P.S.Sawhney v. Union Of India & ORS

  

       
































 



   


 


 

!

     
   
  
 


  
!"

#"  

 

 "


  

$%


&"

%
&"


  ' 
#
(
"

% 

)
  (
"
"#"

 
&     
"




"
!"

#"
 

# 
*+,


(

#
"


"
(
 -
$%
" (
-

.
/


  0

"


"
(
 -
$%
"
   




&

/


















  






 !"

 #$ !

% %

& '()*"* (#+  

!&, *-
.
 *
/012
3 04
5  ) )-


6*
&*
7
*-
&

% *
(
(&
& ('
*
7
&
8)8

),
&
&)
&
*
,)9 % *#

&
*
 )
&
'

(
&
7
(  , *
 ':&
)
(
' ,-
'((
&
&%)&  7
(
)8
7
')
; <443.<1=> '=&
)


)
% #
11 (
),
(
)8
7
),)  )&%
&6&
)
? *
@ (
<A !B  
B B$-

,)9
( 6
)* &)&&
' (
*-
*
, *
&


  )8
*
)'

&
&


*
),

)
% ,
7
( )
'(
*


,
*
7),
'

) &
*
, , *

 )&-
),
(&
%&)
( 6
&%)

7 )*
)
(&
6) -

!(&
%&)
 

&
),  ,

(
(
'

) ,
*
, ,
),
(
%6,,
& ' (
*
) -
% 
),
 (
)&& * )7 )9&
'
),,

*#



&)
*
*&

 :
*
,')
(&
) ,)8 88)8
7
*
%()&
' (
& 

 
 :)8
,6&

),
(*
( 6
 ,

(
)&& *
)6& 8 ) '
),,
7
(
% )
)
*-
),
7
*
, (&
)7 )

8)8

86
*

( )&& *
)7 )

*
 :

*
)
* )C
% *
&
(
*
 )
 6
-
),
*
*&




*
)
*


 ,
(
)

:

*
(
 '

:

) 
*
),
&
7
*
7
& % )

*
),
(
)
7
*
7  *#




, *
 )
 :
),
&:
(
7
*
  ,,&& '((

,,)9


(
'(

'

) ,

,
' (

), (
8 6



),


&)8


) 
*
)'# &


' )8
*
(&
 
*
)

) )8 *
),
(*



)8

6* ()8

*#

'
,
*
'

)

D

=

)

%8 
( &

 ,
),
, '

:

*#

E
 :



)'
7
*

 ,*

% *
&
7&

&% 
*
7-
F4-000
&

*
),

&%),
)
(&

%&&
*
'

7&
7

% *
FG-000
),
()

'

&),
%

*
'((

,,
)
6* ,&&&)

( ,
' (
(
%&)
'(
'

) ,
* , ,
),
&
&)
&
*
8
(
!

%-


'

% *
(
 ))8


)
7
F3-000#

7
*


)
 ,*
7
*
( %-
()

'

 *
)
' ( *

&  8( <%# BE

 !
!  
H !H!E ! 
 H

D
!E


 H 

B
 B-
55-
 5   B

D
B
B!

I


B
J!
!
!


5 - H

 !H
 5! E
 



!E
! 
H !



!
!

H 

E






!

!
!  5!#


 !
H 5

!
H
!

45

!

5 

!
!5
!




ED

! 
!


H  
B!
!   
B
B!


! 

H


!
!

! 

E
H! #

E

 


B!


 #K  
"- #
$



"
 


 

2

"

 %
 

#
"
 3 %
"- #
$


 

"

$


"
"
"
(
& 
(
4)5,+ 6 (


(
 

   
  

&"

%6%"(
$
"


 

4)5,+ 6 (



$
 
$

&
-

"
"
(
"

2&
7
-

 
"
( 

&  -
(
"
&$ 
&&& ( 

(

   
"
$

(
"

#
-

.
/


 8 0

"

"
   
&"
"


" $( 
"

- &

9 #( 




  
888
:;

,!,
:! ( ;
0


(

%

"


# 
*+,

" # '$ 
 

( 


+
"-



"
  

"
   




+
(

"

"
"
"   %

"


#
(

"
$ $

"
$ 
"
( 
( 
- $

 #
"

"


"
   


"
3 %
"- #
  % $



$%
"
 




$

"
 %
# '$ 
  "
$
(( 
$%
 %
  
 

"
9 #( 
   

   <
:;
,!,
! (
88
:!;

(%
 
&

$
 $
"
 
 

&" "

"
$

"

"
 3 %

$



$
#  

"
*+,

1
" $


"
3 %


 

 
"
$
( 


#  
 *+,

"
  
" -

$

(


)&-
"

!


"

"

 


 (
"
"
(
"


#
"



$%

"    
"


  '

+


"


%
#
"
 #"

  
(
"


- &

"
-

  

" !

  

+






# %



"
 



 
!"

#"




"



$%

"   




"

"

 

 %
(( "

"
   

&

$


"
   

"
"  




 

"
 
)1

"


+
 %
"
3 

( 
"
 
 
  

&

$
$



#


"
"



$%

"
  
 

"
  



& "
"




+
&

$
  

 
"
   
$ #

  ' 
"

& 




 


 
"
 #"
 "

  '




"
 


= 



 
!  '




#

 
&" "

( 


%

" & 

"

$

"
& 

-%
  ' 
+
&


$ 

"
   
"

 

 %
(( 
"

"




$%
"
&

$
  

"
"
 
  
# 

 "
   
 #


" $( 
"  (  

"
 
& 
"
!5+
"

$
# -






"
"



 
"
"   %

"
"

#


$$ 


"
  


& "

"
( &

 




   

  

 ! 
!!"  



   # 
:

;
,!,
:! ( ;



#

( 







"
!5+



" (

 



   

(

=""
 #>

7 >2
=""
$

7 >2