Vishal Aggarwal v. Union Of India And ORS

  








 

 
  

     ! 



 
 
 !"#$%
&&$'($%

))
*+!+!,*'













*'"-"

,!,

,.!$
$,.
+#*'"
) *"/,.*,+"



01
 
 
 !"#$%
&&$'($%

))
*+!+!,*'













*'"-"
2+$+*

$'3$,$
$,.
+#*'"
) *"/,.*,+"
 4

 56

 2
22
2 

 56
2
 2
62
66

'*"*,+47
'
$!,$!,.*'
2$!,!8
.9:$+*8
'
+#*
/*+!+!,*'
'
$&.**/
#$,;$'8
2*,!'
.9:$+*8
(!+#

'
6;*"#
2!,#$%8
..%
.9:$+*
*,*'$%8
$'3$,$
$,.

'
2-'*,.*'
2!,&#
$,,-8
8
$'3$,$

'
+#*
'*"/,.*,+
7
2+$+*

$'3$,$

<<<<
22
2$',8

!"#$%
&&$'($%
/*+!+!,*'
!,



 
#$"
/'$3*.

$
('!+

.*:%$'$+!,
+#$+
+#*
:$%%!,&
'
$,.
#%.!,&

=9!%*,+
$&!+$+!,58
':* -%
=>$,.#58
='$.
?$@58
=>%:;$.*

'$!%($3
+'$:;"5
$,.
"!@!%$'
$:+!9!+!*"
>3
/'!9$+*
'*"/,.*,+"
'
$,3
"-:#
+#*'
'&$,!A$+!,
'
/*'",
'
$+
@@-,!+3
$&$!,"+
+#*
!,+*'!@
'.*'
/$""*.
>3
+#!"
-'+
,
  
!,
+#*
:$"*

=-'$'!
6$%
-/+$
9
2+$+*
 $'3$,$
$,.
+#*'"5


BBC

 
$,.
'
/'*""-'!A!,&
+#!"
-'+
+
(!+#.'$(
+#*
!,+*'!@
'.*'
$,.
$%"
/'*""-'!A!,&
+#*
&9*',@*,+

 

'
&*++!,&
$
$9-'$>%*
.*:!"!,
'@
+#!"
-'+
'*&$'.!,&
!,:%-"!,

$+
$"+*
!,
*,+'$%
'
2+$+*
6!"+

$:;($'.
%$""*"
'
'
'*"*'9$+!,
!,
&9*',@*,+
"*'9!:*"
!"
-,:,"+!+-+!,$%8
9!%$+!9*

'+!:%*"
B
$,.

 +#*
,"+!+-+!,
$,.
$%"
!,
:,+'$9*,+!,

+#*
.!'*:+!9*
/'!,:!/%*"
 2+$+*
/%!:3
*@>.!*.
!,
+#*
,"+!+-+!,
$,.
+#*
-,.$@*,+$%
.-+!*"
*,-@*'$+*.
!,
+#*
,"+!+-+!,
$"
$%"
$
/*,$%


*,:*
-,.*'
+#*
,.!$,

*,$%
.*
$,.
!%%*&$%
!,
9!*(

+#*
?-.&@*,+
.$+*.
D C 
/$""*.
>3
,5>%*
+#*
2-/'*@*
-'+
!,
$@
2!,&#
$,.
+#*'"
9
,!,

,.!$8
 
0
2
BD8
$,.
+#*'
?-.&@*,+"

-'+#*'
/'$3*'"
#$9*
>**,
@$.*
'
+$;!,&
"+*/"
$&$!,"+
9!%*,+
$&!+$+'"
+
"$9*
+#*
%!

*8
%!>*'+3
$,.
/'/*'+3

+#*
:!+!A*,"

+#*
2+$+*

$'3$,$
$,.
$%"

'*"!.*,+"

+#*'
2+$+*"
.-*
+
+#*
9!%*,+
$&!+$+!,
*+:
#*
/*+!+!,*'
7
!"#$%
&&$'($%
!,
+#*
"*:,.
/*+!+!,8
!*


01
 8
#$"
/'$3*.

$
('!+

.*:%$'$+!,
+#$+
+#*
2+$+*
>*
'*"+'$!,*.
'@
/$3!,&
+#*
*E/*,"*"
!,:-''*.
,
+#*



/$'$7@!%!+$'3
':*"
'@
/->%!:
*E:#*F-*'
+#$+
#$9*
>**,
.*/%3*.
!,
+#*
2+$+*
;**/!,&
!,
9!*(
 !:+!+!-"
:$%%
'
$&!+$+!,
>3
+#*
/'!9$+*
'*"/,.*,+"
$,.
$,3
+#*'
"!@!%$'
'&$,!A$+!,
"
'
/*'","
"**;!,&
&$!,
!,
+#*!'
/%!+!:$%
%!

*
(#!%*
+#*3
$'*
!,
,
($3
%*&$%%3
'!&#+
!,
@$;!,&
+#*
:$%%
'
$&!+$+!,

-'+#*'
/'$3*'
#$"
>**,
@$.*
'
!""-$,:*
 $//'/'!$+*
.!'*:+!,"
+
+#*
2+$+*
+
'*:9*'
+#*
$>9*
*E/*,"*"
'@
+#*
/'!9$+*
'*"/,.*,+"
'
$,3
"-:#
+#*'
'&$,!A$+!,
'
/*'",
(#
#$9*
+$;*,
/$'+
!,
+#*
$&!+$+!,


"+!%%
-'+#*'
/'$3*'
#$"
>**,
@$.*
'
!""-$,:*

$//'/'!$+*
.!'*:+!,"
+
+#*
2+$+*
,+
+
>-'.*,
+#*
:!+!A*,"
 $'3$,$
,
$::-,+

+#*
*E/*,.!+-'*
,
+#*
.*/%3@*,+

/$'$7@!%!+$'3

"

':*"
!,
+#*
($;*
 !:+!+!-"
:$%%
'
$&!+$+!,
>3
+#*
/'!9$+*
'*"/,.*,+"
$,.
$,3
+#*'
"!@!%$'
'&$,!A$+!,
"
'
/*'","
'
"**;!,&
&$!,
!,
+#*!'
/%!+!:$%
%!

*
$,.
+#*3
$'*
!,
,
($3
%*&$%%3
'!&#+
!,
@$;!,&
+#*
:$%%
'
$&!+$+!,


"+!%%
-'+#*'
/'$3*'
#$"
>**,
@$.*

$//'/'!$+*
.!'*:+!,"
'
'.*'"
+
+#*
/'!9$+*
'*"/,.*,+"
'
$,3
+#*'
"-:#
'&$,!A$+!,
'
/*'","8
(#
#$9*
+$;*,
/$'+
!,
+#*
$&!+$+!,8
+
/$3
+#*
*E/*,"*"
!,:-''*.
,
+#*
.*/%3@*,+

+#*
/$'$7@!%!+$'3
':*"
$,.
+#*'

':*"
!,
+#*
!,+*'*"+

/->%!:
$+
%$'&*
," $'
$"
$@
2!,&#5"
:$"*
"-/'$
!"
:,:*',*.
$,.
+#*'
:,+*,+!,"
'*&$'.!,&
+#*
'*"*'9$+!,8
+#*
"$@*
#$9*
>**,
.!"/"*.

>3
$
"*/$'$+*
?-.&@*,+
/$""*.
+.$3
!,
-'$'!
6$%
-/+$5"
:$"*
"-/'$
 
BBC
 

#*
+#*'
/'$3*'"
$"
@$.*
!,




 
$'*
:,:*',*.
,
%,&*'
"-'9!9*
$"
+#*
$&!+$+!,
'
(#!:#
$:+!,
#$"
>**,
/'$3*.
'
!"
,(
,+
+#*'*


#*
/'$3*'"
'*&$'.!,&
'*:9*'3

*E/*,"*"
$,.
,+
+
>-'.*,
+#*
:!+!A*,"

$'3$,$
,
$::-,+

*E/*,.!+-'*
,
+#*
.*/%3@*,+
 /$'$7@!%!+$'3
':*"
*+:
$'*
@,!>-"
$,.
!+
(-%.
>*
.!

!:-%+
!,
*E*':!"*
 +#*
('!+
?-'!".!:+!,

+#!"
-'+
+
&
!,+
+#*
"$@*
,
+#*
>$"!"
 @$+*'!$%
+#$+
#$"
>**,
/%$:*.
,
'*:'.
(*9*'8
(*
&!9*
%!>*'+3
+
+#*
/*+!+!,*'8
!

"
$.9!"*.8
+
!%*
$
'*"#
/*+!+!,
@$;!,&
@'*
:@/'*#*,"!9*
$,.
.* !,!+*
:%$!@"
'
/$3@*,+

:@/*,"$+!,
$,.
$&$!,"+
(#@
!*
(#
(-%.
>*
+#*
!.*,+!

!$>%*
'*"/,.*,+"
'@
(#@
"-:#
$
:%$!@
:-%.
>*
@$.*

'*
@$+*'!$%
(-%.
#$9*
+
>*
!%*.
+
"-//'+
"-:#
$,
$""*'+!,G
>*"!.*"8
!+
(-%.
'*F-!'*
:,"!.*'$+!,
$"
+

 (#*+#*'
"-:#
$
/'$3*'
:$,
>*
&,*
!,+
!,
*E*':!"*

+#*
('!+
?-'!".!:+!,

+#!"
-'+
-,.*'
'+!:%*


+#*
,"+!+-+!,

,
+#*
:!':-@"+$,:*"8
>+#
+#*
('!+
/*+!+!,"
$'*
.!"/"*.

!,
+*'@"

+#*
'.*'
/$""*.
+.$3
!,
-'$'!
6$%
-/+$5"
:$"*
"-/'$

(*9*'8
%!>*'+3
!"
&'$,+*.
+
+#*
/*+!+!,*'
+
!%*
$
'*"#
/*+!+!,8
!

"
$.9!"*.8
>3
:%*$'%3
"+$+!,&
$"
+
(#
$'*
+#*
'*"/,.*,+"
'@
(#@
"-:#
'*:9*'!*"
:$,
>*
*

*:+*.
$,.8
!

"8
(#*+#*'
!+
:$,
>*
.,*
!,
*E*':!"*
 ('!+
?-'!".!:+!,

+#!"
-'+











22
2 






 











62
66





 

 B D

$@*"#
 

#*+#*'
"/*$;!,&H'*$",*.

4

*"

#*+#*'
'*/'+$>%*

4