← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1150/2020allowed

Rinku v. State Of Haryana

2020-11-03Mr. Justice Vivek Puri7 pages



     

 ! "#!#!

$ "% & '!()#!#!

*+ 

$$   +

,$$ "- 

/$ 

    

$&0 /$-,12)/ %$)"

$2.$$  0 *,123))-

4 5       



 



   2. $.$$ 2 '/%$/1 $$2 //$/ !6 !7 #!#!.

/'-$2///$ ,

+/1) $2'/) /32%2$2'..%$ "/'-$2.$$ +/,%$ (84 $2% $%+1 /

-%2 $ .%,+'

%$)76 5"

 $)9$2 %$9:)/3$2,%$ 8;5#:

3 / 

/

<#= "-)  $2    2  '  1 $/    .+ +%  "  $2 % - "(!!$'$ " . > /!!!$'$ "/  -/ %2 /" $2.

"$2.$$  <(= 2  2 '1 $/  !6 !( #!#!/$2 '

$$/$2$ $2 /-)$2.$$ 3  $//. /+%/"

$2 " $$$2  +$"

/ 2%22 '. $/ !?

!7 #!#!

 3)$2%23  $%% ./3$2$2.

 %,%%@'

$ - $2

'.

$/ +$$2$ .

"  $2  /  ,.%   +$  3

+12$  "

  A$ "  $    "$2% %% /1-) % .$ )$2

.$$ 2/ $$+$/$2"

/'..%$ *1% %

' 2'..%$ 2 '/ 

//$2.+1/ //$/ !6 !7 #!#!

 11/'-$2 / /)$2. $.$$ 2 '  $$+$/

<?= @/% + "

$2.$$ 2 .%/%   %2B+/1$   +$  

 

     

 

 !"# /%// (!

#!6)32$2 '2/$2$%2. $/ 3$2 +$$2.

"$22%A2 '$/ % .$ %2  32%2  /./  $2  01 $$  "  $  $  $  $* 1>%  2 +'

"% .$%23$2$2C+ $ . / 3 +/

$- +$/"+$'"$$ $2%%+ / +

..%$   /'-$2 $1$11%-.. 1$2 +$'

+$$2 $$+ " 3$2.-"

A$ "$ "$2 $2 '"+$2.

$/ +$$2$

C+$,1%2/%  +$$

% &'

  ( '



  #)*#!"# /%// #!7)$2 %2B+/1$  &  + ,

 - . /2 '/%/$ '.%+ 2 /B+/1$3

3/ $2,1%2B+/1$  +$ $ 

 ( '

0101

#!!"# /%// #!

# #!7

< = 2"$)$2 % $  -

% ../+.,1 %2/%   $   ( '



   ##!!"!"/%// 8 !7 #!#!/$2$$2 '

+12$$

'"/$  %2"

% /$2%%+ /3

//$ ' / '

<8= $2% $-)$2 '.

$/ +$'-$2/,$$ +   $2$  $2  .

$  "  $2 

 %  ,%%  @'

$ -  2  '

C+$- +'$$/$2 +$ #!

#!#!/$2% $$ "$2 $'/%'"/" $2' <;=   

   + ,

- . /  '+%2 " % )$2 %2  +$3 %/+.

$

 3$2C+ $ $24' 3&4 DE2$2$2. $$ ".

$+/,%$ ;( 5#:

)'-$2.

%3$2 +$$2.

"2% AF

 %  ,%%  @'

$ -   +$  $

% .$%2/$2'

% "-A$

"$+/,%$ (845?: "$2

, %$)$2 %%+ /  '  $$/  $  '  +/  ,%$   8;5#:



GH <6= E2*1"

/"%),1%22/"/ $3 C+ $ $2 //$/#6 #!8)32%2. /+%/24 ' 3&4

E2$2$2. $$ ".

$+/,%$ ;( 5#:

)'-$2.

%3$2 +$$2.

"%2% AF ,@ +$ % .$%2/$2 '

% "-A$ "$+/,%$ (84 5?: "$2 ,%$)$2%%+ / $$/$ ' +/,%$ 8;5#:

#

"  $2  .-     $2  ""$)  $2  32$    $2

$   1/1  %  -  + /   *

.+  /  .

..-  2+ *  $% )  32%2  %  '   - /$"/'-$2.

% ""%"  + .%$ )

 $ $GH

<7= 2     %2  %  $  $2  % %+   /  2/  

31&4



$2 

 3)$ 

$$2$$2.

$2  2%  A  '  %+//    $2  . $  +/ ,%$ ;(

/3$2 +$32%2$%$' $'$/  '  % .$ %2   /.1  $2  01 $$ $$$*% 1>%/"$  $ +'$$/ 3$2$2C+ $. / )$3 +/

$- +$/"+$'"$$ $2%%+ /+

..%$  /'-$2 $1$11%-.. 1$2 '

+$$2 $$+ " 3$2.-"

A$ $$ "$2 <!= /1/""$3$* C+$$3 ,1 %2/% $

% &'- . // $ + ,

 - . /$2,1%2 $2% $$/ $    ( '

- . :) '

/ "

31&4 D 3"%/3$2 $+$ 32% " $/ 3$2  $3  ,1  %2  B+/1$   "#$   %"

 "&"#  ''()# * "+"',$"'"

)# * "+/'/1 %2B+/1$-.'/$"&"#.")# * "+-$+ $2/ %$ " $/% )$2,1%2B+/1$  "#$ %"

"&"# ''()# * "+"',$"'"

)# * "+ '/1  $2--/ 3.

$ "3$2 +12 $%3$2$23// 3'-$2 %2 -.  '/$  "&"#  ."  # * "+   3)    A.

 - .%$"+/ 1$3$2$2"

$ /,1%2 B+/1$ $21 +/$2$ %2% +/2 /%/$2B+/1$ "1%2$ '.%+ 3 "$2/ %$ " $/% /

$2$$2.%.

"  .  %+  2  '  ../    + -  +/% / %.// $2$"%'/$  %2  1/1  $2  /$-  /  % %$

"  $2 "

$ /,1%2B+/1$

2" % ')$2+ ).%/'"

 9'$22"+ $%3$2C+ % $$+$ %2"

% $$

,%$232 '+ $$// /1$ % "+  1 $  $2  $   )  $2  $$  -  '  % // +1$-

032)$ /%$/$2$$2.$$ ' /

' "+ 21'/ +$-'

/

"$2$ <= $2 %%+ )$$ $2$C+ $2 ' / $  $2  9'  2"  + $%  $  % $$+$      %2  "

 "$2$$   032) $ 3

/%$/ $2$  $2 %%+ /' / '

<#= $ 2 $' +$ ".%$ $ 2$2$ $2 ,1%2/% // 0 '2 .    

  3*!"!" /%// # #!#!)$2 %%+ /3 1$//"+$'"$$2A.-  $2%2 3  $%% ./3$2$2.

"$22%A/% 3 .%/+.

 %2/% -.'/$ #0"#)# * "+ <(= 21+$ "$2/,$$% + $2$$2% $$ $2$'$ /$"'" $2')% $'%%.$/.$%+- '%+ $2%  "-.'/$)# * "+ $2 '2/ "

31&4 DE$2 .%$$ $2C+ $ .

/'-$2/ ,1  +/1  1/1 

  "  $2  % $'/  '1 /$"'  $2 +12  */  -)   .%$   ' /  A.%/* 3/1)3 +/'1$"%-/3 +/ .%$"+- $$$2$$3 +/'1

-+ "$

-+.

+%2 . ' / */- .%$ '%*/'-A.% * 3/1$ $."%

. "  $2  % 

"    ""%  $ +'$   %%+ /$ $21  "$'-$201 $$$2A%

"$ .

3 +/,%$ 7!

2 -3-$2$$%'/   $' 2$2



$+ "% $'/ $2' "$22%A9

.

$/"

$2 

)$22%A9 .

$ 

+       1"%%  "

  $2  $   +$)  $

+$ .  $2-% 1>% " ""% +/  /./    $   4%+ "  $2  2% A9 . $2.

$+/,%$ ;(

) +/A.

$2%%+ /$ +"

+///1 .1 /  /11  2  '$-  %  $2  .  "  $2 

,%$$ ..%'$-$ $/% %+ 

$1$% C+% <?= ) C+$. $$ "$2.

" ,@"$

+'

"'..%$ )3 $A$1+ 2$212$ "$2.$$  */"+$'/$2 1/)"%%'/$ $2 9',+. +$/% 0   4 5

, 6,7, 5

,

..



 !"!" /%// #8 #!#!

2.

" ,@ $$/$ 2'

+'$$/ #!

#!#!) )"$$2. $$ //

 "$2 ..%$ $2/,.% +$//+1$2./%- "$2 . $ .$$  +%2)$% $' /$2$$212$$ /"+$ ' $/ A$1+ 2/

< = I.1    3  $2  $  %%+  11    $2  $$% )$$ $2$% .$%23 . $/$2  C+ $3 +'$$/$ / +$'-$2 $1$1 1%- *1A$ "$"

$2.+.

 " "$2 %  $2A.- ". / )$2%%+ /2  */$2 B+ /%$ "$2 +$ *1/"+$' 2$$2 '// +.

,1%2B+/1$  +$  &1"

 # #.".21 "

("'")# * "+32)$2$$2 '/%$/$ '.%/'"

9'$22"+ $%3$2C+ $$ % $$+$ %2"





"$2$$/"+$2 )$2%%+ /2 ' // ' / '

<8= $2  $ "%%+ )$2.$$ $2 $$%

$$/$ $2'"$ "/"+$' %% +$ "$2.

 $2 .$  "  $2  .

%+$     +'

"  $2  %2  32%2  3   %% ./3$2$2.

"$22%AF

 %,%% @'

$ -)3$2$2 $.+$/$. / <;=

$2"

/

)$2.$$   3//$2 / /$/ !6 !7 #!#!  .

/  '-  $2  /  //$   ,

 +/1)

$2'/) $4 / 2.$$  /%$/$ ' / ' 2 "+ 21''

/ / +$-'

/ "$2$ 2%3 45 6464   ) +  78