Jaswant Singh And Another v. Iqbal Singh Alias Bali And Others




   
  







 


!"

"#
$%#
&'
()*+
!"
+
,+

"#
$-
    

   %#

#
.*""/
,"#01
.21
#
"
-# 333

    4"

#2
-1
-###
5#
.#+
6

"
5

(1
+
"
##

   .75#
%
-
*8
"
5#

.+

2+
5!
#
2 1
9+/"1
#
%-1
2
""
"
--+
92
*8
"
-#'-+
5#

##

5+
6

"


2+
%#5#1
: ;
#
"#
"
<%=
/!
99

"
-+

9 4"
1

9!
#9
"
#2
-1
#
"

5

.75#
%
#
+#

5
*8
"
-#'-+
"
"
++!
-#8#





 


 

  







  


  

 
 






 
  
!


"
 

# $ %& $

'
()
 $ $$*
   



  
$
,
- 
 . 

  
/01"

 



2
3 

4


5 0.
6 





4 


, 7


,
0
" +


8 

0.
6 
 


 

8
!

9
,.




6 


6 
1  
,.
: 
,.
" 
! 
/"
;)4
;<4:324
"21=/4/:)





  
  
9.
 ?
 
%'>'%>

 
@  

" +
, 


1 
4
( 

*


 




















  

 

+ 
 
 

  

 

 







  
 




 









 
 
5:3
/
1),2A<2:/=
42=2;
);
!246/2:
B<1:)
 

 





  

 




 

 

  





  
 

 


  

 
 




 

 


 

 
1 





  


C

4"
5

--
*8

> 
*8
8


#
9
.75#
% +81
*"

"2
+5
"#
2

"
9#

7
#
#*5+
2

#!59
.
"

!1

--+
.75#
% 

92
*8
"
-#'-+
5#

##

5+
6
%
/!
99

"
-+


(

2##
"
5#!
"
-8

"

51

> 
()*+
!"
+
,+
"
5
"#
5
 
2+
5
> 

 
!
"
?59
@+#
#

4"#
-#2
8
A
/!

+#

#!#
"
#!"
)5
"
95
-
*8
2
!"

"
"-


B

"
*2
8

"
*


5#!#
@++

  ;
++!

"2
*
75
*8
2
!"

25#


> 

#!#
"
92*+

992*+
-#-#

(

2##
"

"

51
"
-#-+

"
-##9

"

*
9
-#


(

2##
"

"

51

##

"
@++
"
*
!2

"
#
9

(

+
2##
"

--+
5#
##

5+

%
"
*
92
*8
"
-#'-+

"

5
/!
"#
9-+9


""

-!
05

(

2##
"


"

5

"#1
"
@++
5+
#9

7

5+
*
95

55#


4"

















-#'-+1
"##1
"

"++!
"

@++

"
-#
5
1
"##1
-#8
"
"8
98
*
-#9

9/
"
++!
99

"
-+
'
:

+ 


 +



  








 

  



 




 


 
  

?


!
 %
 



D 
 D






5:3
/
1),2A<2:/=D
7
D/"
;)4
;<4:324
"21=/4/:)





 
  
5
 
> > %> #
 
@  

" +
, 


1 
4
( 

*


 


 + 

 +

 


 



 


+ 







  
 





 







 
 D
&

:
 









 

+

D
   D







 






!
 

'






D 
 D






D5:3
/
1),2A<2:/=D
#

:











 #/





 



1



 




 

7
D! 
 #/:

 
  
5
 
> %> #
 
@  

" +
, 


,1 
4
( 

*





 


+ 
 


+ 






  
 




 







 






@ 
 

 







 

 
 




 + 

 +

 

" +
, 
 

 

 + 





 


  


" +
, 







  
  

 




 
 



@  @ 

 
5
 
> > %> #
 
@  


" +
, 





 + 

 +

 D
$

:









 

 $



 







 
  






















!







D

 D





D


  
 D7
D1







 
%>%
 





. 


 
5
 
> > %> #
 
@  


" +
, 







 + 

 +

 




+

 %'

%>%
 

D
, 
9
3
5 
1 

:  
1 

+
,  
=D

 



 



 



>
1!1

  
 

 








>%>%>%'
 




  



 



 

 




   

 

 

 +

  
5
 
> %> #


 
D

,8
8

"
9-5!
##1
"

--+

9
+!

"
+!

"
-#
#2
- (
"2
"#
+#
5+
#
"
-# ;

A#
5+
#
"
-#
5*9
"
"
#+
5#
##

9!
"
--+
#
99

?
5*9
"

"


"

5
*!
#1

> 
98

5-
"
@++
#
"
98
+
"#
5

"
*

"

@++

?
5*9
"
"
99

*!
5!"
+8
"

2

2
95+-+8

+!
(
5--#

"
1
"
-+
#+

"


" 
E 
F
!


+
,
/  
(0*
G

%>%
,11
)
,1
%'

?

:

(
"2
#
"
5*9
9
*8
+#
5+
#
"
-#
*5

"
9

*
2

9#  +81
2

*"

"
*
+5

"
-#
5

"
9#

7
#
#*5+
2

#!59  .
"
*


"
-#!
-#!#-"1
"
-# -+
/

+#

#!#
"#
#"-

-

"
5
-#-#8

+
/

+#
"
"
+




 

 















++!+8
75
*8
2
!"

25#


> 

++!+1
5++

21
"
9
"2!
*
-#5#
*8
8

#5

9#-#

(


"


"
-#'-+
"
"
5
-#-#8
"
*
###
*8
2
!"

25#


> 

"
*

"
@++


4"
--#"
7-#
*8
+#
5+
#
"
-#

#!#
9
5*)5
5

*
+

55

(
8
1

99

*
++

"
*

9#
--#"



 ++
5#"#1

#!"

+8
*#2
*8
"
#+
5#1
"
-#'-+
"2
+#8
92

--+
5#
##

5+

%


"
5
+
*8

> 

"
*

"
@++

C#
"
#591
"#




++
"
99

"
!


"
#+

"
9
5+1


81
+




#+ 
,
"


981
"


"
-#




"#
5"

99
"5+
*
++

I have gone through the judgment relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioners.


9
 
G
, 
G


!  "#"$! % the judgment relied upon by learned counsel for the petitioners would not come to his aid.

 4"
*!
1
"
#2
-

5

*
2

9#


#!+8
9 

>"!
*#2
"#
"++1
"2#1
*
9

*

7-#

-

"
9#

"
 %!
--+ 1

81
"++
+

-
 
  !    &'(

) 2!#!

Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No @""#
#-#*+

D'>