Sukhpreet Singh Sidhu And ORS v. Union Of India And ORS
!" "#$%$&' (
)*+,-.""!)$&/,)$0,* &0!,".% "!$!$&".% 1% &$& &0$ &0!,".% "%-&0"&!% '
!
" # $%& '
( )%& !
( !# +
,
#
- . / $0 $)
$.
1 2
!
1
4
6$7 ! 1 !1 1
(
1 * )%& ! ! $, $0 )0)0 ! 1 8
1 )%& !1! 1 6)7 !
!
! 1 $ ,
9
)0$4
)0$:
* !# (
;<=! " > '
;!# >
?!
1
9 = .
),
, .
),
1* '
!*
%
!# (
;<=! " >
?! ! '
;@! > @! $:.,
'
;
> @1! $:..
1
.
),
!# (
;<=! " >
! '
!*
=
$::4
1
6+7 ! ). 0: )0)0
1 1 A
! " #$
% &'' $ $ % &''' $ (
( $ ) *
( +
((,
-./ 0$ % !
( % 1123$- ($ + $ 3
3* ( ( $ 3* ( (
( ./ 0 !
(
- % %
( ( ,4
5! %
! " #
%
(( % (((,4
. (&111 . )6 % $ 4 - 7
%
8 - 4
9 - %7.
(:( -4
-
.& 77
- ;49- +
.2 ). 0 $ (
( )./0 %-; ( - +
- &-
<
6,7 8 04 $0 )0)0
(! '
B = 1 6.7 9
! !* C*!
$::4
!
!# !*
( !
)4 (
;<=! " >
/+
(
;<=! " >
$:::
D )+ 0. )00)
!
@
1
!E
!# !*
( ( (
1 (
**
* 1
1 *1
( (
;<=! " >
1 ), 04 )00)
6/7 9
! !*
11
! * * 11 )+ 0. )00) ! * 1! !** 1
C! " (F 4,)$ )00) E4(
+
E
A
= !
!# !*
( !1 ! ( @
1
!
-1 "! ! !# ! 1 1
!1 *
@
1
!
1
1 (
;<=! " >%
D ?! %1
-1 "! !
!
!1 ! @
1
!
!1
A !
0, 0) )00+
A! = (
;<=! " >
!
$::4
! ! ?!
(F 4,)$ )00)
31 02 02 )00+2 @A! <= )00+ ! 1
9
! !* A= ! :$ ! )4 *1 (
;<=! " >
/+ *1
(
;<=! " >
<=
): 0+ $::4
! 1* 1*
=
!
#
1! ! 1*
1
*
= 1*
=
@A! <= )00+ +
.
(
@ .
),
(
;<=! " >
1
= $::: *!
)00) @ .
),
! .
), :
!*# 3E*
!
#!1 02 02 )00+ (F 4,)$ )00)
C! " 9
!
1 $:
#!1 02 02 )00+
C! " !*
! 1
!#
1 1
1
#
% 11
02 02 )00+
C! " (! ! * 3E* = ( +,$$A+,)$ )00.
E, :
= +
E
6:7 3E* = 0+ 0. )00/
( = 1
#!1 02 02 )00+
C! " 3
A
' *
A! = ! !*# ! 1
%*# 3E* =
!
!*# 3E* =
!* 5
31
11 *
A
!1 !
=!
#! 6$07 9
! !*
A
- +$ 0. )0$+ C! "
A 1
1 !*
( !!
0+ 0. )00/
3E* =
1
!
3E* = (!2 11 +$ 0. )0$+
C! " !** 1 *1 ( ..4:A./0.
)0$, *8
>= +
>= 8 3E* = )+ 0. )0$,
( A ++
+, #!1
!A 22 % ($
( , -
$
3$- (
, :
?
#- ! % (( (
-
($ $ $
$ $ $
(4 $ 3 (
@ -$ $ ((-
$ -
! " # 4 @( % 3
(+( AAB
$ ( $ $ - $ 3$- (-$
$ %
(
, %
- '2 -CA + %&1 ,
-
(
%$ ( - 1B,$ - -
$ (
%- $ ( $
(
$ D 20 ! (
+( 3 $ $ + $ ,- $-( $ % (
% % 3$- % ( D( ( &'''
7 % - 11- $ %
% $ - % (-
% $ ! - $- < 6$$7 < *
!
* $:::
)) )00) 1 !
!! ' !!
)+ 0. )0$,
# !
A
$) 0/ )0$, @A
1 *
3E* =
1 )0$$ !*#
! +0 0+ )0$.
= 1 *
GH
*
!1 $:::
)00)
!! ' * ! #!1 )+ 0. )0$,
!1 $:::
)00)
= 6$)7 9
!
!* .
),
@A! <= )00+
$:::
@ .
),
)00) 3E* = #!1 0+ 0. )00/ ?!
!
A $:::
1 #!1 )+ 0. )0$, 3E* =
#
1 1 * ! =
*2 2
.
), (
;<=! " > = )4
1 * ! $:::
3E* =
!1
)4 A !
(
;<=! " > $, 0/ )0$/ =1
.
),
).:
)4) 1
$:::
A )00+ =
@A ! <= )00+
1 1
6$+7 9
! '
;@! > @! $:., ; E $:., @!E>
'
;
> @1! $:..
@! ,;*> @! $:., @! !
!* *
(
'
(
! & !*
( (
!1 $:..
@1!
'
;
> @1! $:..
; E $:..
@1! > 8 1!
1 $:., @! @1! +
.
$:..
@1!
( ! ! *
(
! * '
! ! ! *
! !*
6$,7 "
1
@!
@1!
! !*
@!
1 )4
!* <= 1
= !*
1 '
.
),
!* .
),
1*
'
! 1 !1
!!
1* 6$.7
! !
!;>
1 * !*
@! *
(
*1 '
?!
! !*
'
!
1* ! )0$4
)0$:
( ! $2
1* '
;!# > 1 #1
D*% * )0$$
!
)0$,
/
!!
1* '
;!# >
!
0$ 0$ )0$4
0$ 0$ )0$:
! 1*
!
6$/7 9
!% !* A
# ! 11
* !1
! * 1
!1
* 5 A ?!
# #!1 3E* =
3E* = (!2 *1 1
A
1
@A(! = )00+ !# (
;<=! " >
)00, 6$27 9
!%
!*
.
), = 1 '
)00)
.
),
!
A!
! (?! A! =
)00+ ' A ! =
1
1 @A! <= )00+
:$
D *1 !!
!
)00, 1 1 !!
!* (
!!
*
* ! ! 1
*1
!* 1!
1 1
1
*
, :
$,
6$47 9
!% !* !
)0$, #1
D*% * )0$$
1
)00, <
)0$,
1
1
)00, 1 1 * (
! 1
1 !
1 #1
)0$, #1
D*% * )0$$ *#
8
1 * 3E* = :$
$::4 8 1 @A ! <= )00+
)00,
*! $/
*
!
1
1
3E* = *
*! )I
!1
)0$, )0$$
# ?! * 1!
1
)00, !
1
3E* =
.2 #!1 0+ 0. )00/ E, :
=
+
E
6$:7 9
!% !*
1
1 !
*
! *1 * 3E* = < 1
(
B
! $, 0/ )0$/
1 )$ !1
)0$2
'
;!# >
( )2 $) )0$4 *#
@A! <= )00+
# '
;!# >
9 )0$2
9 )0$4
)0$:
1
1
)00, (
! 1
6)07 9
!% !*
1 ! '
;!# > ' +0 0: )0)0 (F $$$$0 )0$2 E) + " +
E <
9 +/.
)0$:
E9+
>= +
>4 E
1
$: 02 )0$:
! 1
!
6)$7 9
!% !*
1!# !
'
1
( )) $) )0$4
A
@A! <= )00+ ! B
(
6))7 9 !%
1 * $ ,
1!
1* *1 '
?! =
)0$,
11 *
*! )I
1
D*% * )0$$
#
)0$, * !
1 = 1 * )I
!
!
1* '
;!# >
1 !!
1* 6)+7 '
!*
!
!
6),7 ' !
#
)0$, ! !
"
)I
A ! !1 1
5 1 @A! <= )00+
?!
!* *
@A! <= )00+
1
@A! <= )00+
'
;!# >
1!# !
'
;!# > 1 )2 $) )0$4
A @A! <= )00+ " 1
)I
(?!
1
)0$,
)0$,
D*% * )0$$
!
1
#!1 02 02 )00+ !
1
! !
* 3E* = *
= )I
6).7 '
A
* !
@A
5 !
A
!# (
;<=! " >
)00, 8
C!
!
)0$/ *#
6)/7 '
!!
:$ (
;<=! " >
$::4
)00) ! 1 ! 3E* = D
* 1 A #1 * )I
'
1
1
<
)0$/ < @A! <= )00+
* !! '
;!# >
6)27 *1
!* 1! 1 *
, :
$,
!* * 1
1
!*?! 1 * ! (
*#
<
# 1 * 3E* = :$
$::4 *! 1 @A! <= )00+ !
! 1
3E* =
1
*! $/
1 !!
@A! <= )00+
!1
1 1* '
;!# >
6)47 @! ?!
*
!* ?! = ! @!
1
)00, 1
!* D
1 *1
!* 2
1 *
, :
$,
! (
!
9 1 )$ !1
)0$2
'
;!# >
( )2 $) )0$4 6):7 C * !
1
) D* )22 )0)0
4 F 1% J% F * J%