Harpal Singh v. Union Of India And ORS
!
"#$# %& ' '
(& )* ('
+ + +
! "
# $
!!% &' (((( + +
,
'
-*.
* ! "++,-++.
# "* / * 0
1
+23+34 5!
678'/ +9
"/5 8:# ; " * <
* +
& " * * '/ 1"
* /
" $
; " #
* * = 3++3.
=
15!
6>8 *
; "
+ #
' " " *
!
633+3. *
* # " '/ $
! / #
" "
" "
1?/*/ " *"
'6 '1 " ""
"
"1 " * 1
1
! " '
) "*
/
/ " / / * /
" / * /" ' ,>3.+723.3+3, " 35$85"8@
/
/ " / A " "
!
6 " @
!"#"!$
%&'( )*+,-%./.+/,,%+*
,,0 *), 12%23,
00)+ 1,,+*+0*+.4, )
$ *+0,0+.+/5%00)+ *
,,0 ,,% 61 *) +%2&
$#789#$:;!8!< ..#9#!$#!7 =%1* )).%0+04.,%&) >0)+++.,%&2*,100)+61 .), ),+15%-%.*%+,1 00>0)++/.+/1%2,+,%+. 6115%1.,%00,,.12)+*2++ 5%0,,000)++.&+.1&4,. 0,,0 1,16 %,,,,%.5%.%1 ,+2++&)6(
+1+,,*1,4/+5+.+/5*+. 1,%5*+. *+.)5)+,*+.61 +5*/+%+5
),,615+,1%).+&?+20%+. 1 0,,0 +%2& 7<#9$"8 .. #9#!$#!7 %+. + !#@:A@A B+ 1 +,, * 1 ,4/+5+.+/5*+. 1,%5*+. *+.)5)+,*+.61+5*/+%+5C* 1 ,,0 !;79+.+!$@!A@&A*1
,,0 !;79,1%).+&+./+,5%
),-%1*++%2&2++.+10 &)?*1,)**%1,0+.+ =%,+)5A " '
; " #-! " < " # B
' 1
!"
* " "?
) * *'" "'/
; " % "
'
/"
;
=
*
7 '/
;
= 3+3.
!
67)
*6 '/ "/% "
!
"/%
% "
) * *
* ?
+. -+2 1' +3. <"1' +3.
" " "*"
' +4 -$3 1' +3.* * "1'" *" " '/ !
! '
1 '/ ! !"1
" "
* !
6>* * = C< 1 C =
/ " " ; #
! 11
" "1 3++3.5!
6>8* *
" 33+3.
!
6+ *#
"* 32+3.
1 1 " " /"1 ! / ! /'"
"'* " "1
1""
1) /* '/ '/ */
"/ " ' !
6+ */ *#
" 33+3. /'/ '/*/
32+3. * ' +.-+2+3. "1'" 3++3. * * =
>
" '1 " ! /*
* "
6 "'/ 1 *
'1 ! "33+3. * 6 *'
1 1 "
! " "
/
/ "* ' 11 / 1 32+3.'/
" " /" ! /'"
"' 1 " /
6 ' ! /" / " ;1 1 / * '/ ! / ! /* * "1'" 3++3. * =* ** /* + '1 "
#'/
* '
#D +>,3,+32 '/
"
/ E6 ! "
>3+32*
' " '/ * * = #
!
6
, + * "
# ; "
/E6 ! !
6 ) *< " "
*
6 *
"
" "1 / "
" " ' " 1 '/ 1 ' 1
"
/ " 0 ' * 1 *
6 *
" "1 / " 1'/ 1 '1
"
'
1 '1
!
6 7 9
"/5 8:# ; " *< +23+34 '1 * * /"/ " '
/'>*
'1 "
" '/
! /
1/ 1
1
'
/ '1 * *
7 *
"33+3. 33+3. " 35$85"8 !" 4,.'1
.
"* 33+3.* 1 * *
33+3.* / 1/ ' 1''
9
"/5 8:# ; " / 1
/1
$ F " '1
" "
' '/ / / =
-" " * * / /* * 7 F " '1
"
* ! # % 1 ' "
6"
**
" "/
'
/ 1
'1
' B 1
"
' *
& " '/ 9 # ? C' 1#
@
A
B
9 # ? C' 1 #
@
!
"# #$ %
&
'( )$* !+ A %"
2 ,-,'1 & "
" '/ " * '/ ' = * '
/
/ 1 /#* /
* B 1 '
1
+0),*%)%, > F " '1 "
/B"
* *"
" )!<!!" '
"' "0 '/ C' 1 #
!
6$37++33.
*/ "
" " ;
#
' $ '1 * # "*
!
6* '/
!
6+? *#
" * '
1
"<1 * * * / "* '/
* / ' '1 ! * # % 1
"
/'/* 1
" / <1 " '
4 " " /
1
'
*
/
/ !"'1 "
' * * "
'/ 9
"/5 8:# ; "*"/ '" * ' 1
'
" !"
! ! "% &' '1 1
! &'
/ " "* 1 "
*
/B /"
") * * "
"
" )!<!!"' "
" /' '/ C' 1#
!
6. !
6 * *#
"33+3.
6 " " 1 "
! " 6 *"1 !
6+ / '/ */
32+3. *
'/
;
=
!
67
" "?
* ?
+.-+2+3. "1'" /
3++3. !
* ='/ ! 0 '/
; "
3 #
;
,3$+3+ " ! / '1 ' # * "
"
1 * " ' * # /
" ) +$3+3+$ " * '/ # "1 *
/
;
"1 +23+34 * '/ 9
"/5 8:
# ; " * /' "
* !
67 " "1 34+3.*
*
; "'/ "/ % 1 * '/"11 1 ! * '
" /
# 1 ! / #
* 0
*/
"
- " " 35$85"8 !" '1 " ) 34+3.*
/"11 ' 1 '/ # % 1 ! #
C
" C
" ! /
!
6 " 33+3.'
'/ ! / / ;
+$3+3+$ # " 1 '
"1
; " #
1
#
" " 6
)/ " " "1 "
; " "1
" ";
"
"0/'
" $ * / '/ / /
"
! /'/* ' *
"* " " " '
/
+23+34* *
7 '/ !! / "*
33+3. 1 33+3. *
* "/ /
""' 1) * ' 1 '/ " $ ' "* *0 '/ #
'/ / / **
" "
'/ 9 # ? C' 1 #
.
) /' *
*
* '6"
& 1
"
"*
+ * '1 /
'/ / / ;
0/ '
" $ * /*
! / !
! / = * '1 *"
=
" 7 !"* * * " 7* /
"
"""
" ""11* '/ "
# % 1
' / " "1
" '* '
"1/"
/" = / "1 1 /
* 1 ' 6 "11 / "
' " +* " +* * " * * "
/ " )
" 7* " +* /
"
* " " "
"1 " #
* " $
*
6"
*'
'
/
# 1
/' * ! # % 1 "
"" "* * ' *6
!"' "* 6"
**'
$
* " "
"1 " $ /
+0),*%)%, %.)2 02'
/
!"
"
* * '/ C' 1 #
.
) /'!
" " "- * "
/ '/
1 *
/
1
+0),*%)%, *
6"
"*
* " "
"1 " * # "33+3.5!
68 +23+34 5!
6780 ) ! " *
* 1 /
" ' 0 ' *
6"
* ""
# *
# % 1 ! /"
/
"* '/
! /
" /
* / "
0 '
1" ' "/
"" "* * "
"/
"" " * * "1 * *
"
# '" " $
7 * ' '
-+ +
.
1%2?
D
- G +D ' G