← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3717/2018disposed of

Chander Bhan v. Bank Of Baroda And ANR

2020-07-31Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj4 pages

  

      

    

 

 

    



       

     



 

 

 

 

 

 

 





    

  



    !"!"#$#%%&!'#(!)$*)+%+,%)$!$-( ,.#(,)* ,#+!$-!$#/)0, '+!1!$#&+,0!"!)$*+)1 ()#$,#+&3.#(,4 ,+,!$$)(!',4#"!""5,. )$6

,#+$,.  ')5$",&  *)+  ( ,  +,"%)$.,$("  #0,  $)(  )%%)",.  ( , %+#3,++,"5&(#$(&3( ,.#(,)* ,#+!$-!$( ,1#!$'#",!"%+,%)$,.()().#3

%%&!'#(!)$"(#$.".!"%)",.)**

 ,  %,(!(!)$,+  #"  %+,*,++,.  ( !"  '+!1!$#&  +,0!"!)$  %,(!(!)$ ' #&&,$-!$-( ,%%,&&#(, )5+(85.-1,$(.#(,.2 6%#"",./3( , &,#+$,...& ,""!)$"5.-,#9!&:#4 ,+,/3( ,85.-1,$()*')$0!'(!)$ ;)+.,+)*",$(,$',.#(,.< =%#"",./3( ,5/!0!"!)$#&5.!'!#& #-!"(+#(,/) #+!$'#",'+!1!$#&')1%&#!$() =<)*  5$.,+

 ,'(!)$6,-)(!#/&,$"(+51,$("'(664#"5% ,&.  ,*#'("&,#.!$-()( ,+,0!"!)$%,(!(!)$#+,$)(!',./,&)4

')1%&#!$(4#"*!&,./3 )1%&#!$#$(#$:)*#+).#( +)5- !("  +#$'  #$#-,+  #$.  +!$'!%#&  **!',+  )$  ( ,  #&&,-#(!)$"  ( #(  )$ 2 = 6#&)#$)* "

&#: "4#""#$'(!)$,.!$*#0)5+)*( ,#''5",.#"

!1!(#$.!$)+.,+().!"' #+-, !"&!#/!&!(3()4#+."( ,')1%&#!$#$( #$:( ,#''5",.!""5,.#' ,>5,/,#+!$-) ?7.#(,.?

  @.+#4$  #(  $.!#$  0,+",#"  #$:  /) #+  +#$' A  *)+  #  "51  )*

"

?B  !$  !(C"  *#0)5+    ,  "#!.  ' ,>5,  4#"  %+,",$(,.  *)+ ,$'#" 1,$(/5(( ,"#1,.!" )$)+,.*)+4#$()*"5**!'!,$(*5$."#$.4#" +,(5+$,.4!( 1,1).#(,.7    ,')1%&#!$#$(",+0,.#"(#(5()+3 &,-#&$)(!',.#(,.  5%)$( ,#''5",.#":!$- !1()%#3( , #1)5$(/5(( ,#''5",.*#!&,.()#. ,+,()( ,"#!..,1#$.  ,+,*)+,( , %+,",$(')1%&#!$(5$.,+,'(!)$6,-)(!#/&,$"(+51,$("'(664#" *!&,.

*(,+,D#1!$!$-( ,%+,"511)$!$-,0!.,$',( ,(+!#& )5+( 0!.,!(")+.,+.#(,.  "511)$,.( ,#''5",.()*#',(+!#&*)+ ')11!""!)$  )*  #$  )**,$',  %5$!" #/&,  5$.,+  ,'(!)$  6  ,-)(!#/&, $"(+51,$("'(66

)%+)0,!("'#",( ,%+)",'5(!)$,D#1!$,.4!($,""," E

#:,"  51#+ )3#&+ #$#-,+#$. E

5$-#+!#+ #$#-,+#$.

#&")  (,$.,+,.  .)'51,$("  D !/!("    ()    !$  "5%%)+(  )*  ( ,  '#",  ,+,#*(,+"(#(,1,$()*#''5",.4#"+,')+.,.5$.,+,'(!)$ + 

4 ,+,!$#&&( ,!$'+!1!$#(!$-1#(,+!#&4#"%5(() !14 )!$+,"%)$", %&,#.,.  !$$)',$',  )4,0,+  $)  ,0!.,$',  4#"  &,.  /3  #''5",.  !$  !"

 .,*,$',

 ,(+!#& )5+(#*(,+,D#1!$!$-( ,,0!.,$',)$+,')+.*)5$. ( ,#''5",.-5!&(3*)+( ,)**,$',%5$!" #/&,5$.,+,'(!)$6,-)(!#/&, $"(+51,$(" '(  66  #$.  #'')+.!$-&3  ')$0!'(,.  !1  #$.  !1%)",.  # ",$(,$',)*3,#+"

 #&)$-4!( *!$,)* "

B#$.!$.,*#5&(() *5+( ,+5$.,+-)+!-)+)5"!1%+!")$1,$(*)+?1)$( "

--+!,0,.#-#!$"(( ,85.-,1,$(.#(,.< =%#"",./3 ( ,(+!#& )5+(#$#%%,#&4#"'#++!,./3( ,')$0!'(/,*)+,( ,..&

,""!)$"5.-,#9!&:#4 )#**!+1,.( ,(+!#& )5+(0,+.!'(#$..!"1!"",.

( ,#%%,#&)$2 6

,$',( ,%+,",$(+,0!"!)$%,(!(!)$

,#+$,.')5$",&*)+( ,%,(!(!)$,+"5/1!("( #( ,.),"$)( %+,"" !"' #&&,$-,()( ,')$0!'(!)$%#+(!$( ,!1%5-$,.85.-,1,$(#$. ')$*!$," !"%+#3,+4!( +,-#+.()1).!*!'#(!)$!$( ,",$(,$',%#+()$&3 , "5/1!("( #(( ,%,(!(!)$,+ #"5$.,+-)$,1)+,( #$3,#+#$.=1)$( ")5( )*( ,()(#&",$(,$',)*3,#+"#$.!"%+,",$(&3)$%#+)&,5%()

,#+$,.')5$",&"5/1!("( #(:,,%!$-!$'5"().3%,+!).5$.,+-)$,/3( , %,(!(!)$,+( ,",$(,$',#4#+.,.()( ,%,(!(!)$,+1#3:!$.&3/,+,.5',.() ( ,)$,#&+,#.35$.,+-)$,/3 !1

$( ,)( ,+ #$.&,#+$,.')5$",&#%%,#+!$-*)++,"%)$.,$( ) ')1%&#!$#$( #")%%)",.( ,%+#3,+#$.')$(,$.,.( #(( ,",$(,$', #4#+.,./3( ,(+!#& )5+(!"%+)%)+(!)$#(,()( ,-5!&()*( ,')$0!'( , "5/1!("( #(( ,+,!"$)1!(!-#(!$-'!+'51"(#$',"()+,.5',( ,",$(,$',

'')+.!$-() !1( ,#%%,&&#(, )5+( #"#&")1#!$(#!$,.( ,",$(,$',#$.

( ,+,*)+,$)!$(,+*,+,$',!"4#++#$(,.!$( ,+,0!"!)$#&85+!".!'(!)$ 

= ,#+$,.')5$",&*)+( ,(#(, #"!$0!(,.( ,#((,$(!)$)*( ,

)5+(()( ,'5"().3',+(!*!'#(,()')$(,$.( #()( ,+'#","#+,#&")%,$.!$- #-#!$"(( ,5$.,+%,(!(!)$,+5$.,+,'(!)$6,-)(!#/&,$"(+51,$("'( 66

*(,+ ,#+!$-&,#+$,.')5$",&*)+( ,%#+(!,"( !" )5+(*!$."

( #(,$.")*85"(!',4)5&./,,>5#&&31,(!*( ,",$(,$',#4#+.,.()( , ')$0!'(!"+,.5',.()( ,%,+!).#&+,#.35$.,+-)$,/3 !1 "%,+'5"().3 ',+(!*!'#(,( ,%,(!(!)$,+ #"",+0,.#%,+!).)*3,#+=1)$( "#$. .#3"

,"5&(#$(&3  ( ,  85.-1,$(  )*  ')$0!'(!)$  .#(,.  < = %#"",./3( ,5/!0!"!)$#&5.!'!#&#-!"(+#(,/) #+!$'#",'+!1!$#& ')1%&#!$() =<)*  ')$0!'(!$-( ,%,(!(!)$,+5$.,+,'(!)$6 ,-)(!#/&,$"(+51,$("'(66#$.5% ,&./3( ,%%,&&#(, )5+(!$

+!1!$#& %%,#&  ) =22  )*  =  =  0!.,  )+.,+  .#(,.  2 6  !"

#**!+1,.

)4,0,+( ,",$(,$',#4#+.,./3( ,(+!#& )5+(!"1).!*!,.() ( ,%,+!).#&+,#.35$.,+-)$,/3( ,%,(!(!)$,+ )4,0,+( ,*!$,%#+( !1%)",.)$( ,%,(!(!)$,+" #&&+,1#!$!$(#'(*#!&!$-4 !'  , #"() 5$.,+-)( ,.,*#5&(",$(,$',

 ,%,(!(!)$,+!""(#(,.()/,)$%#+)&,(!&& ,/,",( #(&!/,+(3!* !"'5"().3!"$)(+,>5!+,.!$')$$,'(!)$4!( #$3)( ,+'#",

,0!"!)$%,(!(!)$!".!"%)",.)** 5&3

   5&#(!

 ! E ,( ,+ ,%)+(#/&,  ,"B) E ,( ,+%,#:!$-B ,#")$,.

 ,"B)