High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/16346/2013allowed

Balbir Kumar And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2021-04-09Mr. Justice Ajay Tewari,Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj10 pages

! " #$$ %

" # $ %&"

"("

")"$"* "

" # $ %&"

"("

" $ !!

" # $ %&"

"("

'( ) *+,-.'/012.((31.('2 ) *+,-.'/012.'(.0),)(' (

,- ",-$-$-"'.(/ 0

" - ,-"1,

.((---.&"- '(.0),)(' (

% "

/"%(&

" "( 03345336

%"('&"*% "0 %7 % 5,"( % 8 "*.

%0 ( (39-:-9;<6=""> !9?"(3@-:-9;<<=""> !3? ("( $0 " :"(4

A"(08 "0 .9<;:= "%

0 ? '0 /&"(

( (3-B-3@9C "*D

( (3;-@:-3@9C)0 "*

" "(%

(0"*

"("

" % 08 "*"*

*. &.%("( / /

' /

0 "( 09:

"(- &.

" "/ /("

>0'

%0 (%%"0 "

"( 0

"(08(

'0 /'

" - D/.% / &

%0 /" 1"% 7 !94C:4!3@9C ="(

# -$ %&""(

?- %0 >

%&" (

%0 "( (39-:-9;<6=""> !9?"($0 ":

0 "

"("*

"( "* CB-64 0 %

(/ '"

"( E %"( ("

"(0 0$0

99.1

% D(D

%0 ""($0 "4

0 ( (3@-:-9;<<=""> !3?- )0 " D"/ %

0 "0"("( D" "(% 0&"*

& 0 ".

D( D ' "0( &

A"( 08 0

. " . "0 1 "93-:-9;;@%

"( "* C:-490 "&- A"(08 " 0

(

D(F

-9.@<.@@@5!'0% D

"("(08 ""/*

* "( "-

F C@G "( (( " '" "F93G'""%

( %"

%0 ""($0 :

( %D(D *"

(- " ''"((

1 ) '" ""> !: "*D

"- "%

"((

% %

%0 "D (&

%&" "($0 ":

0 ( (99-3-3@@3% 08"*

"( "* 934-C@ 0 % ("

. 0 0 "( "

" ''

$0 "4"(99.1

- "%

"0 %"

%0 ""($0 "4

"( "*<9-;9 0 "*"*

:C"(

( D (.( %D 0 /"

%" ("':

:C "(

( "

691" @4 --<-;0 ."/* *.

"/*"

"( (D @;-@:0 -

' /(((

"( ( D"

' %"

%0 ""($0 "4

0 "(

"0 %D( 0 ' "

6(%%"

( "(

"( "

9C1" @< --@9-460 -

/*/"

% C9 (%%"

( D

"( D ( % 08 ""/D

( ' (&

* "/ D

" .

%D 0 "

C341" @< --:@-<@ 0 -

( /"''"(( "*D

" ""> !4

!<-

"((

& (0 "*(

% ( 08 " &%"* 7 !C69!3@@< D 0 D ( ( D

(D"/( (( (99-9-3@@<&*"

"* &

%' "

0 "0"(% (

*/"0- "0 "((

" %(' "

"( (33-9-3@@<"(

% *"

0( 9C-9-3@@;D (

"("

'&"*%

08("( "' &D

& (' " D

"(D (&

" (("

%"(%/ D

"("

&D% D

'' 0

* &%"*7 !9<C@!3@@;- D D(

(D"

* "(

' "

D (&'"("*. "0

' (&

" - "%

"((

$" D" "".D

D ("*D

(( '0%0"

"( (B-6-3@9@ " ('

"/D

"( % 08 ".

0""

(/ '(.D 0 % %

" "(

"'0( "0 ( ""> !9< D

"- '

/ '&(

0 %

"("

" "

( "* %

( D

"((&

("( "0)0

& &.

( 0"

&"(" ""

& %D- / ''"((

0 ( "(

/ (

* &

"H'> ' ( / * .

0 -

/('

/D 1"&

"H '> /( ( ( ( 36-C-3@9B "

(

> 0

' /'

"(+!

& (

"H'> "">(D

" ""> !3<- .

/ (

& "

0 (%%"

( "( "0

08("( ( /(

08 "-

(

0 "/D

/ (

* "(

"H'> .

0 8&0 /(% *"

%%. '&(% - %

" "

" / 0 "*(

08 ""('&(%

08("(- (

/'&(% 8 "*

(( (( (9B-4-3@93 =""> !96?- & /"

&%(7 !9CC64!3@@4 "*D

0 "

"( D" -

" */(

% C9"( D" .D

( (% 08 "-

"(0 ' (" -945C"

/* *"(/( (( (93-99-3@@6

"%(&

" --7 !9B333!3@@4D ( '

%"/D (( 39-;-3@@6- ( '

"&*"

"* &

1' "

0 "0"(-

"(/ &

"D "

"("D

" 9455C "

( % -94559C "( "0

0/ 0"

''0 " D %( 1"* 0 0 %

" 94559C"

( % -9455C- ''0 ""*,

-99;4; %3@@;"7 -9CC64 %3@@4D ( '

%/( ( ( (6-<-3@@;& /"*

'"%

''0"

1 ' "

/ - & "

""*

0 0 "D

0 " (("00 ("0D

D- ( """>(D

" ""> !:- (

0 "

"- &

"" $ %(

'&0 "*"*

%0 " "

% "

" - 0 &.

" "

"( "* 9;1";0 ' (" - -C. -4=C!96?.6=6!9<?.9:5C =3!@?.9B=B!9:? (D

/" %/*".

" . 0 1

D D"("('

'(0 !"!"

D '

08(/(

%0 ""(

08 "-

"'&(

- - "( %

(( %%"*% 0"0-%

(

"("8 ""(D 0

"" '0 %"8 "36-4-3@9C.

(' "

" 1"* "(

/&''

("( "("/D %

) 0 "1 % 08( "(- 0 '& %

' "

" ( 39-9@-3@9C """>(D

" ""> !9C-

* "( %0 "*/ &

" - % "0 %"

"("

''("0 "(%(

'0 /D

- '

"("

) %(

08 ""(0 "*"(% (

" " "*

08("('&

* "( %(& "(0 - "0 * 0&"

"("

D("

08 "D ""

"0( "93-:-9;;@

/'' 0

0 &D& %%"*

' "

" %

" 34 & %

- " %

0 '" "'(

" "(

"(/ "

( (D

- 7 / (0 " %

' "*

"(' (

' 0 ( (/- A"(0 " %

" $ - "$ -$-$- "' / / "

& 0 "((

" /D %

0"0 "* 0"

' (0( "0 (

*" &"*

* .

08(

% (

) "1

' "0

/ ' "

" ("(

( ' (&

/ * - "( D 08( %

0"("

"''

"$0 "4"(99.1

08("((&

( (-A"(0 " ''"*%

/ 1"

( ' (&

* D

"H'> "0

( 08 " D "

& / "

(

- A"( " / (D"

( ' (&

"H '> "

(

.D 0 "">( ""> !3<"(

0 '"0

D 0 "">( ""> !

3;-A"(0 " %

// "

&0 "((

4 0

" &"

%*" "0"

(%%"

"(0""*

D ( /(0

" * &( 0"

&"*/ / 09:

%"("(

( /

(- & /%

"((

% D 0

"( D 08(&

&(% (& "*

) "1

"("( /" %

" 0'

D"( &

" . 1'

D ( %"

% (/ '"*

% "

-- 0

4"(99. "/ *(&

$ - ,-"1,

"(((---.&" / "

/ 0 " (&

" -

/(&00'

0 '" "% 08

"(' "

D(.D 0 D ""

"0( "93-:-9;;@.

"(D 1"&

/ "

$ "( "0

0 %0 " '&"*%

"(08(-,-,

/&0"((&01"

D(*(

(/ '"

1'0"

0 "%0 "(* '0 %

( - (

. '0( "0 (( (& '"

08('

"$0

4 "(99.1

D 0 0 " /&( "0& 0""- ,-,

(D"

"(08("( (D 0

D""(%%"

0 - (

. (D"

"(08("( ("(

IAJ0 "("

& '"- (%

'" "*' (0( "(+!

% -.5.* $- - 08 "( %"(08("(A-0 .9<;:

"0 9- $0 "!:39-:-9;<6 :4-:;

3A"(>0((5 B 9@-<C C- $0 "!43@-:-9;<< CB-44 :- A"( ( D"5 4"(D( 9-@B B- D(93-@:-9;;@ C:-49 4A"( (% D( 34-<C 6-

%0 "8 (='

"H$' /?

<- "0A"(=B!=4K6?

6-6< ;- 7 '"("*5 3:=3?

:-@B4 9@- 7 '"("*

"5 3:=3?

9-93B 99- 7 ( (508 "'

( 93- 7 D(508 "8 (& "H*

$A %( &

%(- @-B@ .1(2-0 6 $- - 7 -

5 3:=3?

"$0 3:=3?

994C:453@9C# -$ %&"

5 3:=3?

3463;53@9C")"$"* # -$ &"

5 3:=3?

C9@:B353@9:" # -$ &"

5 3:=3?

:- C96653@94$ "

# -$ &"

" 0 "3:=3?

0 " %

' . "(

) "1

"( "*"*

& ("( D" (&

( ("(

D%"( /

& " *"

(/"0( & 0 " %

0 "

(%%"

D" D

"( (&

( (-7 *(D

% D 0

"(D 08( (&/ (

' '"% D 0

"(D 08(0""

%%(& ""*

" -"0.("&"*

" "

"(D ( / & %) 0- .

/ 00((" "*

"(0""*

'&%

'0 /08("( / / % 09:

%"("(

(-"0

% "

" D(00 ("*&-

" D(-

((31.('2 '(.0),)(' ( / 5.

/ 5.

01&

'1"*5 "(+ 5

+ 5