High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14460/2014allowed

Navdeep Garg v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2018-03-07Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan8 pages

!"!#$%!&!%'!(#)**+ ,$!(-!./&/(#)+*0*1 ,'!!2,% !$/$/(#!% 3!%& & 4$,$!(-

#5,6,#($7!%& !&2(#!#$&

%!&!#$)

%* ,8,#9 ",%:4%*'(.,$!8/$7

%*3/2/#9 ",%:'(.,$!-(%$7!2!$/$/(#!%*

%*'/#/$',&$7/:***:

#5,6*

%** *7(2%,:'(.,$!-(%%!&2(#!#$#(** ;;;

7,<<!# !/#$7!/#&$,#$8%/$2!$/$/(#/&$($7!(%!%,$! **##!= :2,&&!6>$7!/%!.$(%(-

6</.#&$% .$/(#& 4** :

#5,6%!5!.$/# $7!.<,/"(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%&!!?/# ,22(/#$"!#$$( $7!2(&$(-3(.,$/(#,< * %/!-<>: /$ ",> 6! #($/.! $7,$ $7! !2,%$"!#$ (- 4.7((< .,$/(#:4$,$!(-

#5,6/&& !,'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@/#'/$/# ,22</.,$/(#&-(%%!.% /$"!#$,&3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!%&A /&$%!&&!&/#',%/( & $%,!&* +1 2(&$& (- 3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!%&A /&$%!&&!& /'/< 8!%! ,<&( ,'!%$/&!( $(-87/.70@2(&$&8!%!$(6!-/<<! 2-%(","(# &$$7!

!#!%,<.,$! (%>.,#/,$!&* 7! !&&!#$/,< B ,</-/.,$/(# 2%!&.%/6! -(% $7! 2(&$ 8,& ,&

#!%)

!"#$$%&"'&#$()*+, "'"

- ./0./0 01

!$/$/(#!%6!<(# &$($7! !#!%,<.,$! (%>,#,22</!-(%$7! 2(&$ (- 3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!% /'/< * 2(# &.% $/#> (- (.

"!#$&: , 2%('/&/(#,<"!%/$</&$(-.,#/,$!&8,&%!<!,&!/#87/.7$7!#,"!(- $7!2!$/$/(#!%-/ %!,$4%*(*++,#7/&"!%/$8,&!$!%"/#!,&C** 2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# 8,&.(# .$!/#87/.7.,#/,$!&-%("4%*(*$( 8!%!.,<<!* !$/$/(#!%/#$7!</ 7$(-7/&"!%/$2(&/$/(#!$!%"/#!8,& #($!</ /6<!$(2,%$/./2,$!/#$7!-/%&$2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# *7!%!,-$!%:(# *+* &!.(# .( #&!</# $((? 2<,.! /# 87/.7 $7! 2!$/$/(#!% <> 2,%$/./2,$!*

%!./&!.,&!&!$ 2(#6!7,<-(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%/&$7,$, ,/#&$0@ 2(&$&,'!%$/&!(-3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!%&/'/< /#$7! !#!%,<.,$! (%>:+ 2(&$&7,'!#($6!!#-/<<! 2,#/#&2/$!(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%6!/# !</ /6<!: 7,'/# 2,%$/./2,$!/#,2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# ,#.(#&!B !#$<>6!/# , &!<!.$!.,#/,$!:/&6!/# !#/!,22(/#$"!#$*

!%.(#$%,:.<,/"(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%/&6!/# %!&/&$!6>$7!4$,$! 6>& 6"/$$/# $7,$2!$/$/(#!%7,2,&&!7/&7%!!!,%&/2<(",/#/'/< # /#!!%/# /# ,>: * 7!%! 8,& , &2!./-/. .(#/$/(# /# $7! ,'!%$/&!"!#$ ,$! 0*@*@ $7,$ $7! !=2!%/!#.! 87/.7 , .,#/,$! 2(&&!&&!& ,-$!%2,&&/# $7!%!B /&/$!B ,</-/.,$/(# -(%$7!2(&$:8/<< 6!

.(#&/!%!*D!,%#!4$,$!.( #&!<& 6"/$&$7,$!=2!%/!#.!(-$7!2!$/$/(#!% ,-$!%2,&&/# $7!!&&!#$/,<B ,</-/.,$/(#7,&6!!#$,?!#/#$(.(#&/!%,$/(# ,#,&2!%.%/$!%/,-(%"

<,$!"!%/$(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%7,&6!!#%!.?(#!,& C* 6> $7! 7,/%",#: !2,%$"!#$,< 4!<!.$/(# (""/$$!!!,.7/# *

!%/$(-$7!<,&$&!<!.$!.,#/,$!/#$7!.,$! (%>(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%/*!* !#!%,<.,$! (%>-(%$7!2(&$(-3(.,$/(#,< /&C*0* ,&&/# (-$7!/"2 #!(%!%,$!**##!= /&&( 7$$(6!

0 &$/-/!(#$7!6,&/&$7,$#(.,#/,$!<(8!%/#"!%/$$($7!2!$/$/(#!%7,& 6!!#&!<!.$!,#,22(/#$!* ( #&!<-(%$7!2,%$/!&7,'!6!!#7!,%,$<!# $7,#2<!,/# & (#%!.(%7,'!6!!#2!% &!* 7!-,.$ ",& %! ,%& 2!$/$/(#!%6!/# !</ /6<!,#7,'/# 2,%$/./2,$!/#$7!2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# -(%$7!2(&$(-3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!% /'/< /&#($/#/&2 $!* !%/$(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%&$,#&!$!%"/#!,&C**

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

</.!#&!(-,.$/# /#,#,%6/$%,%>",##!%/#.7((&/# #($$(-/<< 2$7!

',.,#./!&-%(","(# &$$7!&!<!.$!.,#/,$!&* $/&6>#(88!<<&!$$<!$7,$(#.!,2(&$ <>,'!%$/&!7,&#($ 6!!#.(#& "!:$7!#,.,#/,$!#!=$/#(%!%(-"!%/$,&!$!%"/#!/#, %!

<,%2%(.!&&(-&!<!.$/(#:/-,',/<,6<!:7,&$(6!/#'/$!-(%-/<</# 2& .7 ',.,#.>*

7/&( %$(#,2%!'/( &,$!(-7!,%/# /*!*(#*+*+ $,?/# #($/.!(-$7!,"/$$!2(&/$/(#(--,.$$7,$+2(&$&( $(-$7!0@ ,'!%$/&!2(&$&(-3(.,$/(#,< ,&$!%&/'/< !#!%,<.,$! (%>,%!&$/<< <>/# ',.,#$,#$7!2!$/$/(#!%/#&2/$!(-6!/# !</ /6<!,#7/&"!%/$7,'/# 6!!#,&&!&&!7,6!!#!#/!$7!(--!%(-,22(/#$"!#$7,.,<<! 2(#$7!

4$,$!$(.("2<!$!/#&$% .$/(#&,&%! ,%&,#>.(#&./( &!./&/(#7,'/# 6!!#$,?!#6>$7!.("2!$!#$, $7(%/$>8/$7%! ,%$(-/=,$/(#(-,6!#.7 ",%?,#6!<(887/.7#(.,#/,$!8,&$(6!,22(/#$!&(,&$(5 &$/->#($ -/<</# 2$7!+ #-/<<!2(&$&* 7!(%!%,$!*+*+8,&/#$7!-(<<(8/# $!%"&) 2 0 '%040'&#40 5

6 7

/ -

- -

8 07 9: / ; + ( /

,6. 64

/ 6

0 -

01 #2 %2(%$!.("2</,#.!(-$7!/%!.$/(#/&& !6>$7/&( %$,# ,/$/(#,<,--/,'/$,$!C*@*+(-$7!/%!.$(%:

6</.#&$% .$/(#&4* :

#5,6,<(# 8/$7##!= ,$!@*1*08,&2<,.!(#%!.(%*

!% &,<(-$7!,/$/(#,<,--/,'/$(!&#($%!'!,<,#>.(#&./( &!./&/(# $,?!#6>$7!.("2!$!#$, $7(%/$>,&%! ,%&-/=,$/(#(-,6!#.7

C ",%?A2!%.!#$, !,#6!<(887/.7.,#/,$!&/#&2/$!(-7,'/# 2,%$/./2,$! /#$7!2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# 8!%!$(6!&!!#,& #& /$,6<!-(%,22(/#$"!#$* %/# $7!.( %&!(-7!,%/# <!,%#!4$,$!.( #&!<7,&.(#.!!$7,$/#-,.$ #(& .7!./&/(# 7,&6!!# $,?!#* %/( &<>,/$/(#,<,--/,'/$,$!

C*@*+%!-!%&$(,#(%!%,$!@*1*0,22!#!,<(# 8/$7$7!,--/,'/$ ,&##!= ,#,&2!%87/.7,!./&/(#8,&$,?!#6>$7! %/#./2,< 4!.%!$,%>:('$*(-

#5,6:!2,%$"!#$(-4.7((< .,$/(#$(.,#.!<$7!

8,/$/# </&$2%!2,%!/#2 %& ,#.!$($7!%!.% /$"!#$2%(.!&&/#/$/,$!'/!

,'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@* <!,%<>:4$,$!87/<!%!5!.$/# $7!.<,/"(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%-(% ,22(/#$"!#$,&3(.,$/(#,< !#!%,<.,$! (%>7,&2%(.!!!

(#,#!%%(#!( &2%!"/&!* !$/$/(#!%/&#($&$,?/# 7/&.<,/",&,8,/$</&$! .,#/,$!* !./&/(# $( .,#.!<A&.%,2 , 8,/$/# </&$ 8( < 6! (- #( .(#&!B !#.!* 4$,$! .( #&!< 7,& %/# $7! .( %&! (- ,% "!#$& ,<&( .(#.!!$7,$#(8,/$/# </&$8,&2%!2,%!/#$7!&$%!,"/#87/.7$7! 2!$/$/(#!%7,,22</!* <,/"(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%/&, ,/#&$$7!,'!%$/&! 2(&$&,#87/.77,'!#($6!!#-/<<! 2*7/&( %$/&(-$7!.(#&/!%!

'/!8$7,$$7!,'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@.<!,%<>%!-<!.$!,#/#$!#$(- $7! .(#.!%#! 4$,$! !2,%$"!#$ $( -/<< 2 0@ 2(&$& (- 3(.,$/(#,<

,&$!%&A /&$%!&&!& /'/< -%(" ,"(# &$ $7! !#!%,< .,$! (%>* %!&!#$ 2!$/$/(#!%/&,&!<!.$!.,#/,$!,#7/&"!%/$7,&6!!#!$!%"/#!,&2!% .%/$!%/,* #$7!,6&!#.!(-,#>.(#&./( &!./&/(#(-,--/=/# $7!6!#.7 ",%?,#6!<(887/.7$7!,'!%$/&!2(&$&8!%!#($$(6!-/<<! 2:$7!

,.$/(#(-$7!4$,$!('$*#($$((--!%$7!2(&$/#B !&$/(#$($7!.,#/,$!

#!=$/#(%!%(-"!%/$8( <6!&!!#,&,%6/$%,%>,#'/(<,$/'!(-%$/.<!& ,#(-$7!(#&$/$ $/(#(-#/,*

D!,%#!4$,$!.( #&!<7,&(22(&!$7!2%,>!%(-$7!2!$/$/(#!% &!!?/# ,22(/#$"!#$$($7!2(&$/#B !&$/(#6>.(#$!#/# $7,$$7!%!8!%!

,<<! ,$/(#&$7,$.!%$,/#.,#/,$!&<(8!%/#"!%/$/#$7!%!.% /$"!#$2%(.!&& !",#,$/# -%(",'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@7,6!!#&!<!.$!,#, !./&/(#8,&$,?!#$(%!-!%$7!",$$!%$($7!!2,%$"!#$(-3/ /<,#.!

#5,6-(%/#B /%>*'!#/-$7,$6!&(:$7!%!8( <6!#(!"6,% (/#$7!

",$$!%6!/# /#B /%!/#$(6>$7!3/ /<,#.!!2,%$"!#$,#6,&!(#,#> -/#/# &%!$ %#!:$7!#!.!&&,%>.(%%!.$/'!:%!"!/,<"!,& %!&8( <6!

$,?!#&$%/.$<>/#,..(%,#.!8/$7<,8*"/$$!<>:,&(-,$!$7!&!<!.$/(# 2%(.!&&7,&#($6!!#&.%,22!* ,$7!%.,#/,$!&7,'!6!!#,22(/#$!,# ,%!8(%?/# *'!#/-$7!2!$/$/(#!%8!%!$(6!,22(/#$!:$7!.(#&!B !#.!& (-,#/#B /%>!#$% &$!$($7!3/ /<,#.!!2,%$"!#$8( <,22<>!B ,<<>$( 7/",<(# 8/$7($7!%&!<!.$!,#,22(/#$!.,#/,$!&* !%!<>%!-!%%/# $7!",$$!%$($7!3/ /<,#.!!2,%$"!#$-(%/#B /%>.,##($6!.(#&$% !,&, &$/-/,6<!6,&/&-(%!#>/# .(#&/!%,$/(#-(%,22(/#$"!#$$($7!2!$/$/(#!% (#$7!2(&$/#B !&$/(#&$%/.$<>/#$!%"&(-7/&"!%/$2(&/$/(#* &,",$$!%(-<,&$%!&(%$:<!,%#!4$,$!.( #&!<7,&%,/&!$7!

(65!.$/(#(-!<,>*$/&& 6"/$$!$7,$$7!%!.% /$"!#$2%(.!&&8,&/#/$/,$!

/#$!%"&(-/&& ,#.!(-,#,'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@*$/&.(#$!#! $7,$/$8( <6!$((<,$!/#$7!,>-(%/%!.$/(#&$(6!/&& !6>$7/&( %$ -(%$7!2!$/$/(#!%$(6!,22(/#$!$($7!2(&$/#B !&$/(#* '!# & .7(65!.$/(# (-!<,>7,& 6!!# #($/.!(#<>$(6! %!5!.$!* #$7!8%/$2!$/$/(#$7!%!,%!&2!./-/.,'!%"!#$&$7,$,-$!%$7! 2!$/$/(#!%7,2,%$/./2,$!/#$7!2%(.!&&(-.( #&!</# ,#7/&"!%/$7,'/# 6!!#!$!%"/#!:,# "6!%(-%!2%!&!#$,$/(#&8!%!& 6"/$$!$($7!

+ .("2!$!#$, $7(%/$>&$,%$/# -%("0*@*(#8,%&&!!?/# ,22(/#$"!#$* 7!.(2/!&(-%!2%!&!#$,$/(#&A,22!,<&&$,#,22!#!,&##!= %!& C,#

,<(# 8/$7$7!8%/$2!$/$/(#* /</# (-& .7%!2%!&!#$,$/(#&,#$7!

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

/#&$,#$8%/$2!$/$/(#8/$7( $,#>!<,>* 7!,-(%!#($/.!&!B !#.!(--,.$&,#./%.

"&$,#.!&.<!,%<> &7(8$7,$$7!2!$/$/(#!%7,&6!!#'/ /<,#$,&%! ,%&7/&%/ 7$&,#7,&6!!# , /$,$/# 7/&.<,/".(#$/# ( &<>*<,/"(-$7!2!$/$/(#!%:,&& .7:.,##($6!

!#/!(#$7! %( #(-!<,>*

(%$7!%!,&(#&%!.(%!,6('!:8%/$2!$/$/(#/&,<<(8!* %!% ,$!**##!= /&&!$,&/!* /%!.$/(#&,%!/&& !$(,22(/#$$7!2!$/$/(#!%(#$7!2(&$(- 3(.,$/(#,< : !#!%,<.,$! (%>:, ,/#&$(#!(-$7!',.,#$2(&$ $7,$8,&,'!%$/&!'/!,'!%$/&!"!#$,$!0*@*@*4 .7,22(/#$"!#$

1 8( <%!<,$!6,.?$($7!,$!87!#($7!%.,#/,$!&:87(7,2,%$/./2,$!/# $7!&,"!'!%>&!<!.$/(#2%(.!&&8!%!&(,22(/#$!*22(/#$"!#$<!$$!%6! /&& !8/$7/#,2!%/((-$8("(#$7&-%("$7!,$!(-%!.!/2$(-,.!%$/-/! .(2>(-$7/&(%!%* $/&:7(8!'!%:.<,%/-/!$7,$$7!2!$/$/(#!%8( <#($6!!#$/$<!

$(,%%!,%&(-&,<,%>-(%$7!2!%/(/#B !&$/(#*

!$/$/(#/&,<<(8!/#$7!,-(%!&,/$!%"&*

< .?> 7!$7!%&2!,?/# A%!,&(#!) !&A( 7!$7!% !2(%$,6<!) !&A(