← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13846/2015dismissed

Sat Narain v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-11-05Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Rameshwar Singh Malik6 pages



     

 "# 

# $#% "#&'(#

)*    

 

 

!   

    

# +# ,-./#0*-0#()# 

 "

 (112()#/#)(**

 '

3 %* %*# " 4 ' 3  ( 5* 6%0 7849#(#:(;<#)-1&0/11 ** 3

7%*%*#"47(0/(#=&1*>%#2 ? # 1%*2 ( 1*  ( )# ( = 1 % #> 6% ()#/#1*>%#2 !.18+#1 %*  $112 21 .10 # ")  ( * 1* => %=,>#6%-*(#*()# *(#@-112##*2#>11/((2( #)* 1A#0 =% ( )  ( 2#>  11 /#  )#-**  (>  (#0 2%#B(%>= >)#  11 ( #># /#=*%>=#=1C))#0/((/#1#>%*# #2 %#2#* /#  #&   ( =  %( /#  #&0 #2* 11=# 2#>  ))1& 1 # #*1

1/##* (=%(#2*11=#2#>0 174!!

3*-1)#*11&/%*-%# #)*3%*#(#&-1)>' 2%1 #= # 0 8D    0 (##0 ( )# E%* 1 ** 

39E%# @D<-%#+B )%1*/11* -5* (##0 ( )# 1*  /# ) =#2 F 8D??  !

4 =# ( %# (1122 ( 1 ** * ( 11=#2#>(*/#)/*)*-*#*# **!

4/(*#))C2#*#>)1 (**#0#*#(-=)*

!!

*!

!!

9E%# @8 ' @ <   ( #*# **

!!

0 ( +22 ##0#&"*%#1'##%%#-1)>#)#0

(C%10#&G#)*!(1%**%*# H -/  ( =- * )0  (- >  ( 1% ( ( )# ( (112* ( 6% )#*2(2#%*((/#*=&(=%1*#11 (1**1**E%*=&(>-%#(=%1*#= *((>)%(#&*(1 ** E%* =& ( )#  -%#  ) %1*# *

- 5* * & #1  ( #2#*  = *#* =& ( ()#(*#*11=#2#>/( ( =%1*# * (* ))1* # 1  /-#0 ( )1  ( )##2#*2#-(1=***=&( )#>/'%#& 12()#(%#(# #6%* # 6%(2 ( #1  1* )%#(* =& ( )#- #)*(#1#*#(1#*&=%* 3

7 *(*#6%(2(#1(1*( 2I (*#*#0/(((-=(112*=&()# ()#/#)

?

(1**/E%*=&()#!

3( #/#)(1122(1**/1*(&#! 4# >#(D&#(6%0/((#1**=)#>*  = *)%*   /# ) # ( E)#&  %#& )#*  (112(*%>( (# &# %*# ( 5> 0 83?0 /E>*=&(%#F  3DD !

1*:#$%&'

&( )

*+,-.

#.

*&*,

&-'&/& ) *+,-.;*** 47!

0/(#( ,%*2>#*#*=&#*((%#F  8 83 1*:""2('(#$"#&'(#;***  !!

? *###*=& ()#0 (= E2%(*  ( %#(1*%*# H(112(1**/#)(&#!

 ( 2#%* ( %( *%> # #%*%1 %# #> ( 2#*1&*1(#,%*2>" #* (# - +> +(&0 9!

< ? "%)#> %#  4?30 ;=1 "%)#> %# (1* ( (%2( ( 5> 0 83? *))1&/#,%#*=%(*#1>=2 =*)%=1)1&0()#)1(#*(##))1=1 ( %# 1 %* (   12 ))#( ( %# # >2C/(#12#*=&(%#>1#0 ( >  %#(  )#)# E)1 # *1& * 1( (%#=#-*%*# @ !(-#&#))10(#)*1*/#)   !

 1>2 #1 %*# (  **  878 /   873 /(% %#(2 & E)1 #%(#**1&*1((#)#"? (5> 83?0>C=12#&()# ( %#  *> ( "% # ))1  >* # ( )##=*)#*-(%2((1>%) **(#)1#(%1>- ))112=%>(>&2( #  ( ># 9"  5((> "/C "(% - > %)

"(%' #0  844 #-&%1!4J*.>1(=% -5,) "(#>'#9!

7< !" DD<

?*1&(5> 83?*))1& /# ,%#* /-#0 ( *#  1> =2 =*  )%=1 )1&0 ( )#)1 (#* (# # ))1=1 */#)#*>*1 2 (2#%**1&*1(1C(*022 )#%1# )& 1 >& 2- #   #%##2 %  %(-%1&0()>&=*>* ( 2#%*  *1& * 1( * ( %# >& #%  2##1#(1)#*%E)1** #**1&(0(#)*1>*( #1#>   873=&12)  !

=%( 2( %# # > %E)1* # 2#* ( #1 / 3 8740(%2(-(**3  878 >C))1=1/   873

4(%#(1&#,*(( )(%1*=*#*2#2(*1&*1( ()#))#((%##>2C/ (#12#*=&(%#>1#(>  %#(  )#)# E)1 # *1& * 1(  12/C%)#>*)1%>=#*1>>)% #> ( ,%*2>   /(# > *12 )# (* ))#(*(%#/(#=1>9" +B %) >*'#- *'#0  878"3D4J ".#C' #-"+.#&&' #09 883<3 "!3DJ*2*(51' #-"#&' #0   88D"!?33<I +%(-"+(#(#09! ?< 4" ?

40(;=1"%)#>%#%)(1*(#*#(2(%# *>2(/#)(2#%**1&*1(( %#(1* @ H 7  ( =  & =, # ))  ( )#)*6%(5*6% #/# >C/#*/(((**8@ @ 878/1&# (11#95*6%<*()#*2# C2 -# ( )  ( 1*  6% ( ( 1*/# 1*  -1 %  /(( (& (112* (

/#* >* =& ( 11# /(% #2 & 6% #2#*2 ( -1*&  ( *1# >* %*# " !39!<  ( +    #* /( " 3  ( 5* 6%  ( % #>* )*2 # #1& E &# =# ( > / /(*#/  (112 ( 6%)#*2F# 3D  8831* =# ( 2( %# ( (112 /  (    =##* =& #* *1& * 1( ( 2( %# / %11& ,%*  *12  ## /( ( 6% )#*2(2#%* EEE  EEE !!(-/C=&(%(1- 5-##1(09 8D <4"!7 (=##* =& (# % ( *  *#)%# #( #> "(C# "> 5* - "  ,(0 9 8D < 4 "!83(>#(*(%# +%)1 #)  ## >=& - *%#1 -1)> ->  9 < 5*0 9 883<  "

0

>, %*- *0 88?"%))9!<"!

*5#'%=#5*-"%,#09 887<4" ?7D(>>(#*(#%(#%2(11(*  (  #*#  %*   (112  ( 6% )#*2 ( #* )# >% #> -21 * /(%1**20(#*)#11/ 2#2#/%*#(0(-C()/# ,%*1 #-/ E#=1 %*# #1 !!

3  ( % ( 1%#  ( #* )#  C #*#())#)#2*/(%%*%*1&/%1* %(2-##((&(-/-* (#=,(6%(=>1(( 2(%#12>1&*1-C(#)/# ,%*1 #-/  ## /( ( 6% )#*2 %*##1!!

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

3 #>#(D&##(#>(&#! 4((112 %(1**/#)#121)>=#* #(###**$,& 1;9%)#<6%1&0/* *&>#()#/#)(>*>* 9+

<  

  9   5 < $>1