Michal v. State Of Punjab And ORS.
!
"
#$#%&#'() *+$,- #.+.+#'
/#'010 2..# 13&.,#'0 #04#.0 " 23##5 #561 #.+.+#'
/#'010 2..# 13&.,#'0 #04#.0 *78 9* 2 *9 2 :::
! "
# !!
$$"%& '$ ()**
!
+
# !! "
,&"
# !! -. +
! / !1$. 2 3
'&4" &5$
4 2
*9 2 ) 1
6
55 4"
.'
" - +
!
# !!/
16
5
+7 !! !!-
8& 6 $
/ 1
5 $
4 ( "
# !!$ (
5 &
5
6 $
" " $ .'
"
)&
4 9
-1
5/ " 6 $ "
16
-1 /
-
# !!/ 5 6
! !!!:
+ - ) 57 /
" ; 5 % " & '$ 6
)&
4 9
#! !
8&! .'
"-
$ /6
<&
=
>
?
55 6
$@ ""
&
5 " &
516
5
4" # +
> A!! # 5
! - '4& /6$ 5$)&
-1
5/6 ""
8& $@ !96
@$
6&5$
)&
-1
5/" '
4
+ 1 4
@!::A16
5
4
46 &
&
5
& '$ )&
-1
5/6 5 1 B&5
6 6 $
&55 5"
5=
4 &56(
16
4
455
5)&
$
)&
-1
5/ &5 65 6 4
" !A!!!::
1B&5
8 4
16
5
65 6 556
&5C)C& '$&
5 -. & "
/.&5 !:A
-
.&5 / D&5
& " D&5
"
%&4 5"
16
.4 5 5
4
*$@
& 16 5
-9 /
"$ - /! EF 5
4>
45 @ 8 > -
/! EF G "
45 A@
8
16
46
4 ;+++"<40.0 1+-+604#$.';#$,+$-",5+6 =#'0 #>4#'+#$#+?-+6?+6 1+-+604#$.'?+.,#6'##++5+-6+##'+6 ,5+6 #>4#'+#$# ?'@+6 0 01$, '
%++%1%4#'+ =#'0+.,#?-+6?+6
> + ! !! &5 6 " 556
A B&5
65 6
16
D&5 & " D&5 "
&5
5"
& "
4
* &
@7
&
&5$ "5@
5"
& =
4" 4
*&
@7
& 8 6(
@
1&
4 $6 5
4> G " )&
-1
5/ 6 6@6 5 @8 B&
" 11"
6
"5@"& $ "5@&
5 @ 8 $
5"
& 5=
4" 4
*H
@79
& 9
55@ $ 6 5 " F
16
-
55 )&
-1
5//
44
5=
46 "
"&"6@ C8
5
"5@
46( @
16
4
4 6 6@6 "
"&"B&5
4 5"
&7 5=
45 6(8 @ "$ $
&5 # 9
&
16
6 &5
6 55$@ " 5 !: !!
-
8&+/ = &55@ 6 "
!! !!
$
6
14
&4
"
5@
)&
$ "
655@$ @"
A 5@ 5$@-. ! /
5 $ "
G6 $ 6 & &
6
45 &@ A$&6
:
4
5
@
I&6
5@ $ "
&
$ $&@ > $ $ &
5 *
@5
)&
4 9
-1
5/- 6/$
B& B&
8 )&
-1
5/
6 5 $5 "
16 5
&
J"&K 5 $5$
"
1 '& 4 $@ "
$
$ 6&5 $
&
55 5@4
> $5 + &
5 " (
" $ ( $@ ! 55@ $ 6
<&
=
!# ! 6 6(
4
)&
! !16 4
& =
4
4- 4 / 6 $ (6(
)&
# +
8& 9
5 "
5@ )&
-1
5/6 "
!::A $
+6 " & " )&
6 "
@!:
! "
"&"B&5 $6 @ 5"
5=
41 & & " 6 " "5@ 6(
4 <&
=
16 5
-)&
4/) 6 6( )&
$ & B&5
@ 5 $ -<&
=
)&
/6 "9 5 $ "
5@<&
=
6 " " "
16
4
4"& )&
C
& C )&
-1
5/ : 1 4
- ' 4& /
5
"
5$&
"
$@
"& @6$ 5 $)&
-1
5/ A!! #
&8 4
@
'4&
6
<&
=
&
5 ;& + +!::A 6
" @&
5 "
"$!::
( <&
=
->
?
/ !+ !-
8&!
/6
16
4" 7
4 &
5 9
@ 5 $ )&
-1 / <&
=
" " 6
4
4& )&
!+ !
8&! > 6
<&
=
->
?
/&@ "
5 !
5
4
4&
5
# +1& $@5 4 5
'&
9 5 $ 5544 5
$@
" 4
*
& ! 5@ 5$@ ! $
4
$ "
5@ 5$@&
5
5
4
" ( $@
5@
# !! 5 $@ !
6
9
6
'
$ 4
5@5 $ '
&
5
5 !$& !# !9 $ 6 6(
4 )&
"
! ! 6
4 '4& $
5@ 5
5
$( $ 6(
4
)&
4$ "!+ ! 6 -
8&!6
! /6 5@ J
5 4" K !! 1 ""
$ &
+ ! !! 6 &5 6" 5
4
16
-1 /6 !
& : 6$ 55&$@6@" 6 + - !
/6$ 55&"" )&
-1
5/ 6 @ 8
16 5
4
4
4
5=
46 "
"&"6@
8
6
4 9
& + 55 + ! !! -
6 5@
4 $" " &5 / $ 55 &
6 & " &5
B& 5@
6
6
4
5=
4 @ B& @
8 )&
-1
5/ + ! !!6@ 5 $5$" 1 >
4
5=
4 " 6@
8 )&
-1
5/ & 6 5 $5 $ " 6
B& 5@" "&4 +7 !! !! ! 1 .'
" 5 5
B
&55 $
6
55@(
" '& @
" 1 $ ( $@
5 4 554
5 4
=
4 $ 554$@ $
4 " 9
& &
=& .' 6
"H
@
I
( "
& & & 4" & "
6
4 " : + 9 &$
& '&4" A ! ! -
# + ! 5 6
4 1& '$=5
@)/ 5
B& &
5% " C
& "H
@ 9
&
.' 55 6
4 ) 51
5=& "
9
&$
4&
=
455
& G 5 '&4" G " 5 G 4&
# ! + !!
4 !
; &
5
4 $
4&"
5
"
,&" 5 &
5
4
4&
4"
5@6( 5
! ! 6 )&
5@ 5$@&
5 56(8 4
$@ " $
"5
& )&
4 9
-1
5/ A7 :!! #6&5$ &
8 4
)&
L & 8
$ & 5@
@ 5
4 & &@ 4
&@7 8 4
$
"
4 '&4"
)
&
*#,.; '"5+.05#'+6 =-!::#/+1 !+ G
4
4&"
$
5
$
&
&6&5 $
46"
& $
6 6 5@"$
4'&
1
# !! 5 5@
6
)&
#! !$6 6 6(
4 - /
!:
+ 5@
5@ 5 $@ &
5 '&4
C $ $ .'
"66(
4 <&
=
+ +!::A !# ! 5@ $6
)&
-1
5/ A!! #1 " 6 4 $
4C 5C )&
:!! # - " A!! #$
4 :!! #/ $ ( $@ !
5@ 6551& &5
&
)&
4 9
B&
!
& 4 G6&
5 &(
5@ 6 6(
4 )&
! !-$
"5
&
5 '4& / . + ( 6 6(
4
16
4
4
! $&4 @
" <& + $
&& 5@6(
4 )&
-1
5/" 6
5 &
5 '4& &$"
66
A7 :!! #
'
4
)&
"6
@
$ & ' 4&
4$ 16
4
4
!+ !
4'
" 7
4
+ C
@6&5 &
4"@ ! 59 @ &$"
$( $
"6
4
! ! $@&
5
55!+ ! !
1 @6&5 $4
$ &
@ ' 4& )&
-1
5/
$
$&
4"!+ ! 6&5 &55@"( "
56"
5@6
)&
-1
5/ 5@ #! ! !#
& A7 :!! #
& $56 J %>M=.=1>IH<) =.1=1>I;>;%>M=.=1
-;%9).G/ >.=.
.'
" '4& <&
=
->?/ &
5 " 5 )&
4 9
-
5/6 "" 1
@ "5@
)&
-
5/ 6 55$
" '
4
7 ).)'' A!! # @%& '$ " ; 5% " = 7!
:7 #!!7 # :!! #K I&5 &5 $5( .&5! .&5 1 &5&
556
!
N
"# $!
O% 1&
&5
@ $6 ""$ $ &
"
.&5 -!/ &5
$"
$@ 5 4
&&
4
.&5 &
556
$& "#'
&
!
(
)
*
+",#-
"# ! !
" # .
( // 0 1 2-
3-2
4 " #
.
- !
5
( //
+
6 /
" #7$8 ,$8
9
!
( / % 8888K
A !A 9
"
'4& 6$6(
4
4
"
@
5 <&
=
$@6
)&
56 6(
4
$&6 6(
4 -6/"6 6 5@ " )&
#! ! 1 6 '
5 4 $ 6(
4
16
4 6 @6"55@
7
)&
-1
5/ $ "556
4 " 7
&
&
5
16
4
)&
"
)&
-1
5/ 5 ! !!!:
+ ) 57
4 - / #! !
'4&
+ +!::A <&
=
!+ ! <&
=
A7 :!! #
! !?P +P<=
A7 :!! # .'
" !# ! <&
=
!
1 &
5 4 .'
"
$
"5
& 7
)&
6 6(
4 &
! !6
'4&
5 @
$( 6 16
5
4
4L &!+ !-
8&!
! /6$@ '4& 5
6 "=
4" &
5 716
4" 6 J
5 4" K 1& $ & 5@ &
5
&
$@ &55@@
4 &55 @
8& !G6 &
5 .'
" "
5 ! 5 @$@6 6 &
516
5
4" 7
4 )&
-1
5/ 5 4 & &@$
7 5 49
8
4 16
4
4
@ !&4 5
8
8& 6
-
# !!/
# +
$@ ""
&
5 "
4 .'
" <&
=
->
55/ C1C " 6 &
@
4 @ 6 6 1
@"
66
6( )&
45@
4 (
5@
6(
4 )&
! !
8& 5$@
5@
# !!
5 :
$@ ""
% " - /
4
$ .'
" '4& 6(
4 )&
-1
5/
!! #& & % " :!! # 1&
@$ &
& $@6 .'
"6 55@
"@ @ )&
-1
5/ A7 :!! #6
5 '4& 6$"55@
&
!
1 &4 8 4
16 5
4"@$ " & " )&
1 6&5$
45@5
4
'&4" 6 &
@
4
&5 &44 8 4
16
47"
$
"
4
@"
)&
-1
5/
$
"
.&5! .&5 -!/
6 "5@ 6
)&
-1
5/ 6 "5@6
4 "
4
@
5
4 &5
1& 5@
4 &5 '4& &4
" )&
-1
5/ A!! #65
4
4
"@ 5 @65
4 <&
=
6 '4&
4$
&
+ +!::A .'
"
4 $
<&
=
!# !G ' 4& .'
" $ & 5@ ' 4&
6
@
&G6 6 $ 5 5
$@$( '
)&
"@6 16
4
4
( 1
' 5 5$ 4 5 &4
6 $
' 4& .'
" $ 6
& .&5! 6 .&5 -!/
$5@ 5 $ .'
" ' 4& 6&5 $
5
6 $
- 5 C/
" )&
-1
5/ #! !6 6(
4
4 $&6 6(
4 C6C- /
5
-
8&!/"
4 "" )&
-1
5/ G6
5 C
@ 6&5 &55@ $ 5
" 1
66 55$
&
&
'&4" &
5 (B&
8 ""
&- 5 C
@/
$
4 "" &
55@$@
&
@
& 55 4 $@ '4& $@ .'
" & &
&
5$'& & !: 1 8B&
6 @
1 6 .'
" $ "5@8
"
4
" " &5 + ! !!&4 55
$@
" 5@ "&4 !! !!
:" 6(" " 1
5
16 5
55
4 )&
4 9
-1
5/6 8
"
4
6&5
+ ! !! 5@
&
1 &
& & $
48
G6& 5 5
& $@5 &@ % 56&5
B& 6 $@ 15(
4&
" "
16
&
516
+! # 6 "
1& @6 6 "
$" " .&5 + ! !! "$655& & $
& &$5@ 56 655 5
'&4"
!/6+,.,#'05 2'##+50.,#'0-9.!:
+/
4& 5&5 "& $ 55
&5 " "
&5 &"$
5 $"
4& @(
&
55
5&5 $& 5@ 6&5 156
4
5 5 4655 5
2..# 13& .,#'05 '1C1%' 66'?-.,#'0- A/! + G6
4"5 " & 5 5
&&
& 6 @ &
4$ ( 1 "& $
@ + ! !! & " 15(
4 &
516
@&4 55
5@ !! !! $@" "
" " " &5 6&5 55 $ 55
& " &5
B 3&4 @8
4 " " &5
$ 55
5&5 8
@ B&5
B&
4& & @$ 6 @
&55@ 55&$ 6
( 1
6&5$ $ ( 6 &4 &5 5!: !! 15&5 5@& 5
4 1
$ 55
8 F" )&
-1
5/
4 @ 8
16
4 " " )&
4 9
6 4
=
4
4 8 6(
4 & "
"&" 6@
16
4
4 4 5 B&5
&$
&$' 4 $
45
5@ " 6
B&5 1
$ 65 &5 $ "
6 ( $@ 6 $
& &5$ " @
@ 8
16
4
4 ! "
4
&8 4
$@$
16
4
4
@ $ & & "
16
5
"
6
&5C)C.&5 9
" &46 &
5 B&5 J)&
4 9
6 4
=
4
48 & "
"&" 6
@
16
4
4K6 J & K 8
B&5 )&
-1
5/ )&
@ 8
16
4
4 16
$" 1 45
4)&
6 B& 8 6@ 6(
4
16
4
4 & )&
6 5"5$" 1 ")&
-1
5/ 5@B& @ 8
16
4
4 86 6 J & K
&5B& )&
-1
5/! @
8
16
4
4 "
$ '4& " @ 8
16
4
4 "
!! !! 5
&
4 .'
" $ 6(
4
16
4
45
@ !6 $(
$6 6 5 "
6 5@ @
<& + 1 4 8 $ 8 6(
4
16
4
! ! @
$& "
8 $
&& " # ! "
55@ 5
& '4& 6 6
4 !+ !G 4&
B& 6 & 8
6
8& ! 6
5 6&5 6 $
& 8 5@"
&$
" )&
#! ! 9
$
5
" #! !
6 C6C - /
&
5 16 5
&
5 " " 6 " )&
1& @ 8
16
4
4
&5).&5
$ 55@
6&5" &
8
16
4
4$6 " )&
#! !G6 & 8 6
@
"@
$B&6 8 4
4$@.'
" '4& <&
=
1
6&5$ $
6 "
5@
<&
=
6&
5@ 6(
5 )&
5@ 5
6 @ 5<&
=
" )&
-1
5/>$ & 5@@ 5
" <&
=
7)&
I&
4
5
46
46(
"
5)&
$
<&
=
- &$ 5 $@ ' 4& .'
" A!! #/ 16
4
4 G &4
$5 56
46( 6 56 & @
&5 B& 8 6 8 4
$@ 4& 6 56(
4 <&
=
16
4
4 "5
)&
-1
5/1 @8 4
$@ 5
16
5
4
4
" )&
$ @" 55 6
4 &8 4
$@ "
$" 8 6&5$ & $5& " " )&
1 1& 6 @
4 $ 55 & 5@
!! !! ' 4& B& ! @ " 8
16
4
4 5 B& :@ ! " @ 8 . B& ! @ +" ! @ & 8 =
& 8
$( &
6 ( $@ % " 55
!: !!4& "$ 8 ! @ 6 5 15 4 8
& $5"
1
' 4& 556 $@ .'
" $@ 5
9
& .&5 - /-
/
" " + # $ @
1
& +! #"
""
=
&
%99$" $
@ &"" 1
"5@
6&5$ 5 $5 $
" 4 $
"5@'&
"L & 5
"5@ C"
"$@
@ &
"
$" '&
"5@ "
6 $
4'&
5 '4& - 5
( $
"$
'4&
C / &5 $ "$ '4& 6
4
&"4&
C + 1& &4
5
$
8 @
& 6 5@ 5 $5"
46@ 8 6 4
5=
46
&
$5
&
$
!+ !
4 '4& &
516
4" 6 &
6 5@
# !!
4
<&
=
6 "
" "16
4
4"& )&
6 & " 5 !:
! I&
4"
B&5
@ 5 $ "
$ & 8 4
$@$ '4& 5 " ! 55 " &5
)&
-1
5/ A7 :!! #6 &55@8 4
)&
@
16
4
4 $ (4&
$5 +
5@
! '&
A $ &
@
'4& 6 6(
44
)&
8 6&5 & & >$ & 5@ & $
4 16
5
4
4$ '4& $
<&
=
6 &55@"
46()&
>6
5 B& " &5
)&
-1
5/"& ! @ 6(
4 8
16 5
4
$5 $5" (1 16 '4&
4$ 16
4
4 !+ ! "58
6
4 B&
8).&5 !
!!1& " 6 " 16 " !! !!" @ 8
16 5
4
4 $
5 )&
-1
5/ A7 :!! # 5 ! ! !!55 8 @ $@$&6"
4$
)&
4 9
-1
5/ #! ! 6 &
4 @ 8
16
4
4
&
5
G
45 $
$ 6
$ @ 6
& & "
8)6&5 $ @
16 4B&5 -4
=
4/ 5" 5
&5
$
6 .&5 - /-
/ 55@ &5 "
B&
$" $
@ &"" " &"
@G 5 $5
"& $
" '&
45
@ 4B&5 '&
"5@"@ 5@
"
4 4
"5@ $ " $@ &
4 "
4
4 $
&
5@
5 4 '4& $ 5 5@
45&5
@8
@ !! !!- &55@ !
!!/" "
)&
-1
5/
16
5
> &
5$ '4& 6&5 5" "'& $ & "55 48 " # $
4B& 5 @4 -) 5 1 54@/ $ " & L 6 6&5 55$ 56
"$@ '4&
5
56
" 5$@ 9 $ 4 ) 5=
4$
$@.'
""9
& &
=& .' "
@
4
*4
"
'&4"
)
&
C'.'2+6,5+ +- ! /+1A+! #!! ! G6 &
&
"
&"&
;-/
A:
A:# ! A! ! 6 & /
1 : !,,
/
)
:
;
- <
;
:
'. : & ' ) :!
.
<
1 : ! ,,
% 8&
4
" $ $&4
&G &4 & &$5@45$@ $ 5$ 5 4$@
& 4& "H
@
B& "
"559 &
51
5 =& -91=/ " & 6 $
4 4
) 5=
47)1 6 '&4"
& 6$
& 4 $ @$@ Q$5&"& 15
$
$
5 ) 5 C4
=
4 55
66 $ 5$@
& 4& 6 &55@B&5 $
" .'
"6 "
&5 @.'
" C4 55
;
5@ "
B& &
( A 6 5
&
$
!
556 "&4 !! !!
B& . !
'4& "
16
5
6 !! !!6
6" " @
55
B& 5$ &5 @ 4 6&55 $4 " 9
5 &4 @ 4 1 $ "
46( 6
55$" &55@ & 4@ 55$
56
4"- &5 @/ 4 6&5$4 "
# !!
"
5
4B&
8 " .'
" 1 55$
6
D *9 2E "$!A !