← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13166/2016allowed

Punjab State Cooperative Supply & Marketing Fedration Ltd. Markfed House, Markfed Moga v. Registrar Cooperative Societies Punjab And ORS.

2019-12-11Mr. Justice Jaspal Singh4 pages

     

  

      

 

!"# $% &#'()($*+ ,,  

    

    

                        

              



      



!"#"$%& ! #""' () *+,-(%"

.,! %/" 0"%)%),$"!

! /(!($0!""% )$1/ 

.,! !"#0,$*"$%# ,  ($* 

,$" .,! !"#0,$*"$%# , 5 %, 6

 

  

    )# (88,9"* #243"-% %, 32#% ":-"0%),$# ..)*(+)% )$ %"!'# ,. ,!*"! *(%"* 5 5 ; )# %(<"$ ,$ !"-,!* /(88"$1" )$ %/)# 9!)% 0"%)%),$ )# %, %/" ,!*"! *(%"* 6  = >$$":2!"

?@ 0(##"* 4A /" **)%),$(8 "1)#%!(! >"$"!(8@ ,,0"!(%)+"

,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/?!"#0,$*"$% ,  9/"!"4A %/" (00"(8 0!"."!!"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! /(# 4""$ *)#')##"* ,$ %/" 1!,2$* %/(% %/" #('" )# *"8(A"* 4A =; *(A# "+)#),$ 0"%)%),$ 0!"."!!"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! (1()$#% %/" #()* ,!*"! /(# (8#, 4""$ *)#')##"* 4A /" "1)#%!(! ,,0"!(%)+"

 ,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/?!"#0,$*"$% ,  +)*" ,!*"! *(%"*  5 6  = 6 >$$":2!"

?5@ % )# %/" -,$%"$%),$ ,. %/" 8"(!$"* -,2$#"8 .,! %/" 0"%)%),$"! %/(% %/" 0"%)%),$"! /(# )$)%)(%"* 0!,-""*)$1# 2$*"! %/" !4)%!(%),$ -% (# 0"! %/" (1!""'"$% 4"%9""$ %/" 0(!%)"# .,! !"-,+"!A ,. ($ (',2$% ,. = B B6 ? ,$ (--,2$% ,. ')#(00!,0!)(%),$ ,. %/" 0(**A #%,-<# .,! %/" -!,0 A"(! ;;?; 4A !"#0,$*"$%# , 5 %, 6 /"

,)$% "1)#%!(!

,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

"!,C"02! 9(# (00,)$%"* (# %/" !4)%!(%,! 9/, 0!,$,2$-"* %/" 9(!* ,$    >$$":2!"

?@ *)#')##)$1 %/" #()* (!4)%!(%),$ -8()' (# 0!,3"-%"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! /" #()* 9(!* 9(# -/(88"$1"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! 4A .)8)$1 ($ (00"(8 2$*"! "-%),$ B ,. %/" 2$3(4 ,,0"!(%)+"

,-)"%)"# -% ;B 9/)-/ 9(# *)#')##"* 4A %/" **)%),$(8 "1)#%!(! >"$"!(8@ ,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

2$3(4 +)*" ,!*"! *(%"* 6  = ,$ %/"

1!,2$* %/(% %/" (00"(8 9(# 4(!!"* 4A 8)')%(%),$ (# %/" #('" /(* 4""$ .)8"* (.%"! ( 8(0#" ,. =; *(A# 9/"!"(# %/" 8)')%(%),$ 0"!),* .,! -/(88"$1)$1 ($ (9(!* )$ ($ (00"(8 )# B *(A# "+)#),$ 0!"."!!"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! /(# (8#, 4""$ *)#')##"* ,$ %/" #('" 1!,2$* ,$  5 6 >$$":2!" ?5@ 4A %/"

"1)#%!(!

,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/ ,2$#"8 -,$%"$*# %/(% 4"-(2#" ,. %/" $"18)1"$-"

-,$$)+($-" ,. %/" ,..)-)(8# ,. %/" 0"%)%),$"!

%/" (00"(8 9(# )$)%)(88A $,% .)8"* /"!" 9"!" +(!),2# !"(#,$# .,! $,% .)8)$1 %/" !"+)#),$ 0"%)%),$ "#0"-)(88A 9)%/ !"1(!* %, %/" !"(#,$ %/(% (!')$*"!

)$1/ 9/, 9(# %/" *"(8)$1 (##)#%($% ,. %/" 0"%)%),$"!?(!<."* 9(# -,$#)#%"$%8A ,$ 8"(+" ($* %/" .)8" 9(# 9)%/ /)' 42% 28%)'(%"8A )% 9(# .,2$* %/(% %/" *"8(A /(# 4""$ -(2#"* ($* (%%!)42%(48" %, 2!-/(!($ )$1/ 9/, 9(# %/" *"(8)$1 (##)#%($% 9/, /(* .)8"* %/" (00"(8 (.%"! %/" *"8(A " (8!"(*A #%,,* *)#')##"* ($* %/"!".,!"

$, .2!%/"! (-%),$ /(# 4""$ %(<"$

 (1()$#% /)' /(% 4")$1 #, 9)%/ ( +)"9 %, (+,)* !",--2!!"$-" ,. #2-/ )$-)*"$% ,. *"8(A# $#%!2-%),$# +)*" 8"%%"! *(%"*   5 /(+" 4""$ )##2"* 4A %/" ($(1)$1 )!"-%,! ,. %/" 0"%)%),$"! ($* %/"!"(.%"! %/"

12)*"8)$"# %, .,88,9 20 %/" ,2!% -(#"# ($* 0!,+)*)$1 %/" -(#" (00"(8 *"%()8# )$#%!2-%),$# 9"!" )##2"* %, %/" "$"!(8 ($(1"! )(#,$ ..)-"!

"9 "8/) ($* %(%" ,.

2$3(4 ,$   ; /"

2$-%),$(8 "(*# ,.

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

/,9"+"!

-,$%"$*# %/(% %/" )'021$"* ,!*"!

(9(!* 0(##"* 4A %/" (2%/,!)%)"# 2$*"! %/" ,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"# -% 4" #"% (#)*" ($* %/" -(#" !"'($*"* 4(-< %, %/" **)%),$(8 "1)#%!(! >"$"!(8@ ,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

%/" (00"88(%" (2%/,!)%A .,! .!"#/ *"-)#),$ )$ %/" '(%%"! ,$ '"!)%#

,%)-" ,. ',%),$ 9(# )##2"* )$ %/)# -(#" 42% *"#0)%" #"!+)-"

$,$" /(# 02% )$ (00"(!($-" ,$ 4"/(8. ,. !"#0,$*"$%# , 5 %, 6  /(+" -,$#)*"!"* %/" #24')##),$# '(*" 4A %/" 8"(!$"* -,2$#"8 .,! %/" 0"%)%),$"! ($* ,$ 1,)$1 %/!,21/ %/" !"-,!*# ,. %/" -(#" (8%/,21/

%/"!" )# *"8(A )$ .)8)$1 %/" (00"(8 ($* %/"!" )# $, 0!,+)#),$ .,! -,$*,$(%),$ ,. *"8(A 4".,!" %/" (00"88(%" (2%/,!)%A (# 9"88 (# %/" !"+)#),$(8 (2%/,!)%A 42% <""0)$1 )$ +)"9 %/" 0"-28)(! .(-%# ($* -)!-2'#%($-"# ,. %/" 0!"#"$% -(#" ($* %/" *"8(A (# /(# 4""$ *28A ":08()$"* 4A %/" 0"%)%),$"! )$ .)8)$1 %/" (00"(8 9)%/ .2!%/"! #%"0# %(<"$ #, %/(% #2-/ %A0" ,. *"8(A *,"# $,% ,--2! )$ .2%2!"

%/" )'021$"* ,!*"!# *(%"* 6  = >$$":2!" ?@ 0(##"* 4A /"

**)%),$(8 "1)#%!(! >"$"!(8@ ,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/?

!"#0,$*"$% ,  ($* ,!*"! *(%"*  5 6  = 6 >$$":2!"

?5@ 0(##"* 4A /" "1)#%!(!

,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/?

!"#0,$*"$% ,  )# /"!"4A #"% (#)*" %, #(."12(!* %/" )$%"!"#% ,. %/" 0248)- ',$"A 9/)-/ )# = B B6 ? 9/)-/ )# (88"1"* %, 4" !"-,+"!A 9/)-/ /(# %, 4" ".."-%"* .!,' %/" 0!)+(%" !"#0,$*"$%# $ +)"9 ,. %/" (4,+"

4A #"%%)$1 (#)*" %/" )'021$"* ,!*"! *(%"* 6  = >$$":2!"

?@ ($* ,!*"! *(%"*  5 6  = 6 >$$":2!"

?5@ %/" -(#" )# !"'($*"* 4(-< %, %/" **)%),$(8 "1)#%!(! >"$"!(8@ ,,0"!(%)+" ,-)"%)"#

/($*)1(!/ .,! .!"#/ *"-)#),$ ,$ %/" (00"(8 ,$ '"!)%# 4A /"(!)$1 %/" 0(!%)"# -,$-"!$"*

#'#-.#/ 0

 

1   1    E/"%/"! #0"(<)$1 !"(#,$"*& "#

, E/"%/"! "0,!%(48"

& "#

,