High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12645/2016dismissed

The Amritsar Tea Traders Association Regd Office: Katra Ahluwalia, Amritsar And ORS v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2016-11-28Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan9 pages

#$% &%'()(*+ ,

!+ - .!// .

- .!/ // 0%)%*$+ !0/1*(23#&3#4/%*(0&5'#$%6($3 !07%)388#06#24&5'#$% 0$3%9%$($(*%0) !0:#7#2/%38#24&&2&5'#$%%*%0#241*;#< !0/#*;%%5/*(#*&!0*(2:17#0/3#07#4 &5'#$% 00%)9*&%*$)=#*& !0// %324&5'#$% 0$3%#992('#*$ (*! #;%)3 (*&#2 >#0(1)#))'(#$(*) $0#&%0)'#00?(*8*<1)(*%))(*<#@##0)A )$0%%$)*%#02&%*%792%470($)#03#5% (2%&$3%90%)%*$9%$($(*90#?(*8

0)%$$(*8#)(&% 0%)21$(*9#))%&<?!1*('(9#2090#$(*470($)#0(* %*%0#21)%7%%$(*83%2&*B, 3%)1<)$#*'% $3%0%)21$(* 6#)$0%)$0('$5%3('12#075%7%*$ $0#

('(*'%0$#(*#0%#)'2)%$$3% 2&%*%792%(*#90;%'$ 0($)<%#1$( ('#$(* 3%'*$%*$(* 2%#0*%&'1*)%2 0$3%9%$($(*%0)6#)$3#$ $3%9%$($(*%0)#0%'#00?(*8*$3%(0<1)(*%)) 632%)#2%#*&0%$#(2$0#&%(*

<#@##0)A)$0%%$)'2)%$$3%2&%*%792%)#0%)12$ 0%)$0('$(*)* 5%3('12#0$0#

('(*'21&(*8%5%*$663%%2%0)#*&3#*&'#0$)A0('C)3#6)4 $3%(0<1)(*%))3#)<%%* #

%'$%& <#&2?$6(22#71*$$1*0%#)*#<2% 0%)$0('$(*$'#00?*<1)(*%)) $3%$0#

('92('%3#) #(2%&$0%812#$%$3% $0#

('(*$3%#0%#4$3#$&%)*$8(5%#0(83$$0%)$0('$$3%$0#

('(*$$#2($? *2?0%812#$(* 5%3('12#0$0#

(''#*<%9%07($$%&#*&*$'792%$%<#* $3%0% *$3%#0%#4$3%0%#0%*17<%0 0%)(&%*$(#231)%)3%0%)(&%*$) 6(22 #'%90<2%7)(*2%#5(*8$3%(0)'328(*8'3(2&0%* #*&%5%*$3% #7<12#*'%'#**$0%#'3#$$3%&%)(0%&92#'%)#0%)12$4$3%9#$(%*$)7#? )1

%0 %'#1)% 0%)$0('$(*) 5%3('12#075%7%*$(*$3%#0%#4*%7#?

3#5%$$#C%#2*8%001$%01**(*819$ $=C7)$0%#'3#92#'%463('3 7#?<%;1)$ $7%$%0)#6#?$3%06()%3%0%)(&%*$) $3%#0%##0% 0%#&?$)1990$$3%#1$30($(%)(*$3%(090;%'$ <%#1$( ('#$(*436%5%04 $3%(0(*$%0%)$<%#2)$#C%*'#0% %#1$( ('#$(*)312&*$<%#$$3%')$ $0#&%0)#*&$3%0%)(&%*$) $3%#0%#3%/$#$%()&1$?D<1*&$$0%#$#22 ($))1<;%'$)%E1#22?6($3*90% %0%*'%$#*?*% * $3%$3%0 3#*&4 2%#0*%& '1*)%2) 0 $3% /$#$% #*& $3% !1*('(9#2 090#$(*)1<7($$%&$3#$($()#90%)$(8(1)90;%'$463%0% <%#1$( ('#$(*#01*&$3%2&%*%792%()<%(*8'#00(%&*3%2&%* %792%()#602& #71)9(280(7#8%)($%463('3()5()($%&<?$3%9%92% #22 #($3) #(2?#<1$ 44 &%5$%%)5()($$3%#0%# %)(&%)4$3() 5%0*7%*$3#)'#00(%&1$7#*?&%5%297%*$#'$(5($(%)(*$3%#0%#3% 90'%))4(* #'$4)$#0$%&6#?<#'C(*$3%?%#0F,,463%*$3%2#*&#01*&$3% 2&%* %792% 6#) #'E1(0%& 0 #2(#0# 90;%'$ 3% /$#$% () 6%22 '*)'(1)#<1$$3%&(

('12$(%)$<% #'%&<?$3%$0#&%0)#*&$3%0%)(&%*$) (*$3%#0%#229))(<2%7%#)10%)3#5%<%%*$#C%*$%*)10%$3#$$3%?&

= *$ #'%#*?90<2%7436%5%04)$(22<#2#*'(*83#&$<%&*%*5#0(1) 7%%$(*8) 6($3 $3% $0#&%0)4 63#$%5%0 )188%)$(*) 6%0% 9))(<2% #''%9$#*'%46%0%#''%9$%& <2#0&)91$19#$&(

%0%*$92#'%)#0%)3( $%&#) 9%0$3%)188%)$(*)8(5%*<?$3%9%$($(*%0)4$3#$6(22)9(2$3%%*$(0%90;%'$ 3%0%612&<%5%3('12#0$0#

(''0))(*8$30183$3%9%&%)$0(#*6#?%

10$3%0 )1<7($$%& $3#$ %*$(0% <%#1$( ('#$(* $3% #0%# (*'21&(*8 $3% 909%0$(%)6*%&<?$3%90(5#$%9%0)*)3#)<%%*&*%<?$3%/$#$%#$($) 6*%G9%*)%)#0%)12$$3%0% 4$3%<1)(*%))(*$3%#0%#6(22(*'0%#)% 7#*( 2&#)$3%$10()$)A&%5$%%)'7(*8* $6(22'%0$#(*2?5()($$3% )39)#)'79#0%&$$3)%463$0#5%2(*5%3('2%)*?'3#*8%(*$3%92#* #$$3())$#8%()*%($3%09))(<2%*0 %#)(<2%3%9%$($(*%0)#0%7%0%2?

#990%3%*&(*8&(

('12$(%)* #'$4(*$3%2*801*4$3%?6(220%#2()%$3#$($ 6#)#22 0$3%(0<%*% ($*2?3%?)312&)1990$$3%90;%'$ %#0&2%#0*%&'1*)%2 0$3%9#0$(%)#*&9%01)%&$3%9#9%0 <C

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

#C3$H(("#0:(#10(H(((" 1C3 3#*;#*( %01;1<%0%%"H(5"3#0# /#3(<H5" %0 #<# 1&3#(H5("101&6#0#2#'3( %0H5(("$3/#$3 (0#$3H#*&5(((" 1*8# #<# %%9/(*83)9%0%)$(7#$%)4$31)#*&) &%5$%%)5()($$3%92#'%*&#(2?<#)()463%0%#)*6%%C%*&)#*&)9%'(#2 ''#)(*)4$3%*17<%00%#'3%)(*2#')3%<%#1$( ('#$(*90;%'$#01*&$3% 2&%* %792% #2) $#C%) $3% $10()$) $ #22(#*6#2# #834 #*$3%0 3()$0('#292#'%(*$3% 0%%&775%7%*$3%7%70(#2'77%70#$%) C(22(*8 #<1$ 49%92%#))%7<2%&$3%0% 09%#'% 127%%$(*8* = FF4*(*&()'0(7(*#$% (0(*80&%0%&<?%*!('3#%2I ?%0* )7%90$(*) $3%<1(2&(*8)(*$3%5('(*($?

4<122%$7#0C)#0%)$(225()(<2% 63('33#5%<%%*90%)%05%&#2*86($3$3%7%70(#26%224(*63('3)7% 9%92%;179%&$%)'#9% %)(&%)$3()42'#$(* $3%'($?()(790$#*$4($ <%(*82'#$%&'2)%$$3%(*$%0*#$(*#2<0&%0<%$6%%**&(##*&#C()$#* 3%<%#$(*80%$0%#$'%0%7*?3%2&$3%0% %5%0?%5%*(*8()#*(790$#*$ %5%*$ 0#*?$10()$()5()($$$3%'($?()*$'792%$%41*2%))3%5()($)$3% <0&%0#*&3#))%%*$3%'%0%7*?3#*8% 1#0&6($3(*3#*&)3#C(*8 &()$#*'%<?*&(#*#*&#C()$#*( 0'%)7#C%)($#)9%'$#'2%%5%*$*$3% <%#$(*80%$0%#$'%0%7*?

108(#*# %792% .#C)37( #0#(* %792%" () #*$3%0 3()$0('#292#'%4 1*&#$(* 63('36#)2#(&<?#*&($!#&#*!3#* !#25(?##7(0#$3()#*$3%03()$0('#292#'%2'#$%&'2)%$70($)#0$ ()<%2(%5%&$3#$($0%2#$%)<#'C$$3%9%0(& #7#?#*#$3#)#*#*'(%*$ $#*C#*&7#*?$%792%)!#$#/($#8#5%<(0$3$.15#*&:1)3#$$3()92#'% $()#2)<%2(%5%&$3#$63%*.0&#79%0 07%&)36#7%&3# #8*#4.15 #*&:1)3'#183$$3%30)%(*70($)#0#*&%5%*$(%&.0&#*17#*6($3#

$0%%#$$3%92#'%'2)%$ 108(#*#%792% 3%'($?()$3%06()%#2)

#71) 0$0#&($(*#2 &49312C#0(#*&3#*&('0# $) 3%90;%'$463('33#)<%%*$#C%*<?$3%#1$30($(%)()#)$%9

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

('<?<%#1$( ?(*8$3%#0%#91$$(*89#5%0)$3%0%*$ <%1)%&<?9%&%)$0(#*)#2*%22<1(2&(*8)(*$3%5('(*($? 3#5%<%%* 0%*5#$%&#*&<%#1$( (%&<?$3%/$#$%#$($)')$3%7#**%0(*63('3$3% #0%#3#)<%%*&%5%29%&()60$3)%%(*8*%3#)$)%%$3#$$<%2(%5%3% #990#'3 5%3('12#0$0#

(' 070#&A)$0%%$)9%*(*8*$3()90$(* $3% 0#&463('33#)<%%*9#5%&43#)<%%*)$99%&<?91$$(*8<2#0&) 3% 7#**%0(*63('3$3%9%$($(*%0)#0%)188%)$(*8$0%75%<2#0&)#*&#226 5%3('12#075%7%*$#'0))$3%9%&%)$0(#*6#?6(22&% %#$$3%%*$(0%90'%))

063('3$3%90;%'$3#)<%%*&%5%29%&*$3%7#(*0#&4C*6*#) <#@##0:#$0#3216#2(#4$3%0#&()9%*)#0%)12$ $3%0%)$0('$(*)*

$0#

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

'792%G4 ()#7#$$%0<#)%&*)'(%*$( ('0%)%#0'34)$1&?#*&%G9%0(%*'% 2%#&(*8 $ 0#$(*#2()#$(* 2#6) <? 6#? 2%8()2#$(5% %*#'$7%*$) #*& 012%) #*& 0%812#$(*) 0#7%& $3%0%1*&%0K*(*8#*&92#**(*8&0%)12$(*3#0&)3(9$ (*&(5(&1#2 909%0$?

B 909%0$?(*$3%6#?$3%?2(C%4())1<;%'$%&$0%812#$(*#*& '*$023%90(5#$%6*%0)#0%$)7%%G$%*$90%5%*$%&

077#C(*8$3%7)$90 ($#<2%1)% $3%(0909%0$? 1$

0$3() 0%#)* #2*%$3%'*$022(*8 0%812#$(*) '#**$<% $%07%&#)#0<($0#0?01*0%#)*#<2%3% 90(5#$% (*$%0%)$ )$#*&))1<0&(*#$%&$$3%91<2('8&$'#*<%)$#$%&(*# 6#?$3#$96%0$92#*&%5%297%*$ '($?#*&$0%812#$% $3%<1(2&(*8#'$(5($?$3%0%(* 26) 07$3%92('%96%0 $3%/$#$%3%%G%0'()% )1'385%0*7%*$#296%0();1)$( (%& *#''1*$ ($<%(*80%#)*#<2?*%'%))#0? 0$3%91<2('

3%#2$34 )# %$?4 70#2) 0 8%*%0#2 6%2 #0% #*& %'28('#2 '*)(&%0#$(*)H $3183 #* 1**%'%))#0? 0 1*0%#)*#<2% (*$%07%&&2(*86($3$3%90(5#$%6*%0)3(9 $3%909%0$?7#?

*$<%;1)$( (%&I 3%# 0%)#(&9#))#8%6#)E1$%&6($3#9905#2(*)3#C$# 9#0$7%*$)9%0#$(5%1)(*8/'(%$?.(7($%&#*&$3%0)5!1*('(9#2 090#$(* !17<#(#*&$3%0)4 =" /= B $ ()63%*# 9#0$('12#090;%'$() 1*&$<%#8#(*)$$3%7#*&#$% 2#60$#(*$%&&1%$ *2?$3%*$3%'10$'#*(*$%0 %0% 3%)188%)$(*4#)7#&%<?$3%9%$($(*%0) 09%*(*8$3% 9%&%)$0(#*6#?#$$3%0$692#'%)<?0%75(*8$3%<2#0&)0<?3#5(*8$3% 9%&%)$0(#*6#?*2?(*$3%7(&&2%90$(* $3%0#&4*63('3$3%$0#

3#)<%%*0%)$0('$%&#*&#226$0#

('*<$3)(&%)4()7%0%2?#)188%)$(* 7#&% 0$3%)#C% ($#) (0)$2?$3%)#7%6(22&% %#$$3%5%0?<;%'$ 0 63('3$3%#0%#()<%(*8&%5%29%&#*&)%'*&2?4($()*$90#'$('#<2%C%%9(*8 (*5(%6$3%6(&$3 $3%0#&*63('3$0#

('3#)<%%*0%)$0('$%&

, 3%92%#$3#$)#2% <1)(*%))7%*(*$3%#0%#6(22)1

%0* #''1*$ 0%)$0('$(* 5%3('12#075%7%*$()#2)90%)179$(5%3%#0%# #01*&$3%2&%*%792%())'*8%)$%&$3#$&10(*8&#?$(7%#2)4$3% 5%3('12#075%7%*$()E1($%0%)$0('$(5%3%<1?%0)'7%$$3%7#0C%$*

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

1&8% #0(*&%0/(*83/(&31"

1&8% ,

7C 3%$3%0)9%#C(*8A0%#)*%&+

%)A 3%$3%00%90$#<2%+

%)A