← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12709/2016dismissed

Manoj Kumar Tiwari v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2016-08-19Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Darshan Singh12 pages

       

 !"

#$% &%'()(*+ ,    



   

     !+ - .!//  .

- .!/ // 0%)%*$+ !01(2#) %345/%*(0&6'#$%7($3 !0(8#*)3990(5&6'#$% 0$3%:%$($(*%0 !0*290!($$#45&&4&6'#$%%*%0#45#0;#*# #<%)3 (*&#4 3%  :%$($(*%0  3#)  #::0#'3%&  $3()  '90$  (8:9=*(*=  $3% '889*('#$(*&#$%&, **%>90%? "56(&%73('3$3%))()$#*$ >'()% #>#$(*

('%0>'()%"590=#*&(0%'$%&$3%:%$($(*%0$)3( $ 3().? 6%*&$#:0:%04'#$(*(*$3%090#4#0%#5 073('3$3%4('%*'%3#& @%%*=0#*$%&$$3%:%$($(*%0 .%#0*%&'9*)%4 0$3%:%$($(*%0)9@8($$%&$3#$$3%:%$($(*%0 7#)  =0#*$%&  4('%*'%  0  4'#$(*  7($3(*  $3%  0%6%*9%  %)$#$%    6(44#=% #3#0:90):%0$3%%>'()%:4('; 0$3%;%#0(*A9%)$(*5$3%6%0*8%*$

  0($)#=%*'(%)7%0%$8#2%%

0$)$:06(&%):#'%$$3%4('%*)%%) 0 09**(*=$3%6%*&)#$0%#)*#@4%')$*6(%7 $3#$'4#9)%(*$3%:4(';5 $3% %:9$;>'()% #>#$(*88())(*%0>'()%"590=#* 0)30$5 - "-6(&%8%8&#$%&,B 0%A9%)$%&$3%!#*#=%05#0;#*# /$#$%  *&9)$0(#4   * 0#)$09'$90%  %6%4:8%*$  0:0#$(*5  !#*%)#05 90=#* 0)30$5-/ -"$:06(&%):#'%$$3%:%$($(*%0 04'#$(*= 3()6%*&7($3(*$3%0%6%*9%4(8($) 6(44#=%#3#0:90 3%)($%7#) #::06%&@;/  (*#44;6(&%'889*('#$(*&#$%&CD **%>90% ?

B :%$($(*%07#)#44$$%&4(A906%*& 04'#$(*7($3(*$3%0%6%*9%%)$#$% 6(44#=%#3#0:90588#*&0%#?#3#0:90#*&6%*&#0%#-90#4-%

90$3%00% %00%&$'4#9)%B(*$3%%>'()%:4(';5&% (*(*='88#*&#0%# #*& $3% 090#4 6%*&5 73('3 :06(&%& $3#$  $3%'88#*& #0%#3#) $  @% :0%)'0(@%&@;$3% "3%4('%*)%%)3#443#6%$3% 0%%&8$4'#$% 3()6%*& #44(*=(*$3%'88#*&#0%#7($3:0(0#::06#4 $3%)($%:4#*

08$3% "3%:%$($(*%03#&:%*%&3()4(A906%*&(*$3%90@#* #0%#7($39$#*;#::06#4 $3%)($%:4#* 08$3% "3%8#$$%0 '#8%$$3%*$('% $3%&%:#0$8%*$1(&%'889*('#$(*&#$%&  5 $3% ()$0('$7*4#**%0590=#*4#**(*="(* 08%&$3% "$3#$ :4$B 5/%'$0 5!#*%)#05&%6%4:%&@;/ 5 #44)7($3(*90@#* #0%#:;$3%0% 7#)&94;)%06%&9:*$3%:%$($(*%0$()$3%4'#$(* 73%0%$3%:%$($(*%03#&:%*%&3()4(A906%*&0%A9%)$7#)8#&%@;$3%

"$$3%/%*(07*4#**%05/ 590=#* 07($3&0#7#4 $3%:%08())(*=0#*$%&$$3%:%$($(*%0$:%*$3%4(A906%*&#)$3% 4('%*'%=0#*$%&$$3%:%$($(*%07#) 0090#4#0%# % 90$3%00% %00%&$$3%)$#$%8%*$8#&%@;$3%:%$($(*%0* D @% 0%$3%))()$#*$>'()%#*&#>#$(*

('%0>'()%"#*& >'()%*):%'$0573%*$3%;(*):%'$%&$3%4(A906%*& $3%:%$($(*%03% :%$($(*%0#&8($$%&$3#$$3%4(A906%*&:%*%&@;3(87#)4'#$%&(*90@#* #0%#  %  )$#$%&  $3#$  3%   3#&  0%'%(6%&  $3%  '889*('#$(*  )%*$  @; $3% &%:#0$8%*$(*$3() 0%=#0& #*&7(44 )3( $$3%4(A906%*&$ $3%:0:%0 4'#$(*7($3(*B?C&#;)3%)9@8())(*()$3#$$3%4%$$%0&#$%&   #*&$3%)$#$%8%*$8#&%@;$3%:%$($(*%0*D 7%0%'*'%#4%&@;

$3%:%$($(*%0  73(4%  (4(*=  $3%  70($  :%$($(*5  73('3  () )9::0$%&  @; #* #

(&#6($&#$%&,  )$3%:%$($(*%03#&'*'%#4%&8#$%0(#4 #'$)

C

08$3()'90$5$3%70($:%$($(*&%)%06%)$@%&()8())%&7($33%#6;')$ $3%70($$%*)$#$%8%*$ (4%&@;$3%/$#$%5*0%:4('#$(*7#) (4%&@;$3% :%$($(*%0 %#0&4%#0*%&'9*)%4 0$3%:#0$(%)#*&:%09)%&$3%:#:%0 @2 08$3% #'$)573('3#0%#6#(4#@4%*0%'0&5($()%6(&%*$$3#$ $3%:%$($(*%07#)=0#*$%&4(A906%*& 04'#$(*7($3(*$3%0%6%*9%4(8($)  6(44#=%#3#0:907($36%*&#0%#E090#4F):%0'4#9)%   $3% %>'()%:4('; 0$3%;%#0(*A9%)$(*5$3%6%0*8%*$0($)#=%*'(%)7%0% $8#2%%

0$)$:06(&%):#'%)$$3%4('%*)%%) 009**(*= 6%*&)(* 90@#*#0%#)73%0%6%00%A9(0%&5 #$0%#)*#@4%0#$%) 0:%0#$(*=4(A90 6%*&)(*:0%?

#@0('#$%&)$09'$90%)3%0%4%6#*$'4#9)%()%>$0#'$%&@%47+



 !!"#$%&#'""!"(# &")!"'*$"$&$+ 3%6%0*8%*$#*&($)#=%*'(%))3#44)$0(6%$:06(&% ):#'%)$$3%4('%*)%%) 009**(*= 6%*&)(*90@#*#0%#) 73%0%6%0  0%A9(0%&  #*&  #6#(4#@4%  #$  0%#)*#@4%  0#$%)  0 :%0#$(*=4(A906%*&)(*:0%?

#@0('#$%&)$09'$90%)F

%):($%$3% #'$$3#$$3%:%$($(*%02*%7$3#$3()#44$8%*$ 4(A906%*&7#) 0090#4#0%#53%8#&%#0%A9%)$$$3% " 0 :06(&(*=):#'% 0:%*(*=$3%4(A906%*&*3()0%A9%)$5#)()%6(&%*$

084%$$%0&#$%&,B **%>90%?" 08$3% "$$3% !#*#=%05  / 5  !#*%)#05  90=#*5  $3%  8#$$%0  7#)  0% %00%&   0 :06(&(*=)9($#@4%)($%$$3%:%$($(*%03%())9%7#)'*)(&%0%&(*$3% (*$%0*#4'00%):*&%*'%#8*=)$$3%

('%0) / #*& (*#44;5#)() 0% %00%&$@;$3%:%$($(*%056(&%'889*('#$(*&#$%&CD **%>90%

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

 (8:9=*(*=$3%0&%0&#$%&, ($3$3%70($$%*)$#$%8%*$5 4%$$%0&#$%&  **%>90%?B"3#)@%%*#**%>%&$7#)#&&0%))%&@;

()$0('$7*4#**%0590=#*$$3% "8%*$(*(*=$3%0%(*$3#$ $3%:4$573%0%$3%:%$($(*%03#&:%*%&$3%4(A906%*&7#)7($3(*$3% 90@#*#0%#:; $3%)#(&4%$$%07#)&94;#'2*74%&=%&@;$3%:%$($(*%0 90$3%0573%*$3%))()$#*$>'()%#*&#>#$(*

('%0>'()%"#*&*% >'()%*):%'$0(*):%'$%&$3%4(A906%*& $3%:%$($(*%0*D 5 $3%:%$($(*%0#&8($$%&$3#$$3%:4#'%573%0%3%3#&:%*%&$3%4(A906%*&5

#44)7($3(*$3%90@#*#0%##)'* (08%&@;$3% ()$0('$7*4#**%06(&% 4%$$%0&#$%&  % 90$3%0#&8($$%&$3#$3%3#&0%'%(6%&*$('%(*$3() 0%=#0& 08$3%&%:#0$8%*$%9*&%0$2$)3( $$3%4(A906%*&$:0:%0 4'#$(*7($3(*#:%0(& B?C&#;)3%# 0%)#(&'889*('#$(*)7%0% #**%>%&@;$3%0%):*&%*$)@; (4(*=$3%70($$%*)$#$%8%*$&#$%&  5 73('37#) (4%&(*'90$*  $3()5*0%:4('#$(*3#)@%%* (4%& !%#*(*=$3%0%@;50%'%(:$ $3%# 0%)#(&4%$$%0&#$%&  #*&$3% )$#$%8%*$8#&%@;$3%:%$($(*%0#$$3%$(8% (*):%'$(* $3%4(A906%*&

 7#)'*'%#4%&73(4% (4(*=$3%70($:%$($(* 3%:%$($(*7#)4()$%& 0$3% (0)$(*'90$*  &90(*= 6#'#$(*)$$3%$(8% *$('% 8$(*5 447(*=)$#*&$#2%*@;$3% 4%#0*%&'9*)%4 0$3%:%$($(*%0#::%#0(*=#$$3#$$(8%7#)*$('%&+ E0(%6#*'% $3%70($:%$($(*%0()$3#$$39=3$3%4('%*)%7#) =0#*$%&9*&%0**%>90%?

  )$#$%8%*$$3#$($3#&@%%*=0#*$%&0%'=*($(*@;$3%5 73('3*%'%))#0(4;(8:4(%)$3#$0%'=*($(*7#)=0#*$%&(*$%08)  /%'$(*C $3%'$0%#&7($3%=94#$(*) #*&, $3%

%=94#$(*)3)%8#*#=(*=$3%#

#(0) $3%#::%44#*$) &*$@%4*=$$3%'#$%=0; (**'%*$5(44($%0#$%G9*%&9'#$%& :%0)*)573#0%*$'*6%0)#*$7($3$3%0%4%6#*$)$#$9$0; :06()(*)#*&$3%'90$:0'%))3%6%0; #'$$3#$%#'3 $3% #::%44#*$)3#&)9@8($$%&#::4('#$(*(*$%08) %=94#$(*

#*&8#&%($)%4 #6#(4#@4% 0(*):%'$(*@;$3%$%#8'*)$($9$%& @;5 3:#4)37)$3#$$3%;7%0% 944;#7#0% $3% #'$ $3#$$3%;'#*=%$0%'=*($(**4;# $%0 (44(*=$3%'*&($(*) ):%'( (%&(*$3%'$#*&$3%%=94#$(*)#*&$3#$5 3:#4 3#&*$=0#*$%&0%'=*($(*$$3%8$7($3)$#*&(*=$3()5$3%; 8#&%@4&)$#$%8%*$$3#$$3%;3#&@%%*=0#*$%&0%'=*($(*@; $3%'8:%$%*$#9$30($;#*&$3%0%@;)9''%%&%&(*:%0)9#&(*= $3() 90$ $ %*$%0$#(* $3%):%'(#4 4%#6% :%$($(*)#*& :#)) (*$%0(80&%0)3%8(*(898573('3'#*@%)#(&#@9$$3% #::%44#*$)()$3#$$3%;3#6%*$#::0#'3%&$3%90$7($3 '4%#*3#*&)#*&)9''%%&%&(*:449$(*=$3%)$0%#8 <9)$('%@;

8#2(*=:#$%*$4; #4)%)$#$%8%*$3%0% 0%5$3%;#0%*$%*$($4%& $0%4(% 9*&%00$('4%B $3%*)$($9$(*3()6(%7 (*&) )9::0$ 08:4%$30# :0%'%&%*$)*

"  *

) B/DD,5("   (  , 

"B/ #*&4#0=%*98@%0 $3%0 '#)%)5$3()90$&%*(%&0%4(% $$3%:%$($(*%0G#::%44#*$*$3% =09*&$3#$3%3#&*$#::0#'3%&$3%90$7($3'4%#*3#*&)

, * 

"  *

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

0):%'(#44%#6%5$3%/9:0%8%90$8#;'8%$$3% '*'49)(*$3#$(*)9'3#'#)%):%'(#44%#6%=0#*$%&$$3% #::%44#*$9=3$$@%0%62%&F *("   ( ,)9:0#"5 $3%90$*$%&$3#$$3%#::%44#*$3#&'*'%#4%&$3% #'$$3#$ $3%#7#0&'94&*$@%8#&%@;$3%.#*&'A9()($(*

('%0

  7($3(*$3%$(8%:0%)'0(@%&9*&%0/%'$(* $3%.#*& 'A9()($(*'$@%'#9)% $3%)$#;0&%0:#))%&@;$3%(=3 90$#*&@)%06%&+ EHH 90(9)4;%*9=35$3%0%()*0% %0%*'%(*$3% ):%'(#44%#6%:%$($(*)$#*; $3%)$#;0&%0)#*&7% '#8%  $  2*7  #@9$  $3%)%  0&%0)  *4;  73%*  $3% 0%):*&%*$)#::%#0%&(*0%):*)%$$3%*$('%#*& (4%& $3%(0  '9*$%0?#

(&#6($  *  90  6(%75  $3%  )#(&  (*$%0(8 0&%0)3#6%#&(0%'$@%#0(*=*$3%A9%)$(*0#()%&#*& $3%  **?&()'4)90%    $3%  )#8%  '%0$#(*4;  #89*$)  $ )9::0%))(* 8#$%0(#4 #'$)*$3()=09*&#4*%5$3% ):%'(#44%#6%:%$($(*)#0%4(#@4%$@%0%<%'$%&$()7%44 )%$$4%&(*4#7$3#$$3%0%4(% 9*&%00$('4%B $3% *)$($9$(*  ()  &()'0%$(*#0;  #*&  #  :%$($(*%0  73 #::0#'3%)$3()90$ 0)9'30%4(% 89)$'8%7($3

0#*2#*& 944&()'4)90% #'$) 3% #(4)$&)#*& )9::0%))%)8#$%0(#4 #'$)53()#::4('#$(*()4(#@4%$@% &()8())%&  %  #''0&(*=4;  &()8())  $3%  ):%'(#4  4%#6% :%$($(*)F *)-  .'  " /C5$3()90$ *$('%&  $3%  :0=0%))(6%  &%'4(*%  (*  $3%  6#49%)    4( %  #*& @)%06%&+ E08#*;'%*$90(%)*&(#*)'(%$;'3%0()3%&$7@#)(' 6#49%)    4( %  (%  E)#$;#F  $09$3"  #*&  E#3(*)#F  **?

  6(4%*'%"  !#3#6(05  #9$#8  9&&3#  #*&  !#3#$8# #*&3(=9(&%&$3%:%:4%$(*=0#(*$3%)%6#49%)(*$3%(0 &#(4;4( %09$3'*)$($9$%&#*(*$%=0#4:#0$ $3%<9)$('%?

&%4(6%0;  );)$%8  73('3  7#)  (*  6=9%  (*  $3%  :0%? *&%:%*&%*'%%0##*&$3%:%:4%9)%&$ %%4:09&$ $%44$09$3(*$3%'90$)(00%):%'$(6% $3%'*)%A9%*'%) 7%6%05  :)$?*&%:%*&%*'%  :%0(&  3#)  )%%*  &0#)$(' '3#*=%)  (*  90  6#49%  );)$%8  3%  8#$%0(#4()8  3#) 6%0)3#&7%&$3%4&%$3)#*&$3%A9%)$ 0:%0)*#4 =#(*  3#)  @%'8%  )  (*$%*)%  $3#$  $3)%  (*646%&  (* 4($(=#$(*&*$3%)($#$%$$#2%)3%4$%0 #4)%3&5 8()0%:0%)%*$#$(*#*&)9::0%))(* #'$)(*$3%'90$ :0'%%&(*=)*$3%4#)$C ;%#0)5#*%7'0%%& 4($(=#*$) 3#)'0::%&9:3)%73@%4*=$$3()'0%%&&*$ 3#6%#*;0%):%'$ 0$09$33%;)3#8%4%))4;0%)0$$

#4)%3&#*&9*%$3('#48%#*) 0#'3(%6(*=$3%(0=#4) *0&%0$8%%$$3%'3#44%*=%:)%&@;$3()*%7'0%%& 4($(=#*$)5$3%'90$)3#6%5 08$(8%$$(8%5%646%&*%7 094%)#*&($()*77%44%)$#@4()3%&$3#$#4($(=#*$573 #$$%8:$)$:449$%$3%)$0%#8 <9)$('%073$9'3%) $3%:90% 9*$#(* <9)$('%7($3$#(*$%&3#*&)5()*$ %*$($4%&$#*;0%4(% 5(*$%0(80 (*#4F * !$(.#4/*=#0#60%80#2#)3I#::9#*&#*$3%05

B" /

5 *-@4%$3%/9:0%8%90$5'*)(&%0(*=$3%())9% 0%=#0&(*='*'%#48%*$ #'$)@% 0%$3%'90$573(4%@)%06(*=$3#$E'90$ ()*$#4#@0#$0;73%0%'3(4&0%*'8%$:4#;5:(*%&#)9*&%0+

 E,3%)%'*& 4(8@ $3%)9@8())(*()73%$3%0(*$3% @$#(*(*= #'$9#48#$0(>5$3%0&%0:#))%&@;$3%(=390$ &()'3#0=(*=$3%#''9)%&?

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

  0#&%)3#*&$3%0)5 B" /B , *)(&%0(*=$3%'*&9'$ $3%:%$($(*%05(*90:(*(*53% '#**$ @%3%#0& *8%0($)''0&(*=4;5$3% 70($ :%$($(* () &()8())%& )9@<%'$$')$  5

G?573('3)3#44@%&%:)($%&7($3$3()'90$ 7($3(**%8*$3*'#)% #(490%5$3%'#)%@%:9$9:(*'90$

% 0%7%:#0$7($3$3%0&%057%&%%8($#::0:0(#$%$*$('% $3%'*&9'$ $3% "#)7%44&9@$5$3%:4(';:06(&%) 0# '*&($(*$3#$$3%6%0*8%*$#*&($)#=%*'(%))3#448#2%%

0$)$:06(&% ):#'%$$3%4('%*)%%) 009**(*=4(A906%*&)(*90@#*#0%#$&%)*$ %*6()#=%$3#$>'()%#*&#>#$(* %:#0$8%*$()$@%(*646%&(*$3% :0'%))(*0%'88%*&(*=$3%'#)% 0#44$8%*$ ):#'%3%:06()(*() #::4('#@4% 04(A906%*&)(*90@#*#0%#&8($$%&4;5$3%:%$($(*%07#) #44$$%&  4(A90  6%*&  (*  090#4  #0%#  /$(44  $3%    "  07#0&%&  $3% #::4('#$(*  (4%&  @% 0%  3(8  @;  $3%  :%$($(*%0  0  :06(&(*=  ):#'%  $ / 573('37#)$$#44;9*?'#44%& 0 #<%)3 (*&#4"

9&=%  #0)3#*/(*=3"

9&=%  ,  3%$3%0):%#2(*=G0%#)*%&

%)G 3%$3%00%:0$#@4%+

%)G