(O&M) R.K. Saboo & Sons Huf v. The Commissioner Of Income Tax, Chd
!"
##$$ %&' () ** &
*+,)(-.&( # -
/& 0& -(1 '&, & -2 3( 0& 0
-, -2
&(##$$
0& !&2(('.., -.) '$
&(&# -
! (( $-(#&##$'-&
( *+ ,45
&( &6( 67.( &-&--
* + ##$$ & '$, )(-.&( 5
& ( & 6& '$67 (*8&2 $2-4494
&-. (##$$9,(
$$ 3.'
$ :'
$3&
& -& 9
!
!!
"
# $! % %& " ( )
* & ( * +
* , &
- .
"
!"
# #
# /
# ++0
1
++0 "
'
! 2
##$3-*-
& -&.:'
57,57- 57
;
( 9 !" $- &'& -$&. *
,,<9
&(*8&4494 (3$-
&'8- 3'- ( .=
&,2- &-&-- 4 444,* . (&(.,*---
,,<9 -$$ 3.--'
&$*-'-& 57
(
..&2-
(* &-&,##$3 $- ( ) ** &
*+5 ##$7,)(-.&(>)5 7?,2- &-& -- ,$$ 3-(##$
(&2' $-##$
&(& '$ (& '$, 2- &-&-- ,-( &-&
) 5 7-$.( --
,,<9-'#($-(-- *- 8( .
=
&
..&2-
( &-&,(#&##$( $- 8(
#&(.&*&- 8(3(
'&#& , (
&& 3- '- 2(&
0< *$$- 2@*-/&3
&
$ 3A#&'*
($-&3& '8(&
0< *$$-2@*-
(& 3*- &(*
&#& -
8&- -8
(& &, ( ##$$ 3 #8 * 8 - (& 3& & &&- ( '&.(&$2*8&,($-& (-#'&(-(&(* 3$*-((3(
$
((& ($*---'
& #- ($-&'-& 57
(
( '.((&'
$:'
$3(2 &*-
('2 $2-3 '$- 3((&(
,(3$- --' '-& 57
B
(($$.(##$ (-$$ 3
--' &$8.'# (-
( '#&*) '&(
3$$
'--
3 '$- ##& #& :'
$' 4 -
.&*9 + !
# ! ! *34
5
6 !
# !!
!
!
! ! #
3
6
!
# !
!
.
! . #
# "
"
!
! !
. 1 $ 7 8-
! 7 !
"
6
"& *#$&-.
()$'4
(.&* 2-((##$$3
'- #'&($$((& *(
; $-& C8*''$.&*,$-& '$-#'&('# A
(&$$ - (--' 3&.($8-$$ 3-,3 $8 & -
(8&,3 '$-*&. ( 3*8(&3&'$$8 & &&- (##$$
&-. )$',(
&& 3& $-  (* '
$ ,$-&(- #
&# #&
&* &
$$( (&(& '.( 1D+(., #*&1 &' - (& && 2&( $* ' #&($'$ ,(##$$ 3 *
((&(-
8&- -8
$$ *
((& ((&3&& &&- (##$$ ;
(& '$, -&.(
,---('.( ( #& $#&
&-&:'
- $ 39
.
!
"
# .1 '
%& ,.
&
! !
#
# ) 9 : ;
:" 7
!
! !
!
. !
" 5 5#
# ! !!
# !
# < = ! . !
!
#
5
! 5 !
# 1
< # .1
# %&,. & " > ? $! %
( )# ,!
!!
5
-!# #
# $
!
#
!
# !! ! * &
- .
+0 $ * ,
!"
# -! -! #
- "# !! 7
& # !! #
" "
#
# !#
# !!
"
#
$
"
# !! $! %
( )# ,! # !
!!
!!
# !! "
! "
!
#
# !!
&
"
# "
#
!!
# #
# %&,.
#
(
(#&,(#&9 &:'
57
( (+#-'&3*-
&( #'&#
*1. &&. * - ( '#&*) '&
5'#&7($-((& &:'&* '-& 57---' 3 '$- $$ 3- $8 8 * '$$8*- &&- (& :'&&$3((-#&
!-#'-$8,-'&.(&$28&,(##$$3 (
((& ((&3&#'&(-(*
$-&3( 1#( (&
&(&8& &-.$8,(&.'*((##$$3 ( $
((&-($-&(-1#((& $8
&(#'&#
'&8-&2&E (',(
##$$9 .(
((&-'&.(8&'-& -& , -&2- *(
&-#& '*
(& & & &3(( -.& &-- 8(
& '$
( '
$ :'
$3 $*- 3&- &-.$8
(##$-*- " "
# $% & $'
!
' '
! 7 2 @ ! 2 @