High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26295/2026allowed

Bhagwan Ram Alias Bhagwana Ram v. State Of Punjab

2026-05-14Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

< < 2

A5#"*"*$ 9#0+&+ ( !""# $% & ' A5#+-$ /# "# $% #)*+ "# $% #)*+ "# $% #)*+ "# $% #)*+ "# $% -.$ "# $% -.$ "# $% -.$ "# $% -.$ , , , , 0#+# ", 0#+# ", 0#+# ", 0#+# ", , , , , 8 <

8 <

8 < 7 2 7 2 7 2 7 2 /*

, /*

, 8 <

8 <

8 < 7 2 7 2 7 2 7 2 =1 5 !

! =1 5 !

! 1 1 1 1 05 >0 /##- !

!*/&7 /9$ $)"# %$0 "# -#"*"*$ #05 05 # "

0 .7 & '

(5 ?????

?????

1 1 1 17 5 416 7 5 416 7 5 416 7 5 416 ! ! ! ! 0#+# " 30/ -#"*"*$ + (## %*.#/ / & /#0 !#)"*$

@3 $% "# !!7 23 4#0+"

* *.# !#)"*$

3 05 556 %$0 +## #:*

" $% 0# &.0 (*. "$ "# #07 *

)+# (#0*

$5 /"# / 25<<52 7 0# *+"#0#/ %$0 "# $%%# )#+ -& *+(.# & /#0 !#)"*$ <@ $% "#

! )"7 <@7 " $.*)# !""*$

*"8 '-&07 *+"0*)" "*.5 5

09# $% "# * ;&# #+"*$ *+ "" "# -#"*"*$ #0 *+

))&+#/ $% (# #*

-#0"*

"$ ! )" * 9$.9*

..# 0#)$9#08 $% 3 :

$-*& %0$ "# -#"*"*$ #05 1#0 #/ )$& +#. %$0 "# -#"*"*$ + *"#0"#/ "" "# -#"*"*$ #0 *+ *

)&+"$/8 +* 25<<52 5 1#0 #/ )$& +#. + 0 &#/ "" "# -#"*"*$ #0 + (##

%.+#.8 *-.*) "#/ * "$ "# * ;&#+"*$ 5 1#0 #/ )$& +#. + %&0"#0 +&(*""#/ "" /"$0 08 -0$9*+*$ + $% "# ! )" 9 9# $" +)0&-&.$&+.8 (## )$-.*#/

*"7 / "&+ +7 "# -0$+#)&"*$ )+# +&%%#0+ %0$ #0# " /#%#)"+5 1#0 #/ )$& +#.

+ *"#0"#/ "" "# "0*. *+ /#.8#/ / "# .*(*.*"8 "#0#$% )

$" (# %+"# &-$ "# -#"*"*$ #05 1#0 #/ )$& +#. + 0 &#/ "" "# -#"*"*$ #0 + +&%%#0#/ %$0 $0# " 2<B 8#0+5 &+7 0# &.0 (*. *+ -08#/ %$05

"# $"#0 /7 .#0 #/ !""# )$& +#. + $--$+#/ "# -0#+# (8 0 &*

"" "# ..# + 0*+#/ +" "# -#"*"*$ #0 0# +#0*$&+ *

"&0# /7 "&+7 "# -#"*"*$ #0 /$#+ $" /#+#09# "# )$ )#++*$ $% "# 0# &.0 (*.5 1#0 #/ !""# )$& +#. + %&0"#0 +&(*""#/ "" "# * +" " (*. -.# *+ (00#/ (8 "# 0* $0+ $% !#)"*$ 3C $% "# ! )"7 / "&+7 "# +# $& " "$ (# /*+*++#/5 1#0 #/ !""# )$& +#. +##:+ "$ -.)# $ 0#)$0/ )&+"$/8 )#0"*%*)"# /"#/ <352527 * "# $&0" "$/87 *) *+ ":# 0#)$0/5 5

9# #0/ )$& +#. %$0 "# 0*9. -0"*#+ / 9# # "0$& "# 9*.(.# 0#)$0/+ $% "# )+#5 5

+ 00#+"#/

25<<52

#0#* %"#0

+ )00*#/ $&" / ).. ;& "# -#"*"*$ + -0#+# "#/ $

<352525 $". < -0$+#)&"*$

#++#+ 9# (## )*"#/7 $&" $% *)7 $ .8 2< + (## #D* #/ "*.. /"#5 " *+7 "&+7 * /&(*"(.# "" )$ ).&+*$ $% "# "0*.

*..

":# .$

"*#5 # 0*9. )$ + 0*+#/ " 0 *9# 0*+# "$ /#("(.# *++&#+7

*) +.. (# 0"*$)* "#/ &-$ /&0*

"# )$&0+# $% "0*.5 *+ $&0" /$#+ /## *" --0$-0*"# "$ /#.9# /##- * "$ "#+# 0*9. )$ +7 " "*+ +" #7 .#+" *"

8 -0#'&/*)# "# "0*.5

*(.# + (## (0$& " %$0 0/ "$ * /*)"# "# .*:#.*$$/ $% "# -#"*"*$ #0 (+)$

%0$ "# -0$)#++ $% '&+"*)# $0 * "#0%#0*

*" "# -0$+#)&"*$ #9*/# )#5 5<5

# "0*. *+ * /##/ -0$)0+"* "*

/ %$..8 "#0#$% )

$" (# +//.#/ &-$ "# -#"*"*$ #05 + -#0 )&+"$/8 )#0"*%*)"# /"#/ <35252 %*.#/ (8 "# .#0 #/ !""# )$& +#.7 "# -#"*"*$ #0 + .0#/8 +&%%#0#/ * %$0 -#0*$/ $% 2< 8#07 2 $ "+ / 2@ /8+7 E *+ $" +$

"$ (# * $"#0 4+65

*+ $&0" * '&/ " "*".#/ + >&.

/#0 9#0+&+ !""# $% & >&.

/#0 9#0+&+ !""# $% & '(

'( -++#/ * 2C

2C 2

2 42,,226F %"#0 0#.8*

&-$ "# 0"*$ /#)*/# /* $% "# '&/ "+ $% "# $ =(.# !&-0## $&0" * &++* 0 >"$$

9+5 $# !#)857 !""# $% *0 4<@26 < ! @<F (/&. # "&.8 9+ 5!5

8: 4<6 < ! F 9#/ &. (* !*: 9+5 !""# $% 0+"0 $"#07 2 436 40** .6 F $/ &+.* &++* 9+5 !""# 4

$% #.*6 0#-$0"#/ + 23

! 3<<F 0** . --#.

$5 G22 /"#/ 2C52522 "*".#/ + H*"" *+ + .*+ !&(+ 9+5 # !""# $% I#+" #

.JF *"*+ /*:08 - 9+5 # !""# $% I#+" #

.J7 !-#)*. 1#9# "$ --#. 40.56 $5322 /"#/ 52@52 "*".#/ + H$/ !.

*% !*: 9+5 # !""# $% &'0"JF 0** . --#.

$5<< $% 2 /"#/ 252@52 "*".#/ + $-. >0*+ "0 $-.0&+ 9+5

/*7 :&0 &/08 9+5 !""# $% /8 0/#+7 2 6 40** .6 <CF + #./7 "&+, HC5@5

# 0* " "$ +-##/8 / #D-#/*"*$&+ "0*. *+ $" $ .8 9*". +%# &0/ "$ -0#9# " & /&# / $--0#++*9# * F "$ *"* "# D*#"8 / )$ ))$- 8*

"# ))&+"*$ + #.. + "$ )&0"*. *-*0# " * "# (*.*"8 $% ))&+#/ "$ /#%# / *+#.%7 (&" "#0# *+

$9#00)*

+$)*#". * "#0#+" -9*

8 %$0 +-##/8 "0*.5 *+ 0* " + (## 0#-#"#/.8 )"&"#/ * "# 0#)# " -+" / "# 0"*$ /#)*/# /* $% "# ($9#0#%#00#/ "$ !&-0## $&0"=+ '&/ "+ 9# .*/ /$

+#0*#+ $% /#)*+*$ + $-#

&- 9*+"+ $% %& /# ". 0* "+5 # )$ )#-" $% +-##/8 "0*. *+ .

"#/ * "$ "# 0"*).# < + #++# "*. -0" $% "# %& /# ". 0* " "$ .*%# / .*(#0"87 &0 "##/ / -0#+#09#/ & /#0 $&0 $ +"*"&"*$ # 0* " "$ +-##/8 "0*. (# + *" "# )"&. 0#+"0* *-$+#/ " "# "*# $% "# 00#+" $% "# ))&+#/ / )$

*) )$ "* &#+ " .. +" #+7 #.87 "# +" # $% 7 * ;&*087 "0*.7 --#. / 0#9*+*$ +$ "" 8 -$++*(.# -0#'&/*)# "" 8 0#+&." /&# "$ *-#0*++*(.# / 9$*/(.# /#.8 +* "# "*# $% "# )$*++*$ $% "# $%%# )# "*.. "# )0** . -0$)##/*

+ +&"# * "$ %* .*"87 )$&./ (# 9#0"#/5 # +-##/8 "0*.7 #0.8 #0*

/ ;&*): /*+-$+. 0# +* # ;& $% )0** . '&0*+-0&/# )#5 $9#0)0$ /#/ $&0"/$):#"+7 "# #98 9$.&# $% $0: / "# 0#+&." -0#++&0# $ "# -0$+#)&"*$ / "# $.*)#7 * /&(*"(.8 :##-+ "# # "*0# )0** . '&0*+-0&/# "*. #) *+ & /#0 +"0#++ / +"0* 5 $ #9#07 "*+ )

$" (# #D)&+# %$0 :##-*

"# + $0/ $% $).#+

))&+#/ %$0 /#%* *"# -#0*$/ $% "*#5 " /$#+ $" +#09# 8 )0#/*" "$ "# )0** . '&+"*)# +8+"#7 0"#0 *" :#+ %$0 +/ +""# $% %%*0+5

&0 "## $% +-##/8 "0*. *+ * /#/ "$ 9$*/ $--0#++*$ / -0#9# /#.8 (8 *-$+*

"# $&0" / "# -0$+#)&"*$ $(.* "$ -0$)##/ *" "# "0*.

*" 0#+$ (.# /*+-")5 &0 "## +#09#+

"0##%$./ -&0-$+#5 *0+".87 *" -0$"#)"+ "# ))&+#/ +" $--0#++*9# -0# "0*. *-0*+$ "F +#)$ /.87 *" 0#.*#9#+ "# ))&+#/ $% "# D*#"8 -&(.*) +&+-*)*$ /&# "$ & 0#+$.9#/ )0** . )0 #+ / .+".87 *" -0$"#)"+ +" "# 0*+: "" #9*/# *.. (# .$+" $0 #$0*#+ /*#/ (8 "# -++ # $% "*#7 "&+7 *-*0*

"# (*.*"8 $% "# ))&+#/ "$ /#%# *+#.%5 $#+ *"$&" +8*

"" "# )$ )#+ $% -0#"0*. /#"#

0# 09#5 ))&+#/7 -0#+&#/ *

$)# "7 "*.. -0$9# $"#0 *+#7 0# +&('#)"#/ "$ -+8)$.$ *). / -8+*). /#-0*9"*$ + $% '*..*%#7 &+&..8 & /#0 $ #0$&+ )$ +5 ;&..8 *-$0" "7 "# (&0/# $% /#"# +&) ))&+#/ %0#;&# ".8 %..+ #9*.8 $ "# *

$)# " #(#0+ $% *+ %*.85

#0# *+ 8#" $"#0 +-#)" $% "# ""#0 *) /#+#09#+ +*/#0"*$ " "*+ +" #5 # ..# + * "# -0#+# " )+# 0#."# "$ ))&+#/ (#*

9$.9#/ * 0#."*

"$ )$#0)*. ;& "*"8 $% "0( / & /#0 "# ! )"7 <@5 I*.# )$ +*/#0*

(*. -#"*"*$

)+# * 9$.9*

)$#0)*. ;& "*"87 "# $&0" + "$ :##- * / "# 0* $&0+ # &#0"#/ & /#0 !#)"*$ 3C $% ! )"7 <@ *) /"#+ "" $&0"+ )

" (*. "$ ))&+#/ $ .8 %"#0 #0*

"# -&(.*) -0$+#)&"$0 / %"#0 9*

+"*+%*#/ *"+#.% $% "

+ *) 0# 0#+$ (.# 0$& /+ %$0 (#.*#9*

"" "# ))&+#/ *+ &*."8 $% "# $%%# )# )0 #/G..# #/ / ""7 # *+ $" .*:#.8 "$ )$*" 8 $%%#

*.# $ (*.5 # +"0*

" 0* $&0+ $% !#)"*$ 3C $% "# ! )"7 <@ &+" (# #"*)&.$&+.8 +)0&"* *K#/ +" "# ():/0$- $% ))&+#/=+ %& /# ". 0* " "$ +-##/8 "0*.5 # 0* " "$ .*%# / -#0+$ . .*(#0"8 )

$" (# 0# /#0#/ & "$08 (8 &

00 "#/ /#.8+ * "# '&/*)*. -0$)#++7 -0"*)&.0.8 #0# +&) /#.84+6 *+ #*"#0 ""0*(&"(.# "$ "# ))&+#/ $0 '&+"*%*#/ " "# # / $% "# -0$+#)&"*$ (8 )$ " 0#+$ +5 /*9*/&.

)

$" (# :#-" (#* / (0+ %$0 $0/* "# -#0*$/ $% "*# (8 ":*

0#%& # * 0* $&0+ .*/ /$

!#)"*$ 3C $% "# ! )"7 <@5 .# *+."&0# * *"+ *+/$7 * $0/#0 "$ # +&0# +-##/8 / "*#.8 /*+-$+. $% "# )+#+ & /#0 "# )"7 + -0$9*/#/ %$0 "# )$ +"*"&"*$ $% +-#)*. $&0"+ & /#0 !#)"*$ 3 $% "# )"5 $ #9#07 "*+ $&0" )

$" "&0

#.+$ =+ #8# "$ "# -0$"0)"#/ /#.8+ / +8+"#"*) * #%%*)*# )8 "" %0&+"0"# "*+ .# *+."*9# -&0-$+#5 $&0" $% . *+ /&"8($& / "$ # +&0# "" *" /$#+

$" (#)$# )$-.*)*" * 9*$."*$ $% /*9*/&.=+ %& /# ". 0* "+7

*"+"

8"*

"* #/ * +""&"#5 I*.# /#.*

*" (*.

)+# $9#0 #/ (8 "# 0* $&0+ $% !#)"*$ 3C $% "# ! )"7 <@7 "# $&0" &+" +"0*:# '&/*)*$&+ (. )# (#"

## "# .# *+."*9# " "$ )&0( "# # )# $% /0& + / "# +)0$+ )" 0* " $% "# ))&+#/ "$ %*0 / #D-#/*"*$&+ "0*.5 0$.$

#/ * *"$&" '&+"*%*(.# )&+#7 0*+:+ "0 +%$0*

-0#"0*. /#"# "$ -& *"*9# *-0*+$ "7 $&")$# "*"#"*). "$ "# -0* )*-.# $% '&+"*)# / #;&*"85 0 $7 "# & #;&*9$). * %#0# )# *+ ""

#0# "# "0*. + %*.#/ "$ )$ ).&/# *"* 0#+$ (.# "*#7 0#+&."*

-0$.$

7 *" *.*""#+ +" "# -0#)*$&+ %& /# ". 0* "+ $% .*%# / .*(#0"8 "#/ & /#0 "# . /7 + +&)7 )$ . .*(#0"8 $9#00*/*

"# +""&"$08 #(0 $ )0#"#/ & /#0 !#)"*$ 3C $% "# !

)"7 <@ $& " "$ (# )$ +*/#0#/ + -#0 %)"+ $% *9# )+#5

$"#0

$0/+7 " $% (*. * )+# -#0"*

"$ )$#0)*. ;& "*"87 $

0$& / $% & /&# /#.8 * "0*.7 )

$" (# +*/ "$ (# %#""#0#/ (8 !#)"*$ 3C $% "# ! )"7 <@5J

"*+ 9*# $% "# ""#07 "# 0* $0 *-$+#/ & /#0 !#)"*$ 3C $% "#

! )" +" /+ /*.&"#/ * .* " $% "# 0"*).# < $% "# $ +"*"&"*$

/*5

535

/&(*"(.87 "# -0#+# " -#"*"*$ *+ "# "*0/ ""#-" (8 "# -#"*"*$ "$ +#)&0# 0# &.0 (*.5 # %*0+" (*. -.# + /*+*++#/ + *"/0

2<5<252 / "# +#)$ / (*. -.# + /*+*++#/ + *"/0 <@52525 $ #9#07 :##-*

9*# "# # "*0#"8 $% "# %)"&. "0*D $% "# )+# * /F #+-#)*..87 %)"& $% "# -#"*"*$ #0 9*

+&%%#0#/ #D"# /#/ * E -)# $% "0*.F "*+ $&0" *+ * ).* #/ "$ %%*0"*9#.8 )$ +*/#0 "# * +" " -.# %$0 (*.5 -0$%*"(.# 0#%#0# )#7 * "*+ 0# 0/7 ) (# /# "$ '&/ " $% "*+ $&0" -++#/ !33 33 33 3323 23 23 23 "*".#/ + %*; > 9#0+&+ !""# $% 08 / $"#0 %*; > 9#0+&+ !""# $% 08 / $"#0 %*; > 9#0+&+ !""# $% 08 / $"#0 %*; > 9#0+&+ !""# $% 08 / $"#0F 0#.#9 #0#$% 0#/+ + & /#0, H<25 + #-*.$ &# "$ "# ($9# /*+)&++*$ 7 "# %$..$

-0* )*-.#+ ##0 #, !#)$ /G+&))#++*9# 0# &.0 (*. -#"*"*$ 4+6 %*.#/ *+ * "* (.# * . )# +&) -#"*"*$ $& "

$" "$ (# 0#'#)"#/ +$.#.8 $ 0$& / $% "* (*.*"8 "#0#$%5

!&) +#)$ /G+&))#++*9# 0# &.0 (*. -#"*"*$ 4+6 *+ * "* (.# #"#0 #0.*#0 -#"*"*$

+ /*+*++#/ + *"/0

G/*+*++#/ + $" -0#++#/G/*+*++#/ %$0 -0$+#)&"*$ $0 #0.*#0 -#"*"*$

+ /*+*++#/ $ #0*"+5 $0 "# +#)$ /G+&))#++*9# 0# &.0 (*. -#"*"*$ 4+6 "$ +&))##/7 "# #0G--.*) " +.. (# #++# "*..8G-#0"* ".8 0#;&*0#/ "$ +$ +&(+" "*.

)

# * )*0)&+" )#+ / +$

$% #0# +&-#0%*)*. $0 $+"# +*(.# )

$&./ $" +&%%*)#5 # #"-$0*) #D-0#++*$ $% +##:*

+#)$ /G+&))#++*9# (*.

-.#4+6 $& "

$" (# (+"0)"#/ * "$ .*"#0. *"#0"*$ + $% -#"*"*$ 4+6 *"$&"

+&(+" "*.7 #%%#)"*9# / )$ "*. )

# * )*0)&+" )#+5

$ #D&+"*9# &*/#.* #+ ) -$++*(.8 (# .*/ /$

+ "$ "

$&./ +"*"&"# +&(+" "*. )

# * )*0)&+" )#+ + #9#08 )+# + *"+ $

& *;&# %)"+G)*0)&+" )#5 :*

+&) ""#-" *+

(&" &"$-*

/#9$&05 0 $7 "*+ *++&# *+ (#+" .#%" "$ "# '&/*)*.

*+/$ / /*+)0#"*$ "# $&0" /#.*

*" +&) +#)$ /G+&))#++*9# 0# &.0 (*. -#"*"*$ 4+65 L

)+# $&0" )$$+#+ "$ " +#)$ /G+&))#++*9# 0# &.0 (*.

4+67 )$ " / .&)*/ 0#+$ + 0# -#0"* ".8 0#;&*0#/ "$ (# 0#)$0/#/ %$0

+&) -.# /#+-*"# +&) -.# (#*

+#)$ /G+&))#++*9# -#"*"*$ 4+65

$"#0 $0/+7 "# )&+# %$0 $&0" 9*

+&))#++%&..8 )$& )#/G# "#0"* +&) +#)$ /G+&))#++*9# -#"*"*$ 4+6 $& " "$ (# 0#/*.8 / ).#0.8 /#)*-#0(.# %0$ "# +*/ $0/#0 -++#/5J !&%%*)# "$ +87 %&0"#0 /#"# $% "# -#"*"*$ #0 + & /#0"0*. *+

00 "#/ * "# %)"+ / )*0)&+" )#+ $% "# )+#5 C5

9*# $% ($9#7 "# -0#+# " -#"*"*$ *+ ..$ ..$ ..$ ..$ #/5 #"*"*$ #0 *+ $0/#0#/ "$ (# 0#.#+#/ $ 0# &.0 (*.7 *% $" 0#;&*0#/ * 8 $"#0 )+#7 $ *+ %&0 *+*

(*.G+&0#"8 ($ /+ "$ "# +"*+%)"*$ $% "# 1/5 )$ #/ "0*.

$&0"G&"8 *+"0"#5 $ #9#07 * //*"*$ "$ )$ + "" 8 (# *-$+#/

(8 "# )$ #/ "0*. $&0"G&"8 *+"0"#7 "# -#"*"*$ #0 +.. 0#* ($& / (8 "# %$..$

+, 4*6

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

$" *+&+# "# .*(#0"8 "#/5 4**6

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

$" "-#0 *" 8 #9*/# )#7 $0. $0 /$)&# "087 /&0*

"# "0*.5 4***6

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

$" (+# " *+#.% $ 8 /"# (#%$0# "# "0*.5 4*96

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

$" )$*" 8 $%%# *.# $ (*.5

# -#"*"*$ #0 +.. /#-$+*" *+ -++-$0"7 *% *" "# "0*.

$&0"5 49*6

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

*9# *+ )#..-$ &(#0 "$ "#

%%*)#0G! $% )$ #/ $.*)# !""*$ / +..

$" )

# *+ )#..-$ &(#0 *"$&" -0*$0 -#0*++*$ $% "# "0*.

$&0"G ..; *+"0"#5 49**6

# -#"*"*$ #0 +..

$" * 8

#0 "08 "$ /#.8 "# "0*.5 49***6 # -#"*"*$ #0 +.. +&(*"7 $ "# %*0+"

$0:*

/8 $% #9#08 "7 %%*/9*"7 (#%$0# "# )$ #/ "0*. $&0"7 "$ "# #%%#)"

"" # + $" (## )$*++*$ $% 8 $%%# )# %"#0 (#*

0#.#+#/ $ (*.5

)+# "# -#"*"*$ #0 *+ %$& / "$ (# 9$.9#/ * 8 $%%# )# %"#0 *+ (#*

.0 #/ $ (*. * -0#+# " 7 $ "# (+*+ $% *+ %%*/9*" $0 $"#0 *+#7 "# !""# *+ /"#/ "$ $9#7 %$0" *"7 %$0 ) )#.."*$ $% *+ (*.

*) -.#7 (&" $% )$&0+#7 +.. (# 0"*$)* "#/ &-$ #0*"+ "#0#$%5 @5

)+# $% (0#) $% 8 $% "# %$0#+*/ )$ + / "$+# *) 8 (# *-$+#/ (8 )$ #/ "0*. $&0"G&"8 *+"0"# + /*0#)"#/ #0#* ($9# $0 &-$ +$

8 $"#0 +&%%*)*# " )&+#7 "# !""#G)$-.* " +.. (# "

.*(#0"8 "$ $9# ) )#.."*$ $% (*. $% "# -#"*"*$ #05 5 0/#0#/ ))$0/*

.85 <25

+*/ #0#* ($9# +.. (# )$ +"0&#/ + #D-0#++*$ $-* "# #0*"+ $% "# )+#5 <<5 !* )# "# * )+# + (## /#)*/#/7 -#

*+)#.. #$&+ --.*)"*$ 7 *% 87 +.. .+$ +" /+ /*+-$+#/ $%%5 4! 1 ! 1 ! 1 ! 16 8 <

8 <

8 < 7 2 7 2 7 2 7 2 9*0 I#"#0 +-#:*

G0#+$ #/, #+G I#"#0 0#-$0"(.#, #+G