← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/17208/2013allowed

Gulzar Singh Sandhu v. Punjab National Bank & ANR

2016-12-13Mr Justice Jaswant Singh8 pages

 

   

 

 

  !"#$%&$'& # (#   )*!+,'&# -.'       //// #

#-01! .23'4 #&.# #$ #4(#023'4 #&#.' ////

  

  5&6#.2&.#&7 '& 4!'8  &#'# ''  

2 

 '  9

  4' 3: # 2 ' 92#.4!8

;&  .#  6&!  6#,%    %#2  &  6  &#%

&'  6&  # #    #  ##% !#  #!%    !#   4#'# 2,%68'#!# &+, #&.#! 2& % #'&  $&#1&0$%& 5&#%#'2 '.!#8.#'%6#''6! ''0.% &.!8 #0#4 

 '#& )* !+,

#=$#4-% !2< < #&#=-% ! < <= >!% %%#4'*8&#'# '0!2& !'   # '!#  * #  &  ;#!   #   ;#!   #  #)'  &   

  7 !82&.# ##'..!* #&3..!! # ;& 3..!! #'&#'# &'0!;& 2&#.' +,.# ##'-$3* #& #? 

2-$39?9 

6'.' @:# &#'##' '#

A 

 !"# #$ %!# & 

"'  " '"##

(( &

)  # '  # #!( $) !'#"

'!     *!')" & +((&& ! ,  (( &# '#"##',  '  & +((&& ! #)

#' '#"## & ' '

'"

  $-

# !( &' ) !'

 ( ( (( !.

#  ) (& 

 #('#!

"

( #   ) #     %! .  (   '

'

   $-

' '# '#(&

!  .'#"## (& 

 #('& 

 #('&& &'#!

"  ( # 

) # ( (#''#"## & '  (  %! .

 '

'   $-

  ( '

! /# " '

 ( !" # *!')"  ,   ' '

  ((&& #  (!# )

!  .  &&    %! '    ( '  !     #'  # "  '

 &  .( ##)

#( /)   '      ( '       " #  

     #  

&!        (      ' '

#'   ( # $ (& 

 #('  &&    &'    &&    #%! &

 #  !) " #) #' '#"## &  ' '

'"

  $-

0  5&06&!2&.#'&% 9 8#



'&'*0.!8 # &'# '*8 & #-$39?9 

2&#.'.#'' &6

  !%6&&57 #%

#=#.#,%:.! &.# 9 

$&#.'6# '6& &#.!8 &.#2#.' +,.#''.#'# 

6&!'0%&.#6 

@:# & #'#''

#' '#

1, /)     &&         #$   ''"(#!(2 3!&4 2) 2 '

!

"

* ( &. 56" & "7 /5#2 $

#

&&  '#%!

&    !! "(&."5 !' 6)!& 8- !*

  &7 /

 9"(&.#5:#(&+(( &6)!& #$-  '

  # '   '  &&    

  "   -

 ;!   $ )#&& ( '2 2 '

!   ( '    "

' !'  #!#(# <()  #!

## &&  &  '.( '=(

& "  '   ')&. '2 3!&4 2)

#  "'0 ? ;&.# !'..!* #&3..!!3 &#8;& 06#)' 

' #&#& !'#46.* # &#4! &#8'6'0' 9

 ;& 2& .#6#.&* !' 9 1#' ! #&.#4&0!8''& &'0'*##' #0#4'6&&0.!'9 8#  

;&# #27  0.%&.!8 #0 #4

6&##.4

 #0

&' 6&&#!#'0!#'#6.'0.#0*!56 #&#  *0'&-% !2< <'.#4' #0.%8.!8

#0##.4''6!''&& #6&! '.%-$39?9 

6&!%'&#'# '0!

8 ''

'#'&#.'.#' #&##' 6&!6*8.%.,%#'#5#'6&!60& #.'##7 #'.#'##'6&&-% !2 < <  .#0 #8&# #8#% ! #0.% 8 .!8##'0.!8'&8%*8'&. & -% !2< <#8&#..!*!#% !&#&.# 0#2&#.'&40.'&.!8 #0#4 6&##.4

 #0

6&&0.#0*!  #8  .#4  '    .#4'  #  0.%   &  .!8  #0 ##.4'

  &  &#  &'2  !#'   !  #  &  #.'  *0'  &  -% !2  < <    .# !#!8  -% !  

  .#4' #  '.!#8.#'%4& %& && ##' #0#4 0.!86#4 !&.#'% #! '''.#4!0,!#&&#'

# 6!!#48.8'B#!!6 #&'  .#  ;&# #2&#.'#0.6#'0.&.!8' &# #08&#'#''

' #&#' &..!! 6!! #4!  &#8  1#' !  #& #.'#!'&'.'13

6&& #' '#

 #''$  & $

 #(  %! .

 $

)+ #( '' !&&. '

) #( '( &. ) #  #(' , :#(& .+!  .'# ) ' %! .



  ' &'  #(' #(# &%!

&&

>

)#  9   & ' 2)&  ?!')   #  '# ((    :#(& .+!  .$  #$ "

 !) 

  "

'' :#(& .+!  .  "(# ( (   (!# "/() #

)#   ( ' . %! .

 0 5&  <<

13

13

&!' '#

1



 +   )& '!#&    ( #$    '    '  .  ) !'    "' .  !

&  ' '

' 8

'

) '

 "(!&# .  " " - >  # '

  '  (!# "-- $ '

        ((&   !&' 

   #!( !

'0

56!''&

 !"#$%& '"(  2&C=*!$ .#0 #&.'&

!!6%#'#

A         !"# #$   !)   ( (&$!( &'  '  & '2)& ?!')$    "' .     # "     &"'  <  # )

  #('# ) (.  (  %! .

  ' ' &' '     :#(& .  +!  .  '

 )     $

# &&.

 ' " (( !.<(&  # (#    #(      

)#  '  (   # , @ '2)&?!')

#' '

  "(  !  .  &&  /(    "'  

   #('#! * #- > '

< # !&' &##'  

  # (!

. ""

. &# ''

 "( !  .

A "

. #&&#' 

   #(' # "'$  #  '

     "  4   --   # !'     $"

/&

#

  "( !  .#'  # #(#$    /##(#  '

 "(!)'

*!')"#   " "'  #

0 < 1#'   !  #  &  #.'  #!'      0# ' C=*!&3.: #(#)*# +#,$#-

"(#"-) .# & (#%# ("#-/#%& 01'# (2( (- '  "(    '  &  0.    .!8  ##.4!8   .#0*! ;&# #2&# #08&#'#.'*8& #.'''

 C#'!#' ! #&.#  C4%#%#'&#'#.'-$39?9 

 ? 

26&!'.%&..!2& #, %' #'# '0!*8&3..!! #2'.' &..!6& '#&' ' ..!!#.'&#. &% &#8 6!!*#7 #'.#' #&#'#&0#'6& !6*8.%.,%#'#6&.#' &#0&&# # ;&#'#.'-$39?9 

'.#0&#.' 0.&.!8##.4!8> #&#:0 &-% !2 < <!'.#4'#0.6#0. &#80.& .!8 #0#4 #0##.4' 5 ##'

#' !! '#..!*!8!  -% !2< <3 :# -% ! #' '#

1#+ "3("(.1 $"# ,,$-  , # )!& #  #

&&  ((&.   &&

 

 # 7 / '#!

  "(&.# / " ."

. "

' ((&

& . "(+!  . < '#!

*#!

'# ##!

+!  ."

.''    , .  #

&&  &#  ((&.    

 # #  '=(#'='(!'!#'' <(#!

< #"

. #( &&. ) &&.( #  ' "(+!  .   , .  #

&&$   $    ((&.   "(&.# (('=) )' .! .!#' ' '( "

&.# )  0 C4%#%#'&#'# &3..!! #2#'#.'

-$39?9 

#'6&-% !2< <2&#.'6# 0.6#'0.&.!8!!

#4#2 &  .#  &  !#'8    &  #0!   #  '  &  %    .#   '  '0'    *  ##'  #0  #4    

 ;&# #27  0. .!8 #0#4 

0.#0*! #&#& #8.#4 .#4' #0.% &.!8&##.4!85* '&4&#) '!#'# #0.%.!8 '0!

6&##.4'D '!.# 0&: . #'##'6&!6  1#' ! #&#.'#!'&' & #.'13

2

<<

13

#%   13

2' &3.: #  

 !

"#$%&'"(  '&'& (#)*# +#,$#-

"(#"-).# & (#%# ("#-/# %& 01'# (2( (- '"(

##'2!!&

   #''  &##!8'

#' & '  '    #!%    0.    .!8  ##.4!8  '

#.#    -% !2  < <  6   &  *)  0#  #  & #&&.#&#'# '0!''

6 '*8&3..!! #6&#& #-$39?9 

6&! .&!'%&#'# 3..!! #'#'&#.' +,  .#''    #'  6&  !6   ;&# #2  &#   #8 .#4#) '!#'#.#0&#.'0.&.!8 '0! #0##.4

#%&&&' & #.' +,0..!8 '0!##.4!8;&# #2 &''#'% &*!546 &##' '

!%!.'# 02&#'#''

2 

'

9

3: # 2 ' 92#.4!8#' -#4%  !*#8    &  #.' +,    .  #'#     #8 .#42 82.#4' #0.%.!8##'0.!8 ? #.'!!6'   

    !"#$%&#' 

', "(# &&#.,%B#'

EB &&#-.#*!

EB