R.S. Labour v. Food Corporation Of India And ORS
!
"
#$
!
"
#$
!
"
#$
!
"
#$
!
$
!
$
!
$
!
$
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(
/-0-0*/( /(+'+ 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+
/+,*1/*-+ "!3 "!3 "!3 "!3
" 5
" 5
" 5
" 5
$$$$
"
"
"
"
(/+/*-!
(/+/*-!
(/+/*-!
(/+/*-!
"( &0* '--$ 16.%-/(-2/,/-0-0*/(7+8 "( '(0$ 16.%-/((/+,*1/*-+ - "+ "//*%9+20:%;$ ++0+-%*- 16.%-//*/(%;$ '*<%& "(
//,%*+2'%0*$ 16.%-/((/+,*1/*- = "(
2, 0*>2$ 16.%-/((/+,*1/*- @A@A@A @A@A@A @A@A@A @A@A@A
$
$
$
$ 20+(1/(+2%;;10+,+/060;(0- /-0-0* + 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* *10% %*1 -2/(+8 *10% %*1 -2/(+8 *10% %*1 -2/(+8 *10% %*1 -2/(+8$ ? 7
%&'( ) (%*+,(- 7
%&'( ) (%*+,(- 7
%&'( ) (%*+,(- 7
%&'( ) (%*+,(- *-(%.-( 6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-( 6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-( 6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-( 6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8$ 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* 7
%&'()(%*+,(-*-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0* *10%%*1-2/(+8 *10%%*1-2/(+8 *10%%*1-2/(+8 *10%%*1-2/(+8 %*1= 7
%&'( )(%*+,(- 7
%&'( )(%*+,(- 7
%&'( )(%*+,(- 7
%&'( )(%*+,(- *-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8 *-(%.-(6 1(,(%-0**10%%*1-2/(+8
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
-/10*60/C%*(1/(1%-/1 ,%++/1 &: -2/ (,(%-0* 0* -/(B+ C20.2 -2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B2%1&//*1/&%((/1(B,%(-0.0,%-0*>0*%*:'-'(/ -/*1/(,(./++(%,/(0106/:/%(+ 0*./-2/(1/( &;%.9;0+-0*> 1%-/1 2%1 &//* 0B,'>*/1 &: -2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B 0* % +/,%(%-/ ,(.
#$%..(10*>;:$C20;/0++'0*>*-0./B-0*0* -2/,(/+/*-&'*.2,/-0-0*+$-2/+%B/C/(/10(/.-/1-&/ ;0+-/1%;*>C0-2060;(0- /-0-0* # 060; (0- /-0-0* # .%B/ - &/ 10+,+/1601/<'1>B/*-%*1(1/(1%-/1 &:+/--0*> %+01/ -2/ (1/( 1%-/1 %*1 >(%*-0*> ;0&/(-: - -2/ (,(%-0*-,%++%(/+2(1/(C0-20*%,/(01-CC//9+ %-/(%(10*>-2/,/-0-0*/(30(B%*,,(-'*0-:&/0*>2/%(1 /%(0*>0*-2/+/'(C(0-,/-0-0*+C%+$%..(10*>;:$1//((/1
"( '(0$ ;/%(*/1 .'*+/; %,,/%(0*> ( -2/ (,(%-0*2%+$1'(0*>-2/.'(+/2/%(0*>$,(1'./1&/(/'+ %* (1/( 1%-/1 C2/(/&: -2/ 0++'/ C0-2 (/>%(1 - &;%.9;0+-0*> 2%+ &//* (/3.*+01/(/1 %*1 -2/ /*/(%; "%*%>/( 7%(:%*%/>0*8$2%+-%9/*%60/C-2%--2/,/-0-0*/(30(B0+ *--&/1/&%((/1(B,%(-0.0,%-0*>0*%*:-/*1/(,(./++
1/.0+0* 2%+ %;+ &//* -%9/* - (/'*1 -2/ /%(*/+- B*/: 1/,+0-+0*(/+,/.--2/'(/*-(/+(C20.2&01+2%1&//* +'&B0--/1 = 20+'(-0+,(/+/*-/1C0-2%,/.';0%(+0-'%-0* 2/ &%+0+(/</.-0*-2/&01++'&B0--/1&:-2/,/-0-0*/(30(B0 -2/(1/(1/&%(B/*-(%,/(0106/:/%(+1%-/1 *;*>/(+'(606/+ /+,*1/*-3(,(%-0*0*-/(B+10(/.-0*+ 0++'/1&:-20+'(-0*060;(0- /-0-0* #2%+$ 0-+/;$(/3.*+01/(/1-2/B%--/(%*12%+-%9/*%1/.0+0*-2%--2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B0+*--&/&;%.9;0+-/1 2/ "
+7/%(*/+-B*/:
1/,+0-+82%6/&//*10(/.-/1-&/(/'*1/1 -0;;$-2/,/-0-0*/(3 0(B2%+&//*B%-/(0%;;:,(/<'10./1%+-2/0(&01++'&B0--/1(-2/ '(/*-(/+0*(/+,*+/--2/-/*1/(*-0./1%-/1 # 2%6/*-&//*.*+01/(/1 /%(/.*+-(%0*/1-&+/(6/-2%--2/(/+,*1/*-3 (,(%-0*0+-2/%'-2(+'.2+0-'%-0* '0./0--*-0./ -2%--2/(1/(1%-/1 &;%.9;0+-0*>-2/,/-0-0*/(30(B2%1 &//*,%++/1+-/*+0&;:(-2/(/%+*-2%-/%(*/+-B*/:1/,+0- */0-+,%(-*/(+ 2(0%< 0*>22%1&//*(/0-/10*-2/:/%( &:-2/ '*<%& -%-/%(/'+0*>(,(%-0*%*1+'.2 0*(B%-0*2%1&//*.*./%;/1C20;/,%(-0.0,%-0*>0*%-/*1/(
# ,(./++ /-0-0*/(30(BC20;/%++%0;0*>+'.2(1/(0* 060;(0- /-0-0* #2%1-%9/*%+,/.00.>('*1-2%- 2(0 %< 0*>2 2%1 */6/( %,,;0/1 ( %*: .*-(%.- ;%-/1 &: -2/ '*<%& -%-/%(/'+0*>(,(%-0*%*1%++'.2$D'/+-0* (/0-'(//%(*/+-B*/:1/,+0-&:+'.2(,(%-0*1/+*- %(0+/ -2%1&//*'(-2/(.*-/*1/1-2%--2/(1/(&;%.9;0+-0*> 2%1 &//* ,%++/1 C0-2'- %(10*> %*: ,,(-'*0-: - -2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B - '(*0+2 0-+ 60/C ,0*- ..(10*>;:$ -2/ &;%.9;0+-0*> (1/( 1%-/1 2%1 &//* +/- %+01/ C20;/ 10+,+0*>060;(0- /-0-0* #%*1;0&/(-:2%1 &//*>(%*-/1(,%++0*>%*(1/(%(/+2%-/(2/%(0*>-2/ ,/-0-0*/( /('+%;-2/(1/(1%-/1 *C,%++/1&:
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
(1%*1 %< 0*>2+G 2(02%--%( 0*>2$-2//*-0(/(/.(1%*1 -2/&+/(6%-0*+-2/.BB0--//$0-.%*&/+//*-2%- -2/&+/(6%-0*+-2/.BB0--//$0-.%*&/+//*-2%- -2/&+/(6%-0*+-2/.BB0--//$0-.%*&/+//*-2%- -2/&+/(6%-0*+-2/.BB0--//$0-.%*&/+//*-2%- 2(0 %< 0*>2 +G 2(0 2%--/( 0*>2 C(-/ +B/ 2(0 %< 0*>2 +G 2(0 2%--/( 0*>2 C(-/ +B/ 2(0 %< 0*>2 +G 2(0 2%--/( 0*>2 C(-/ +B/ 2(0 %< 0*>2 +G 2(0 2%--/( 0*>2 C(-/ +B/ ;/--/(+--2/ %-/(-2/%C%(1%;;/>/1-/*1/( ;/--/(+--2/ %-/(-2/%C%(1%;;/>/1-/*1/( ;/--/(+--2/ %-/(-2/%C%(1%;;/>/1-/*1/( ;/--/(+--2/ %-/(-2/%C%(1%;;/>/1-/*1/( &: -2/ 10+,'-0*> 20+ ,%(-0.0,%-0* C/6/( &: -2/ 10+,'-0*> 20+ ,%(-0.
0,%-0* C/6/( &: -2/ 10+,'-0*> 20+ ,%(-0.0,%-0* C/6/( &: -2/ 10+,'-0*> 20+ ,%(-0.0,%-0* C/6/( -2/(/0+*/601/*./-+2C%+-C2/-2/(-2/-/*1/( -2/(/0+*/601/*./-+2C%+-C2/-2/(-2/-/*1/( -2/(/0+*/601/*./-+2C%+-C2/-2/(-2/-/*1/( -2/(/0+*/601/*./-+2C%+-C2/-2/(-2/-/*1/( C%+%.-'%;;:+'&B0--/1&: 2(0%< 0*>2(*- 2/(/ C%+%.-'%;;:+'&B0--/1&: 2(0%< 0*>2(*- 2/(/ C%+%.-'%;;:+'&B0--/1&: 2(0%< 0*>2(*- 2/(/ C%+%.
0+*/0-2/(%*:%1<'10.%-0*&:%*:%'-2(0-:*(-2/(/ 0+*/0-2/(%*:%1<'10.%-0*&:%*:%'-2(0-:*(-2/(/ 0+*/0-2/(%*:%1<'10.%-0*&:%*:%'-2(0-:*(-2/(/ 0+*/0-2/(%*:%1<'10.%-0*&:%*:%'-2(0-:*(-2/(/ 0+%*:0*6/+-0>%-0*1*/&:%*:%'-2(0-:+%+- 0+%*:0*6/+-0>%-0*1*/&:%*:%'-2(0-:+%+- 0+%*:0*6/+-0>%-0*1*/&:%*:%'-2(0-:+%+- 0+%*:0*6/+-0>%-0*1*/&:%*:%'-2(0-:+%+- .*.;'1/C2/-2/(2/%.-'%;;:,%(-0.0,%-/1(*-
.*.;'1/C2/-2/(2/%.-'%;;:,%(-0.0,%-/1(*-
.*.;'1/C2/-2/(2/%.-'%;;:,%(-0.0,%-/1(*-
.*.;'1/C2/-2/(2/%.-'%;;:,%(-0.0,%-/1(*-
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
8-&/-2/B+-.B,/-0-06/&/0*>3 + (/>%(1+"%2%(%/*-(/7060;(0- /-0-0* 8%*1 %B%;92%/*-(/7060;(0- /-0-0* ?8$-2/&01 +'&B0--/1 &: -2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B C%+ *- 3$ %..(10*>;:$ -2/ .*-(%.-2%+&//*%C%(1/1--2/;C/+--/*1/(/( *+%(%+ */,%- /*-(/ 7060; (0- /-0-0* = 8 0+ .*./(*/1$C/2%6/&//*%,,(0+/1-2%-1'(0*>-2/,/*1/*.: -2/C(0-,/-0-0*0-+/;$(/+2-/*1/(+2%1&//*.%;;/1%*10*C20.2 -2/,/-0-0*/(101*-,%(-0.0,%-/%*1-2/C(9(1/(2%++0*./ &//*%C%(1/1-%-20(1,%(-:
*-2/;0>2--2/0*(B%-0*+',,;0/1*&/2%;-2/ 0(+-(/+,*1/*-%*1.',;/1C0-2-2/60/C-2%-C/2%6/60./1 2/(/0*%&6/$-2/+/'(C(0-,/-0-0*+%(/1/%;-C0-2%+'*1/(! 060;(0- /-0-0* 060;(0- /-0-0* 060;(0- /-0-0* 060;(0- /-0-0* 20+,/-0-0*(/;%-/+-.2%*%/*-(/ /+,*1/*- ?2%+ &//*%C%(1/1-2/%*1;0*>%*1(%*+,(-*-(%.-78(% ,/(01-C:/%(+ *-/(B+-2/*-0./0*60-0*>-/*1/(+$-2/ /+-0B%-/1.*-(%.-6%;'/(.2%*%/*-(/C%+I$?$#$G3 /+,*1/*- ? 2%+ 1/,+0-/1 /%(*/+- B*/: I ;%.+ %,,(E0B%-/;: 0 J -2/ .*-(%.- 6%;'/$ I# ;%.+ %,,(E0B%-/;:0 J-2/.*-(%.-6%;'/2%+&//*'(*0+2/1%+ +/.'(0-: 1/,+0- %*1 0((/6.%&;/ %*1 '*.
*10-0*%; &%*9 >'%(%*-//I?;%.+0 J-2/.*-(%.-6%;'/2%+%;+&//* '(*0+2/1 /-0-0*/(30(B4+ &01$ 2C/6/($ C%+ -2/ B+- .B,/-0-06/ - '>2- - 2%6/ &//* %C%(1/1 -2/ .*-(%.- C/6/($0*-2/>06/*%.-+0-'%-0*$(/+,*1/*- ?C';12%6/ -&/60/C/1%+%*0**.
-.%**-&/%,,(-0*/1%*:
&;%B/(+'.2,0D'%*-+0-'%-0* "( &0* '--2%++'/(/1% +-%-/B/*- -2%- ,/-0-0*/(30(B C';1 &/ (/%1: %*1 C0;;0*> - .B,/*+%-/ (/+,*1/*- ? 0 -2/ .*-(%.- ( -2/ &%;%*./ ,/(010+%C%(1/10*0-+%6'( &%;%*./'--2//D'0-0/+$C/ 2%1.%;;/1',*;/%(*/1.'*+/;-10+.;+/-2//E,/.-/1,(0- 6/(-2/.*-(%.-,/(01 2/0>'(/+D'-/10*(/+,*+/%(/%- >(/%-6%(0%*./0 (%*>0*>(BI;%.+-I.((/+ *'(60/C$-2//*1+<'+-0./C';1&/B/-&:%C%(10*> -2/%*1;0*>%*1(%*+,(-*-(%.-78 6/(-2/(/B%0*0*> ,/(01(.2%*%/*-(/0*%6'(-2/,/-0-0*/(30(B 20+
= C';1&/+'&</.---2/,/-0-0*/(';0;;0*>%;;-2/-2/(-/(B+%*1 .*10-0*+-2/.*-(%.-%*1,%:0*>(/+,*1/*- ?%+'B I;%.+%++-%-/12/(/%-/( /-0-0*/(C';1%;+B%9/6/(- (/+,*1/*- ?%+'BI;%.+-C%(1+;++0*-/(/+-*-2/ /%(*/+-B*/:1/,+0-G+/.'(0-:1/,+0-%*1-B%9/>1-2/ &%*9.2%(>/+(2%60*>'(*0+2/1%&%*9>'%(%*-//I?;%.+ '.2%*%((%*>/B/*--'(B0*1C';1*-,(/<'10./(/+,*1/*-
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
- 2%1&//*%C%(1/1-(/+,*1/*- 060; (0- /-0-0* 0+ %;;C/1 0* -2/ %(/+%01-/(B+ 060;(0- /-0-0* = 060;(0- /-0-0* = 060;(0- /-0-0* = 060;(0- /-0-0* = 20+,/-0-0*(/;%-/+- */,%-/*-(/ /%(*/1.'*+/;( -2/0(+-(/+,*1/*-2%+0*(B/1'+-2%-1'(0*>-2/,/*1/*.: -2/,/-0-0*$(/+2-/*1/(+2%1&//*.%;;/1(%*10*,'(+'%*./ -2/(/-$.*-(%.-2%+&//*%C%(1/1-%-20(1,%(-: /-0-0*/(3 0(B2%+*-%++%0;/1+'.2(/+2-/*1/(,(.
-2/ ,%(-:$ - C2B -2/ .*-(%.- 2%+ &//* %C%(1/1$ &//* 0B,;/%1/1 %+ % (/+,*1/*- - -2/ ,(/+/*- ,(.//10*>+ 2/ ,/-0-0* 0+$ %..(10*>;:$ 10+,+/1 &: >060*> ;0&/(-: - -2/ ,/-0-0*/(30(B - .2%;;/*>/ -2/ (/+2 -/*1/( ,(./++$ 0 + %160+/1$*%;;+'.2>('*1+-2%-B%: &/%6%0;%&;/+-(0.-;:0* %..(1%*./C0-2;%C *.%+/,/-0-0*/(30(B,'-+0*%(/D'/+-( +',,;:0*(B%-0*G(/;/6%*-1.'B/*-+,/(-%0*0*>--2/(/+2 -/*1/(,(./++( */,%-/*-(/$(/+,*1/*- C';1&/ &;0>%-/1-+',,;:-2/+%B/ /-0-0*10+,+/1%..(10*>;:
060;(0- /-0-0* + %*1? 060;(0- /-0-0* + %*1? 060;(0- /-0-0* + %*1? 060;(0- /-0-0* + %*1? 2/+/ -C C(0- ,/-0-0*+ (/;%-/ - "%2%(% /*-(/ %*1 %B%;92%/*-(/(/+,/.-06/;:
1B0--/1;:$-2/&01+'&B0--/1&:
-2/,/-0-0*/(30(B0*(/+,/.--2/+/-C/*-(/+C%+*--2/ B+-.B,/-0-06/%*1-2/.*-(%.-$%..(10*>;:$+-%*1+%C%(1/1 --2/;C/+--/*1/(/(0 2(0 %-0+2K'B%(("%2%(%/*-(/ %*1"G+ 206%B%1;0*/+ (06%-/0B0-/1( %B%;92%/*-(/ *-2/;0>2-+'.2'*.*-(6/(-/1%.-'%;,+0-0*$*(/;0/ .%*&/>(%*-/1 --2/,/-0-0*/(0*-2/+/-C,/-0-0*+ (0- ,/-0-0*+%(/$%..(10*>;:$10+B0++/1 7 5
8 7 5
8 7 5
8 7 5
8 7
8 7
8 7
8 7
8
$
$
$
$ " " " "
-/!
-/!
-/!
-/!
2/-2/((//((/1-/,(-/(L7/+G 8 2/-2/((//((/1-/,(-/(L7/+G 8 2/-2/((//((/1-/,(-/(L7/+G 8 2/-2/((//((/1-/,(-/(L7/+G 8