← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12723/2016dismissed

Baljinder Singh & ORS. v. State Of Punjab & ORS.

2020-05-28Mr Justice Jaswant Singh,Mr. Justice Sant Parkash12 pages



         

! "

#  

  







  



 

  

"##$! "

# 



  







  



    

%&" ! "

   







  



  !   %""! "

% "#  







  



 

  $   $ ! "

%   





  



  '  ()'

 **   ()'

 **  +*

,-.%& '

 # "( ()

 "

#* ) + '

 "

  "(()"

#* ,'" - )"

#* , '

  #   ) "

##* , '

   

   )"

#* , '

' # 

)"

#* , 

 '

 

 )

 .

/ "

#*

)   '

  (

 )

"

#* )+'

0  ) "

#* )

 ! 1 -2  

456, 

 !  5 1  -2  455! 

456,

 $31 -2 744

476 */. /,0/-12 8  (      

&( 

 #  1$6 +    / ## ( * ( 9  + :



)   *  2         -2   45



 8       

 

 "

*

5;

3   -  < ) 

#   * +   

-

 ) /  9  *  

=4= 4! 1"

>

 &$6 

 / 

?:  * -((

 

 /  #   ) .

    .

# (  

   */)    @



 4$4 4! 1"

>

 &56 

 / 

 &.

* )*<  * 1A A 6) )

>  /A  /8 

8 *

1A886+

   $3$ *1 +4! *

6 B 

.

    .

# (    */)  ) + (



   .

A * ) )+  * (        A *  .

   4!) /     

 / ( (     (  ( 445 4 

#

 A  / *) 

 B           8 

# 9  *  

44 445+

/ /

>

+  /)    **      A * .

         (   #

A  / *) (    +*) + 

 

    .

    .

# (  */)    

;(



  .

A * )  8 

# 

 /

 * +    

' ()

*  



/ 08-

   **      ( /8 *

   / 445;

443)      +* /   

 +

   ( 445;

443  4) +



     .

  A * )  +





 .

 .

# (   */)   #

 *  

 44 445   (       /   

 )   (



     A *  .

)  #

 *  

=4= 4!



)* 

*     (         +*  / 

     '

-



 <  

 * 

 / 

 *   

 

 +

 

  (   *        .

# (     */ .

)      A *  .

 A88 *



/+

 +   .

# (   */.

) )+

(



  *

A888 *

+

 + A * .



# * 

     / +

 *

       

   

*(  /     / #



   */<  /   **      ( 8   #

)#

 *  

44 445)

'  !!= # ( / *

#

 ( / * ( A * .

 .

 .

# (   */8

/ 

  *  

 (A *  .

)        .

# (    */ .

)     (   *    



   / 



( #

  */) #   +* /

#

 ( / 445 4)  /   * .

)  (    ) * +

 

    .

    .

# (    */)   #

 *  

 44 445    *)   *   

  * 

  *   (   

     / 445;

443    /

*   

# *

 *  

* 

/.#  *-   *  

      

     

  !  * 

 #

08 *

 B 08 *

 + / *  

)+

   



( ) (

        

 8



)   *    

   (  



  +# 



 B *  



 *  )   

  

 /   *     

 2   

  (

  &

  /  8 



*(  / ( 445) +

  / #  

   

/  ( 434 4! 

*  

  4     A *  .

)   #   

(

    

2   8 

+

 

# 

A * .

)   4! /+

+

 

 */<  8 

# ** 



(*   (







 * =4= 4! +

 + **/ #

 /+ 



 +    "

 **       *  ) 

 

 A *  .

)     +)  / *         *  *  (



<  *   )

 * 

*

 "

#$ %&  #  '#  ()#  * 

 ) +

    

    /   D E 

 -   

**   

(*  (



) 

* *  (  # 

*      



*

 <  # +) 9  



(   

 *

% 16 +  / 



(

   (

   +  

(/

  (  ( *

F 16 +    * 

& +



* 

 

 ( 

F :



(   9   (

  *      )   

            (

 

  (       *

   9   8

 #    





 

 #

%

34/5

/1/6/.

/4

,7/,6 /1,- 8 ,3.7. / .- ! *,9: 3;- ""# !,

< ) -1;- !,/7  =,- ! >?,- !,, 3, *.

 ,/ ?.1 -. @#8 :! /1/6/. /4.

34/5 *./. 3/. ;/--  ,7/,6 *1;- /,: *,9 3;-

@@ !,/7 3, >,9- . ,.; "@!-..3.!/

 (   B 

* 



 

(      A *  -<<<

"   / - A> *# @*

  

*((

     *  *((

 "    /  . * A *  @*

 * *((

% - ( B

- A> *# @*

. *A * @*

!'

(

.

2 

 - - $ '

(

  .

    

5'

(

.

  /  ( B  )        /

#

 / (  #

 - 

    (  +   +  

% @

 *  

   (  /

 ** / 

 * ( #

   #  + 

*  +  !   * $  * @

 *   +

   

/

 !) / 

 

 ) 

  

* *

  

)  



(

/  

 *  *



/ 

  7    -#

1

 -(( -   

6 ==!)+* #

 *   

   *     *

  

     * * -<<<

-

   (      

    */  * ==!      */ (    B 

#   (    "   =5!  (   

 -#

  (    "   =34 < #

 (  )( 

# )    

 /#  * 8 



 +

 *

 #  +

( (

 



 ( 

 + (

 / 

 *  -((

    . *  # ) *    - ( ) B  ) A> *#  @*

) B  ) . * A *  @*

 1AA6)



#   2 

 .

)

   2 

 .

    .

 8      / 

+ - A> *# @*

B  

*((

 

 * -((

8 

+

 

     .

  A * )   / +/  

   434 4!)#

@



4$4 4!,+

  # 

 +

 



1+ A * .

) 6 





==3 +  * (" ) 4 <     (        *  

=4= 4!   @



 4$4 4!) 

 +

 

 (   

) +



)  / 

 A *  .

)     ** 

    

(   *     +   @  * *   + 

               ! 

2  

( *  #

** 

/

) + ) /*  

(

+ *     (  

   *(  / #

   #   +

  



  :

(

)  

   7      -#

   -((  -   

6  ) ==!)  / "  

   

     * *

   

  



(

/  *  

 * *



 8)      

 *(   / /     



 B      

 *

 "     *  9    * *

 #G H+   * 

&H+



* 

 

 ( 

FE  +   

  



    5       * -<<<1 ( / *-

6

 )==3)+*

  *



  +%

 " )  +,, #  ) - .##/ #  #" $%&    '(     )*+*# ,( '(    - #- 

               $&.    (  /)     )*+* $0&      '(         ""     (  

"

>          #

   44I

*  (     #

 /

(

 (  



/+/

)(



   8

 #      "

>

  *





%

 

  .

 

   ( 

*;  (  J*  ! 0  *    *

; A  /8 

*

44I

*  (  '

 *;4K 8   

  / *

   

/ *       (  /

  L  8

 /

*

9

* G

/   #

 8  

     ==3 +

 (

     / 4 /+/  (

 ( *  (

/+/  

 8

 #  (

 *

  /  #

 

  *



%&

            ' 1(            

" 

    #  (

   * / +   (  (

 / +/  

 +    * 

 +

  

  *

*

( )+ #

)    #

)    )

 /  /*( 

 *8



)

*  +





/ (     B          / 8

      # +*+  (*( *

  /) *(

 8

 #  *

 *      *    

 ,

2 +

   

     **  *   /  

     

   + 

*

<      * )       



/ 

 1  #

# 6) +*          

 8

  

  

   ** )      * #

 / 

 8 #  

 +

  

  

 1

 A *  .

)  6  

 

  ==3   +  *  ( " )

4) +

 

 #  

  

 / +/  

   434 4!) #

 @



 4$4 4! < + 

    ) 

       /  #  

)   / 

   #

/ #

   #

 "**

 /)   (   * 

,

      *  *  8

 

  ** 

    (

 *  *   / /(   <  * "

#$ %&  #,

)( +( * 9  *( 

D E " >- )+

     +

 

0  A 

1A * *6  "<  ) + .

 (( ( +

=73&==4@      #

   0   A 

    A * * 2      .

)   

 

( ) ( ( ( +



  ==58  



 + +/    +

 

(     .

   8  

(   *  ) * /         +    



  2  3 

 +  * 

  

*

  2) 4 38

+ ( (   

 # (  8 "   

 # "

* ! 5 -  <  

/  

 * 

 @' =;<<;$$& 

 =$=+*



%

 25       6                        5     (     $      &/(   ! (  6) 7   (     89

         /(       

( 3  2

  +      ##

 )   



#

/ D E 

- 

%& 25 8:

- %:;  8<

% (  ( (   7  '5 9   $ &         ( 7  (

= (               (    (    $  &    (                      2  3   ( (       2) 43           ( (        (                        7   ( (      5 8      (      ' %   (     %:- 3 A#         * ) 

 +   ** *   +

/  + ** 

 / 

   

 

           

           ! 

 8



)   9    *(   / / 

 #



 ++



/

#   *

 A * .

)     

 8   #  

 

 (*    

  *

 A * .

)  < # + (

) 

#    

 

/ ( >  /  )  

 +   * 

 /   .

     /)    # *)  

+   *   

 *   

(/

  A *  .

 C   ( 

# + ) *( 

** 

) 

+ *( ( /(



 + +



*/

==3 "* *

+



/   *

#  

(

    2   <   *

 +  



   *

(

/

*/)+    /    

 ) /

/ 

 :

( 

 * )+ 

 * 

     *  

   

, 

  /    (/  (

 * ;

  /) +   

(

  8/-?/.*A1:8*/. /,0/-1:     3A  3A '/6 %.12 "

" #  2

  % M ;  8

 

  % M ;