Manmohan Singh v. Ut Of Chandigarh Etc.
! "#
$
%&'(!
%)*+,(&-./0 ,'&'(-,,0/1
!
"
# $ %
!
$ &
# !
'
$
!" #" ! $ %
&
"" &
"''
(
* +," -./ &0
2 (
"
!!" # !
$% &''%"(& 2 3 " &
"
'
( ) " ) !
* + " , "
" ) -
.
/
0 !
" 1 + ('
)2)34 5
( '
)2)34 5 "
.,") !
%
6
%77 55 ! 5 '" (899:9; 66<:959 :9.69=5299 1</=89;<9=9;29'>>9; :9.6/=/6<:959 11346" " $/ " "
&
!) " "
) 5 + ) ! )
. ) !
! "
) ! ) 8 " ! " !, !, )
) "
) " "
0
&
5
&
" "
0 0 "
% &
&
& 5
& 0 % &
& 0
5 "
0 & " & "
0 3
&
"
0 7
0 0
4"
0 & " %
&
"
&" 0
0
& 9"
" & "
0
" % &0 & &
7 - &
0 " "& " :
3 &0
&"
& &
0 0 0 "
$
0; - 0
" 0
& " &
" & " 0 -
&
%
,
" " "
" " " & 7 0 " 0 7 "
0 "
0 &" 0
"
7 ,
&
"
0 :
3
"
& , &0 %"
, "
"
,
& " "
0 4
" 0
"
,
"
"
&
<.$ *$' ( " =
0
. )
>??
" "
# "
* ).
$
"
"
. )?
$ @
$ '
=" 2
0
3 0
))> (
9"
0 0 " =
% & "
0 " 0
0 "
% $
0
" $
"
"
" %
" 0 !"
" 0
& &0 ( A" +A" 2 / (
)< * %
"
7
(;
))< +
BC/ &
$ " %
" $
@ $
0
* +," -./ 2 &0 &
"'
(/ ) " !) ) ) " 9 .
! ! " ) "
" #!
/ - !
! )
! .
, ) )
) ) !
" !
) : =
?@& A&.9
:"
!
- : 6
&@ !.
/ ", ) "
"
"
, " !
!
"
!.
/ " ,
,!
! / "
" " "
!
D
"
" E "
0 2 0
" 0 '
0 " 0
E " "
! # " $ D"
?> <>
3 &0 2 0
0
" & 0
4 "
0 & &0 2 D5& 2
("
* + *,- * +%'!&./ 012
!. $% &''%"(&
,
" (%B
456714 1. / "
- 0 0
+
) ) 9 6!# ) / " )
" #
,
!
#
)
C?& "
!
0 )
)
9 )
! !
"
)
) 6 # ")
+ !
*
* %C %
4
* * D. - D./ 9 0 " - D. 000000
!
000000
000000 000000
000000
( E , " )!
)!
- !
!
E " "
" 9 " ) " !# !
" @" , ) 9 ) )
"
" 9 )
9 &7 .// 9 " + " ./ "
:"
!
"
) )
) .)
+ %)
! " "
+ " %%) 9 "!
) 9 %% D.
* 2 9 ,+ ! ,(," +
4 5)
"
' !
) 9 '
! " "
" " "
!
!
!
!
4% 5) !
) )
+ E " )
!
)
& /
! ) - , ) 9 %?! # )
# %? 9 D.
E ) * !+ +"(+* 9! = ) ) # " ) 9 # !
! ) " !
! 9 &% ! 4 &% 9 - 5) , 9 " "
. )
+ 4
! 4%
&% 9 && # ) ! 0 )
, &%
)
! 9 "
9 %%@1%%? / &A / 0 ! ) 9 ""
+ " -
D.
:* %&;. = ?!
" ! ! -
/ ) = /
" =
= ?"
"
# ! # : " !
! 9 - ) &% " %% 9 - !
!
+
9 ! 4
&% 9 " #
"
. ) ) 9 !
4 %%4 4
! 4%
&% ) )
+ !
4% %%4 4
! 4%
&%
= ) !
) !
!
)
+ !
'
%7 7B %7& -
!
%%4% 9 "
/ ! 4
%% 9 - 5)
"
'
) 9 !
- )
9 "
0 0
!
! &F
= ?
!
= " .
= ) $ # : "
/ ! !
# !
! #
- %
!/'' 2! % $& & G )
) = "
+
= ? )
- , = !"
" =
8 6 ! - ) ! ,
" " !
/ "- = ?" ) = " " !" ! "
&@ / <!* = ! / >!! %8&)33 !
! ) "
@ : 9 CF@
.
!
"
7C 7C %77F
' . !
!! " !
) " , !
%7 % %77A" !
!
&?
/ !
"
$ = ?"!
) "
" " "
= !
, , )
! ! 0 )
"
) 9 " ) .
- ) "
& 9 / ) !
- " # ) 9
!
# = ? - ) ) )
!
- = ? , ! " # / " =
?" ,
, ) ! ," "
)
!
= /
) !# ) = ?
&B
)! ? " ) !
. = " " ) !
) # " = ?
" " ! !
) ! " " " ) "
*)
!
9
)
" !
= ?
@"
(
(; @"
))>
"'
( +( ,+ ( !,,2
+? @4
,
!#
5)
+
4%
#
!. 4 .
.. + ) " #
" ) ! 4
" !
!
" +
)
!
" ", )
) + )
) - , !
-
1!
+ !
!
4 )
*
4 !
" !
"
+
) ! H ' 9
4)
!
! + " ) !
,
+
4)
+
5) !
4)
4) !
, ) !
!
) ! "
4) ! 7
4 0
'*'*!
"
! +
" !
" ! +
) ", + !
)
- +
+ " !
, # " + )
!
9 ;
=.5) 6 +
! / 5 ' ! %7 ! + )
) )
) ,
' !
!
G . .
%%
40 ) / 5 ! 40 !
- ! 5) - "
!
!
+ % D5& " (" ("2!*"
88$%&'''
B "C
& " &0 "
3
&0
F 3
3
!" B "C
0
6 "
!" 6 "
" &0 "
"0
" &0 @ $ =" 2
0
& 2
0 "
3 0 & &0 2
* "
," -< D"
?> <>
! # "
$ 3
2
"
"0 " =
0 ; = " " $
% G %
" " % G %
"
0 ; "
+," -./ D"
<.$ *$' (
. )?
$ @
$
"
?$ 0
?) 0 0 0 D"
<.$ *$' (
" &0
0
# "
% 0 ;
8 @ $
0
"
& 9" & 0 9"
'
0 $
" 9"
% 0
0 & %
+/ 0 "
" ! $ " " & "
% 0 " " 0 "
9"
0
$ % !" " &
< 3
&
3" +," -./
%
"
@ $
0
0 2 G % (
$
0 D
0 & "#
$
3 #/ 4
-