← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/12995/2016allowed

Namrata Pandit v. Union Of India And ORS

2017-04-07Mr. Justice Darshan Singh13 pages

   

 

          

      



 ! "# 

  !

 " #   $% " #&'(!)  #$%&'()  *

 +  ,+-   ,,   ,-

/   ,  . ,

0

+,!-1

!-1

/ ,, (!)

    , "

 ,-



 " "

/

 + " ,-"2

34!-1

/

. 5- 6 4#/ % "77  . "7  .

 "

 ./ , 8/  

 %,-"7!,-"  %,-"7"/ ,

.

/

9 ,, 

 ## ,,."   ,,- ,



:,,    $-

 &     #+- (!)"   , +   

+,!-1

, ./   ,-



;

/ .  ,   / 

  ,+- 

< &   . "7"   - . +  "2

3& .   + = ."

/  +"7 /

+- 

(!)  ,7>5?> ? ;

*

 #& -) ,-

-

,7>5?> ? ;

       / , /  ,#*  +.

 ,/  , / / ,-

"+  / // /"   = ."/ #

,   *      

   

 0    1   



0    

*  (!)

  ,0

+,!-1

/  ++, .# #      / , ,#  

-*    ,  = ./  2

3    /  /

  . "7 +"71 / ./,,

/   ,   = . 2 "   , +,  #- 

/  / .     , "   ,  +  = ., "+, +-   ,>@ ?! ,= 0 ,0 # ,!#  >6@ - 

?     "   >

@ =<? >

  A  6)

"B?

. 

  -+, 

* + , -             * .

 6)  "  



@=<

+  

#       "+ #+ .

8 / 

 .

<+

, +,,  @ /    ,>@ ? 7 (   #+ ,     00! ";

 6) "*  .

 # .  ! , 6) "*

9 ,, 0.-A B/ #  

A  + , - , B/  ++, C# # 6@ , . #    , , 1  ,  " , . ,,

"  , -* ! ,  #   # 0.-A B, # +- #

;

2 "  .+-(!)     .

,-,,  ;

   6) ", ./   .  6@ -

 5 &  " .

+  ,,  6) "   00! ;

 , 6) ""  ,-

/ ,,  ,-+ +, / / ,, =  ."/ # , 

(  @ ,= /  +  / /  ,-/    9 +   , #  ,, /  "  + 

  

,, + D,   . @

" / 

+,   ,

,<>?"  +   ,,/ 

+

 +$ -A , B, .

  + " @   , 

, +, 

 /  ,  =  <>?

 +,/ = ,= / 

. -

.

0, > ? +=,>? ,"/ /

 ,-  /          9

+    , # ,, /  "  + 

   

,, + D,   .  @ - 

"   /   

+,     ,

,<>?

 

  ",, /  ,  +$ -  , , .

  +

" @   , 

, +, 

 /  , B E

,<>?>? +  +- /,/

      #          7  )+-"    /

+   ,   

 # . .

,,/

= A>? 

  ",,/

 ,  +$ - ,

, .

  +

"       @         ,  

, +, 

 /  ,

  , "    , . + , -   

. 

 #  , +#  0 ,

0 # ,!#  >

? ";

" 0 ,0 # , !#  >

? ";



,,+

, +,"

#    .



 / 

#

, B ;  # / , # , ." 

 

     ,    @ - 

        .

  

/  / .    .

,.,,-+  # +D

   # !

 ", 

,  $% ", 

,    '(!)  * D ,, 

   

 , ,-

,=  6)

"  "  

  = .  / 

     ,-       

/ 

,  

 = .!

 ,-  , +  

  ,- 

"  . = " 

        ,      !- 1

D +- , ,-

"  , @

0.-F(9+   / ,

/ ,# #  .  ,#

+ - " "  ,5G  ,-

,-, / +-  0.- F(9 .

 

 

1    ,,   0.-  F 9 /  ,  /     +-     0 , C#   /    % -"  ;E5               

  7 -0 ,0

  *  , 

, + , - ,5> ?

;

+  -

 /  @ -,  0.-F 9  ;

" ,-

/,+<G

,-, / +- "+ 0.-F(9"  ,-

/,+5G" "  ,  +   , #

6) "  .,-.  ,

 , ,-

 +    ,-H

 ,   

#/ .,-

 -   ,-

 0

D ,-" ,-

,+ +    , $-

   .

/ 6 4#   *  ,-       .

      <  ,"  5  >

@  =?





, . +, ,-

+  = .*1 .  " /,++  / .0.  F 9 F(9! , 6)

"/  ,,/

= A0.-  A B=       + , -      ,     ++,    C#   #  6@ , /,+   , , 1  ,  " , . ,,

"  ,  - 0.-(=  + , -

        ++,      ..#  +- C# #    +  @   ,/1 #  "

+$     @  /      

     , 8  ,   + , - /,+@ , B <   / ,  -,, 0.-F 9( ,   0.-F(9/, ,  

,  +-   ,,, /,,  ++,..#+- .# #  ,- # 0.-F 9/

.#   #

 ;

&  ,  . 0.  F 9 F(9 /, D "

  /,,, ,- 0.-F 9/ 1  00!  ;

*  +      

/ 

  - ,-

,7>5?> ?

 ;

"

   / ,   #-   ,7"       - ,-

 #  +   -     -   ,- 

   = .  =  ./ 

 ,-  +  . .

/    - / /  :



+      ,=  0 ,0 # ,!#  >6@ -

? ";<;   +- 0 ,0 # ,!#  >6@ -

?   "

*  + @-  

9  ,<>?  , # ./  6@ -

+.# +- ,  

  + .  @ 

, 

, +, 

 /  6) " ,  , . + , - 

#  6)

""+#+- ;

*  ,,/ 

 ;



,,+

, +, #  -  .



   /      #

      ,   *   D   .

- 

 -+/ / ,,    ;

 ;<;'. #   D   ,- / 

-  -

;

/

 /  6)

"  .

  7 0.-F 9! , 6) "  ,

+     @

  , 

-! ,, /     

  -+,   + , -      "/ #+

.  # .  *  

 0. 

F09F69

, +,

*     

/ 

0.-F(9 / ,  /  (!)

   ,, 0.-F 9 

 .   ,, 0.-F(9 /,, 0.-F 9 ,  5

,  =    

 ,  #         

 ,   / / /  9 +   

, # ,,    

         !

 

,,      +   D,         .    @

" / 

+,   6) "

    +"       /    ,           .

   @

#       +,

 

     ,-     9  + "  +       , #    ,, 

   /

, . = "   , .

,0

+,!- 1

  * D 

/  

  , # ,,    

                  

   " 

  / ,,    + D,  @

2 

   / F  + 9 F

 9 ,/  , 



.  +  ,,

 -  +1.  $ 2  ,-  

 ,-,-  ,



"/ # ,,*

 +  ,"

- , 

 .,+ $  , ,,

 ,, / .

= =,/    ,,- @ 6#

- , @  -

1 

- 

*

,  ,/ 

    + $ "#

 . 

 # , /  

 /  +-  /    /,  ,-  "+  ,-

$   + , ,+ ,,"

 ,- 2

3"+  .  ,, !-1



 ,, 1$  -@

E = . (!)

,   , / /@

 

# /  

,  /,,    ,,=  .#.

  

 ./ / "/   #, +,     -"

/#"@



,/  = .1 ,       ,        ,-  /      ,     +-     , .#  ,- + *

+

    @ ,    

,

-

  ,/   ,-

@

,

     ,* , +   



   * ,//    - ,.,

 ,

 - , /  . /  +   +-  @  * , -- / /+= 

  -

, + . .=    *

  .

   .  , #=  , 

  * .

   



.,,-/  , 

;

,    ,  +-   $  % "  

 .    



    "7>?!0*

; 

,*

/  +-  # ( ,

2 .

0 / ,= / +  

  , .

-* , 2 .

0

       -    ,-/ ,

,#  /  /    ++,    # "      "  ,  

    ,@ - ,-

"+ ,-  - ,-

*       

 @=<  6@ -

  .,-"    ,  

 !

    # ( $. 

0

 

    >0:

;<   <-"?/ 

 #,#, $-

/ , ,,#/  ,  + , -

$-/,+ #+  + , - # :

 ,- ,,# 

,,#"+  

/, #+1 -" 0 ,* 

     ,



 #,#

,  $. ,  +- $%

+-!

., (

0   

    "<>?

!0*<</ ,    ,- / , , /  <= >?>? 0 ,0 # ,!#  >6@ -

? "

;;E   ,   1/ ,

 $ , .# , . ,,#/ ,

/ , + ++,..#+-.#

#  *   ,               @=.   ,  

  @

 , ,-

/ ,+



+,* , !

.,%. , / , ..

# ,  + . "      + +- @ +   # /  

+   /  ,- . F

D -9    -  # /"     @ - 

 ,   

 ,

#

, ;

. , !

 ,,// ,,

# ,# #=  . ,,/* ,1 .  -  ;

+ /  +1    @ - 

 ,   ,  =  .     / /  /   9 +    , # ,,  



/,+  , +  @



 ,, *

" /#"     / /      ,= / 

 , # ,,  # . ,&

,

" 

+@

   D - #    /,  ,     ,-+  / 

  , # ,,  # ,,. , / "+

   +   , !-1

/-    .,-"

,,/   .

 <  ,"5>

@=?     

 

=    # -  ,

  

,=  6) ". @

2/#"  / #  -  +     ,     / ,,  +     ,, .  -#    "+ #  / ,, + / /

  ,- , +- 

"# .

- # ,  ,

       (!)           /  , .   .

   

   #       #   

         

   # ,,. .

#          .

+  , # ,,.      /         H  + H     H

 H    ,  = . + = =,/    ,-  /- 1 .  , #



    , 

 

# , .

 

#    ,   -  =  6) ""    ,=1 .  -  ,, . -

1 

-  ,/ +-

 

  ,.-+  / ,

,    +-

 D -

."



. +

 ,, #  #  , 



"/ ,       /       A ,, B

     ,=  <  .,-"

,/  

#       ,- /  , *     -  

 



  /  ,// 





*     -

  , .



$.  %#) ,+ , 

.