High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17152/2013allowed

Som Das And ORS. v. Karnal Cooperative Suggar Mills Ltd. Karnal.

2018-10-17Mr. Justice Darshan Singh15 pages

!" " #"$ %!&"'(") $*"''+ ,&"'-( !" #$ % & "

". ($",/ ) "!(" "&$0,/ ) "!"(

& ' %! 1" "" "( &"'

(") $*"'' + ,&"' "!"2! "( 3 ''4!*!' " .$,

5 * 6 ''$(!783'* ! $' 189" ' *":( & ";-$" '!(:'

3<13

3 8'' %*)

! , ! (" 9! 9" ")* ': 9* 9" (( ;(" !(7:" " 6!.$':,

5/> 3

/ 9 "!!": !"": ""-0' *! !"(("! !$"7: '*9" (559!!9 ( 9! "!!' !(" "((!( & "7 " $"$7" ) "

6 7*"' ,!:*(("! !$"7: '* 6

9!!9 ?9)", "9

$ !"( ''$(!( & "! 7 ":$70!(': "")(('7' /**") 7:!" ",-0' *!(("! ! $(" $",7$! +9 %!:*(("! !$" 7: '*5

5!*"$ !":9 *" 9!' "* ! "( " (( -( = 5

5"!(" ("7'**!-") *":9!"-0' *!

7'* !@"'*": !.$':,

59 : "!((;("" " 6!.$':,

59( )$" !("(",!$"9!'$*

" ! (7",

5*" " : " " ! ! ) ( & "7 '' $(''!> !"* /"$' !:" ",!" " 6!.$':,

/> 3 9 *)

! ((;("9"9!!' 7:!"( 3'' "!:" "%!9"(9 =! A7"$":,

!' *!9"(,!$" $7 ! $' " ! (" ! ! ("9 "@"'*": 9" """) *":,7$!"9)"!"*" ! 9"(%!$"'7") !! ' !"'"

9"( ' 7:-0' *!! ':7 " ! $("$"%!$((, :,9$' !)7 8(*)9!"")(':%!$"!' ! !("!77'!9!!:7'*

"") *":,!(( !(")"( ! ("("9$' '' ":"

"?9)", '7":9*" !("!"9!9" """) *": ' "!(!''**!(( :

0$" '"':$ $!9"(9 ' = ! ! ' ! " 9" (,! "" " "$'*"))' !" "

((;(" 6!.$':,

5/>3B!98 !'* * ',!"( 3''$ " " 6! A7"$":,

/> 3 ((* ! (" ("! ( & ";-$" '%!"

")9"(' ("7 "(" :"9!!$'

7> 7:!($!":%!:9" " ) " " 6!A7"$":,

/>3=%!:' '":

!"7 "! ("!!"'9 " ,!:") '*' *'": !" C$' 7 "6! .$':,

5 '' ! $'

0* !A7"$":,

9!!99!!' $!" " " !.$':,

5( 7:!$"

%!' !("!7 ' ) "(': !.$':,

/>36!'*',!*"$ !!(" 9"8 "!(" !:" ' '": 6 /**") ,!("!)(("! !$" *! '* !"'!*"$ !!:9" (") '":($"$!"" " "* ) ( & "7 '' ''> !"*%!

:" "$ '' ' !9"(%!" ",!:

9" $' $' 7 '":!:9"9''* 0 $:,7$!:9"''9 7:!"( 3'' ('9!!"" "%!:$"*!!"" " !"* 9!! '" " !73>%! 9$' ' !"))' !" " !:9$' !)7($ 78!( !"" "9"( %!$, 9!! " 9"(9 '': ,!" " "*)

"!")*(" !"'78! $ !" " "*)*

"6!.$':,

5 %!C$9!! '' " " !$" 9!"!C$ !:" "9!! $'': ) 9! ! ' ! 9" ( ",9!$!"7*:('" "( 7:!$" 9!7 !(" ! ":

B!)!" '" $' "!(" !) *!"$*!!(("3789!!" 5 B9"!C$( "":7! ( (" "*$ !

!:" ""**9!

! ' !!"*! !9!$' 0:

!7 *" 7:!(':"!''$!' B !

55 ,! $("$"7") $ "

2BC$'':9''' !" " :

*" ( * (' 9"(;$"

!" (" *, 9! ! ' !$7)(" * !

! $: !$"$!($! ("!(!:9$' !)7 7$ "!"" " !$"4 B

/B-

,! $("$"7") $ "

B !" # $

% &

!# $!"

= ,!

$("$">( !'9! ''9*" 2! $ ! (":, ("$ *!$"(" ",9!!! !' $7',!"$' (":** )*9!!9$' !) !"9" ,"!!"(":!$

" ()"!9!!9$' !)$

" 7$ "!" " !$" ! $!

(":,!!$ $'(": '':!' ' "' ,7'" :! !'*,' 7( !"9!!!("9$' !) 7 !"" " !$"9$' !)7( %!$ $'(": ! ')": 7 " 7:!(( (":$ "!"" " !$","7 8"$ "9!!'4 B "

$ !( % !

/B-

6 6,! $("$"!' $ "

2'( )

# !

% * #

# 4 %! "

$ $(" ! 7

''9 $7" $!" $ " ' ) * & $

/B-

'+$ ,$ %

= - . $ "

' /

- 0 " $,

) * /B-

= = B )9 ! '*' ( >(' 7: !" '" !( ! $("$",!("" " * 9( $7:)"$ !:" "%!:" " ")" !'*'(""*!* "!("" ""':

7$! ") 9: 9! "

''$( )(''!> !"*9!!" "9 ''9 $''! ' (' !9"(/''! 9$' !!("" "$' 7*)

$"*!(" *D($' (" *7: '

!:" "7$ %! '

!$"9!!!("9""( 7((' "!"(" ($""() ! ! ""*! '7':!)7'( 7:!:" " '7(""': %!$,!(" !)7 '* ! (9!!!"9$' !)! !:" "7( %!$70':"": "! '" "9!'!" B!("!'" $' "!("

"($" !!("(' 2"8,:4 7((' !! !("" "

): !("7$9!!$' 7*)

7$ !": "*!'' '' (%! ("!)9!!' !"'7$" !:9" (")

!"**!" $':$ !:" "7 7:

-0' *!9!9"$'':%!" "(" ! ':9*("& "!79! "9, " ")" 7:!($!":!"( 3 '' 9! $"'': ''9

9 7 <''":!(9$' '9,$' (" $!"* !"*$9"!9*! *' B!"$ !,!"'"$' 2"8, :4 9$' 7 (('7' / (" 9$' 7 ' "" ''!7 9!!!98(9:$0$':

7$0$9! -0' *!,9!! 7 !:" "%!("('9)') 7:! $(" $" )/ 55/B-

, !$*!( ('":(" *,7$!("(' '*:9$' ((':!(" !"7"!

")'9%!"*!'":9!"(':,'!$*!99''* 9"8,7$98(9: "9"8 " $' !9$'

$"%!9!"!("" 9: " !9"89''*': '': "!"9 $' "$0, '" $' (("* " ! "( 3''"*$!!! !''9" ! (( $' 7 ': " ! (' ! 9"

(%!"*$7 $' ?$7!9!! 7 9*" 7:!"( 3''9!! '

-0' *!E,!(") "(" 6! A7"$":,

/>-3 !"("9( "*$'"((& ";-$" '$'

7 ':5!A7"$":,

/>-3 %!,!:, ! $" "! ((;(" ! ("

("7 9 :" 9 (""7 9!! ! (" $ $'': (' ': 6! A7"$":,

B ! "$,!("''":!(:' ("" ! $' 0* & ";-$" ' $"*!("

,!("9"8 ':9* 7 "9!!!:9"( %!"("7(" 9>

":"9 6!A7"$":,

) " "/>-3# " " 6!A7"$":,

/>-3=,!("F9"8 $9" $ ": !"("7(" 9 ''9 7(' %!("( !"0* 6!A7"$":,

!:!)9"8 ! (("" 6! A7"$":,

%!: )0 (""! %!" ",!:!$' 7(( "'*'": "! (" "78 !:!)"*!''": "! (" '' $"!","*$ !!($

" " ':

'! '!*"$ (('%!("9" ''9 0 "! ' ! " 9"( =! A7"$":,

9!'!("(!7 ' 6!

/$*$,

" '( ;

:" !"

((;(" '": 7 ' ! 7'

*!:!)( !"0*6!A7"$":,

9!$(" !)7( !"'": ''9!: "' $(0* !" "%!:"(( 7:!"

9 $ "'*:!*" "!(" (""0* 6 B!) " ! "$0,7$

$7: !B99!!"' ! (" $$ !"" "''"* 9!

! ' %!"((;("" "9: $ ("%!:" "9 ''$( ( %!! 79!9$%!( !(" *97: !"'$!' !"( 3 '''!:$' !*>(9 "!$

!9"(%!" " 5!A7"$":,

/>-3 9( 7:!**""((*!(" '!"(':& ";-$" '%! " (':9" " ("

"!" $:'" :

* ! "!

+" $' "! "( 3''"$(("!"**)!"(': !'*''*' 0$ %!"*)!"(': !$' "!("!!'"' (( '": !" C$' 7 %! ("9"' ':9*9"8"9!9"8 ': 9*7,9!! $*""(9(' ,! !("8!"'": ':9*(" 9" "' " ! 07 %! "( 3'' ! ! ("9"(" ;(( & "6! .$':,

5 9 :!" " !.$':,

5,!:" "9 ( %!" "$' 7*)

': "! ('

!9"( %: ,!"(':!'*' " "

'!9>( ")! 0$! $7 !> ("" " "$0,'" $' "': $"* !"* ! ! " "

((;("9$ !("(" ! "! !" " 6!.$':,

5B 9 $ ,!9$' 7$ !!("9" ' (( ;(" 9 6! .$':,

5 B ! "$,9$' 7!*!':C$7' $0$ :! !"*! '9* "6!.$':,

5'' !A7"$":,

B $: !$"($!("78 ""!!" (%!("F((

!"7"

"!((;(""!":" ""*!

"!" B!)'*!"$*!!90$ *"' $( 7:"$0 %+ % / )

5 =

&$ ,

6 (" 5 %! %+

$("" '*!" *$!7'%!((''!"9" ")9! !!9''*:789*? ( $!"9!$789*7:!0*"(" %! $("$"!' !7:!9 $,!((''! ( !"" !" " "9!$78

9*D "!"$,$7C$ ($" 7:! "*" *789*9!' 7'%!!"" " ( 7:! $("$" !'(!"( 3'' %!"9"" "( 7:!$" '9!

B &$ &,!"9""" "

0$*!((''31" "")"* $!1' &$' ( *!9.$"<*"!") !1" %! >( (" "!( .$"<*"9/ <*"?9' 7(" /<*" 5 5,7$$!("9" $ !':!*"$ ! ! ! 8 ! ("' > ? '" ! ("'>$ $'':55 %!" ",!! 7 $$': $7* "(" ! 1" "

("/<*"B55 $!1'9 (( /<*"("":7 ! ((9 $70!"*! 9!:

7(( !"*$'"$"%!1" ,!9)",")"

$!1'" !:("&$' ( *!!:!$'

!)!( /<*"B55=, $!1' ' $9!!!8 "0$""*!1" " ")"*!!( .$"<*"&$' ( *!9(":

!$/"0$9*" !$ )$"

$!1'%!$(! !"" "9!!(

/<*"9!!!$' !)7*)&$' ( *!

9$( 7:! $!1'B''!(" * ' 7:

$!1',!1" ! ':8! !! (*9!! $!1'9(""':(( 9

"") " ! $' 9!!&$' ( *!9

$!1'F$9$'':

1$7:!, !9 " !( .$"<*"B9!&$' (

*! ' 9"!?*!$"%!$" ( !9" (7: "*!1" ! ($" 7:&$' (

*! "%!1" ( " "

("* &$' ( *!9 =

55 7*! 9!&$' ( *!! ( ! ("'> ! 7'*7'%! 9"(9 ' 7:&$' ( *!

7 "!?*!$"'*'("9

55 ' "(: ''789* C$'7 *!"9!" G "! "9!!789* 9" $$'$'(:%!9"(9''9 &$' ( *!9!' ' ("9

55 9!! 7'*7' "("%!1" 7 "!?*!

$"!&$' ( *!9' '("" 789* ":(" (""

!$7" (! 7" $ 7:9: !"$'%!$7 9 $ 7$(7'%!" $ !("': ("!(9!!&$' ( *!9' 7 (( !)*"*" ! !9 ( ! $!1'9$*!' !(%! $(" $"!' !!?*!$"""':"0 !C$

" $ (!"$ !%!?*!$" " !" $("$"":( "&$' ( *!

$!1'! 7$*") "'*("

(" !''""" '":!$' 7( &$' (

*!*!"9!5G"9!9! ! ! " "%! 987:!1" 7 "! $(" $"!(('9' 7:! $("$"': !C$ """ (:B!78*"$ ,! $("$" !' ''9 2 / " ! C$ """ (: " ,>( "!(" $"*9!!!" 9 "" " 0$ ("*

$!1'F$""*!(('' " ")"* $! 1', 9 " "

" 9! ! ! ?*! $" %!" ",!"( 9''7' """ (:9!

55 $(!

"" "!$9!!5 55= * "

9! $!1'F$ 9 $('=

"9!! ':!"( !7( !9* ! (: ' (('7' / <*"4

%$,9"*$ !!(" :! 7 >'$ " ! " " &$' ( *! " %!?*!$"! " " $("$"":

( $!1'! 7$*") "'* (" (" !''""" '":!$' 7( &$' ( *!*!"9!5G"("$%! $(" $" $ *"$ "

"9!! !?*!

$"B!9!9) 9 $(': (:*9

" ! 07 ! ( " ! %!" ",! *$!7'

B)9 ! "** $,!' ! (""!' 7)' 0$ %!(" :" "

9"8! )* !(" " $'

!"%!:!))" "9!!' !"** $$ " !("" "%!(";((" " ")7 *)

'" ("

/"$' ! "** $,!( ''9 %!"*!($* "(': ! .$':,

/>36C$! '!C$'" "*) !" !("%!(""!' ' (: ''9 "!(" 26

4%!"""

" ':9*'" :( ! !(:!(: ' !("'( "! " (" 7'$' ( !("9!!"! "!

"( " (: !" "B"("('$

: $(" :" "

= .$ *9"") ! 7",

("$ : !7"

& (

) & $2 &0