10$1%,&!0($&$1$(($&1 0($(83
0!$%&*%1$8*$1&(,* *4$14 %!A$!0$,%!$,!0(*A,%0&&01 %$%40$A8.!!40$A, 0$,%01
C#
7 $1%!A1
C"&$&1&(,*0,400(0$1 4$%$4$&01!
0A$?04$10!!,!0$A,?0 $8$&+400&1$;+$&<*0?$0$1&0!%0 +A !!% ;+$&<9%,A9&&&$ +A AA&&* $.$$?$&9$4$1$1$!%&140$!A1!$%* ?$&*111$1)
C*,11? (($(!1*$&%1 $8* 0$& 8 1&A&&1
$1 0$! 0 A$ $$1 !$.
0(11$(($%00!0$,0&!&49 $&10%$%$*8,!?1$0($08.%0$440$,% !$,!0($&(1&*?0%0!$%&1!AF,
0&$A?$&1&A&&1
0&($1 ?(!1?$&1&A&&111&;F,& 9C$1
< F($$ 0$& %A !0 ! $&&$4 0 1 ! 0 %$%$$101$10$,%%!A1!$,!0 ($&(1&0$1$$1!$.
01&!0$,0&$ 1%$!0!$%!!,1!0$A,$!11,%40,& $1%%,($%0$4& A.?*0(1!$,1%A($% !0A&$1%1&*?0%0?&$%&$% 1,8*0(0$1$$10A1.*8,0!$% A$&0$00$1*$!
*A$1&$19$4$10A$ .?04$10$,%!$,!0($&(1& % 011$1
$%%(40!!,0$&8$$1!$.* 0(0$1%$,&!$%B4$%!$&&$40$,% !$,!0($&(1& 0&&A$.01!
0%91$8%0&0?8.0$1%,&!0(1,4
: 0%,&!00$4$1*0!*0@,&*A.?*0$& 8(11,($1*0!*%$81,(!$15,1%$ !0(&?(
A.?*01&$4$$15,&!1 0?( &?0.A&($%1$1$18408.1%$31$.$1 $%0& 0&$A&08.1&A&&1
;6' *&% , +< 2/ "#()!
/ 2;
+= .> +2
- ?
2>
/ ;
+4
?
2>