M/S Oswal Denims v. M/S Avion Fabrics And Another
4
IN TH HE HIGH COURT FOR THE E STATES OF PUNJAB AND HANDIGARH HARYANA AT CH ,- /
3
4-&,-& ,-
&&&5
1 2
&&& 6
!"#$ %& '(%)*$ *% ") $ #! 1" / ) *% ")+ '&
) */#* )" ./
/0 /
4)* &/# !"# $ $ % &# '
&()# * &+$ ,
, -#
/#* " . / *# 5( "
..
6 *))#" /#* ("
*(
/# /( "()# * /# * ) ) " . / " ## ) *) ))/) ,/ /(
"
0 /1 / ) ) "
# ## /"*# # #*# / )
,/( "
0 * ) " / " )( * ( ( * " ()## ( /# / ( "()# 2
" )" / "()# )( (1))#""
"##/) ,""6 )) 27 6 #)"1"/ /" ))#" * ( * ##&*) ()) 1 )/6 "
85 # # #6 )6 "
& " ( * "
" 6 " ")# ""(" 5 ) " 0 6 1" 9 93 *#" )((* "" 6 1 ("
6 ## 6 6# / "()# 1 ( 6 ))
6 * 2) 1 1 //")) " (27 " * 0 6 #/ * ) "" 4 1 $1 : ;*# )(&/5 #)# /" ))#""
"*## 6 (# /## # ) #" ) ) " " /#( 1*1"*/ " "# (
)))#" * /#/ /
# < $1:;*# )(&/5" # ) ( +
) !"#$%&$&'(
) *$& $"
&$&'
8&"(( ( "## (6 6#// ) ( /## #" (( 6# " ) =" "" & & =" 1 * / "## () > "
#*
7
# / # " " /## ) # " ( ? % ( : ;*# )( & / 5 " # ) ,- (
)&$#! . + /
&'$ $$) &$##( ) $'
$0 &$#! "
"
# */###")" " ( * " )1 /# / = " # ""#1 )"#1 16 / " / :;*# ) ( & / 5 6 ## /" ""(" (*1) ))#" *(1 * #"#/ ))#"// # /#( 1#*1" * )) ) $ $1 " ( / 66#*1 1)=" "" ( ))) #" *(1 /##)#" ""# 1 16 / /( ))#" (1 * ))#","()# ( %
/ # )) / ) // ) ))#" ## / //" (/ " ?
5 * # " # / ) () *# / #6 6 # ) ( # #$ 6 6###))/#6 //" )6"## ( 6/ " "##/27 61("
#/="/ " 6 #" ( ()1# "(#0"#
8
* )
( 2 ( / 27 1 ) ) =" * " ) 5 / ( /27 ) "*" #" 6 "
*/##) )* ) 7 * *( ) 1*##6 3// ( # "# / ) # ) " / /1 2 +2
)) 7 (#"
""!/ /
''$
5 1 # " # / ) " *# # 1# ( #)#"""/##
5 6## # )) / #6 ))#" "
! ( ( *## 6#/##)#"
"/ )"/ /" 1 / 1 )) ) 4 3
1 ) )4
(&$#" & 5 56' :@*# )(& )6"/"
& #*1* "# #( /=" / 1# # * * " 6 " ""() " "
"/1") & ) 6) *#( ") 6 " " * 1 # / / =" )1 / " #* " "#6 )1 / & )")# / "( (# #6 " ) 6 "/ "
* "="##/
-
* & *# ")"# A/" " " *( 1-3 );
+ * &$## 9 #!
!5 6## =(* & & <2 8 * # ""9 !
6"0 # +:, = 2
23 3 *#"""
#
&$& +:, < +))# *1" )/#6 )" # /"/
)" * " ) ,"" 3 B
)) 6 6 6 # )" / " 1" : * ( "
"
/
: " ( 6/ 0/#"# #/ ) 6 6 " (
#" ( *" " /"1"/ ""
* "#
) /# / ))#" " . / <
( ) / "## / 27 ""* *( ) 93 1" 0 6 93 2)( ) 5) 3 & 0 1" "" 5 *( ) ,"" "#(
1" # ) * 6/# /"## #/27 ( +" /# )# / / " 5 ( 61 / " ) *# /##6 ) (* ) * ( 16/ /" )) " (27
*1 ) * " (# /" " 1" 93 *#" "
6
(/ " 61("
6 6 6#/ ) ( " ( ( 27
))#" */#* ( /#( #* 1"* ))) * & 1()#)6 "## (/ " ( 6/ (" *"/="
61 ( ( # # * ( ," (6
/##) #" " )"#) 5 ) )) " ( ( 27 * 1 ) "
#/# )#
6 / " ( / )06 "/1"93 "
6# #) &1) ))"/ " "
# #& "(( "# )( * ) )"##)16 6 /" 1/#( (
1* 1"* ))) ""#/( ) ) ((
- (MANISHA BATRA) JUDGE 4-&,-&,-
Yes/No Whet ther speaking/reasoned Yes/No Whet ther reportable