Ordnance Civilian Karamchari Sangh v. Commanding Officer And ORS
!!" #$% & '()*+,!
(-
!.
/&'&0&&1'2&3&42-2&+&$&5/3&42-&&/2&
6(*( 2 11&/4 '- ,- / 11* 7- .8
- 3*&&((-('&&/2(
(7/(
!"#$%&'" '& !(#$)*"
22 7( '&7&7(1&+9&:/(2;*/41<
9 /2 7(< , 222;*/41(2*/97/24(<
() $
&;(232-/'&# $ *:&-/'&- 27
$ ;(2:&3420&:&-/'&- 3&/4*(- /&
=====
'& !(#+ 2'2&427(:79+2 /&' & 0&&1'2& 3&42- 2&+& $&5/ 3&42- >(- &&/2&(217*4/&' 2(7/((7'4 &/2*42(1/&/
?"@* A %&/&(:&( 2171& 2//&/!!
!!"@* %
$
&;(232-&/'*(&77&492& 2 7A (*91(2&2119( 27A :
'*/2*4277'2&A17+1@'2&47*(*&'2 (*'(((*/9+2242&*2(2+&!CCB&/& 7*4&9*,AB+&( ('-!
?
!CCB2('( !?B :D1:1&/:2*((*4&+'-1*'2((-&+&/ /&/& 21& 2:D1-(7/
'/*'/ :!B !CCB 17+1 (2:D1-:2'2:&( */(4&/ 21&/&'&/3' .A 2/*(& (7*('-!CB 2:D(E :'17/(D& ' &/2>&9**-29&(( 2'((*(-7&((/&//&/
?"@* A % 2&7 2(&1(@&'/ 29:)A F
!
"#
$ % "
%
#
" &
'& (
#
%
!
'&
)"
#
" & #% "
#
"&
(
# !
'&
!
'&" * "
+,-
, .'/+
1
2 !
'&(
% "
- - " !-(!
3 3'2& 1/&:&/ 2>&9**:&( &''//-&&77'&/&/!B
C"@* A?%:&((*91/ 2 (/4 '&//'( 2(*'&/2 / /&/ !.
!! 7&((/ ( BC
!!
"@* AC%-(*/(19:2$&&41&/2 7A ///&/!!
!!"@* % 2&( *2 9(*91/2&/(72(1-2(7/(//2* 2(&1-:2'2'((&/27A (/&4&' /&/!
!!"@* A!!%-9*2(7/(//&/22 (&1-&2/@* /&/!B !!
!!((*/&7*9'& 4&77'&( '*1 $&5/&/ 19+ @42 &41&(!?A .+&(&/11*149+G*& '&&(1&' 2&(&(9(*91/2&/*424*1- - 2+&!CC8- .7((-/@* AB-2&9&D;9
2'/&/!
!!
!!-&4/2&9(2*424(/ 7(:/&+(9 2&/(1"@* %-:&(&&17 '17+:22(1-:2'22*42:&(1&/ 2&(2& 2'&(( &27(:;'/:2*'11*'& &+ /24*/2&2+// * 249+'/(&/- 2*(-(*'2&' 2(7/(E$&&41&1*/* &&9* 7&''
$ ;(2:&3420&:&-&/3&/4*( 2
-
/&A(7/((*91(2&/*92$&&412&/- 2+&!CC8-&D9&'D(' .17+(* 2( !?B '2/17+(-9*2& 2$&&412&(&D&+ (7('*2$&5/(E 1/&+:&4( *2(*91( 2&2(&*( 23&42(*/'2&4&(2(&1( 4(/&/2+&2119( 22&+&$&5/3&42
&((*91(2&2(1:&((7' 4&442:D1 /&+:&4(-:2: '&/4&':&(&(7// @* A8-:2:&(1/2&B&'&'( 1&/ !, &'&'( $&5/ & (*42 9 / 9+ '&*(4 & &/(12:(7&7&/2(2& '/'&//&(&( 72(7//:*/9((*/&/2+:*/9:2242( &77+ 2(&/7((:2 !/&+( 12/& 27*9'& 2&4/&/(1 -(*77 2('(-2&(/*7 2;*/41 2H93*71*// + ./01+ 303%+ 4++ . 4 3( '-%-'/ 2& 2 7((- :2 & &77/ /&+ :&4(- : 2&4 2 D:/4 & 2 '(G*'( &( 2&4 9 &77/ /&+E17&+9&((&/-2 -2+'&2&&42D2 2+ 41&@7'& 94' 1/27(
$ 32-9*&-(*91(2&2(&'&4'&1 27'&2&2:D1-:2:7& 2 '-:& 7&:2 .$&5/(-:2:'*/!CC8&/$&&412*42 (&'7+ 2'*1'&2&77'&(:2(&1(: (*91/&/-2 -/(21*2 2$&&41
5 (&+2&2:D1-:2:7& 2 '-&+9 '(// /&+:&4( 2&2&/2&/'*( 27&(&/&77&(/ 27&79D
2G*(7(/27(:7(&(:22 2(7/A$&&412&(2*/2(1E&:&/"@*
A %&/2/"@* % :*/9&77/*'2 (1&/&-:2'2&/(2*()A F24564 2* %76 146+(5(8' 2**(!64 !785('47 5%65
1 " # 9 ) '
)
(
" % "
# " .
#0
(
" % "
# #
# ( " # &
(
7 2
" (
&
#
"
"
" "# % "
%
" &
# " % "
(
&
& " #
6
"
&
"
9 )'
)
#
"# % "
"& +")
"# * "
# "& +,-12 ! 3 '*1*&&/4 2&:&//&/
?"@*
A %&///&/!!
!!"@* %-('+(&'&2&2 $&&412&/4&*/&D49 2>&9**4 &771&4&(2/ '7((&/:&(&4/2& &+ (4&7714&41:91&/71&'&/ '&(*&9&((-2(&1(2&91&/&(72&:&//&/
?
( *2/('92&2''/ '2&/(2:'111&/ ('+ 171& 2&:&/7&((/9+29*&-2*(- D74 : (*'2 (1- 2 7( : + 27 * (D4&77127((:2'22+::D4-9*2 27(2&9(2&/:2+ .7((* !?B'2/ 17+(:&D9&'D('-2&2+&!CC8 2'&*(4 7*9'&"@* %/&/!B !!
!!
9+ @4&419:!?A .+&(&/&(11*1G*& '&&( 1&'*&G*&2&(/7/27( 1(*914 2&77'&(-2*422@'(2&(9/9+2$&&41 9+ (/4 & ' /&/ !
!!
!! :2 : /&+( 9 2 &/(1'&4*721&77+7*(*&'2&/(1
&/2( &'(&(/ 12'( 27+24&' "@* A8% 3'27(// * 211*1&4 '&&/&(:&(2/*'&&G*& '&-9*(+2+'*/ (*91 2 &77'&( &771 &/ 2 (&/ 2 $&&412&/&2+2&'*/&+'&(*&E/&+&/ 17+(((*(&&9 (&'&'*1&/& 2(1- :2'2&(1& /*92&7&/&771'&(*& 9&((71&9&(( 2;*/41 2H93*71* &/0(2H('&("(*7&%/(&77+2 &'( 27('&( &(:&(&'&( 17+(-:2::D4/&+:&4(&/(*42 ' 1& 2(&'&(( (*'2D/
2&' 2$&&41&774 .17+(* !?B'2/17+(2+&!CC8(&'*&9@'( 7:(-1*'2((-* &&9*7&''&/-2*(-2((&/('1& &14(2(&1'&((&(27(2&9 242&//+
2 &' 2 $&&41 7(4 2 /&/
!!
!! ( 9&('&+ & &''& @'( / (2: 2& 2 $&&412&/&17/-1*'2((-'17/:22(1-9* 2 &'1&(2&2+:2D:/42&&27( :*/9('/ 2&((2&2+:9:2&4!?A
.+&(-1*'2((-2&/1&'*&' '&(
2&(((&/&9-2:7(&:/ 2 7(&29+//9 (&/('&4:2 '*+ (' :-2(2&9/:24&/2 &:&/4 9&'D:&4(-9*// &+24&@7((-2
7 $&&41 ( /'/ 7&+ '(/&/ (*1 . -
EA 2 7A &/(*'2@'((2*/9/:2&7/ : 12( 12/& '7 ' /'7+ 2(/- &4:2'2 2'17(& .
-
EA(2&& *2(I!
J7 &*1
#08,3(5 '& ! +1 #$)*"