Ashwani Kumar And Others v. Presiding Officer And Others
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA AT
CHANDIGARH CWP-14345-2014 (O&M) Date of Decision: 12.10.2023 ASHWANI KUMAR AND OTHERS
...Petitioners
Versus
PRESIDING OFFICER, CENTRAL GOVT. INDUSTRIAL TRIBUNAL-CUM-LABOUR COURT-1, CHANDIGARH AND OTHERS
...Respondents
CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE HARSH BUNGER Present :
Mr. Ashwani Bakshi, Advocate for the petitioners.
Mr. Anil Rathee, Advocate for respondents No.2 to 4.
HARSH BUNGER, J.
!
" ! #$#%
& '(
)* +' ! , - .
) ''/) '
0 - .1
! )* ) ! *
3 - . ! . ) 4#5##
& ' ! 6 !) )** ! )*
' . '
))*
%#7#%
!* )* .
) ) %
)*
* /)
& ' ! $$5'$$( - 8 ! . 3). ! 6 4#$$$ * * 9 7': ;
* *5#* .* ! ) !
* ! *
* !!
" * )*3! )*< 1)9
! "
# )*
) ! * * * 6 9 7'< ;
!*
! ' * !) ! 5 . '
)*
'8 ! = 6 )3 * !
; ; .9 ! & )9 > ! 02 9 +!/1 29+/ #####
) !
'
!!
)* ! =; * 8)
)* ! = ; *
)*
'8 ! =; )* ! = ; * ) = ! * * )
*
)* * )*
* = * )* ' 6
* * )
'
5#* . )* ' * ) 6 !* *
7
! = ) .
) ) ! #$#%
& '( !
' )* !
) * * )
'
' ) ) 4 /
) .
) )
!! ) .
) ) ) !*
* * ) ! =; ) !
' ! '
* ! )* ) ! !
)*
' ! ! ) ! ) ! ! * /) ?! ) $4# 0 $4#1
) ! ! )
' !) ) * ' !*
)
; 6 ! ) ) )
! '
*
) ! ( , '
! =; )
)*
)
* *
5#* ! ! 9 7'2 ; )
'
! )
! * * )* ! =; /
' ! =;
'& +'
'& * *
)* ' /
) !
! $4# *
)
! =; ) ! ! $4# ) *
) !
)
! *
)** 9 7'< ;
!* * )
$
) )
#
* * ) 8 ! )* !
!! )*8 ! 5#* * ! * 5#*
! ! !
'
& +'
)* * < !
* * # #%$$ 4#$$$ ! ))* ! * ! *)* * !
'
'& '
*
)*
< * # #%$$ 4#$$$ ! =; ) ! * )*
* ! *)* * ** )* ! . * * )
!! ! *3
! @ % ,
* * )* * ! )* * * ) * * )
! =;
'
! )* = ! ) )* * 5#* ! * * * ) 8 ! ! ) 3! )*< A)9 $ % & '
'
( )* +!+"
'','
< A) & B
!"
#
$ %& '
(!)
$ %*&
#
+
,-
.
+
,- # /
# # # #
# 0
0
1 & #
.2 $.
$
%*3 * ,- $ %*
#
# !"
# #
3#
)% ((%
&
!"
# #
#
%4 ((!
5% ((%
!"
#
&
#
/ $ %3 '
0
#
6 # #
#
7 0 #
! 2 6
#
#
#
#
8 * #
/
#
*
# 0
*
#
#
#
9
% : 7
2
# 0
7
2 0
;<
5 : -
.
% % '
.
/ * !0"
< A) & B
(
#
# #
!"
#
=
#
!"
# : #
#
> * 0 >
#
# #
#
# !"
#
2 #
# /# 6 2
#
/
$ %&
'
# # 8 # #
/
$
%3, -
*
$ %&
# * $ %?
%7 #
@ A 0
#
#
#
0
# #
# #
0 #
#
* 2
# #
0 2
2
#
2
0 ;< 7
! ! ! '
! $4#
)*< 1) 9 )* 3! 1&
2
'
'
( &
4 5* !+"
, ! !
B'
! +
, - ,- 3 B# 4
(45
/ 2 ? $
? ?
0 C ? C
269
/
#
# 2 ?
# #>
# #
#
2
? ? >
#
? $
?
,-
0
/
,- $
'
,- 2 ?
#E
#
,- # # ,-
# 2 ?
,-
# #> ,-
#
2 ?
? #
? $
?
,- ,- $
", - 269
# #
#
? +
, -
2 # 3
$ # 3
#
>
,-
,-
/>
,-
* ,- $
">
,-
2 ? ' (
()5
# / $
"
/ #
/ #
7
2
#
E
,1"
(
% 2
%
%* )
7 &
%
/& % * 2
/ % 2 % % &
- %
8 /
% !"
2 % *
- /&/ 2 % % & *
%*
)
& /'
9&
% & /&
%
9
2 % % &
) -
%% & /
,!- = *
.
,- # #
# E#
7
2
. ,-
,%- F $
", - 269
#
#
/
#
#
E
*
# #
#
,5-
$
", - 269
?
#
#
#
#
#
#
0
0
#
# 0
/
/
9 '
! $4# )* ; 2 :&)
-
'
;
<&%
% : *
!+"
'','
#
) B'
5 #
#
#
>
#
#;<
4 : & 2 3 * =4
'
>'
'
6 4
*
6
+
/
+ * < A) 9 B C) /
7
2
5 /# 2
+
0
0
#
0
2
# #
/
#
#
#
2
0
2
#
2
/
#
#
#
$ #
#
#
/
/# #
0
2
7
2 5
# 0
4
# /#
=
>
=
2
#
#
0#
# #
# 0 7
2
#
#
2
#
>
#
# #
2
# # #
/#
#
=
#
< ( + ) ! $ ! ) *!*
#$#%
& '(
)* - . ! * )* & ! 3 ) !) *
#
! = * Ocober12th, 2023 (HARSH BUNGER) gurpreet JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned:
Yes/No Whether reportable:
Yes/No