Krishna Devi v. State Of Haryana & ORS












 




   

 !  "" #  $

""  %& '"

(




 
 
 

   



"
!#
$!%&$
'

(" & 
)&*
+
&$$!( ,
!

-.,/) 1 !
+
#

,
!

"
!
'!

2



-.,/)
"

!.$,
+

,
3'

3/ 

"* +% "

,'!-"

 +%

("

,.,%&  +(
$/ ,'!-"

 "0 +1 ,'!-"

 " 
  4
 )&  )

") "" 

$ 3"

"$  - " "" / ' "

3 44 ))

0 '""

36  /$ 7  /5 5 "$

-

'  ' -  3' '3 4 ) ) 5 "

' 0 '3  43  5 "

4 -" ' " ' 1 4&,"

-"

  "

"*' )"5 '' -' '" 44$) 3 6  #44/ .

44$,

4('$, "-"95$

/ "- 3 /!

7&3& 5$ '"

$/ )

!44/      ) ""   ))4 '   0: '  44  '-$5  3 44   8)  -  - " -"      )   )4-&  '" '

  :,"

36 3 "7  44 '$) 5"

  '

5 !44/  '  / /$) :*00&    ) -" , 3  5   -4

,  ;$4 -" '<56 -  4 "

- -44 '  " ! 3,3 4'

: -$ '=56 "0

 -  "0/" 565 "

"0,

'3 4 -" ' " ' 36 // ! '7&"

 4 -"   "  0,  "

 ) ""   4 '   )) 4  '" '

:

 "

 )$"&
55

,95$ /- /  /$4" '4 "

-""

3 " -$ 

"0 ) )4-&'" '   :  "44&"

)) 43 $75"" '"''" 4 )$"&
55

,95$ /,    "$ '  "

5     

 7& "" /  "

"  "  "

-5) "

"$"

"&  )) 4,"

 ,3 4 '7  "

 )$"&
55

,95$ /,3  $/ "-55 7$""

' )"5 ' 4& '"

5""  ) " 8""

"

 " , "

) 36 3 "  '7&   "* )"5 "    !44/    ! 57 ,  

   

/ ))4 ' ') "7& /44"

 ;$ '

'-$5 7$"/ "3 4 -" ' " '7&"

"*' )"5 "7&/   0 '

> / '7&"

 /$ ""3 5' 3"

$"

443 -"  ) "

)4-& ?  '-$

4 - ! / 8)  - 7$" 56  8)  - 3  /!

 %'

/!

- ,

3$4'

56 "03 4 -" '

""4 ?  '-$

4 $"

- "

,   "    !

 ''  "  ))4&    '-$5

 ! 3   $75"" '3"

 !

5"-$4"

- " -" 3 """- '3"

"3 5)4&5 "44"

3$4'7 )'$- '""

" ! 3?  -$

4  4   - "  "    " ! 3 /  44  "

 -

>

,5 "4 - ) ) '  5 

4 -" '- ''"   "3 '""

' 4 3"

',3 ,"

4 - "&) ' " "

4  '-$

4"

" ,"

 56

/!

""

- 7$"

'

 '"

 4  " ! 33

"03 4 -" ' 

5'  )-6 '-  )4-&7&/! 5 56 " ! 3" 0 ' '7&-

'  4 -" '- ''" ""

" ! 3,3

3   "  !

$))4 '  "  "

 "5   $75

 ))4-" , ,"3 ) - -44&5 "- "

" -5)4 "  5

344 "7 -- )" '7$" "44"

3   $75"" ' $7 ;$ "4&, 3$4'

3"

5 3   $75"" ' " "

" ! 3?  -$

4

 4 '$) ! 1 @$'/5 
$"

3"

&
&'3
&',
!

"
5"


!#
&*&'&
&',
!

"
 >?3$"

A%<0,3   ,"3 4'"

"3") "" "5 " 74 

0 36  '@$'/5  /4 1 ' 7& ! 1  ?  '  -$

4      0  '    $75"  "

 5'    7  -5)"!  5 "  4 -" '

3  5 5 "$ !B**!B) "" ?  '-$

4  "   

 4    '    ) 45 &  7@ -" "  "

 3"

"5 " 74  '3"

$"!4  5 '& )) 4,"

)

") ""

4 ' %  $"

$75"

'!"3

$75"" '7& " ""   3$4'7

$))4 '""

" ! 3?  '-$

4  "

 4 '$) @$'/5 % C74 "

) 8
$"

!#
6&'& &7&
&',
!

"
5"
)

+3
&',
!

"
 < (D<,

!#
& &&"

&
&',
!

"
5"
&)&,&
"

"

 ,
',

"


(
( ( ": ' 
$" 63"

'&
5"


!# &*&'&
&',
!

"
 0

,' -' '

<

''.

6&.
5"


!#
.'-&+
&',
!

"



::< ,' -' '

 

, $))" -

 ?  '-$

4 "*""  $75"

'' & 8)  - - " -" 3"

5 0: ,"

 , 56 3  3' '" 

 '' "/!  &$ ' "6 /4 5"

$75" 8)  - - " -"  $7 ;$ "4& -$ '""4= "0

' "03 ,"

 , 4 -" ' " '

5 " " 56 , ,"

?  '"" -$

4 $"

$75"

5 "4 "3 ) ) ' 3' '  -' 5- ;$4 -" ' 8)  -   4 ' )) 4

  ' 5

'  7$"  '   )

'    )) 4 

"  7

/ ' % '"

/$5 '!

- '7&4  '-$

4

)" ! 4 / $/ !474  4 

3 44 / 4 -'  '5"" '4&, 36 3 44 ' &  "

    

     &    ,  "

 ) ""    3 44 "04 "

- ))4 ' ') & 

,"

3 44 "4 "

))4 ' 36  ) -

,"

 8)  -  !  3' '" 

,56 3  3' '" "0"

4  '-$

4 "

" ! 37 3' '""

 ,

3$4'

4 -" '  " "

/$5 4  '-$

4

"

" "'' '-$5 "4 ))4-" 5 3 '' '4" 

4 " ! 33"

') $ 4 " ! 34 3 6 3$4'

3"

"3 4! ) 

 "&) '4

7'" "

 -   5 4 $57  >"

3""

3"

''$4& '7&5 57  
55""  
, '

",+ 4+ '4 '/55 

-  '$7",

' " 56   '"6

3""

"" 5 "  7&      "  >   "   "  

$75"" ' '-$5 ""

" ! 3 $ ' "6 /3

/!

7& ""

$75

"

7

'5"" ' 3""

"" 5 - ))4 '

  36   - , 5 4&,$

5,(@4 (    !  $75"" '  "

  '-$5  "  "

)"  3  3   '$4&

'  '( "3 $ $"74  '--' /4&

4 -" '"

3""

"" 5  56

 5

 8)  - 3  /!

""

""

7$" "44

$ $"74  "

7

) "

") "" ''  8)  - " -" 3"

5 5 3   ")'$- ' !

" ! 3 $- 56 3  3' '" ""

"5  
  -",  5 ' 
4'   ! 4)5 "   )"5 ", %& #' 4 "" '" '   :

$ '

"$-"

3"

 /'" )) 36  - " 5 '5 3  5'

!'  4 ""   '" '  0 <     "  7  5'  7&  "

5 57  
55"" -

" /  '

",#44/ ? ! 4$7
55""  7  / 
5 ,  44  "

 5  

 7  /  + 57 ,  '

6

+ 45$ 7  /8) ", '

"+ 4 + '4  7  /  + 57   ' 
-4  $) !   7  / 
    

)

 '

$7
55""  $) ! 

& '  7! ,   "

 )

-    "  4 "  "3  "

  5 57     4

& 
5 -5)4 " 3

$5 57   )

"   )   4/74"& -"   $"    ""4   56 ,  8"& 56  3    5"-$4"  85 , - , / "56  '$/ " * *43  " ! 33  "7 /!



-  ) -  '7&6 ) / ! 3"

$57 

&  544&'

"56  56 ' )5&,5''4 )

'  56  4

E    5  "

E    5"-$4"

85    " 

 4   7  5 '    

"$-"

< ))4-"

 344  7   !" '  7& "


5  #44/  ? ! 4  $7
55"" ,3

447 -5)4 "  44 ) -"



-5)4 "  ''-$5  

5-

7  @ -" '   )

"  - ,  "    )) "  "

"   "  * $

5 !'' &- " -" 4

5!

) $ 4 5 "3$4'

3 "

"

'"  7"

 & 8)  - " -" 3 $75"" ' '"  5

 "

3""



'!"3 $75"" '7&  ==

  ,"

"   $75"" '""

" ! 3 ))4-" 55&7  @ -" ' $ ' "6 //!

7& 3&

'!"-4 4&

3 '-$5 3  ""- '3"

))4-" 5 5 3  "7  $75"" '""

" ! 3 '"  " ! 33 :

'!"3 /"""

" '

==

 3 44 " 3' '

056 5"-$4" "

3' '

" ! 33

3' ' $     '

56 7 "3 " ) $ 4  -' '56 3' '" 4 -" '-

3 )) )- '$ 

443 ' !  3' ' ) /$' 4

$ '!'

4 "" '" '    : "

7 "74

5"

 -'

!474  4 "

4 -" '- ''"   "'' "

$75" '-$5 4   ) 

3   $ '5 $4"3"

$7 ;$ "4&"))  "$ 5 57  
55"" 3  '@$ " '  

:

)- 7 "3 4 "$    ))4-" 5 4 3' /56 ' !

-" 

443 ' ) 

"$-"

 --' /4&,"

'

!

"7 443 '

0 '""

3 6  ' " ' -" '"

"  ">

' "

) -"! 5 "

44"

 $75"" '

))4-"

'7&3' /56 )  5 -4$' / 8)   - ''"  ) -"  '/$' 4



)- '$  '-" 

$4'7  443 ' "-"4& --'

- 3"

/$' 4



& 8 - 7 ' 3"

) ' "35

5"

'"   - )" -)& '  +& , 9
  :

)@