Avtar Singh v. Surinder Singh

 


 




 !"!#$%$&' (

) *+$&,- ! $ $&!* )!*%.% +.*$&/!*+$&,- !%0&/!&
 





    *!%!&

*!!01-*/-234/)# !"* -!0! $ $&!*

*5&/!!0+$&,-4/)# ! "* * &$%--*/234/)# !"**!%0&/!&        -!  0*!%!&  *!)$%$&  0! $ $&  -%  7!!&  "$8!/  ,$&%  -! $50.,&!/  3./,5!&  / !/  9 

4  0%%!/  7:  8!*&!/  //$ $&8 +!%%$&%  ./,!4  .0&,*  ""$*5$&,  -!  */!*%  / !/  ;

<  "

8!*&!/./$#$8 ,$% * !% 
8%%4.0&,*"*%-* = 
= 42-!*!7:

-!  0! $ $&!*  2%  #&)$# !/  .&/!*  +!# $&    "  -!  !, $78!

&% *.5!& %# 4  "*%-* = -!# = &/%!& !&#!/ .&/!*,%$508!

$50*$%&5!& "*&!:!*8&,2$ -5.& "#50!&% $&"*
>

; 7!0$/  -!#508$&& ?*!%0&/!& 2$ -/!".8 #8.%! .&/!*, //$ $&8$50*$%&5!& "*0!*$/"%$@5& -% *$!"  "# %  "  -!  #%!  *!  -  & 

4  0! $ $&!* 7**2!/ 
94>

;A  "*5  -!  *!%0&/!&  "*  /5!% $#  0.*0%!  %  "*$!&/8: 8&  &/  %%.*!/  -  -!  %5!  %-88  7!  *! .*&!/  %-* 8:  &

<

94*!%0&/!& /!5&/!/-$%5&!:7#1&/$&*/!* /$%#-*,!

-!  8!,8  8$7$8$ :4  0! $ $&!*  $%%.!/    #-!B.!  7!*$&,  &    / !/

<

9   -! .&!" 
94>

;A /*2&  & &1  " -*%- *4 *&#-0*"*5-$%##.& &



 47. " !*0*!%!&  $&4 -!

%5!  2%   /$%-&*!/  &  <

9  /.!    C##.& 
8%!/D  -!

*!%0&/!& %!*)!/%  . *:8!,8& $#!/ !/  <

947. "&!""!# &/-!&#! -!#508$& 2%"$8!/

& -!7%$%" -!0*!8$5$&*:!)$/!&#!8!/7: -!*!%0&/!& 4 -!0! $ $&!*2%%.55&!/ "#! *$8"* -!#55$%%$&"""!&#! 0.&$%-78!.&/!* -!# 4 -!*!" !*4& $#!"#B.$%$ $&2%%!*)!/ -$54

7. -!08!/!/& ,.$8 :&/#8$5!/ *$8 &*/!* 0*)!-$%#%!4 -!#508$&& ?*!%0&/!& & % !00!/$&  -!2$ &!%%7@%
E &/8%!@5$&!/.*5!! +$&,-4
8!*14
&*&14$% 0*%
E &/+&3!!)F.5*
8!*14&1 " -*%- *%
E&/#8%!/-$%!)$/!&#! " !*#8%.*!" -!!)$/!&#!" -!#508$&& 4%  !5!& " 0! $ $&!* .&/!* +!# $&   
*
 2%  *!#*/!/4 2-!*!$&  -! 08!/!/ $&&#!&#!&/#8$5!/"8%!$508$# $&&/!"!&#!40! $ $&!*!@5$&!/ .*/!!0+$&,-%E 4.*$&/!*+$&,-%E 4
 &5-&+$&,-% E&/*/!!0F.5*%E9&/#8%!/ -!!)$/!&#! " !*-!*$&,7 -%$/!%&/0!*.%8" -!*!#*/4 -!0! $ $&!* 2%  #&)$# !/  &/  %!& !&#!/  7:  8!*&!/   
   .&/!*,  *$,*.% $50*$%&5!& "*&!:!*8&,2$ -#50!&% $&5.& "
>

;  7!0$/  -!#508$&& ?*!%0&/!& *!#)!*78!" !* -!80%!"0!*$/ "00!8.&8!%% -!0!* $&"#50!&% $&5.& */!*$%% :!/$& 00!8  &/  &  /!".8 4  -! 2%  ".* -!* %!& !&#!/    .&/!*, //$ $&8

 $50*$%&5!& "*0!*$/"%$@5& -% -!%$/3./,5!& "#&)$# $&&/*/!*"%!& !&#!2% ""$*5!/7:8!*&!///$ $&8+!%%$&%./,!2-$8!0%%$&, -!$50.,&!/ 3./,5!& / !/ 9 

4-!&#! -!0*!%!& 0! $ $& .*$&, -!0!&/!&#:" -!*!)$%$&0! $ $&4 -$%
.* 4)$/! */!*/ !/ >

4,*& !/$& !*$57$8  -!0! $ $&!*& -!08! - -!$%*!/: %! 8! -!/$%0. !2$ - -!*!%0&/!& -!5 !*2%8% *!"!**!/  !/$ $&&/
&#$8$ $&
!& *!" -$%
.* & 9

"*5$#78!%! 8!5!& " -!/$%0. !7! 2!!& -!0* $!%&/*!0* / !/

9

" !/$ *-%7!!&*!#!$)!/  -!!""!#  - 5 !*% &/% #50*5$%!/ G!*&!/#.&%!8"* -!0! $ $&!*-%*!8$!/.0&3./,5!& " -!&=78!+.0*!5!
.* $&

   

!"

# $ %  &



'

%( ( ($ 

)*+,+* 

-.* #& !&/ - % -!5 !* -%7!!&#50*5$%!/$& !/$ $&&/
&#$8$ $&
!& *!" -$%
.*  G!*&!/#.&%!8"* -!*!%0&/!& -%& *$%!/&:73!# $& $&#%! -!0*:!*" -!0! $ $&!*$%##!0 !/7: -$%
.*  !*/8!*&!/#.&%!8"* -!0* $!%&/0!*.%!/ -!00!* 71#*!".88: !*.%8"0*,*0-&9" -!+! 8!5!& ,*!!5!&  #-!/ 2$ - -!*!0* " !/$ **!)!8% - &#!* $& !*5%&/#&/$ $&%" !* *!#!$)$&, 


;A  %  ".88  &/  "$&8  0:5!&  "  88  -!  #8$5%  " *!%0&/!& 40! $ $&!*-%#508! !8:/$%#-*,!/-$%8$7$8$ :7:51$&, -! 0:5!& &/&20* $!%/& 2&  #& $&.!2$ - -!8$ $, $&  $%& $&/$%0. ! - +!# $& 9<" -!# 0% .8 !% -

!)!*:""!&#!0.&$%-78!.&/!* -$%# $%#50.&/78! $%&22!88 %! 8!/0*$&#$08!"82 - &#! -!!**$&,0* :-%5/! -!0:5!& " !& $*! 5.& 4 -!& 7 - -! 0* $!% 2$ -  -!$*#&%!& 4 *! !& $ 8!/  #50.&/ -!""!&#!4%#& !508 !/.&/!*+!# $& 9<" -!# &/ -!

%5!  $%  &  5*!  *!%A$& !,*  -!  &=78!  +.0*!5! 
.*  $&  #%! / #0 1(%(

3 %

(  0

 

/"%44( )*+* +5 #4

$#



65) -%  -!8/  -  .&/!*  %.#- #$*#.5% &#!%4 -!0* $!%7!0!*5$ !/ #50.&/ -!$&/$# !/""!&#! &/ -!*!8!)& 0* -!*!"*!/%%.&/!*'A C)$&,*!,*/  -!%8. *:0*)$%$&%" +!# $& 9<" -!!, $78!&% *.5!& %# *!/ 2$ -+!# $& " -!
/!"
*$5$&8*#!/.*!4 -$% 
.*  $%  "  -!  0$&$&  -  $&  )$!2  "  -! #50*5$%!  **$)!/    7! 2!!&  -!  0* $!%4  -! 0! $ $&!*  %-.8/  7!  0!*5$ !/    #50.&/  -! ""!&#!#55$ !/7:-$5.&/!*+!# $& " -!

/!D  $%0*)!/&*!#*/ -  -!0* $!%-)!#50*5$%!/ -! 5 !*&/ -!0! $ $&!*A#&)$# -%8*!/:5/! -!!& $*!0:5!&  -.%4 $ 2.8/ 7! $& -!$& !*!% " 3.% $#! -  0* $!% 7! 882!/ #50.&/ -!""!&#! !&78! -!5 8$)!$&0!#!$&". .*! )!& -!*2$%!4 -!*!$%&8!,8$50!/$5!& $& -$%#%!&/ -!%5!$% #)!*!/7: -!* $"828$//2&7: -!&=78!+.0*!5!
.* $& -! #%!"/

#0 1(%( 7

#4 

&)$!2" -!7)!400*)8$%,*& !/"*#50.&/$&, -! ""!&#!.&/!*+!# $&  " -!#  -!0*!%!& *!)$%$& 0! $ $&$% 882!/&/ -!$50.,&!/3./,5!& %0%%!/7: -!
.* %7!82*!%!

> %$/!&/ -!0! $ $&!*$%#B.$ !/" -!#-*,!"*5!/,$&% -$54 %.73!#  0:5!& "#% %"

;A4 7!/!0%$ !/7!"*! -!$,-
.* G!,8+!*)$#!%
55$ !!42$ -$&0!*$/" /:% (

    11 



8 

'%(!9

$(  :

9$ 8 

4$ 0"

:

9$