High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14277/2014dismissed

M/S Mehta Engineers v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-10-21Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Registrar-Judicial18 pages

!"#$ "

%"& '( )"*" +, !"# $%&'( )*+,-( !.(*/,$0!'

$%&'( )*+,-(! */!$1,$2/ "

"(,-*."/"&01%0

"," $(!.'.2"0,&*1%-".0)"*

!.(*/,$0!'3 ',",,"&"$,&!!""

314&"5,6*"" 7&" $$"0)"*0%2,,. .6*!""

,6*-".!"5&$58""070+2"0

314&"5:02$'&"!"!$

#"&. ","&6$," &, & $& &" ( . $,0 '&6&."0 $,0 & &"$,"&"0" +2" 7 $ $$". ,"& :::: 7 "$

,"% +&. 95; )"*-".(.'4+&.0:

< "

"0=+&.=0,",,. "& .!6.*"

" %.! 6 "$ ,*$ 4 ' .!6.* " 2 & ,"

' ,"

.!6.*2 "$::::

'.$& "2 ,"&.%.6 "$ 42 9.1,"

,"% +&. 95; % +&.0$& .4 ""26, "4,"* %*" "$2 & 3 ' ( )"* $ " %"

"".4" ". ::

" "6 " ""=($=7,"% ".!6.*0,"&" ".$!

6 0",*$ .,2" "%"* &.1,"

$0",*$ " ".26 ","

% *" ' . 2 ," 33

7$$.*" "$&&&,2,(. '4,"$" "2"!&.".*, ""!.1

""6*".0,"&.& 6&0"$ .2+&. 95; +&.0 .!6.*" !","22"2$! )!"#%.("!$$.

'""2 %*,"%."

)2%"06*$0 "$& 4."*6, 4'4 ,"$%" "..6"&" 7&" ,"$ 1 >& 2"2. .!6.* " 0!&"*%"" 9

0.&. " & "$ ," ' $& 2 "$ :09 < 51!!"%!""0,"," "",,. '8 4'4$$"1,,.0?"60% ""

:0,,,." ""5.&.

3 "0 4'4,"$"%$&

4 " ," " " " . "$ 7&" ,"$ '" "0 % ""

0 1!

1&"*"5.&."& "$,"

5/ $$& 9

30-".!"5&$58""0 70 +2"0 " ," ,* "0 2 2

" $& "." 6* 4 '4 ,"$ &6>&.* 1!!"% ! $$&0 ," ," "" ,,. 6 " ""

7&"0)"*02%""

30$$ #"&. ","&6$($

"" ". 6*-%"$ )"*0.&

,"% ",2""%".7 5,*$0&.6 "%"""" ."%&7 * &.".* ",*$ ." ,.*2"!6.,"%&" )"*-".(.'410:

3 ""0=1=+&.

"$ "&" ',"% *$" ,"% "

"!! "$&,"6 "& '" &.",*$ ."$ .&<022 &6", " %*"20 0,2," < .& ($%@,"% )"* &6.*+%"*1 ""%"* .0 &."

.*",*$ .?".%* ",.*0,"% 1&.6%@

' ($ , % $ ' 6 "" %"2,"% +&. 95;

+&.'.$ (.'4,"$2 0$$ $& 42,'"($ "& "$,"&%!+&. 95; +&.7 &,," ,.".2,.&,A&!$ )=6. (&,"$&"

/('

3(+ A&!$

&"#1

3B ! "# 033

"0."&. "(&6$ ,".!6.*" &,"0&.%. 6 "$ ,*$ 4& 9.' ," .$2 "$::::

&"!&""*0 ,"%.6 & 30:

03:

5" "

,".*.,.,".*2.&1,"""0" 2,"& "$3

( &""" ""30 < 0.!6.*" 02,"% " ,"&"$,"& &"".6.*,* "'" "2.$+&. 95; 6 +&.,"%! ""&"2.!6.*" !"&&.62"2+&. 95; % +&.2 ." ""&6$,*$ ""$&26$ "4,"* ," %*"702." ""! .& < ($0 2 &6$ ($6A "22 "$%6 "A&2+&. 95; +&.' &.6

< "2" ".2+&. 95; +&.02& 2,"2.6 " ".7.*.!6.&".&&"+&. 95; +&.02&.%. 6 " ". 9 #"&. "( &""&6$.&

($,"% &.0,"% 1 +&.2..6,,.6.7 &.2"," . 2 $& &"! %* % &"! &""*

.!6.* " .!6.* " 2"20 >&"!%.6 " ".2@2*7 "&$0"!2"!"!$ "

"$,"( &""&6$ A&!$ 6*."&. ","".% ""%"*& '" ".2," "$$$ "$ $&&&"1'." .".*6.,"% +&.($ 65.@$& .266 "$&

(6""&72." "$" ,"* : 7",0."&. ","&6$ .& ($6%@*" "," $.*!& ,"&"*" ","! &"1.&2"2," " ,"046, 4'4,"$0$* 6 " "! . "$ 7&" ,"$0 " 2 .%6.&"1

)"."&. ",","&,,"

6@ +.%," " ".$"4" 6.2 C)1+D11-/ + '

7E('+7 ( 1+' '

+ + '!%". &"0-%"" )"* ,. "$&.2$ "%"

"".4" ".'. &" $"&"

;8 '7/ %2,"$&"*." ,0(-%"$ "$&.&".

,.* 2 ,"% &$6" .9 .

%22..4!","&" & % !" . 4 4$, "$E"4!,.* 4 '4 ,"$0 &". & .!6. "44$, "$&"

F 1 $,"!

"..* 6@2" " <

4,.

%$ <G 4 ,. %$ 6& 4!

+ "" :*" F ; $,"!

"..* "0 "

H1 <G

4 %$

G 4 ,. %$ 6& 4!

+ <""

*" F $,"!

?"60 ;..6!"

$,.4 1$"

4,.

%$ :

G 4,.

%$ 6& 4! + 3 "" <*" 7 ."7&"*046 & "$ "

*"&,<

G 4,.%$

E7'(E +'1I7- J1(7 7/ +(7?71'7

G .

4 ,.

%$ :

G . 4 ,. %$ 6& 4!+<"" :*" ;

G . 4

G .

4 ,.

%$ :

G . 4 ,. %$ 6& 4!+ "" <*" ' ,"&" " .$! . 4 4$,

"$6.2(-%"$0 4 '4 ,"$ -(+

9:0 <9:(-%"$ $ "$$$$@ ,"&"$,." 766"&! -%"$ ""42"%"6. "," % *"6!"$ " ,&", $,&!$4.6.*&" 35; 7$'41'(-%"$0 " "0,"%" "."&! $04 .4.6. 7&".

E2, " "",*$&" &".,.* (-%"$

.!6.* 7&".&2 %&".!6.*" 6&6*7&","$ 7&". & 2 %&" .$ " 6&6*" '0 2..6.!6.%.$.% $ J#11'7 ' .!6. &". & .! .!6.*.$" %.$.% 6 $6*,!%"4 "" " ,"%& *" 7" ?" # ,"%$&"7$'41 "

9 *"6 .H 3+ E+ 7&".&,! "%" ".

$& .47"?"#..!%" , $ ,,.*! " !" "2.

.$" ",&* 4 '4$$"',4"2..6

. ' ,&* 4 '4 $$" ".. "2" &".& .!2 ,* .$ " -".!""7&""" "$&6&$,&* 4'4 $$" .. $ " * 6@ !&"

,". &" $"!! *, !"$ ,"% $ (. '4 "$ 4'4,"$ "$ &","&" '-".!""7&""2.. " ".>&%.$4 .6. *"0 6!& " "*" ?" &6>& *"0 . 2.. 6 "

@! &

"&. $ 4 .6.* ,"%& *"0 .

.$,"0.!6.* " ',"2..6$,.22@ ", .$ "2." ) 2..$&.&.*@&".& &" &"*,"%$!"$

"4& 7&".&2"%.!$.% 6 $ . 4 "$ " 2 "& !!$%"" " .0 "2. *""&".&2% %..4 "$6&"7$'4"&" %6 .H "0.,,.*-".

: !"0 " 7&" " " "

%" (.'4" ". "2. *"" ""."," * &" " !"$" "&" %&" -". !"0 " 7&" " " )2%"0& ",*$.."$ $!"6* 4'4 ,"$,"%)"*-".(. '41"&.$"&" '@!&>&"".*"&" .6* 7&".&&.*" 6*!&" 2.! .0-".!"0 "7&""2.."6.."&"* %"*>&"" "$& ""!&"", =

5(.'459

"",K06! $$&A")C 9<5# "/..! ($..7&"5

5"#0.& "". 4,*$ 1"2..6 .2 &!",

4,&"0&"2..6$&" ",)2..4,&"&" L

5(. '45(5" ",0 & $&" ""A")L 9<5#

"/..!($..7&" "!"!"

"..& "".4 6L 9<5# "/..!($..7&"59

" # & $& $ "$ A"

) L

5(. '4 ,"% " "" ,*$ .4 ( E+7'7 ( .!6. 7&". & 2.. &" *

..2!&" "! "5,& "! 2 ""4 .6!&"M "!..".%!%.&

>&%..$& "!& 6* ".

(.?.7&.H

(&. ;@ ,"% &

$"! %.6. % <G . $& "$ 6@ !&" 9<G "$ ,".

&" <+ 1D '

'" "..& ""$&

.42..6"%"6. "," %*" ,"%6* 4'4,"$+&. 1 )"*-".(.'41 '&".&,$&" 6 "&'"&"*&"L 9<5 # " /..! ($.. 7&"5($.. (. 7&"-" 7" ?"#.& "" (.'4K

+'(1'7 -".!" "7&""

""2..% &..,2". .& $& ""44.!6.* .$ " 6 & %&" &".&

+'+ / +') #1 -".!" "7&""

""2..6 &..*$,2""%"

. &.""" ."%&&"

,"% )"*&6.*+%"*1 7 * &.".*",*$ ."

,.*2..6"!,"%&")"* -". (. '4 1 +&. $ "&" )2%" ","!&"1602& ,"."!2..6!"&". &

97'+7- ' .. &".& .!6.&".&2.. .$%"* *"&"!&""* .-".!"0 "7&""2 $ . ?.*"' .$2...& 6. 0 "! & ," . $ & :1 1# 1,,. ! -". !"0 "7&"""!"!! . ""%"*" ..."" 7&"0 )"*K

)'(45 +/( )'(* C+&. 95; '!** $0)*+ ,(*3 ( ,0$0 +/( $0,+,$* 6("7+,$8(( "($+ " !9"($+ !6( 35; <51 '.!6.*" !"&".& .. 6 .6. 6 2"2 * $ &"! &""*6*,,","("!$$

..2!"&$ %"666* "&0 $","0 $5$ " .$ $". M & 6&6*&".!

2 6& " && ," 4!4$4, "0 . "&"..$0"0"@".@& 2, $$" 6*". &M ,."" "6*& * 4 %".*

! $& &"! "

,"&,*M 6 .!6.* " 2"20 4$, .$" ..6$% 62"2 "$* %.*& ..6.6.,*$ 40"",.*&"

1 4$, .$" % 6!" 7 . " " &0 6. $&

6 .44$, "$..6, ,&""

" " & 2 $ !".%. ,"&2&,! * & 2 2&. %".*

$& &"!","&,* & " "$!,"&6A &.

.$ .. "&.

"%"" 2"2. .!6.* " ..6$2&

"!"6. ,,"&* 6!"

&MK 1,"&. ($22 "$2%2 !%". &"022"."*.!6 "$ ,*$ .4'$& "".42 6%"" ".7 0$2 ::

0$&,""% +&. 95;+&.02 2%$$9<:::/ +&. 12+&.

% "$ :9 33::

"$$"& ,"% ( 35; 7$'4102"6*&,.42"$ "$! $0"$& "$ 4 2%"" ".6%6*7&" ,"$ .!6. &". &0 2 &" 2 6

3 " "" 4 '4 ,"$ '" 2 " 1 >&0 &". & 2" 6. .$ &&"7$'41 3 .& $ .!6.*.*& 2 %&" .!6.* " 6 & 6* 7&" ,"$.$" 6&6*" ,&* 4'4$$"02".!6.%.6 $.&3,"% ","&" ",,.*! "" " ..& ,"%" ".!".& "" $& .426"%"6. "," %*"7$* 6$ " "$ .4&"+&. 951

10",*$26$ " %*"02""$

+&. 95; % +&.0 ""$& 426, " ," % *" '&! $ 2 ,"%! , ..* "!" " ". "$& 4 "" &" +&. 95;0 6& .. 6 " 2 6! !" ' 6 "2",,*% ""&"!$& " ". "," %*".& ($,"% ",2" -".!" "7&"""%". """ ."%&0"* &.7%&.*0 " ,.*2."!6.,"% "&"1 +&. +&. 95; +&.,"% ". &"0," " "4$, "$ "$,*$ 4' ,"%,"2 "$9::

!2,.*

"%&""$ "%6*-%"$

)"*7&","$'6 "" "4$,

"$,*$ 4" "$ ",*$ 4.!6.&".

& ","4 $&$(&65+&.< " '6 $".%2"2"&"* 2. < 1,"+&. 95; +&.0.!6.*" !"&".&2.6.62"2*$&"! &""*6*,,",""!$$ & $266* "&00$","0$5$" .$ $". M"&&6&" .2$ "&&," 4$4, ", "&$",."" " 6* &%".*

!$& &"!,* 7 2"2. .!6.* " 0 4$,

.$" $%62"2 "$ "* %.*&2.6.,*",.*&" 1 .$" %"6!"1,"+&. 95;

% +&.0 ""$& 426, "4,"*

%*" "$2& 70 """0%.* .!6.*" ,"2 "$::::

' .$& $6.6 ,"2 9.0&

2 30:

03:

5 2 %. 6* ," &, 3

'" "0,.$"*2,".*.,".*2. &?"$3

0&,"&1,"%. .!6.*" 0$"2,&&,:

< )!" #%. ("! $$

%. . 2 +&. 95; +&.0 $$2"2.!6.*" 1>&0 ,"6$.6.,*"$& 40" ,.*"$ +&. 95; 6 +&.0 6

"$ 4 4$,2%.6.," 1 ,"". "$7&","$,*$& 4 4'4,"$06 & 6%. '$& "2.&.6*1!

1&"*1!!"% ! ""0,"," "",,.

.$!$& 42,,"$$$.* " 6$& ""! " " . "$7&" ,"$00"2,*6.1,","% 10 .*,*$ 40""!6.&"( << ,.*"!6.&"( 9 1 9 ' ,"$"* " 6* ." &. " ,"" &.",*$ " ". ","% ".%* "E"($0$

"..*&.. ")2%"02 *&6 "',"% +&. 95; +&.($ "0 06"!"'6 "$ ,*$ 4 %.6.&".&02 %&".!6.*.$ " %6&&","% +&. 95; +&.'"""1*&%.!6 &.

.. .&"0.!6.*" &.6 2"2&"!&""*"$ +&. 95; +&.1

>&0&2.6.,*40",.*"0 .!6.* .$" 2%"& : 1."*66%0"$ ( 35;

7$'410&& 42"$6. ,"&."*".* 2"&..*,"&.61 $& .426!,6*&%.!6

"$ ,*$ 40$&26!"$ "&.!.%* $47"&$0$!

&.$!&6 0( "$($ "%"! $& ""4" ".1%." 6*7&","$&!!2$".*6@"* "$ (,"$"'".%.6!='4,&" %.%..6"&"",)C

:5(.'459

"+,0K6!$$&A")C 9<5 # "/..!($..7&"59

5".0.& "" .4,*$='"2","*%.%

1,"&. ($26 " " . &. 6 %. .* 6* &". & 2 %&"

.!6.* .$" 6&"$ % $ <:9:+&. 951 +&.02%"0 ,&($2$,,.6.%6 " &"+&. 95; +&.7&, .!6.*" 0&..$6 " ". &"($$.!6.*" 2"20" .@6,&6@0$.*0,"%. " 6 22. '($&

,2"52%2+&. 951 95; +&.

"6*."&. "," ,0($,02&.$% 2".!6.*" !"&2"2% 6 "," "",*$ " ".4,"0$& &.6"%" "$&&02.@ "0% &!&2..$*6 " ". ($(&","2&.6..*6&" .* $ " ".0"&$6A 222 "$7 ($","$" ,"&!!02&.$" ".%&02 " . " %.!

6 7 6@ " -%"$ & " "%" ! ," 2 ..$6 " ". "$*02&.6.6. ,* " &60 ..* ,"%! . .6.* .4,"$6*"!. "$7&" ,"$02&.".*6$.6.,*"" ,"% "&"1 ",".$&2&.

'A&!$" ""6*,"$* ., &.2"2"$." ,.* "0,$*6

" ;& 2" 2 $0 $.*0 ,"% +&. ($ " "5,0 . %2 6 @ "

",",&",0!4&26A6%

3 ?""$6%02 *$" ,",'$"!.*$ +A;. 8&!

"(! % 8&! ",@!

" D "+,"6. D