High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/19990/2012dismissed

Vice Chancellor, Kurukshetra v. Raj Rani And Another

2015-10-16Mr. Justice Darshan Singh25 pages

# !$%&

' ( "

)

*&+& &,

$ &

)-( !"

*&+&

$ &

)-.- !"

*&+&

$ & *

)-/0 !"

*&+&

$ & *

.- / !"

*&+&

$ & *

)) !"

& *&+&

" &,

$ & *

/- !"

& *&+& " &,

$ & *

0 !"

*&+& &,

$ & 1

" (" !"

*&+&

$ & 1

" (0 !"

*&+&

$ & 1

0 ( !"

" #

*&+&

$ & 1

*&+&

$ & 1

) !"

*&+&

$ & 1*

"" "

*&+&

$ & 1*

"" 0 !"

*&+&

$ & 1*

"0-- !"

*&+&

$ & 1*

"""0/ !"

*&+& !

$ & 2'

342 5 *

& ' % $ &!

% % &!

( )* +,,,- .-+// .-+01 .-+,2 '.-+. %

( )* +31+04.+2-5 '.-++ )* .-52- .-5., '.-+. % 6 ( $

% &!

( )* .211, '.-+. % &

( )* +/15, +/131 +/102 '.-++ ..-2- ..-+/ ..-.+4.+,3+ '.-+. % &

% &# &!

( )* ...20 '.-+.

% *! $

( * + )* +,,,- '.-+. % 6

( * .42 )* ..-.+ '.-+.

)* +/102 +/15, +/131 '.-++ % $ &!

% % &!

( * . 2 )* .+,3+ .-5., .-52- ..-+/ ..-2- '.-+.

+31+0 .+2-5

'.-++ % &

( 7"

)* .-+01 .-+// .-+,2 '.-+. % &!

( * . 2 )* .211, '.-+. 66666 + '

(

9 . ) (

* 7 + 8

( ''

+3"

( #

! )* +,,,- '.-+.

! . 8 "

! " .3&(

.-+.(

& !((

( " '' "

" 2 8"

( '

% % &!

! 8" '

' 1 8

'' ( * +7"

(

" . :

.--+6

! " " ( " 8 " (

"' 8

77 ''

' (

" ( ( 8((

( ;

! ' '(

& " (

" 8 ! ' '

/ 8 ( " '' " ((

" 5 8 ' ! "

(

'( !

(

"( 8 " "

# ! !

8 ! ("(

8+3 7<(

3 8

" ' ! (( <

" ' ( ' ./7: ' < $( & +,13 =

> &?@ "

" ' ! /-A " 8 ! "

" ! ((

( & !

(

! ( ! (

8 ! " !

' ( * +

8 (

( ' ' ;

! " ( ( !!

! ' ' ! 8

(

" ( + (

.--58 '

' ( * + ( " B '

( ' (

" ! < ( ! ,:

.--,

( " (

" (

'( 0 ! '

( ( .1- '

( ! ( '

, <

''!"

* * ' * ,3 ,.

,5 ./- ./. '.--0 (!

' 8'! " '

( ' ( ' ' '" " ! ' '

& +- 8 ! ((

" ''! (

D ( '

( ' ' " '!

' ! 8 '

+3 ( "

' "

'' 8"

" '

'' E

( ( ! "

! '

' '" B "

"'' 8 '

! "

" ( '

( (

++ 8 ! ( (( "

" ( "

' '

! ' ./7:

'&! '( ( .1- ' !8 (

! D ' (

(

(( ( ' ! '

"& +1 +5 ' '< 8(

" (

(

" D '

"" ! ( ' B ' '

(

!" ( ' ./: ' &"

! " (

8 ! ( "

( '

" F #$2#&7 8 9:5%:

:# # ! ; 5 9: # $ #

:< .--2 G1H 30- 2+ %,#

+ %75#8##! #;=+8#<G.--5H20+C# 9#$:# #! 58 &48$<G.--3H+/22 $# +9& :#8#%+%#& 48$ ! >8 < G.--3H+ 1-0 &# > ! $# ! , #: 5:#8# # $ #

:< G.--5H 5 ..+

? , #

48$# $#

:!;2#;$

5# 9:# $ :&< G.--3H / 3// 2#: $# 4 # ! $ ,8 +:

@<.--/G+H 1+, +. < !

! ;

& +,/5<'

! ' ! ' (

" !

(

((

;

! (

( ((

(

' ( ! 8

'( 8# &:+=+8#*$@#:!5# !:## $ :&<A+,,3H1 /5- (( ( '

" ((

( '

B B 6 ( ' '

(

! '< $(& +,13

+2 D ' ( '.1- ' ! ! " "

(

! " ( .1- ( ( '

8 ! (

! '

! (

" +1 8 !

" ' .GH '&

"((

'( :@&%#

&#%:4#B # @!=5:#8#<+,,3G2H .+/"

! ' " ( ' (

! "

(

( " (

( 8 !

(

!D <"

" ! & ! (

( '>

?" .GH '& !

( ( # 9# #5+,,@5?#9 #$! #;#,,# &<+,30/10 !

&@ !

: #8#:7G+,51H.3-2I&<+,51+052

! " > ?( 6 <

, #

!@ !#9,+8, @& G+,5-H.,1. +/ ' ( " '

!" (

''8 D "

' '(

+5 &( "

(

! .---

!" " (

& <

(

' ' "!

! ! 8"

" !" ' "

! ! (

7(( ! !

7"! '' ( '

+3 <! ' '

! " ' < (

* 2

( * +"

" !

2+$

.--3 '

" !"

! # " "'''

.--0 2 .--0

' !

.& " +-G+HGH ' & " "(( "( .---

"'B

;

! '

$( ' ! 8 % * & 6"

" ;("

' ! "

( !(( ' ' E

(

! "

* 222.2-

.--+ " ((

( "( " .25-J7 .0--J7( "" "

.-* !

.--0" "( ! '

" " !

( '" ' ( (

"' '% "' ' ' "' '

% "' '$ "

" ! "

( /

" '

! 8'(

.-* !

.--0 " !" (

( D ./7:

"!" '!

' ( < " '

! ' ! E((

(

D "

!" '

" E !

7( "

! ( D " ' !B( !

< $(& +,13 ( 5" (

(

" <

! (

"" '

! '

" '

(( ' ( "'( ( ' 7 ! (( "

! !

' " ( +0 <! ' (( " ))+& B 71(/. '((

7B ' ! .--0

! "

.+ &(

.-++ '

%)+ K

# ! " (

7 B

( ( ''7"

.--+ "

2+$

.--36 ""

'( ''!

$( ( 6" D

F$ ! < 9C ""

(

6 "!

" (

" 6

' ( '' = )

( J"

@" "

/ 5( =

!@"

( 6 " " ! " 6 ' " !

( ( "

( '( 6

" ( '

B" < (

$( ! (( " (

7( ''!

8 (

* '

" J (

( ( '

(

+, 8 '! '( '

( ((

" ! "

G &

H& +,3-< '! ( ( !

" "

! " (

" ! '

B '

( '!"

"" '

( '( 6 "!

' ( '' ! ' ' ((

.-+/ ('

F7 > F% % &!

% 6

% *! $ &!

% &# &!

% &

% &!

( * .42 )* .211, '.-+. !

' % 6

% % &!

% &!

' ( '

! "

' ''! "

( ( "

"( ! E (

' E J

" ' " '

'' (

( 8 ''! "

E ' " ! ! ' ' ' (( ' ( ! '

(

" ( +.-..-+/ &( ( '

( ' '

.- < (

''!+0&(

.-+/ '

! < ( 2 ' ''! '

" ( F7 >2 8 ( * +"

-.-..--+"(

" !

( !" ( ""' ./-,.--+6 !" +5++.--+ "

( +--3.--.

+5-+.--1 2++..--3 "

J (

-+-+.--0 -1-5.--0 ' "

! " '

8 ! ' +1 ( "

" !

E "' -+-3.-+1 6

;

E (

'.-+18 ' "

( "

'( " !!

E "

G& B L&LH # ! ' " E

' '

* + '

E (

! +0 .-+1 " ! 2- .-+1 G& B L#LH?

.+ & B L&L"''! '

' < '

" ''F7 !"!"#!$ %!

!"!"#!$ %!

! !

.. 8 '( " !! E(

;

! (

'.-+1 B"''! ! '

"F7 5

+ $

+/++.--- -/-1.--. -/-1.--. -+-3.-+1 . "(

+/++.--- -/-1.--. -/-1.--. -+-3.-+1 2 #

+3++.--- -/-1.--. -/-1.--. -+-3.-+1 1 "(

+0++.--- -/-1.--. -/-1.--. -+-3.-+1 / "(

.-++.--- -/-1.--. +.J2-J,, +.J2-J,, "( -.-..--+ +5-+.--1 * ! '

3 $! "(

+,-..--+ +.-+.--. +.-+.--. -+-3.-+1 0 $! "(

.--..--+ .+-3.--+ .+-3.--+ -+-3.-+1 , * "(

.-+..--. .-+..--. .-+..--. -+-3.-+1 +- "(

+2+-.--2 +2+-.--2 +2+-.--2 -+-3.-+1 ++ E

+--..--1 +--..--1 +--..--1 -+-3.-+1 +. "(

++-..--1 ++-..--1 ++-..--1 -+-3.-+1 +2 $! "(

+1-..--1 +1-..--1 +1-..--1 -+-3.-+1 +1 % "(

.0-..--1 .0-..--1 .0-..--1 -+-3.-+1 +/ "(

-1-2.--1 -1-2.--1 -1-2.--1 +.J2-J,, < ! '

! ( " E'

' '((

( ( " '''

+5-+.--1?

.2 & ' * 5

' ((

. :

.--+ +5

.--18( * ++ +/! E! !"

' & B &7+ ' "

! '

.--1 .--5

.--3 2+ $

.--3 ' (

.--0 1 .--08 ." ''!

L$ ' E ' !L "

' "

> ! ' ? .1 8 6

;

! (

;

& $( =; !7<@* ' +0 .-+1( & B L#L"''!8

' E ' ! ' ;

(7 ;

(7$ (

! (

8 '

'"(

2= @ 2- .-+1

!8 ''! !

''' ' "

( ( < "

. :

.--+ 2+$

.--3 " (

' ! "(

.--0'

" ' (

"! "

! '"

.--0 8 ' "

! ( ( ( ! ' .--0

! 6 !"

! ( ' "

(( " ( " E8

& +14+5 ' '< <

" (

' ' "

' !"

" '' '

+0 .-+1 " ' "

;

! '6

((

! "

> 2 +0 .-+1? (

' !

" ' ! "/-A " ./ <! "( ' '

' !

" '

E " " ! " '

( &'!((!"'!')!

*!+!!!', #$ % ! & '

( "

)''

) *

( '"

+ (

( ( ,

& '"

( -..

("""

(/ ' )'

(". ( (

& '

' ( (

) .

( "

( .

" ! '

( )'

* '

% .

*!!! !!!!' 1 -., #$ % '

% .

(

. '

3 4

1 '

( ( !'

5& '

" " (

( 4 '

) (& '

& *

(" ,

( . & '

% .

(

. *"

6 >6 "!

" ! '

(

" "

D "

!((

< J

( " ' E

' " E ' '

! "

' "

! D "

! '& +1 ' 8 <

! D

(

& +1 !

(

! ? .3 8 ! '!

' < '

( '( /!'!!'!! 0! 1! ! 2 1 !% 0!(+! !)!'! &!!#'!!"'!3!!

# $ %

)''

7. ( !+4 ! &!!!5!!' 1 6#!)& #!$

/ )'

(" "'

( . . ( ()

( (

.. 8*

+ "(

(

( "

(

% .

( '

.""

( "

( ) ": :

* *0 (

( ( ..

. * .""

* ; 0"'

< 1 " ' '

1( " )'

( '

( * '

= "

' '"

( * '

< 1 " *

' '

)

1 )''

" ( ) ( '1

( *(

< 1 ">"

( *

(

) + "(

1 )

( "

% .

*!("')7(!% !!'7"!& #$ %

-. /

)(

* *"

(

* ( (

2 ?

" 1

( *1

(

" ( (

( ..'"& '

. ( )( "

(

' '

(""*

(

* '

& '

)( "

+ ( 1 ) )'

" .

1" + "(

.1( ( * 2 !

(

, "

(

7. (

( -" ./ ( '

. ( ( 1 ) (

.!)8!!+7'!#& #

$ %

! ( 9#&7#!1 6 .!4 #$ %

!- *'

' ( * 9 5 @

=&@/

7. '

)

& ' "&

" *

(

(" 2( & '

)0 ( 1 '

)' )

(

( ' "

( *

1 * ( "

.""

( * ; 0"'

< 1 " )''

( ( "

7. (

". (

)0 "

' ..'

(

( )' + " "

+ " '

' " '

( '

< 1 "

)

)0 "& . '

" & '

)0 "> ) .

) ( ( '

)("

( )'

(

; 0"'

< 1 " .""

( "

* "( "

( '

( * '

)''

. "'

*0 '

" "

(

( ( '

@ &

>B> . ( )'

= "& ; 0"'

< 1 "& ; 0"'

( ( '

2.& *

( *

( '

& '

. ( )("

( (

( '

* )

) "

)("

"1 (

" ' '

)0 "

. . (

A (

( '

) (

" '"

) ( *

" .. ""

( )0 "

)' " '

1 '( ( '(

" '

)''

( .

( "

. .

(( ""

( (

C !

D ')0!(!')&775'!6)+ ( "1 ( * '

( %

@ (

( 2.& )''

( )'

"& B("

""3,E 1

; 0"'

< 1 " "

( 4

. ( "

. 1

* &

( * F1

9 ( (. ( * ; 0"'

< 1 " ( 4

( )

""3,E

)' '( 1 ( '

< 1 "

. '

(

.& & "

* & ( )

)0 " 1 ."" '

)

"( (

' . "

(

* '

< 1 " * "

)

( < & '

( *

*( * '

* ( '

< 1 " )"

( ( 0

*0 '

* '

& '

)

(

( *

(

7 (

. '

(

!3"'!'1 ! *!+!! ! ',

#$ =%@ ( )

. ( + (

( %

@ (

D ;1 % '

1 %

9 ( '

( ( (

" @ & (

8C2 !

D %

9 ( '

1 ;"'

% '

( ( (

2 "& )'

" " ( .

" )'"

)

"( (

. ( '

)

( ( *

4 (

1 '

; 0"'

< 1 " )"

( ( "( '

" 1*

F .

>> .""

)''

)

( 4

(

" + '

)

4 ( '

' "

( )"

" ( '"

(

) .

(

(".

" + "

* .. '

.. ( %'1 =+

( ("

( (

( '

* "

. '

) ( "

)0 ( "

" 0'":")

""3,E 1 '

(

< 1 "

3* )

" ( * '

" .. (

". "* )("

" '

< 1 " " 4

" * )("

. )0 "

' * " *

(

)''

< 1 "

9 " ("

( "

)''

. ' "

*(& ") ( "

" * ( .1 (

()

((

)0 "&

( .1

1 '( )'

( '"

" , "

G' "H 2 2 #'$

( 4

' "

( " '

". "* "' ( ( )' *

(

.' "

(

" *

("' ( * '"

)' '( ."

( '

. ' ( )'

) ( " '

( ) ( " ((

* ' * " ' "

)' , ".0

. ' " )'

( )'

( )

9 " .

#" .$ )( '

)("

* "

" *"

(

' '

( "

)

.""

( ' "

2( & '

" ( ("."

( *

(

( 1

( " "" (

* 2* . *'

A ( * C % B (7"

)