Wattan Sharma v. Union Of India And ORS
!" !#" !$%&'!(!)"* +%,&-!#!.+#"!&/)" !&/'!*"0 !*
1 1
1
1
1
1
1
!
!
" # $ %
* " ! 3..,/43)" *+%' " /)"!#5!)"/+) /) " ! .!)&/)' 6#/"
.!"/"/+)6 /4 /*4+(/)'%.7+#7/)3,&/*.+*3,"+&38+)" !'#+%)&" 3" 3..,/43)"/*3)!4!**3#8.3#"83*" !"#3/,!#*+7" !(+5/! 35!* +49/)',8 .+#"#38!&" !6+(!) ++&+7%)$3-*+4/!"8.!#(/**/+)/*'#3)"!&"+" ! 3..,/43)""+/)"!#5!)!/)" /*6#/".!"/"/+)
" "
!6#/".!"/"/+)!# 3*4+)"!)&!&" 3"" !7/,(: &"3%)$3-:
.#+&%4!&-8#!*.+)&!)"+ 2 3*.+#"#38!&" !!)"/#!.+.%,34!+7" !
.!+.,!+7%)$3-3*&#%'3&&/4"* %#" !#" !*3/&7/,(/*.%#!,83.+,/"/43, 3'!)&36/" " !.#/)4/.3,+-$!4"/5!+7.#+$!4"/)'" !"3"!+7%)$3-3*3 %-+7)3#4+"/4*3)&.*84 +"#+./4*%-*"3)4!* !.!"/"/+)!# 3*3,,!'!& " 3"" !7/,(/*#!.,!"!6/" &!#+'3"+#83-%*!* !7%)4"/+)+7" !,36 !)7+#4!(!)"3'!)48/)" !"3"!+7%)$3- 3*-!!)&!./4"!&3*"+"3,,8 &!7%)4"
!%)$3-/* 35!-!!)* +6)3*#+%'!*3*3#!*%,"+76 /4 3) 3&5!#*!/(.34"6+%,&-!4#!3"!&+)" !(/)&*+7" !8+%" !!)"/#!
3"(+*. !#!+73.!34!,+5/)'3)& 3#&6+#9/)'%)$3-/*6+%,&-!5/"/3"!&/7 " !7/,(/**4#!!)!& !!; /-/"/+)+7" !7/,(6/,, 35!373##!34 /)' 3&5!#*!#!.!#4%**/+)*/)" !"3"!+7%)$3-6 /4 3*3,#!3&8%)&!#'+)! " !6+#*". 3*!+7(/,/"3)48/)" !4+%)"#8/"63*7%#" !#*%-(/""!&
<
)" !#!.,87/,!&-8#!*.+)&!)"+ 2/" 3*-!!)35!##!&" 3"
" !+):-,!/' +%#"+7%&/43"%#!3"+(-38 3*.3#",83,,+6!&" !6#/" .!"/"/+)7/,!&-8 3)"+(/,(*5"
"& 3)&3)+" !# !&!4/*/+)+7" !
!)"#3,+3#&+7/,( !#"/7/43"/+)63*=%3* !&6/" *,/' "(+&/7/43"/+)
!+):-,!/' +%#"+7%&/43"%#!3"+(-38 3*+#&!#!&" 3"" !7/,( :
&"3 %)$3-: -! 4!#"/7/!& 3* :
2 "/*" !&%"8+7" !"3"! +5!#)(!)"4+)4!#)!&"+!77!4"/5!,8 (3/)"3/),363)&+#&!#+)4!" !7/,(/*.%-,/4,8!; /-/"!& +.#+ /-/"+#8 +#&!#* 35!-!!)/**%!&!/" !#-8" !"3"!+7%)$3-+#-8" !"3"!+7 3#83)3 !*.+)&!)"+ 2 3**+%' "7+#&/*(/**3,+7" !6#/".!"/"/+) 6/" " !3-+5!4+)"!)"/+)*
>
!6#/".!"/"/+)43(!%.7+# !3#/)'+)2 %$38 13)"363,3&5+43"!6 +3..!3#!&-!7+#!" /* +%#"/)4+))!4"/+)6/" 8!"
3)+" !#43*!63*3..+/)"!&3*
!*.+)&!)"*+ 3)&26!#!&/#!4"!&"+*4#!!)" !7/,(:
&"3%)$3-:/)" !" !3"#!+7 #!*.+)&!)"+ +)< 3"< .
( 3)&" !(/4%* %#/3!63* 3*9!&"+63"4 " !7/,(3,+)'6/" " !#!.#!*!)"3"/5!*+7" !6#/".!"/"/+)!# 3)&" !#!.#!*!)"3"/5!*+7#!*.+)&!)"*+ "+23)&*%-(/"3#!.+#"73/#,8 4+((!)"/)'+)" !4+)"!)"+7" !7/,(*+3*"+!)3-,!" ! +%#""+"39!3 &!4/*/+)3*"+6 !" !#" !*3/&7/,(/*7/"7+#.%-,/4!; /-/"/+)
%$3813)"363,3(/4%* %#/3! 35/)'63"4 !&" !7/,( 6/" " !4++.!#3"/+)+7" !3,,4+)4!#)!&*%-(/""!&3&!"3/,!&#!.+#""+&38
%$3813)"363,3(/4%* %#/3! 3*34"!&+)-! 3,7+7" ! +%#"
* " !7/,(63*.#+&%4!&/) %(-3/3)&" !*3(!/*"+-!!; /-/"!&-8 "+(+##+6/"*!,7" ! +%#"7!,"" 3"&%!"+"/(!4+)*"#3/)"/"/*)+".+**/-,!"+ 63"4 " !7/,( !#!7+#!" !(/4%* %#/3!63*&!.%"!&"+63"4 " !7/,( +)-! 3,7+7" ! +%#"3" %(-3//"*!,73)&*%-(/"3#!.+#"+)" !4+)"!)" +7" !7/,(
?
#+(" ! #!.+#" *%-(/""!& -8 %$3813)"363,3(/4%*
%#/3!/"/*7+%)&" 3":
&"3%)$3-:" !7/,(%)&!#4 3,,!)'!&!3,*6/" " !
< 4!)"#3," !(!)3(!,8&#%'(!)34!/)%)$3- !&#%'(!)34!/*)+"
'!+4!)"#/4"+" !#!'/+)+7%)$3- "/*34"%3,,83.#+-,!(734!&-8" !
!)"/#!6+#,& !*%-$!4"/*+)!+7"+./43,.%-,/4/(.+#"3)4! !#!.+#"
&/*4,+*!*" 3"" !7/,(&+!*)+"/)3)8(3))!#',+#/78%*3'!+7&#%'*+# )3#4+"/4*%-*"3)4!* "&+!*)+" 35!3)8/,,!77!4"+7,%#/)'3)8.!#*+) "+63#&*&#%'(!)34!
"&+!*)+"3&5+43"!&#%'%*3'!+#/&+,/@!.!#*+)*"+ %*!&#%'* #+%' " !,!3&4 3#34"!#" !/#!4"+# 3*.+#"#38!&" 3"&#%'* 3#!&3)'!#+%*3)&&/*3*"#+%*3)&43),!3&"+,+**+7,+5!&+)!* !
6+(!),!3&4 3#34"!#/)" !7/,( 3*-!!)-!*"+6!&6/" " !(/**/+)+7 #!7+#(/)'" !&#%'3&&/4"*
!3#)!&(/4%* %#/3! 3*5!#873/#,84+((!)"!&" 3"" !7/,( *4#/."4+%,& 35!35+/&!&" !#!.!3"!&%*!+7!;"#!(!,87+%,3)&3-%*/5! ,3)'%3'!
!7/,( 3*)++-*4!)/"8 !63*5!#843"!'+#/4" 3"" !"3"!
+7%)$3-3)&" !%)$3-/* 3&)+"-!!).+#"#38!&/)3.++#,/' "3* 4+)"!)&!&-8" !6#/".!"/"/+)!# ,"/(3"!,8 ! 3*)+"/4!&" 3")+" /)'
+-$!4"/+)3-,!/*7+%)&/)" !7/,(
%#/)'" !4+%#*!+73#'%(!)"*,!3#)!&4+%)*!,3..!3#/)'7+# !%)$3-"3"! +((/**/+)7+#+(!)*%-(/""!&" 3"" !6+(!) 3& -!!).+#"#38!&/)35!#8-3&,/' "
!(/4%* %#/3!#!*.+)&!&" 3"" !
6+(!) 3&)+"-!!).+#"#38!&/)3-3&,/' "3*4+)"!)&!&
)5/!6+7" !3-+5!734"*3)&4/#4%(*"3)4!*3(+7" ! 4+)*/&!#!&5/!6" 3"3..#! !)*/+)/)" !(/)&+7" !6#/".!"/"/+)!#/* "+"3,,8/,,7+%)&!& )8.#+ /-/"/+)/(.+*!&+)" !!; /-/"/+)+7" !7/,(/) 3)8.3#"+7" !4+%)"#86+%,&.+*!34 3,,!)'!"+" !4#!3"/5!(/)&+7" !
> "+#8#/"!#4#/."#/"!# 3(!#3(3)3)&" !/#!4"+# %*"-!43%*!" !#!
(38-!*+(!,363)&+#&!#/**%!)+#!*"#3/)"+#&!#43)-!.3**!&3**+%' " 7+#-8" !.!"/"/+)!# !#!.+#"*%-(/""!&-8" !(/4%* %#/3!/)&/43"!* " 3"" !#!63*)+.+,/"/4*/)5+,5!&/).#+&%4"/+)+7*%4 37/,(3)&" ! /(3'!+73)8.3#"/4%,3#"3"! 3*)+"-!!)(3,/')!& !,363)&+#&!# /**%!" 3"(383#/*!6/,, 35!"+-!!77/4/!)",8"349,!&-8" !"3"!3*/"/* /"**+,!()&%"8
/" " !3-+5!+-*!#53"/+)*" !6#/".!"/"/+)*"3)&*&/*(/**!&
!7+#! .3#"/)' 6/" " ! 43*! " ! %"(+*" */)4!#/"8 * +6) 4+((!)&3-,!3**/*"3)4!#!)&!#!&"+" ! +%#"3)&" !73/#3)&%)-/3*!& #!.+#"*%-(/""!&-8,!3#)!&(/4%* %#/3! %$3813)"363,3&5+43"!
/* /' ,83..#!4/3"!&
%)! %,3"/ #$