Sanjeev Jindal v. Punjab And Haryana High Court And Another
!"#$$%&"'!( $ & &"$) *$)+,+
,"#!-.!)/!"!&0 ,) .!"
$) $+1"'$"
+ 2 342 342 5 4
! "
#$%
& '& "
& ( )
& * +"
,- +,",./ 0-12* & 3, ,4 +,""./ 0",12 "3 ,+ +,"+./ 0""1 "3 ,- +,"+5&
& 6 '&7 .) 1 ,4 ", "4-8 50) 3 70 0)
+7 ' % ) 3"
,9 +,,+ 5 & +,",0"" :; $ 5 & &$ ' $ "+ ,3 +,"+ 5& ( 5& 7<! =-8+ +,"+
>"3 ,- +,"+
& 5&&
* &
+ 6 7 5
"4 "+ +,,8 '
5& 57?
@55& 00 A 00 5 * & ' 5& 5&
( BA ! C9C "4 "+ +,,8 3,+C4-0"+,0A7 9$ %
( 5 $ 5& / 6 5 & & 5 & 5
55 0 3,+
5 '
5 &7?
@55&
5 / & / &&5&& &5 00 % "C ,- +,,- & %
C34 7 5 5
6 5
& 5& ,3 ,4 +,,- 6
55& %( ,C ,4 +,,-
5 &
' 7
,C ,4 +,,- 5* 6 "9 ", +,,4 ./ 0C1 .# 1 '& D ( 5 ,8 ,3 +,,4 5,C ,4 +,,-
5
/ 6 / E & +C ", +,,4
+"
,- +,", ,C ,4 +,,-
>5 & ( 5 6
* &5& ) ?
) . 1 5 3, ,4 +,"" ./ 0",1 5 ,C ,4 +,,-
6F* &>
& 5 6 5 & / & > 5 * & 3, ,4 +,"" "3 ,+ +,"+
& A % F & ) (( ,C ,= +,",* 6 (;
& .# 1 ( * 0 & >"8 ,- +,"+ % ) "3 ,- +,"+
& 50 .1 C '& 7. G
1 "4-8 ' 2 A
5
%( % &* 5& ) & * & .# 1 &
5&
&
* & & F* &>
&
&
5 & 5 & % &* 5& 7 6
5 &5& /7 $ ( 5& (
5 5 / '
5 6 5 5 & / & &
5& 5 F* &>
> & & !&
5 &
5&
5& $ / 6 * / 6 5& F* & >
& 5 & ( ( 6 5 &
5 5 5
&
5 5& /7 / & ( (
5&
!"#$ % 6 /7 & ' 7 / & ( 5& $ ( ( / & ' 7 & * & 5&) ?
). 1 6 5 5 = < <
( 5& < $ & & 5& F* &>
& 5 2 & ./ 0C1 7 ) (5'&' 7 6 5 H& I $ J &
& 65
5
5 A ,C ,4 +,,- 5 % / & 5&
D ( .# 1,8 ,3 +,,4
5 / 0-& 6 .1 H 6A7DF>B7' F K () % ) $ ! 0 "
5
! 4" +,,- 5& % ! C9C "4 "+ +,,8 C4-0 3,+ "+,0 A 09 $ 6 5
& 7 &
& ,C ,4 +,,- 5
E 5&5
0 H
6 $& $ 7
5
0 &( & &
$B 5 55 &
& J 6 5& & & ,= ,- +,,- % 0 H
* 5
55 $
0 / 5 & &/ 5 555 $ & 6 5 $ J
& ,C ,4 +,,- & ,C ,4 +,,- 5
5 $ & 5 )
5& ( & &
5 K> %F >B'>!;DF6'F7'AFB)L6A7F !%)L%F E0 F A6 F!F DJ - 5 55 & & &
& A $ BD
5 5 & ,= ,- +,,- %
5 5 & &/ 5 5 $ A 5
A & / 5 6 * & * & F* & >
* & / 0", 6
* & "3 ,+ +,"+ ./ 0""1 & +C ,C +,"+ ./ 0"+1 < .1 6
5 5 & &/ 5 5 5 $ 6 6F* &>
6& 5
.1 A BA 5&
( & < .1 ! 5& & E .1 5 & $ $ $ 5 6 &
$ .1 6 $ $/ ( & .1 6 % 5
%
.1 6 %
5
5 5 < 5 5 %
5 5 .1 % & 5 &&5 5 C387 & / 5 & 5 ", 6* &
( / 5&
5 HJ( ( 5 5( 0 5&* &
5 /
&
6
5 & * &
5
5 & 5 ""
!& & "+ & $ 5 & &
5 5& % 7 &
" ' 7< ! "9-=4G"=334 +,"++= ,- +,"9 3C. ( ) 1 5
<* H3C 6 & $ 5 ) & % ) & ' 7
", ,C +,"9 %> ! 7)AE77E7 E+,"C0"9 3 ", +,"C ';57 ) A 5 5
6 (
A
F/
0
!
"
!
# $% "3 A 5 * /7 (
") '
! *#+"+* "" "3 <* H""
< ' 7 &
& 5 5 5 5& ' 7 A ' 7 & 5( 5
M5 5 5& 5 & 6
0
5 (
L$ 5 6% !% &5 5 ) 5
& &
&
5 ( &
55 /
& & "+ 6 7
&
5 ( & & 5 ( E
5&
6
5 5
6
& & ( < $ & 5( ' 7 $/ "3 A !
$ "
! & " ' ()*++!),*- 7 5 / 5 ( &
+39 7 ' 7
7 5
5 (
(
$& A ' 7 &
(
5
A ' 7 $ (
5& 0 5&
& J "C & * / 3+ ( / 7 , , ) " - !
%%%#$"$%. H3+ 6 5& % ) & 5 5& ) 6 $ 5& ' 7 5 5 A 5
&"44"04+ "44+043 "44304C 6 & &
N7N >
6 / 5& ' 7
7
& & N N & >
O 6
5& 6
+4 ""
"44=5& 7 3, ""
"44=5 7 &
&
,= ""
"44=
&
6 ' 7
) 5 & 5 A )
) 5 /// /// /// J "9 A 5
* & 5 6 ; 5 "3 ,4 "4=" 9-&"+ ,4 +,"4 "= A $
.1 7<! +,,,, +,"+ .1
5 & 0 & < 7 * 7 +"
,- +,", ./ 0-1 F* & 3, ,4 +,"" ./ 0",1 7 ! "3 ,+ +,"+ ./ 0""1 > "3 ,- +,"+
& .1 C '&7. G
1 "4-8 .1 6 5
& 5& "3 ,- +,"+ 5 3, ""
+,"- .1 6 5 &
5 "3 ,- +,"+
& 6 5 &5$ .1 5 3, ""
+,"- 5 &
,"
"+ +,"- .1 7 & 6 7 : &.
4 7 / # 0 1 / ( 0 1