High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1819/2006allowed

Rajinder Kumar v. State Of Hry. Etc.

2025-09-08Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja6 pages

/*(

(4-"-)$

G !"

!" # # # # 55(../)* 55(../)* 55(../)* 55(../)* # # # # ("5)2()* ("5)2()* ("5)2()* ("5)2()*" $ $ $ $ '("()*$ '

% & # # % & # # % & # # % & # #

#+",-. #,/'0/1234/*( *,(/55(../)*"@./)2:)(' 6,-)/", /-)1 1/'7/) )/ CCCC 1 '/. 1 '/. 1 '/. 1 '/. # # # # 89

7 :/7 5'("()* /55(/.1 4,/..() );( ,/" 6(() ./-2 * *,( 2(4-"

"-) 2/*(2

5/""(267*,(.(/')(222.

-"*'-4* +2;(1-"/',('(-)/ *('

'* 6( '( (''(2 /" *,( <( ('()4( +'*=1 :,('(6 67 ( ('()4( (*-*-) -.(2 +) #(4*-) *, ,(&/)24>+-"-*-)4*1 ? '",'*<*,(4*=/**,(-)"*/ )4( -*/*-) ./)2:)(':

:/"'(D(4*(26(-);6/''(267.-09 '

-( .7 "*/*-);1 -) *,( 5'("()* 4/"(1 "0( ./)2 :)(2 67 :)(' "-*+/*(2 :-*,-) *,( '(3()+ +( ("*/*( 3-../;( -"/' /26 6/"* ?1 (,"-. -"*'-4* -"/'1 4/0( *6( ( /4>+-'(2 3-2(*- -4/*-)" 2/ /*(2

/)2 E

F-""+(2+)2('#(4*-) )"? *,(4*'("5(4*-3(.7

*,( 5+6.-4 5+'5 5"( 2(3(.50()* /)2 +*-.-A A/*-) *,( ./)2 ' '("-2() )*-/. 5+'5"("1 ..:

:(267:/'25/""(267* *,(&/)24>+-"-*-)..(4*' ",'*<*,(&= =)

G-)*('0" #( (4*-) ?4*1*,('( (67 2(*('0-)-);*,( 0/'B(*3/.+( *,(/4>+-'(2./ /)2*6("1G

@H5('/4'(

4,/,-./)2/)2 "?

@H5('/4'( ';/-'0 0+0B-)./)2,(405()"/*-) )-) *('0" *,( / '(0()*-)(2 /:/'2 :/ /" '(.(/"(2 -) /3+' :)(')

8F9 ;

;;'-(3(2 *,(/""(""0()*0/2 2(67*,(.(/')(2&/)24>+-"-* ..(4*'1 *,( / /55(../)*H./)2:)(' -.(2 ( ('( ()4( +)2(' #(4*-) *,( 4*1 :,-4,:/" ':

:/'2(2**,(.(/')(2( ('()4( +'*1,:(3('*,("/0(4/0( (* 6(2-"0-""(23-2 2(2(4-"-)2/*(2

I6( (-);*-0(6/''(2 8?9 05 5+;)-); / '("/-2 '2 2('1 .(/')(2 4+)"(.

:)('"+60-*"*,/*-)*,(5'("()* *4/"())*-4( *,(:/'2 '/ 457*,('( /" 4)*(05./*(2+)2('#(4*-) ?4*:/"(3('"('3 3(2 +5) *,( /55(.

../)*@./)2:)(' * ,/" /." 6( (() 5-)*(2 +* *,/* *,( .(/') )(2 ( ('()4(+'* *:()*:');:,-.())H"+-*-);

;*,(/55(../)*67'(4'2-);*,/* *,( :/",/3-);B):

:.(2;(/6+**,(/4>+-"-*-)5' 4((2-);"/")*-4(+)2('#(4*- ) ?4* :/""('3(2+5),-0/)2/'(5.

7*,('(*(3()6(() -.(26( '( &&(/')(24 4+)"(. +'*,('"+60-*"*,/*)*- 4(+)2('#(4*-) ? 4* 4/))*6((>+/* *(2:-*,*,()*-4(+)2('#(4*- ) ?4*/)21*, ,+" *,('2('5/""(2 267*,(( ('()4(+'*:/".-/6 6.(*6("(*/"-2( 8G9 ) *,(*,(',/)21.(/')(2#*/*(4 +)"(."+60-*"*,/*-)*,( /4*"/ 4-'4+0"*/)4(" *,(4/"(1)-..(;/.-*74/)6(

+)2:-*,*,('(/")-);'(4'2 2(2 67*,(.(/')(2 ( ('()4(+'*/"*,('( ('()4( (5'( (''(2+)2('#(4*-) ?4*/**,( (-)"*/)4( /55(../)*@./)2:)( (':/"4.(/'.76/''(267.-0-*/*- -) &(/')(2#*/*(4 +)"(. +'*,('"+60-*"*,/**,( :/'2+)2('#(4*-)

? 4*-)*,(5'("( )*4/"(:/"5/""(2)

G67*,(.(/')(2&:,('(/" '( ('()4( :/"

-.(2 ) F

I *,+;, *, ,( 5/70()* 405()"/*-) :

'(.(/"(2 * *,( /55(../)*@./)2:)(' )

/)2 ,( :/" ,/3-); 405.

.(*( B):.(2;( *, ,( /4>+-"-*-) 5'4((2-);" ,/3- -); -.(2'(5.7 * *,()*-4( +) #(4*-) *,( ?4*"('3(2+5),-0I*,+"

"*,(5'("()*/55(/.:/".-/6.(* 6( 2-"0-""(2 89 , ,/3( ,(/'2 .(/')(2 4+)"(. *,( 5/'*-(" /)2 ;)( *,'+;, 5/5('6B 8E9

(

'(2(.3-);+5)*,(-""+(-), ,/)21-*-")(4(""/'7*;*,'+ +;, *,(5'3-"-)" #(4*-)" /)2

?4*1*,("/0(/'('(5'2+4(2 2/" +)2('$H #(4 #(4 #(4 #(4 4*-)

4*-)

4*-) ?4* ?4* ?4* ?4* J *-4(*5('")"-)*('("*(2K ,( ..(4*' ",/.. *,() 4/ /+"( 5+6.-4 )*-4( * 6( ;-3() ) /* 4) )3()-()* 5./4(" ) ' )(/' *,( ./)2 * 6( */B()1 "*/*-); *,/* 3 3(')0()* -)*()2" * */B( 5""(""

"-) *,( ./)21 /)2 *,/* 4./-0"

" * 40 05()"/*-)" '/..-)*('("*"-)"+4, ,./)20/76(0/2(*,-0 #+4,)*-4(",/.."*/*(*,(5/'*- -4+./'" *,(./)2")((2(21/)2", ",/.. '(>+ >+-'(/..5('")"-)*('("*(2-)*,(.

./)2*/55(/'5('")/..7'67/;

;()* 6(

'(*,(..(4*'/*/*-0(/)25./ ./4(*,('(-)0()*-)(2"+4,*-0( )* 6(-) -);(/'.-('*,/) - *(()2/7"/ *('* *,(2/*( 5+6.-4/*-) *,()*- -4(1 /)2 2 * "*/*( *,( )/*+'( *,(-' '("5 5(4*-3( -)*('("*" -) *,( ./)2 /)2 2 *,( /0 0+)*/)25/'*-4+./'" *,(-'4./-0 0"*405()"/*-) '"+4,-)*('( ("*"1 /)2 2*,(-'6D(4*-)"- /)7**,(0(/ (/"+'(0()*"0/2(+)2('"(4*-) ,( .

..(4*'0/7-)/)74/"('(>+-'("+4 4,"*/*(0()**6(0/2(-):'-*-); "-;) )(267*,(5/'*7',-"/;()* F ,( ..(4*' ",/.. /." "('3 3( )*-4( * *,( "/0( (

(4* ) 44 4+5-('- /)7 "+4,./)2/)2) /.."+4,5('")"B):)'6(.-(3(2 (2* 6(- -)*('("*(2*,('(-)1'*()*-*.(2* /4* '5('")""-)*('("*(21/"'("

"-2( ' , ,/3( /;()*" /+*,'-A(2 * '(4(-3( 3( "('3-4( ) *,(-' 6(,/.

1 :-*,-) '(3( 3()+(2-"*'-4*-):,-4,*,(./)2-""- -*+/*(

? )4/"(/)75('")"-)*('("*( (2'("-2("(."(:,('(1/)2,/")"

"+4, /;( ()*1*,()*-4(",/..6("()**,-0 0675"*-).(**('/22'(""(2*,-0 0/* ,-" ./"*B):)'("-2()4(1/22'(""'5 5./4('6+"-)(""/)28'(;-"*('(2+) "(4* 4*-)" /)2

*,()2-/)"*

-4(4*1 9 #(4 #(4 #(4 #(4 4*-) 4*-) 4*-) 4*-) ?4* ?4* ?4* ?4* ,(..(4*'",/..;-3(-00(2 2-/*()*-4( ,-"/:/'2*"+4,

*,( 5('"

'")"-)*('("*(2/"/'()*5'("()* 5('")/..7'67*,(-''(5'("()*/*- *-3(" :,( ,()*,(/:/'2-"0/2(L 8 9 20 0-**(2.71-)*,(5'("()*4/"(1*, ,(:/'2+)2('#(4*-) ?4*:/"5 5/""(2)

G/)2405 5()"/*-)-)5+'"+/)4(*,('( :

'(.(/"(2 * *,( /55(../)*@./)2:)(' )

,('(/ *(' '( ('()4( +) #(4*-) *, ,( ?4*:/"5'( (''(2/**,( -)"*/)4( /55(../)*@./)2:)('

F F

-(:

:-*,-) 0)*," *,('(4(-5* 5/70()* 405()"/*-):, ,-4, -) /4*4/)6(/* **'-6+*(2/"*,(2/*( B):.(2 2;( *,(4)*()*" :/'2* :)('('+"/. '(4'2",:"*, ,/*))*-4(+)2('#(4*-) *,( ? 4* :

:-*, '("5(4* * 5/""-); *,( :/'2 ' (3() /6+* *,( 4)*( ()*" *,('( :/"(3('

'"('3(2+5)*,(/55(../)*@./)2 2:)('67*,('("5)2()*""+ +4,

-)2-);:/"(3( ()'(4'2(2/;/-)"**,(/55(../) )*/)2-) /3+' '("5)2()*"

67 *,(.(/')(2( ( ('()4(+'* 9 +'

'*,('1 *,( .(/')(2 ( ('()4( +'* :()* :'); :,-.( ))H"+-* *-); *,(/55(../)*) )*,(;'+)2*,/*,(:/",/3-);

;B):.(2;(/6+**,(/4>+-"-* 5'4((2-);"I0( ('(.7,/3-); -.(2'(5.7**,() )*-4(+)2('#(4*-)

? 4*"('3(2+5) ),-0,("/-2'(/")-);'(4'2 2(267*,(.(/')(2( ('()4( +'* :/".(;/..7+)"

"+"*/-)/6.(('+"/. *,(5'3- -"-)"'(5'2+4(2-)*,(5'(4(2 2-); 5/'*'( .(4**,/* )*-4(+)2('#(4*-) ?4*-""('3(2+5)*,(5('

-)*('("*(2 ).7 * 4/.. +5) ,-0 ' *,( 5+'5 5"(" 3('- -4/*-) )/*+'( ( -)*('("*-)*,(./ /)2/)2*,(4./-0"/"'(;/'2"* *,(405()"/*-) '"+4,-)*('

'("* ,()*-4(+)2( ('#(4*-) ?4*'

' -.-); '(5.7-)'("5)"(*,('

'(* 4/))* 67 /)7 "*'(*4, -0/;-)/*-) 6( "+6 6"*-*+*(2 /;/-)"* *,( )*-4( +) #(4*-) ?4*:,-4,-" '/ "5(4- -4/)24/*(;'-45+'5"(

0/B-); *,( 5( ('") -)*('("*(21 :, 4+.2 )* 5'("()* ,-0"(.

' *,'+ +;, '(5'("()*/*-3(/* **,(*-0( 5/""-); :/'2I *,(4)*()*" *,(:/'2 8 9 )* *,(5'("()*4/"()"+4, -)2-);

;,/"6(()'(4'2(267*,(.(/') )(2 ( ('()4(+'* **,/**,(./)2:)(':/"(3('"( ('3(2:-*,*,()*-4(+)2('#(4* *,(

? 4* /)2 -) "+4, 4-'4+0"*/ /)4("1 *,( '2(' 2/*(2

5/""(267*,(.( (/')(2( ('()4(+'*:,('(6 67*,(( ('()4((*-*-)5'( ('

''(2 +)2('#(4*-) ?4*/**,(-)"*/) )4( *,(/55(../)*@./)2:)(':

2-"0-""(2 6(-);

; 6/''(2 67 .-0-*/*-)1 -" ,('

'(67 "(* /"-2( /" *,( "/0( :

/20-**(2.7 -.(2 2:-*,-)"-M0)*," *,(2/*( '(4(-5* 405()"/*-)67 ./)2:)(' 89 +'

'*,(')*,(-""+( >+/)*+0

0/'B(*3/.+( *,(/4>+-'(2./ /)21 .(/')(2 4+)"(.

. ' *,( 5/'*-(" /'( /2 -2(0 *, ,/* *,( 0/**(' :-*, '("5(4* * 2(*('0-)/*-) 0/'B(* 3/.+( "*/)2" -)/..7 /2D+2-4/*(2 +5) 67 *,( )= =6.( 5(M+'*3-2 2(-*"2(4-"-)2/*(2 ?

5/""(2-)-3-.55(/. -3-.55(/. -3-.55(/. -3-.55(/."?

?FH ?

G? ?

*- -*.(2/"J/0 /-'" /0 /-'" /0 /-'" /0 /-'"3"# 3"# 3"# 3"# #*/*( /'7/)//)2 #*/*( /'7/)//)2 #*/*( /'7/)//)2 #*/*( /'7/)//)2'" '" '" '"L:,('( (67 *,( "-0-./'.7 "-* *+/*(2 ./)2:)('" 5('*/-)-); * *,( "/0( /4>+-"-*-) 5'4((2- );" ,/3(6((),(.2 ()*-*.(2 '*,((),/)4(2/0+) )* 405()"/*-)N"F G@H 5(' ">+/'(7/'21/. );:-*,/.."*/*+*'76()( -*" (.(3/)*5/'/;'/5,E*,('(

-" (M*'/4*(2,('(+) )2('$H

JE ,('( '(1 /.. *,("( /55(/."

" /'( 5/'*.7 /..:(2 ,.2-); * *,/* /55 5(../)*" :-..6(()*-*.(2**,(./) )23/.+( -M(2/*"F G@H5(' #> 2 /.) );:-*, /.. "*/*+*'7 6()( -*" :(3('1 *,( /55(../)*" ",/.. )* * 6( ()*- *-*.(2*/)7"*/*+*'76()( -*" '*, *,(5('-2 2(./7-) -.-);*,("5( (4-/. .(/3 3(5(*-*-)"/)2*,(5('-2 2(./7 7-)'( -..-);*,("5(4-/..(/3(5(*-*- *-)" / *( ('4+'-);*,(2( (4*"L 8 9 44 4'2-);.71 *,( 5'("()* /55(/ /. -" /..:(2 -) *('0" / '(0()*-)(2 2(4-"-) -( /0 /0 /0 /0 /-

/- '"

'"= 4/"( "+5'/ /)2 :)('-",(.2()*-*.(2 '"-0-./'/ /0+)* 0/'B(*3/.+(N"F

G@H 5('">7/'2/", ,/"6(()/:/'2(2**,('"-0-./ /'.7"-*+/*(2./)2:)('"I/.);:

:-*, /.."*/*+*'76() )( -*"/)2-)*('("*/3/-./6.(+)2( ('*,(/0()2(25'3-"-)" &/ 4>+-"-*-)4* 1 ?/"/55.-4/6.(**,(5'("() )*/4>+-"-*-) 8F9 () )2-);/55.-4/*-)"1- /)7",/.. /.""*/)22-"5"(2 # # # #

#(5*(06('

1111

*-B

G O, O, ,(*,('"5(/B-);@'(/")(2 ("

,(*,(''(5'*/6.( ("

"@ "@