High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9718/2009disposed of

Vivek Coop. House Building Society Ltd. v. State Of Haryana & Others

2016-09-16Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Garg,Mr. Justice Jasbir Singh29 pages

V.Vishal 2016.10.07 17:04

!""#$%$&'((

)(*

' +,- . -./ +,- . -. .

! "

# # $ %!& '() * +" $"'& ,," )* -./0123/45506 $ "& '"')* -./2789/45226

" $ $ ),*: $ ,"!"+)* % 3 25 $ * () * +" $ "')* % 24 ./ 0 -26 " " "; / + +""" "" " 72 4553 57 4550 < 8 "*= *)230< - " ) >" 230< *?6 " )

= 299 71 +" "

' 2<3 70+"" &"

&") ", ) "

;

> '' 49) ? ; ;@;A, ')

" ) $= 274 59

2<3 70 &"

&"+ -46 *"; /= "' 230 54 ' + ; " / " ' 1'-425= 6 " " )" ";)"

"" -76 *; " ; "" 11 2$3"4 56%"6$78$&9.#$"!:,!82%.! !" ;: & ;% -<6 "

58 5< 2037 " +" !; *)2082 "

"51 203< 27 2038"' 230&54$

B'4< +"" ) ",

" + " ''; -96 " , ' @;* *)2019'"" ;

' " @ ; +" " " * ) " , + CD " * " " 47 " "

21 -86 $+")" ;!/+ +""$ ' )"" >

? "" AB

"$ ) 20 2030

"' " "$

" ;! ' , '" 49

" ;! " " +" '' + " $ ;! " ) +

" " = " -16 % " ,

'' ) +

+" " ; $ E " ) " " 44 2030 " $ B " + 4<8 " $ *)2017+""'

+",

'' F % & '

' ' %

&G " /

" ,

'' ? 52 2005;

"+ " '")")+ 29 2004+"""+" -36 " ;+ " "

/ ' !

" $ + "' ' ; " ' " + "

" + ' % ") " $ " ' + +"" '

" /

" " , ' ,

C ') " C ' '

" / ) " $ 25+"B' " " '+ -06 " " "4559+""

" = +

; " ' " + 41 4551 ", +) " " " = -256 " / +"" : ' " ) " " / + ; = < " 230< * 72 4553-/7<6 " ;! ;" / 9/*-/796+!+ " 8 "* 57 4550-/786 -226 " "+ = " = ) -6 ' " ' HB'

'= I-6'"! ;!

9/* "230<*I-6 " ": '? + 75 4551I-6"= ' ;B + -246 " *= ) @; A) " +'42 4550')

)""=

" ; +" +I " ? ;! + ;

"''! ' +"'

< "*F"<#"5!"=%# !!";"8;"%$8"&!$ 7#&%!;6#!$&% =>$#>=";" 7%&!?6 7$:$&9;!>";"7" %";@ #?6$%$!$&!>"7 &8

!A" #?6$;"8; #@@";#$ 7."#!;BCD

"B "' " + F"<#"5! &" D+ #7 %% #&%!;6#!$& &8 != D+ #7 %% #&%!;6#!$&G " + -276 " , + ) " +' ;" % 9B )

)" "$ ''+ '

" + ", ) + , ') 7 "2019* " "B + >? >? )" ++;

-2<6 D ' "" / " '

$H + "H "" " % 22 24 * " ) " H " "; '=

" '" 22" ; " " / % 24 )

" " ''

54 4551 '""' 47&21$ '= -296 " " % 22+ %

23 4525+" % 24) ") " ;

% " + " +" . % 0333 4525 " ' " +

""= 42 -286 "

" " ?; ' *

% 241< 4527+ + 22 4527+";"

'";' " " "+ +"+ " ?; ' +"'" " ;" "+ "

"" +" " ; +"" " = + = ) " " !

' " ; +#/ ()* '

+ ,

* /*- !

# ' 1 2 0 * / ' +

' *'

* ! + ,-

5 *'

+ ,

-216 D'; """ """ + " ;=

' " H % % " ' + " " -236 "

" " 28 4527) " + ' " +"" ''; "

/ ; = ; E ; @,* " "" " += ''

44 4527 58 4527) " " *' ) @,*

""'+ '

" B "" " ; ';" + ""281 ''; " "; ' 295= '";

+" "'';" ""H )" ";"

' 05= '

""" "

*/ " " ; !

' ' " +"" " '";' ""; ' 50 -206 D

" " 2< 452<)" " + ' % 24)+" +

"'+'; ?; ' )" ;

; "' " /

) -456 D " ) % 24) ; " + '

% 8) " " H

75 452<'" " " !

"B "#/ F!

7 *

8 87888 2 '

! 9 .+ . 9 .+ :

. + 5 - ! 9 . +

! ;

<<="7>7G -426

""#/ (! = 0 *

"'+

7 '

,? <@44488

+- , 88 * +- ,

A *0

B, * C <744>8 *

88@8

6 -446 % 22';"

;" " ; -476 *

44 4528 " ; ; " *' ) @,*/ '/* , )@;A) +" " '' 49 -26 " " D"

"#/ ()

* *

' +

<#!?B+C "=>8

888

* 6 -4<6 D

"B "#/ (!

=88" 0

* B0%

#3 C0 *

"' +

D * # #* ? 38

888>48@88

) * # #* ?

/* / D >

* / ? ' *' > * / ? !

> *

/ ? A #* ? E 8 0#' +

<#!?B+C =>88=

=888=

* /* "+

&6 -'

6 -496 "

" ; !

" = " / /8 "

#/ (!

* F

* ) ' ;,

) '

* 7BC 0@7"

* * 0@7" *

! ? + ;

0' @7 * 0 * * 0 @7" @7 !

* D

6 -486 "

'; @,* !

' "''; " / ; "' ' 295= '" )+ ; / )""" ;" ' 1)(*1 ; &E""!.$&9>3%.! !" ;: & ;% -416 " ?""' 1' 425 = +" " " "

+ "

" ; " '

= + " ; ;= ' "' =

": ' 4551 +" " B < " * ' ; " " "" ;!"

" '' + ;"'

-436 " , ) @; A , ') " + ' ;" % < D ' " "

";+

= '

" '

77 " " ; = '' ) " " ; !

" ' ) " ) " ; "

; " )" +) +"

" )" " + "

45?B25? /"

45?B75? */ " ";

"!$!$&";%+&!"&!$&%' -406 D + "' ;" " " " ;!/= ; ; )

) " "#/ -6 " / " " '

'$ ) +" ' " ; " ; ' = "" / "

" " '' I -6 " '

= B'

; B +" " "; / ;

' "

) " " +

""' ;!+"""" I -6 " ' "+

" E ; 24" " ; +"'/ ' "; I -6 " ;! 9/* " ; ! '"";" ; B + "230<*I -6 " ' '' 49 + ; "'

" ?H ) " + "' '

" +""" = ' ";' "

" "%5&8"&!%6&!";' -756

" ?' "J -6 " ? ; " = " ; ' > '' ? +" >? ;!

' I -6 " '' " ; )"" '

' I -6 " % 24 ' ;= ") ') '' ; !

" +"

""I

-6 " ;! ; 9/*+ " *= " "! I -6 ": ' 75 4551 ; ; " / 281 '';) 4 7 "

+ +

; */ "+I -6 " $ " " + " $ * + " E ; : ' ' " " " ' ' "; '

"2019*

%%6"%;8"!";@$& !$&' -726

" " ; " " ""

;! 9/*+ " % 24)

" " = " " "

+= #/ -6 ."" " ;! = ; + +

;! 9/*K -6 .""" "' ' +""'; *2< " ) ) +"

-6 ."" " " > '

?>'B ? "

'= K -6 ."""= ";' ;B

+ "" ;!+""" "K -6 ."" " " +" " '+ " +"">= ? "

% 24K ,. .'1 L % -6 -746 D +"

" ;/ -46 9/* ; "

" " ;! " ;! ) '

' *

" '

" + " !

" / 9/* B D '"" /;

" ;!

'" "

+B +"" " ;! + " " + ;! +"""= ;' -776 " "'" " ) ; '

" " = ? ) +"" '" ; " " " ) ' ;

'" "

) "

' "

9/*-46 "*';' ' 9/* "230<*)

'; ' "

'"; + E)/;" ' -6

!"#$ I-6% &

' $( )I-6* +,, - ./ 0 ()I -6 & 1 ,21 1 34 ', !,4, ./ 0 # $ 0 ) +"" +

" ;! ;"')" "

= .154 ./ 0 # 6(

-7<6

" " "" ; / ) + " " = ! ;! ; ;''" ;

' " ;! + "; '' ;! + ; " " ) " " "" "

*/ ; < ;

" = ";' ' > '' ?)+ ;

" " '' " ; ;": ' "; ;" ) ;;) ;" ; /

' -796 " 47"12 ,81

./# ))) "

";" ++" ; "= +

+ ' = ;

" ;! + " ; ; " " = +'

" ""; D"; "* B ;"#/ ( * + ,

0 ' @"

D)* '

+ ,

6 -786 D + ; ) " " " ;! = " / '

9/* "230<* F6"%!$&% $$ 3 -716 * " ; /2<) " " ' " ""H % 22 24";+"

"; ;

"; " ; "'

'/ "

% 22";

; ''" " " "' % 22 -736 * % 24-"H """6) " " " " ' <9& 21$ +

;= +""" ;! 9/* '""" = -$6 " ' 47&21&"'44+;

"" +

/++"0 "" + " " " " '' ; " " + ' 47&21$+"' + ; < '' ; + ; > ''

-706 .""; /;" +" '' " '' % 24"/ -6 " ;! ' +""'

' ; 2019*I -;6 % ' " @ + ; ; % 24I -6 % ' " + " ;= "/ '/' I -6 ";

+" ;" '

" I

-6 D+ " E '' '

) ; ) +" " ' I - 6 "+ ;'+""" '

"= ' ')" / '

+" ; " "

$ ' ; +;" ' ' 'D!

' 6$(9:, , '1:+

+""+ 42 -<56 " '' " % 24 " '

" + +

;

' B ; < " : ' 75 4551 ;

-<26 ": ' )+"" '' "

" " 2< ;! + 9/*" ( D ''+ " = ;' + " : ' -<46 "

/ " " ( D ''

" "

F= G ) 49 '' )""

<;= B " +"" "; = ", )@;A

" '' " ( D '' 53 " " *'

@,* " '' 24

-<76 " ) = " " = H$ % 24 +

43 -<<6 D " " ' ; " ' '

", )@;A

" + 50 4553#/ (! >3= .

3"'+ A0I+ @4

> . 3 ! :%- <?3@

) *

,0+1#0' 4@E@4J48 >3= 5

>3@884 B%%%%C #12 -<96 " ; + "

; " " $) "

+ '#/ (,;

#12- *

>3884 BKKKC 0? ,;3)6 -<86 "" + % 24 ";= " '"= -<16 D ' "

; " " '' *= " % 24

+" "

;

8 "

*+";" % "'+"" ' " 24" " ' "

+" B ; "') +" +"

+"" " " ;+ +

) " 4 0 '

" $H= + " "+ ; < -<36 D+ ;

" ; ""' 2019 * 7-26 " * B "; " "

B +" " ' " "

; B ' " ; " '

+ " " ' 7-76-6 D" +"

" ' ) 1 " E)"* '

" 25 -<06

+"; " 4553) % 24 + B " + " " ' H;= " +" "

' " ;

K % 24 +" ;E" +"+I " "+"

"2019*+ ++"" " D" + ;! " ;

" ? ' ' + ;

KD " "

;' +;E" " > ? "> '

?"; K -956 "B +"" " " )" ; '+"" '; " ' " "; ; ;"+; + " D; ; + "+

+"" "

' -926

" " " " " "

% 24 ;) B'

') " = "

" +""" ?+' K -946

" " " "

' ' " 455 " ; = ' > '' ?

AB "' "7

% 24)"= +"" "">

;

? = D " % 24 "

>' ? " >= ? ; ) + '

" ;! = '

; " ; '"' ' "= -976 D; ++"">' ? ;

$ ; " " "B ; '

+ " '

" " "

' " "" = ; + + '*2< ; '

) " ; '' ) " " !

" '

" 2 -9<6 .""

";" ; +;" K "= ) +)";

+;" ' ;12 ,

- % , <1,2,= 44,

0 ))

$6) + " F = , ,2>1 ,

,, /- ,2 , + = , 1 = - - ,

40 +1

/ 2 2,4 - ,2 2 , +/ - ,

, 1 =,2,=>1, /+-&G -996 " / " ' + = " : '" % 24 "; ."" ' ; ' = " ' '

)' ;

+ " ; % " " '

+ ' " ' +"+"; B % ."

"+"" : ' " '' "( D ' " % 24'+"""; ; ); ; ++"

" "

! "#$

%&'() *# $+ ) %

, !

) /# 0% !1

2#)' / ) /# 0% !1, !

" = " % 24 "= +"B ' " * )"'

";" " " = " ' "; ! F6"%!$& $$$ -986 * " >'B ? " > '

?")

' "" '

" "2019*

' " / % " $ * + " $ "') " ' )"; ; " ""

" ""

; " * ' " " ' + '

" + " = "

; "= ";

+;" ' ./ <?@,, ;<, $ 6$)+"" "= " "= " """ ' "

@ " " 48 = " ' " '

" " " +#/ (4? *

' * ' *

)

' '

+ , >

* .

)

% *

6 -916 ') " ' B +"' "

; D " ./ ", /% ='

0 A* $6'" " " ' + " ; +#/ (0

% ' < A= "/!,4, &,A,

' ,

% % .

% *

) ' *

% *

* 6 -936 " "

! F6"%!$& $3 -906 " / " "

"""""" "= " " "

" ;" "$ ;

" " ";= + " = " ) + ; ": '

"" + = "

" ' + '' " " = '' ) +""' "455 ";= " " ' " "

D"; ' B ;+"= "

)+ ; " "" ? ";=

' -856

" ) " ; + ; ' " + I " % 24 +" + " = "

.)" +) ; " " 44 4527 4527) " ) ') @,* ' +"

' 295= ' "''; / "

D'; "" +;" " " " ) ;

" ' "

) +"" "+

" +" ;

)

) ;= ; "

@,* " " "B ' " " ' "

; " '';

/ -826 D; +" ;B " " .% 2759 4522)"";"" ''; " " "

"; < + -846 " ; "" "'

') " " ;

" ; " ' "; " : ' B "

' '

"= +"+ -876 D

") ')"+" " = ; " " 49 ; B '' )"" " / - */ 6 " + "

" ;H!

; ') '

) ; !

"+ ) ;B " ''; / ) " ; = -8<6 D " " " ; ) + " +

" +'#/

-6 " 72 4553 57 4550 " = = " ""+

) " "= ) ";' -6 " ;= "/ '/' % 24 = " "B ": ' "

"; "

= " " = +" % '" " -6 " + @; , ' * " " " ; " 44 452758 4527

' " ' 4527 "'';

" / H" +" "

' " " '';H "' "H"' "; B " '

"= H -6 " " ) ') ! " H ' "-. % 2759 45226 " ; ' 295 = ' ; @,* "'' " ;' ' ' '';

/ )"+""+

"4527+" " '+ " ;;'' -6 , % -6 -6"; '

+"+"

% '" " -896

.6;: / &!

689" (( *

;%> &.$&9>

689"