← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19937/2012dismissed

Chief Engineer Irrigation Deptt Pb Chd & ORS v. Lalkar Singh & ORS

2015-09-03Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi7 pages

  

       !"!#$!%&%!%!'

 ()* +%& ,&-!!' 

  &%!%!'&$ .&$/  

   &0',&'%  !"!#$!%&%!%!'

 ()*   &%!%!'&$ .&$/  

 &0',&'%  ) 1 2) 3

.  

$&&'%   





      

!

  44444 # $  

  % & '    ( %

.   5 $ 

 )          )      *  ) "

!

!  "

!

!  

 )

  " 

" " "

 $ "

 

'+ #,,-. &/#& !" 

)  

0     & $          

        

 1

(

      

"&&23&&.   1

0  "

    

&/

" &/#&  0   4"

1  $ 



      "

0     !"    

6)   ")  -/7







- $

  

 0 " 

! " #.65 1  (  " #,8.9

: ";<! 



 = 

24"

&/#& 8 $  "

 6) ) 



 

! 

 + -/>&

#& = #,,>?   !"  

0$  

 !"  @,

0? !") A @,

0! 

## 

#,,>$ 

)

 0 2/

0  B 0     !"  )     )  "  

  #- C

#,,2$



! ) )   0

 0   &8/

0 "  "



0



   !") "

0 



    

 A"))

!  

 !")    *&8/

0   

   !" > $

0 "     

     !"  

 

   

 A  

A 

) "

"A )    " "!

" !

"

! "

  " &>6C "

   ) !) !) 

   ""



 

 ))" "   

"" 2 $

  ) "

0 

  

"" 0  !    

"       "           +',6+$73!'86 ! $&!,!'8

!-&$52+7/$/$%5 +#+',6+$+', %6&$9&//&D#E=-, (! 5" " %+%&

!-&$5 +$:+'+  $7+'  &"&#0;&'%  /%6$!%: ! $&!,!'8  

!-&$  +', +'%6&$9&//#D&E

3 !"= "  .1  

    ) ) " 

 "

  &-&

0  ! )   " &>C "  "   

"" " 6F "

)   

"" !"G $

 "  

0  !"  6) 

 &-@

0 

A   $"

  "  (! 5"   )/<&6=/;+$ ! $&!,!'8

!-&$5 ',/%$!+#>-/;>2+7/$/$%>5+$!,+7+,+',+'%6&$9&//#D&E= -/&  &$?&0/$  &'%$+#  0  +'< 2!;!%&, ! 2+7/$  /$%5

+%6!',++',+'%6&$#,@2+&/893?< ) 

" 0 0 ! "

  &8/

0

  

"" )  " 

 6"

  &8/

0  !") "

)

@

  1) " " " 

 ) 

! 

! " &>C  " "

0 " &>C ""   "

 

"   ") 

) 0           "  "

      "  "

 0?"   !

) 0"  "

 )" &>C) 0)  

 !          "    6   " "

 " 

)  

       

  

      



  





   !  " 

 # !



  "# # 

 !$

%&#! $ % &  '

(  "  ) *   "! 

"&

'



        + D&/#>E88>@ ' ()    )     * 

+*   * #

) , * *    -.   - (  (

,(- (

) , * *  *  /    0* 

*  +# 1  2*- * )&  ( ,* ) * ,)' - ,)   ,  3* 4*

+*)   . *  + #5 ,   -*

 -.  

  )  

  ))-  ,  %     - * - ) *

))(  -  - 5 ,  .- )     - *  

,( ) - * ' -  ( (# )  (   ) - * *   ,(5 , - *  ) )  ,)  * , * * ))  '  -)

    - )(  .   -- * **  *) $6    

'   * 

 * ,(   3:&,+<7"=3+,6+<$!6'+'5

1#,288..   

)    )

  "    "

  " 0 A " )"

  " " " " #/        

  

!



 

   

0 

"



"

  )   "

  

    

 #-C

#,,2

)

     0 !    "

  #& 

&//#)""



>H0

)  1) ""  "  

  "

"  )         

     "  "     "



 0)  



"$

 "

  6    

   0  0     $  "

  !"

"      

   5 

 1  ""     * 

A     !

 ") "





 ! 



#- C

#,,2#&  

&//# )" 

   "   

  

0 $    A    

   

    

   

  *0

  "

 ") )-/7 ")

0

) "

  )"

#-  

&//# "

    6)  ## $   ""

0   '+ #,,-> &/#&   

 0    

 #-C

#,,2    "  #& 

&//#4 "  

0 0  " )) $0)

    

#& $  )" 

   "  )"   "+ . &//# " 0    4"



5 

#&=0 &//8)"   

 !") "  &-2

0$)  )

 )"

0  !")8/7 ") 





  "&8 = 

&///1'+ #@.#@ &//8  (! 5"    

##

   &@

" &//>

)"   D!E&.@ &//2"

  

     

 )")  &/= 

&//20   

   0    

 " (! 5"  

 

  "





5 $    

 ! "

 1"



 ! 

"#8 "



?     A "  "  

!)  ! "

 A   ;=/;+$"'!' ',!+ D&//#E&-@2I 1&/// -2@, #-    



0  ) )

!

"

 (

.   *    3&0%&;7&$ 5